DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- I liked the introduction and the anime original parts, Kizaru definitely added some charm. Rest of the episode was skippable. Retired Sengoku is besto btw. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| This episode was nothing more than a recap of the Marinefold war arc. Seeing Akainu and Kizaru was fun though. |
| I'm fine with them recapping stuff, need to let the manga go ahead. |
 |
| Oh yeah, I missed those old recap episodes. |
| No tomo malas decisiones, solo me gusta apoyar causas perdidas. Disfruté Mayoiga, Ou-sama Game, Evil or Live, Mirai Nikki, Big Order, Arifureta, Ex-Arm, Tesla Note, Shuumatsu no Harem y Platinum End nope les falle con esa, lo siento pero todos tenemos nuestros límites. Así de jodido es mi gusto en anime, ¡Y estoy pinche orgulloso de ello!  |
| Kizarus new voice actor did a good job. Sounded pretty similar. I'm okay with the recaps too. But damn, some of the animation in the scenes with Akainu and Kizaru looked aweful, and I'm usually not a animation complainer in one piece... |
| this episode is filled with fantastic and classic scenes... unfortunately they're almost all from episodes we've already seen... the flashback scenes felt very strangely ordered, I honestly don't understand their thinking in setting this episode up, it was super messy it looks like next week we are back to normal though fortunately |
| well I really am liking these fillers... nice to see it all ... the hype is so on |
 |
| Well at least they show the interesting stuff in the beginning so I can skip the flashbacks afterwards and don't have to waste my time. Also disappointed that the other admiral isn't a woman. |
| I would like to see a movie about saving Bon-chan from Impel Down. |
| Possibly the shortest episode ever lol, barely anything new in it. |
 |
nerfx said: Possibly the shortest episode ever lol, barely anything new in it. Just letting the Manga get further away. Think it is the right time to do it although probably would have liked a number of flashbacks in a row and not interperse any of the main story with them. |
yeah this episode had mabye 4 min of manga content, but i think the flashbacks are acceptable, considering how long its been since we have been at these arcs. Its not always a bad thing to remind us about certain critical events that have relevence to the reverie arc. For anime fans, that makes following it a bit easer rather then us manga fans having to disect all the information from previous arcs. |
ArtimesGamerApr 21, 2019 3:46 AM
  |
| This brought back all the feelings, damn. |
 |
Salokannel2 said: I'm fine with them recapping stuff, need to let the manga go ahead. isn't the manga 1 year+ ahead ? I dislike recaps more than fillers, some small filler acts were actually decent, this is a juts a skip for me. |
| New Age! |
 |
| Battle of Marineford, what a great arc that was. |
 |
| TOEI is going to ruin the Reverie arc and I fucking hate it. |
 |
| As if there weren't enough Marineford recaps... |
 |
| Loved this one... |
WolfWood37 said: exactly........As if there weren't enough Marineford recaps... |
| Yep, Toei outdid themselves yet again - another recap. Tho the seiyuu for Borsalino really is something, he sounds almost exactly like the late Ishizuka-san. Also, i'm both excited and scared about the Reverie Arc, pls don't suck, pls don't suck, pls don't suck |
| Fucking flashback shit episode. |
 |
| Was a good start. Akainu is so pissed about Luffy but also about Fujitora. Sengoku making fun of Akainu was just priceless. Kizarus new voice surprised me. Normally if you get a new voice you can hear the difference but his new seiyuu did a great job. :) Of course it's annoying if they show recaps, but I'm okay with that. At least the manga can go ahead a little bit more. Next week we will see a new admiral? Should be interesting. |
 |
| I am really pissed now. I understand they have to show flashbacks because of the gap between manga & anime, but why not show the not shown parts of Impel Down arc. How the hell did Bon-chan survive against Magellan's poison. They should have rather mixed it up with flashbacks and new stuff from the Impel Down arc. It would have been interesting to see the fight between Blackbeard's crew and Magellan and their escape to Marineford. I suppose that's too much to ask. Also I can't remember seeing Jinbei saying have mercy on me. He have too much pride to begging Luffy to rescue him. However, I remember he said that if they rescued him he could be to aid for him. What amazes me more is that people really thought there wouldn't be any flashbacks. Personally I am not surprised. I am just trying to enjoy the canon parts of the ep. I know it won't change if I complain or don't, so I rather won't! PS! Did we ever see Ace's bounty. I can't remember seeing it before now. It's now that I know it was 550 million berries. |
 |
| Can't believe Toei man, a recap really?????? Does that mean Sengoku saw Luffy got poisoned by Magellan, then detoxed the poisoned when he thought in that flashback? He must have gotten a detailed report on that situation, hmm. Anyways, the impel down and marine ford war was my favorite arc in anime history, whitebeard was soo badass that I thought he wasn't human. He died after so so so so so so many stabs, shots, blows and cuts. He is still my favorite though. The episode also reminded me how useful and great Bon was to Luffy during the commotion, liked that swan! |
How I learned to stop worrying and love the bomb --- Dr Strangelove  |
| Sakazuki realized that Fujitora went to Marijeoise, he sent Ryokugyu to look for Fujitora and send him behind Luffy and Law, Sengoku interrupted him. Sengoku started to remember when Luffy broke into Impel Down, fought with Magellan and assisted to Marineford. It was not boring but unnecessary, it just telled again Impel Down and Marineford arcs. |
 |
| WILL YOU GUYS STOP FUCKING BITCHING!!. Holy christ!! You do realize that on a weekly based anime, flash backs are needed for vewers to understand and remember certain events in the story especially the reverie where many past arcs are relevent to the material presented in the reverie arc. But serously i am getting sick and tired of this shit. I get enough of it from CR, i don't need it in MAL to. CR literally complains every single episode in the series since the damn time skip. Why don't we for once discuss the actual episode or content. |
| |
link9us said: WILL YOU GUYS STOP FUCKING BITCHING!!. Holy christ!! You do realize that on a weekly based anime, flash backs are needed for vewers to understand and remember certain events in the story especially the reverie where many past arcs are relevent to the material presented in the reverie arc. But serously i am getting sick and tired of this shit. I get enough of it from CR, i don't need it in MAL to. CR literally complains every single episode in the series since the damn time skip. Why don't we for once discuss the actual episode or content. We don't need recaps of things that have already been done |
| Please not again. I'm gonna have a mental breakdown if i have to see Ace's death AGAIN. ;____; |
| This episode is a waste, just make a filler arc instead of recaps. |
 |
| Skip this episode. Don’t waste your time |
link9us said: WILL YOU GUYS STOP FUCKING BITCHING!!. Holy christ!! You do realize that on a weekly based anime, flash backs are needed for vewers to understand and remember certain events in the story especially the reverie where many past arcs are relevent to the material presented in the reverie arc. But serously i am getting sick and tired of this shit. I get enough of it from CR, i don't need it in MAL to. CR literally complains every single episode in the series since the damn time skip. Why don't we for once discuss the actual episode or content. You don’t need shitty flashbacks when you can just go on YouTube and rewatch all the scenes. I rather toei do fillers than regurgitate flashbacks over and over |
SuperRed said: link9us said: WILL YOU GUYS STOP FUCKING BITCHING!!. Holy christ!! You do realize that on a weekly based anime, flash backs are needed for vewers to understand and remember certain events in the story especially the reverie where many past arcs are relevent to the material presented in the reverie arc. But serously i am getting sick and tired of this shit. I get enough of it from CR, i don't need it in MAL to. CR literally complains every single episode in the series since the damn time skip. Why don't we for once discuss the actual episode or content. We don't need recaps of things that have already been done You do know that panel to panel requisitioning has to be extended and expanded upon to create transitional moments that flow more cohesively for an anime production. If you actually animated something directly on the same pace as the manga material, panel by panel. The production would lack any kind of fluidity or consistency and would would end up rather stiff and be presented with relentless stil shots and would suffer in its execution when transferred to the screen. Mangaka's go into this career with this knowledge already and know full well that there has to be room for animators to provide more of a motion picture experience. The panels are there just to gauge whats for each particular scene. Also animation is just one aspect of it, there is the transformation and portrayal of story execution as well which is very important. For anime repeated scenes and things are necessary to engage the audience more, where as in manga, its not cause your only reading things straightforward. Anime requires additional scenes and even repeated events to encapsulates on the production and to give it a more movie like quality. I do admit that TOIE kind of takes it over the top some times (obviously) but this post is mainly to retcon that ridiculous video that guy made on youtube. This guy that made this video's is an idiot for not fully comprehending how manga to anime adaptations work. |
ArtimesGamerApr 23, 2019 11:17 PM
| |
link9us said: You do know that panel to panel requisitioning has to be extended and expanded upon to create transitional moments that flow more cohesively for an anime production. If you actually animated something directly on the same pace as the manga material, panel by panel. The production would lack any kind of fluidity or consistency and would would end up rather stiff and be presented with relentless stil shots and would suffer in its execution when transferred to the screen. Mangaka's go into this career with this knowledge already and know full well that there has to be room for animators to provide more of a motion picture experience. The panels are there just to gauge whats for each particular scene. Also animation is just one aspect of it, there is the transformation and portrayal of story execution as well which is very important. For anime repeated scenes and things are necessary to engage the audience more, where as in manga, its not cause your only reading things straightforward. Anime requires additional scenes and even repeated events to encapsulates on the production and to give it a more movie like quality. I do admit that TOIE kind of takes it over the top some times (obviously) but this post is mainly to retcon that ridiculous video that guy made on youtube. This guy that made this video's is an idiot for not fully comprehending how manga to anime adaptations work. I know a 1:1 panel adaptation isn't ideal but this is indefensible, you can't just turn 50% of the most interesting post timeskip chapters into recap episodes and expect people to not get angry. |
| At this rate this arc will recap the entire series lol Retired Sengoku's reaction to Sakazuki's anger was hilarious. |
 |
| I'm alright with this - I need the reminders of who is who and who did what! |
| I'm Bruneian and I like anime. And Manchester United. And fat cats. |
| Sengoku was very funny, haha |
| Flashback of the great battle at marineford sure I'll take it. It is the best arc so I won't complain. Just don't takebl too long |
 |
| Now it's the marines reacting to Luffy's new actions. Akainu has surely gotten more short tempered since the past 2 years. Stress is really a bad thing. 75% of the ep is just recap of the Paramount War Saga. It's a recap but I am not troubled by it. That saga is literally the best One Piece saga so far! Also... Bon Clay, the low key one of the most respectable character in One Piece ever. Will we ever see him again? Is he dead? Who knows, except Oda... (T^T) |
  |
small44 said: link9us said: WILL YOU GUYS STOP FUCKING BITCHING!!. Holy christ!! You do realize that on a weekly based anime, flash backs are needed for vewers to understand and remember certain events in the story especially the reverie where many past arcs are relevent to the material presented in the reverie arc. But serously i am getting sick and tired of this shit. I get enough of it from CR, i don't need it in MAL to. CR literally complains every single episode in the series since the damn time skip. Why don't we for once discuss the actual episode or content. No we can't stop complaining about what's wrong with something we like.I'm tired of people who only want to hear positive feedback. Flashback are not needed when you did not forget any important details,there's zero detail on the flashbacks that made me say oh I didn't remember that. We don't discuss the actual episode because nothing important happened because of those useless flashbacks. They should have made an actual filler arcs instead of those stupid flashbacks. lol I remember posting this comment and i was kind of in a real angry mood then but boy do i take back what i said. The Reverie was honestly the worst adapated arc in a story telling medium I have ever seen. But not so much the flash backs that hurt it. Yes they slowed the pacing down to a crawl but more then that. The studio had the audicity to actually change the order of events and ruin the impact during certain key moments. Big reveals that had marvelious build-up and revelations such as sabo's reveal or luffy's bounty, Cp9, was all ruined because of the way the arc was structured to include flashbacks prior to that actual reveal. How ever that being said i still think fans who post here need to cover both bases. Sure you can provide critism about the negative aspects of the series and god knows this arc needs it but you need to also provide input to some of the larger moments the story is presenting as well. You can't just forget about those because the arc was over shadowed by to much recaps or flashbacks. It kind of gives the wrong message to the fans. I mean the reverie is immportant for indrucing some of the potentual largest players in the one piece world and that is something you should also address. Thankfully the Reverie is not over, its continuing along with the wano arc and now that the studio has a new show runner and director, i think the rest of the reverie segments will be much better. |
ArtimesGamerJul 11, 2020 2:03 PM
| |
| If I'm correct, the great Unshō Ishizuka passed away which is why Kizaru has a new VA. Rest in peace, you sold Kizaru to me and were one of my favorite voices in the series. I look forward to seeing what Ryotaro Okiayu does with the character. On a lighter note, there's now a pattern of Kizaru cutting his nails. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Piece Episode 392 Discussion ( 1 2 )dbaranyi - Mar 8, 2009 |
92 |
by gannoncannon55
»»
8 hours ago |
|
Poll: » One Piece Episode 391 DiscussionKitschi - Mar 11, 2009 |
40 |
by gannoncannon55
»»
9 hours ago |
|
» I miss the old fights.NeutralSide - Sep 14, 2023 |
25 |
by NeutralSide
»»
Today, 6:42 AM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Episode 1062 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )AhriTheS3xyFox - May 20, 2023 |
328 |
by mihirmishra
»»
Today, 5:46 AM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Episode 229 DiscussionVARIAchan - Jan 5, 2010 |
42 |
by kejora
»»
Today, 2:11 AM |