[Oda class] Winter 2019 Power Ranking Committee (Part 2 of 4)

Feb 21, 2019 3:18 PM

Offline

Dec 2015

352

Anime Guild's Winter 2019 Oda Power Ranking Committee
(Part 2 of 4)

Welcome back class ヽ(^o^).

Now that you are an expert in the ways of PRC lets get right to it and get this show on the road! For those that need a refresh on the rules or have any questions, please refer to the directory and click Winter 2019 Sign Up Post. In the directory you will also find the other classes lists as well as the previous class post.

Directory
Winter 2019 Sign Up Post
Winter Oda Power Rankings 1
Winter Togashi Power Rankings 2
Winter Toriyama Power Rankings 2
Character Power Rankings 2

Time to Party! Top 10 for Oda Class inbound!

1. Yakusoku no Neverland (666 Points) [PREV: 1]
[Shift: --]

Tsuxken: 1
swtos: 1
PMBF: 1
HaXXspetten: 1
RisaK: 1
tomdederde: 1
Hella-Sugoi: 2
Mr_Kiwi: 2
js_Vegnagun: 2
Gwathgor: 2
Mullerio: 3
CrazyFrogz: 3
k3ls3yr1ann3: 4
MrZawa: 4
Elias97: 4
moissi: 5
Ataccot: 5
MisaoAino: 6
elkensteyin: 6
MikhailTheGreat: 8

2. Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Tensai-tachi no Renai Zunousen (536 Points) [PREV: 4]
[Shift: ↑ 2]

js_Vegnagun: 1
MikhailTheGreat: 1
Hella-Sugoi: 1
Revvie-chan: 2
Ataccot: 2
Elias97: 2
swtos: 2
tomdederde: 2
HaXXspetten: 3
Tsuxken: 4
elkensteyin: 5
Gwathgor: 5
Mr_Kiwi: 6
CrazyFrogz: 6
Mullerio: 6
MrZawa: 6
k3ls3yr1ann3: 7
moissi: 7
MisaoAino: 8
RisaK: 9
PMBF: 10

3. Tensei shitara Slime Datta Ken (456 Points) [PREV: 2]
[Shift: ↓ 1]

elkensteyin: 1
Mr_Kiwi: 1
CrazyFrogz: 1
HaXXspetten: 2
moissi: 3
MikhailTheGreat: 3
swtos: 3
PMBF: 3
Revvie-chan: 4
MrZawa: 5
js_Vegnagun: 5
RisaK: 5
tomdederde: 5
k3ls3yr1ann3: 6
Mullerio: 7
Tsuxken: 8
Elias97: 9
Hella-Sugoi: 10

3. Mob Psycho 100 II (456 Points) [PREV: 5]
[Shift: ↑ 2]

MrZawa: 1
Elias97: 1
Mullerio: 1
Ataccot: 1
Tsuxken: 2
CrazyFrogz: 2
Gwathgor: 2
k3ls3yr1ann3: 3
RisaK: 3
Mr_Kiwi: 3
js_Vegnagun: 3
PMBF: 8
HaXXspetten: 9

5. Dororo (423 Points) [PREV: 3]
[Shift: ↓ 2]

MisaoAino: 1
moissi: 1
k3ls3yr1ann3: 1
RisaK: 2
Schizoidmouse: 2
Tsuxken: 3
Ataccot: 3
MrZawa: 3
Mullerio: 4
Mr_Kiwi: 5
HaXXspetten: 5
elkensteyin: 6
swtos: 6
tomdederde: 6
MikhailTheGreat: 6
js_Vegnagun: 6
Elias97: 8
PMBF: 9
CrazyFrogz: 10

6. Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari (321 Points) [PREV: 6]
[Shift: --]

MikhailTheGreat: 2
PMBF: 2
tomdederde: 3
CrazyFrogz: 4
RisaK: 4
moissi: 4
Ataccot: 4
Hella-Sugoi: 5
MisaoAino: 5
k3ls3yr1ann3: 5
swtos: 6
js_Vegnagun: 7
Mr_Kiwi: 7
elkensteyin: 8
HaXXspetten: 8
Mullerio: 10

7. Doukyonin wa Hiza, Tokidoki, Atama no Ue. (194 Points) [PREV: 7]
[Shift: --]

MisaoAino: 3
Elias97: 3
HaXXspetten: 4
MikhailTheGreat: 4
js_Vegnagun: 4
Tsuxken: 5
Gwathgor: 6
RisaK: 7
k3ls3yr1ann3: 8
Mullerio: 9

8. Kaze ga Tsuyoku Fuiteiru (166 Points) [PREV: 10]
[Shift: ↑ 2]

MisaoAino: 2
moissi: 2
k3ls3yr1ann3: 2
Mr_Kiwi: 4
Elias97: 6
RisaK: 8

9. Domestic na Kanojo (139 Points) [PREV: 8]
[Shift: ↓ 1]

elkensteyin: 3
swtos: 4
Hella-Sugoi: 4
Ataccot: 6
PMBF: 7
tomdederde: 8
js_Vegnagun: 8
CrazyFrogz: 9
moissi: 9
Revvie-chan: 9
Mr_Kiwi: 10

10. Endro~! (109 Points) [PREV: 12]
[Shift: ↑ 1]

Revvie-chan: 1
Bajar: 3
HaXXspetten: 6
Tsuxken: 7
elkensteyin: 10

~ Honorable Mentions ~
11. Gotoubun no Hanayome (104 Points) [PREV: 13] [Shift: ↑ 2]
11. JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken: Ougon no Kaze [2019] (104 Points) [PREV: 9] [Shift: ↓ 2]
13. Boogiepop wa Warawanai [2019] (101 Points) [PREV: 10] [Shift: ↓ 3]

Individual Rankings & Comments
Click the buttons below to see your fellow classmates full list with comments that maybe included.

@Bajar

@k3ls3yr1ann3

@MisaoAino

@Mullerio

@Revvie-chan

Endro~!
I was actually intrigued to finally put Endro rank down in favor of what have been a solid performance from Kaguya (the series, not the character.) But episode 6 is just too good. (For me personally it's the best episode I've watched from this season so far, from all the anime from this season that I am watching currently.)
Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai - Tensai-tachi no Renai Zun?sen
Solid performance from Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai, mainly from episodes where Fujiwara is involved. While the format of the comedy hasn't changed a thing, that's not really a problem as the materials are still very very funny and worth waiting.
It's sort of hurt with Koga failing the French part, but that part (quoting from a friend) was hard to adapt in the first place. So I won't be too nitpicky on that.
Grimms Notes The Animation
I do love that they take time with Cinderella arc. Favoritism definitely doesn't play a factor here.
Tensei Shittara Slime Datta-ken
It finally got boring. Well, not that boring. I still love my dose of fantasy. Now, if only Veldora can appear again. (Fck these shit ogres and supposedly loli not-loli demon king.)
Kouya no Kotobuki Hikoutai
The Kotobuki Brigade has finally started to dwelve into its one arc per character format, which is... standard, but at least it's still nice to follow.
I do admit that... if you don't understand a bit about air combat, you will have trouble appreciating the maneuvres and air tactics the girls are using here. (That in itself is maybe the anime's biggest downfall, as it focuses so much on trying to make the dialogue seems realistic and not-over-the-top and maybe slightly moe-ified, that it misses on a chance to make a great narrative. It wants its animation to be where the main narration comes from, and that in this case means the viewers have to understand at least a bit of air combat before he/she can ever appreciate of what the anime is trying to do here.)
But the past 3 episodes have been great in terms of characterization and world-building, so I guess I'll rank this in this pos for now.
Also the red baron is fun.
Watashi Tenshi ni ga Maioritai!
Despite solid 3 episodes, great characterization for our MC and a fun new character, Wataten goes down on my ranking a bit. Mainly bcs the jokes are starting to get boring. But also bcs all the other series are catching up in terms of quality.
5-toubun no Hanayome
Yotsuba best girl. It stays here only bcs cute girls are cute.
Egao no Daika
The empire soldier part of the story clearly is more interesting than the Kingdom. Especially with the death flags they're putting over everybody (although they haven't kill anyone of real importance yet from this side. Well, it's coming. We know at least 2 important cast of the squad will die here. And no the ones that already died are not one of those important cast, despite what they're trying to do.)
Kingdom part: I sure hope they finally develop the princess into a real leader so that the Kingdom part of the story can get interesting. (Fck her retainers who continually lie to her despite saying that they love her and are loyal to her. What kind of loyal retainers who continually hide information from their leader? Dear princess will you just execute these people already? Be the tyrant you're born to be.)
Domestic No Kanojo
I hate how they are doing their best to avoid imaging a bitch as a bitch, with all these "I just cannot hurt either" or "I'm just naive and innocent girl" shit.
If she's a bitch, then image her as such (a bitch.) Enough with this supposed drama that only you find sad, dear Mr. Writer.
Ueno-san wa Bukiyou!
It got boring. Would have gone down had Tate no Yuusha not filled a bunch of idiots and all hail Raphtalia.

@Ataccot

@CrazyFrogz

@Elias97

@elkensteyin

@Gwathgor

@HaXXspetten

@Hella-Sugoi

@MikhailTheGreat

@moissi

@MrZawa

@Mr_Kiwi

@PMBF

@RisaK

@swtos

@tomdederde

@Tsuxken

Looks like we got some movement for some shows while others remain cozy in their spot.
Don't forget to share your thoughts by leaving a comment!
Unitl next time folks ＼（＾∀＾）メ（＾∀＾）ノ

BlueSkylarkMar 18, 2019 4:28 AM

Feb 21, 2019 3:19 PM

Bajar

Offline

Jan 2013

1836

Yay I finally got one of my ranked shows in the Top 10! Hooray for Endro~!

Feb 21, 2019 3:33 PM

MisaoAino

Offline

Feb 2017

4819

Awww. Kaze in topppp YAAAY

Feb 21, 2019 3:37 PM

HaXXspetten

*hug noises*

Offline

May 2013

31397

Kaguya sure is on the rise. I think it's deserved though; for one it's the kind of series you warm up to and get into more and more over time (as the manga has proven beyond all doubt), but also whatever adaptation issues it has had were more glaring in the first few episodes I think. It's been stabilizing

Feb 21, 2019 3:40 PM

Ataccot

Offline

Oct 2015

661

Although I still don't understand the mass appeal of Neverland, I'm happy with these results. Kaguya and Mob within the top 3, and Dororo following not too far behind. :good_taste_oda:

Feb 21, 2019 3:41 PM

k3ls3yr1ann3

Offline

Apr 2016

1441

Love seeing how diverse everyone's top ten lists are! Kind of sad Dororo dropped down, but having Kaze and Doukyonin in the top ten makes me so happy!

Thanks for all the hard work @js_Vegnagun !

"An idea is not responsible for the people who believe in it." -Random Fortune

Feb 21, 2019 3:55 PM

Remu_Ramu

Offline

Mar 2016

410

Good results

Feb 22, 2019 6:20 AM

Jokobo

Offline

Jan 2012

2503

I like how in Oda Kaguya is so well-rated! Good job guys!

In Toriyama class Love is War doesn't get a lot of love. :/

Feb 22, 2019 6:24 AM

MisaoAino

Offline

Feb 2017

4819

I should have said this before but I've forgotten...

I LMFAO at that dancing gif xD

Feb 22, 2019 7:57 AM

#10

js_Vegnagun

Offline

Dec 2015

352

MisaoAino said:
I should have said this before but I've forgotten...

I LMFAO at that dancing gif xD

I'm glad you appreciate it XD

Feb 22, 2019 7:59 AM

#11

js_Vegnagun

Offline

Dec 2015

352

Ataccot said:
Although I still don't understand the mass appeal of Neverland, I'm happy with these results. Kaguya and Mob within the top 3, and Dororo following not too far behind. :good_taste_oda:

With all the talk I've heard about first arc being great but the rest is crap. I'm wondering if Neverland is about to peak now and will soon come crashing down.

Feb 22, 2019 11:12 PM

#12

Ataccot

Offline

Oct 2015

661

js_Vegnagun said:
With all the talk I've heard about first arc being great but the rest is crap. I'm wondering if Neverland is about to peak now and will soon come crashing down.

Yeah I've heard that as well. It will be interesting to see if opinions change if there are more seasons after this one.

See All Discussions

Sticky: » 【Anime Guild】Discord Invitation Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Hibbington - Aug 7, 2016	1280	by Hibbington »» Apr 17, 10:19 AM
Sticky: » ❤~Staff Thread~❤ ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Mikochondria - Sep 19, 2014	1164	by RisaK »» Apr 15, 1:31 PM
» [CLOSED] Winter 2024 AOTS Card Edition: BokuYaba Season 2 coziitsu - Apr 9	28	by coziitsu »» Apr 14, 6:15 AM
Sticky: » Spring 2024 Power Ranking Committee Sign-ups Hibbington - Mar 13	40	by HaXXspetten »» Apr 13, 11:16 AM
Sticky: » [Toriyama Class] Power Ranking Committee Winter 2024: Part 4/4 FINALE KANLen09 - Apr 9	1	by KANLen09 »» Apr 9, 9:02 PM

[Oda class] Winter 2019 Power Ranking Committee (Part 2 of 4)

More topics from this board

Sticky: » 【Anime Guild】Discord Invitation Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Sticky: » ❤~Staff Thread~❤ ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

» [CLOSED] Winter 2024 AOTS Card Edition: BokuYaba Season 2

Sticky: » Spring 2024 Power Ranking Committee Sign-ups

Sticky: » [Toriyama Class] Power Ranking Committee Winter 2024: Part 4/4 FINALE

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters