[/quote] anime vs manga comparison enough said: but for those who think that was a one shot moment think again: |
PhantomnocomicsAug 24, 2018 3:49 PM
| Lmao, you just linked a normal budget anime scene compared to a bunch of manga pages edited into a gif.... Of course the manga gif would look better. OPM had a fantastic animation and Im pretty sure you'd rather watch it animated rather than read the manga |
Klad said: Lmao, you just linked a normal budget anime scene compared to a bunch of manga pages edited into a gif.... Of course the manga gif would look better. OPM had a fantastic animation and Im pretty sure you'd rather watch it animated rather than read the manga i would rather have both, but if i had to pick One and only One, i would choose the manga Gifs any day, note: some of those are not edited though since murata use double pages for the art and usually don't include text when he does that. |
| I prefer manga, but the anime is awesome too. |
 |
| if only the manga is in full color then there is no doubt its better |
| The manga art is superior to the anime's visuals. |
  |
| Webcomic is the best (seriously what's that?!) |
Phantomnocomics said: https://i.imgur.com/vNSdKXF.gif?noredirect < manga vs anime comparison enough said: but for those who think that was a one shot moment think again: https://78.media.tumblr.com/6eaad4d4292d95670cb1425aec9f524e/tumblr_mus4ao0YbM1rjf4f5o1_500.gif https://media.giphy.com/media/oogBSX8NjHlTy/giphy.gif http://img1.ak.crunchyroll.com/i/spire4/97814ea1e7c7985a1aed76f5fafedcd31362610601_full.gif https://i.imgur.com/wtatOcz.gif as you can see, the anime added a lot more to the fight, all of the fights were perfectly executed by madhouse. yes, the manga seems like it has more dynamics with different angles, but it's really hard to execute and fit so many dynamic fights within 1 show. you gotta give props to madhouse, i still hardly find any anime with so many fluid animations dynamic fight upd: oh my fucking god, this shit makes me wanna re-watch opm again... @xShinigami3125, where u at @Phantomnocomics not to be confused, my friend, i fucking adore the manga. every chapter gives me more hope to live in this god forsaken world. but i love the effort madhouse put in adapting such complex source material, so it didn't turn out just as pretty static images as a lot of studios do |
]uninstallthegameAug 24, 2018 3:59 PM
 |
| My my, you are easy to please. Glad you like it that way. It helps to not set a high expectation when watching anime. |
mhkr said: Webcomic is the best (seriously what's that?!) Original source material, but not the canon one anymore |
DepravedMagi said: The manga art is superior to the anime's visuals. truer words have never been said in any space or time |
| I have to admit I enjoyed the manga more than the anime. It's pretty good tho. |
uninstallthegame said: Phantomnocomics said: https://i.imgur.com/vNSdKXF.gif?noredirect < manga vs anime comparison enough said: but for those who think that was a one shot moment think again: https://78.media.tumblr.com/6eaad4d4292d95670cb1425aec9f524e/tumblr_mus4ao0YbM1rjf4f5o1_500.gif https://media.giphy.com/media/oogBSX8NjHlTy/giphy.gif http://img1.ak.crunchyroll.com/i/spire4/97814ea1e7c7985a1aed76f5fafedcd31362610601_full.gif https://i.imgur.com/wtatOcz.gif as you can see, the anime added a lot more to the fight, all of the fights were perfectly executed by madhouse. yes, the manga seems like it has more dynamics with different angles, but it's really hard to execute and fit so many dynamic fights within 1 show. you gotta give props to madhouse, i still hardly find any anime with so many fluid animations dynamic fight upd: oh my fucking god, this shit makes me wanna re-watch opm again... @xShinigami3125, where u at while it's hard to criticize an adaptation for not being *perfect* to its source material, OPM anime certainly was close, and while the dynamics might be more fluid alongside the superior art and coloring in the manga, the anime most certainly outpass the manga when it comes to animation like the dream fight which never looked that good in the manga! |
PhantomnocomicsAug 24, 2018 4:00 PM
Jare4lopez said: I have to admit I enjoyed the manga more than the anime. It's pretty good tho. i was never more proud to state that me and Jares4lopez share a common interest |
PhantomnocomicsAug 24, 2018 4:04 PM
hazecloud said: My my, you are easy to please. Glad you like it that way. It helps to not set a high expectation when watching anime. as long as the material is consistent, has an start and an end, then i'm all for it! |
| Nah, Eromanga-sensei is way better. |
 |
Bayek said: Nah, Eromanga-sensei is way better. a masterpiece such as Eromanga-sensei should not needleesly be spoken of, it's already beyond perfection, OPM looks pale and outclassed in comparison, fam! |
| the webcomic version pieces together all the minute details tho |
 |
RedPlaty said: the webcomic version pieces together all the minute details tho damn right the webcomic does!, amigo |
| >The manga is better than the anime because it has better animation What kind of an argument even is that? Usually manga are better because they tell more about the story (adaptation contraction), they have less unnecessary stuff (most filler is anime original), or because the original author understands his own story better than the people adapting it. Saying the manga is better just because it looks prettier is barely even a reason. |
  |
zombie_pegasus said: >The manga is better than the anime because it has better animation What kind of an argument even is that? Usually manga are better because they tell more about the story (adaptation contraction), they have less unnecessary stuff (most filler is anime original), or because the original author understands his own story better than the people adapting it. Saying the manga is better just because it looks prettier is barely even a reason. filler is not canon, so it's point-less, and the manga has better animation and art just few while the anime is inferior in animation and art but have a lot of it you know what they say: Quality > Quantity |
Phantomnocomics said: Do you not understand the irony? Manga isn't even animated, it's a series of still frames that together form a story. Anime has actual animation, hence the name.zombie_pegasus said: >The manga is better than the anime because it has better animation What kind of an argument even is that? Usually manga are better because they tell more about the story (adaptation contraction), they have less unnecessary stuff (most filler is anime original), or because the original author understands his own story better than the people adapting it. Saying the manga is better just because it looks prettier is barely even a reason. filler is not canon, so it's point-less, and the manga has better animation and art just few while the anime is inferior in animation and art but have a lot of it you know what they say: Quality > Quantity |
|
| I love both the anime and the manga but it's really hard to compare the two cuz the current arc in the manga is my favorite one so far. But if I compare the material that was adapted by s1 I would say the anime was slightly superior cuz even muratas god like art couldnt keep up with the errection that some of the fight scenes in the anime gave me. But i would argue that he keeps improving so who knows whether or not s2 ll be able to keep up. So I ll only be able to answer unabigiously once s2 comes @uninstallthegame why did you write @me? |
xShinigami3125Aug 25, 2018 3:01 AM
zombie_pegasus said: Phantomnocomics said: Do you not understand the irony? Manga isn't even animated, it's a series of still frames that together form a story. Anime has actual animation, hence the name.filler is not canon, so it's point-less, and the manga has better animation and art just few while the anime is inferior in animation and art but have a lot of it you know what they say: Quality > Quantity digital landscape knocks, knocks, manga becomes animatable once it's digital, and like i said, the anime sure has more animation, but the manga has superior Art and dynamics |
xShinigami3125 said: I love both the anime and the manga but it's really hard to compare the two cuz the current arc in the manga is my favorite one so far. But if I compare the material that was adapted by s1 I would say the anime was slightly superior cuz even muratas god like art couldnt keep up with the errection that some of the fight scenes in the anime gave me. But i would argue that he keeps improving so who knows whether or not s2 ll be able to keep up. So I ll only be able to answer unabigiously once s2 comes @uninstallthegame one word: lord golden sperm and Orochi sama |
| But i mean it's still a battle shounen disguised as seinen right ? So still nothing to celebrate. |
 |
Phantomnocomics said: xShinigami3125 said: I love both the anime and the manga but it's really hard to compare the two cuz the current arc in the manga is my favorite one so far. But if I compare the material that was adapted by s1 I would say the anime was slightly superior cuz even muratas god like art couldnt keep up with the errection that some of the fight scenes in the anime gave me. But i would argue that he keeps improving so who knows whether or not s2 ll be able to keep up. So I ll only be able to answer unabigiously once s2 comes @uninstallthegame one word: lord golden sperm and Orochi sama EC and other monsters ll also be pretty hard to animate so they ll probably use CG and then they won't be able to do muratas art justice. |
| Well, it's always given as far as i can see that the source material is always way better than the anime. |
| I like the anime but, I prefer the manga more tbh. |
 |
xShinigami3125 said: EC and other monsters ll also be pretty hard to animate so they ll probably use CG and then they won't be able to do muratas art justice. God let's hope that never happen, last thing we want is Lord Golden sperm in BAD CGI, unless they can manage to pull of an Unlimited budget works like ufotable |
Swagernator said: But i mean it's still a battle shounen disguised as seinen right ? So still nothing to celebrate. that is a sad truth, comrade, the saddest |
| I mean, lol, what could be worse than one punch man (anime) anyways *one punch man fanboys smashing their monitors* |
| Signature removed. Please have a positive iq. |
xShinigami3125 said: I love both the anime and the manga but it's really hard to compare the two cuz the current arc in the manga is my favorite one so far. But if I compare the material that was adapted by s1 I would say the anime was slightly superior cuz even muratas god like art couldnt keep up with the errection that some of the fight scenes in the anime gave me. But i would argue that he keeps improving so who knows whether or not s2 ll be able to keep up. So I ll only be able to answer unabigiously once s2 comes @uninstallthegame why did you write @me? cuz you know what's up, obviously, mate :-) |
|
| YES (still waiting 2nd season though). |
| Moved from Anime Discussion |
Swagernator said: @NoLiferSoul did nothing wrong! Ardanaz said: @Nolifersoul did nothing wrong |
| *take a few selected shot where the manga does better than the anime* *actualy only compares one and then throw in shit without comparing to the anime* hey guys OPM manga is better deg said: exept jojo most mangas look worse with colors imoif only the manga is in full color then there is no doubt its better |
| JoJo mangas have horrible color, but One Punch Man is better |
 |
More topics from this board
» Live Action Movie gets new writers (Rick and Morty writer and creator)OvergrownRover - Apr 14 |
2 |
by Kadano
»»
Yesterday, 12:40 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Nov 8, 2015 |
346 |
by Mobesho-SAN
»»
Apr 22, 2:24 AM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Dec 20, 2015 |
986 |
by larryfirst
»»
Mar 28, 5:27 AM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 25, 2015 |
337 |
by Mobesho-SAN
»»
Mar 18, 12:48 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 6, 2015 |
791 |
by Jiborjas
»»
Mar 13, 8:22 PM |