| @fraideii: You're welcome~ always glad to make your butt feel good. ^w^ |
Nekomimi_MeganeMar 1, 2017 10:50 AM
      |
| @fraideii @Nekomimi_Megane Please no fighting in the threads. |
| Ok I've generated some ideas for playing with data more on GA+. I only did some brain storming on this so some of these ideas might not be that great :) I'm hoping this might start a little discussion on the current graphs and lists in GA+ as some could be in better formats (for instance I don't think a pie chart is the best format for the "Favorites types" graph). I also think it's odd that the ratings page doesn't have a rating by year graph but that can instead be found on the "Favorites" page. I also would LOVE to see more flexibility in graph styles. It would be awesome to have Pie/Bar/Line tabs on the pages with graphs and you could view them in any of those of your choosing. As for new graphs and lists, I tried to think of all the data points we have at our disposal. Please chime in if there's more than I could think up! The data we have is: Genre, Studios, Year aired/released, our ratings, MAL "Type", source (LN, manga, etc.), producers, material rating (PG, R+, etc.), and the data found on the MAL stats tab. So some charts or lists I'd like to see: 1) More data that compares us to the MAL community. this would pull a lot from the MAL stats tab. The only thing currently in GA+ that compares us to others is the rating difference on the "Anime List" page. You could add columns here so it would read left-to-right: Title -> Rating -> Difference -> Total users completed -> users dropped -> etc. etc. Also, it would be nice to have a chart/graph that compares some things on our favorites pages. Something like adding columns to the Favorite genre and studios lists that have a % of other MAL users. For example: #1 Drama (C/M/W/Time) then "% of other MAL users that have drama as #1" or some percentile/weighted/popularity score related to that. Same would go for studios, I think it would be neat to quantify how well liked, by scores, Sunrise studio is across the whole community or at least those registered into GA+ for example. 2) More data with Time as a variable. For example; how I rate Dramas over time (this would have to be based on start/complete dates so if that can't be done I'd understand). But we could also have how we rate genre by year aired/released. You could see that you liked older drama series over newer as an example. You could also do this with studios, types, sources, etc. etc. 3) I'd like more flexibility on the History page of GA+. I've been using MAL regularly for 5 years now so there's solid data of Completed by Year (not just month), or recent history to extend beyond 3 weeks (looks like MAL only keeps 3 weeks though). Or a graph showing completed by month spanned over the past year+. Or average episodes/entries/completed per day/month/year. That's all I have for now! |
AholePonyMar 1, 2017 10:41 AM
| I'm just curious, is there any reason that 80s and 90s anime are under one achievement (classics) instead of having separate achievements for each decade? |
| @Tpfang56: Because there is absolutely no need to have them separated. Two achievements for the same thing is an overkill, and would just unnecessarily clog the page. |
Tpfang56 said: There's an achievement for really old anime (before the 80s) and not there's an achievement for old anime (80s and 90s). Considering the amount of anime released in those two decades and their similarities there isn't any point in separating them.I'm just curious, is there any reason that 80s and 90s anime are under one achievement (classics) instead of having separate achievements for each decade? |
  |
NeedSomeLogic said: A tier could be like "did you just assume my gender"A manga achievement for the gender bender genre. It's pretty specific and doesn't have an Insufficient amount of material (1,158 total) nor does it have too many titles. |
 "For the sake of humankind, I forsake my humanity." - Cherry |
Inuchiyo said: Already rejected. Check the master list before posting.NeedSomeLogic said: A tier could be like "did you just assume my gender"A manga achievement for the gender bender genre. It's pretty specific and doesn't have an Insufficient amount of material (1,158 total) nor does it have too many titles. |
| Maybe I'm asking too much but since there is a GAR achievement can we get a MOE one too? And like with the GAR achievement people can nominate animes for that category. Edit: also maybe a bizarre or parody achievement? |
RuuryMercuryMar 5, 2017 10:53 PM
wow not even an explanation? well... you are the bosses so... |
thanks I had read the thread before making the suggestion but apparently I missed those. My bad. |
| Mahou Shoujo Lalabel and Zetsumetsu Kigu Shoujo: Amazing Twins should be added to the mahou shoujo achievement list |
 |
| @NotDolphy: That goes in this thread: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1595766 |
| @CameronM @EMPERATRIX is gonna abduct you ;) |
Not gonna lie, you deserve it. |
CameronM said: Can we get an achievement for watching Gender-Bender anime? Prepare thy backside for my hammer of justice. |
| These should be added to the current "I like them long" achievement list https://myanimelist.net/anime/13163/ https://myanimelist.net/anime/1735/ https://myanimelist.net/anime/16906/ |
ShojoSamuraiMar 26, 2017 11:29 AM
 Are you the bloody applause monkey? Keep your sh*t comments to yourself or go troll on 4chan. |
| @ShojoSamurai: Looking at the source file for the achievement, it seems that it no longer requires a custom list. But thank you in any case. |
| Hello, you should add 1-2 thresholds to 'Long runner' and 'Old Anime'. Thanks. |
 |
| @Kezian: for the Old Anime, there was a poll and it was voted that there will be no more levels, but the current one was increased from 10 to 25. As for the Long Runner, absolutely not, the number of available titles is very low, and it is very difficult to obtain it as it is anyway. |
| @Kezian: that's just super pointless though, given how low the number required is. |
| In fact, this, is my real problem: I can't see my progress for achievement with only one level. It could be nice to show them all, even if we are at level 0. Edit: Just saw the pending suggestions "— progress for the achievements in which the user has not yet attained the first level, displayed as a progress bar with a lock badge;" So, +1 |
KezianApr 22, 2017 4:54 AM
|
| @Kezian: there you have it. I can't guarantee on the time that will be implemented though, but please be patient for that. :) |
| I know that you can see the franchises that you have completed but I would like to see a list of the anime series that I have seen that are only 1 season and do not have OVA's or shorts, in other words I would like to see a list that shows anime that are not in any franchise in my list. |
 |
| Right now for the two long runner achievements, anime is set to 100 episodes and manga to 15 volumes. There are not many anime with over 100 episodes and heaps of manga with over 15 episodes, so I was thinking that either episodes be moved down to 60 or manga volumes increased to 25-30. |
 |
| @Aassdddai: The anime achievement was already reduced from 150 to 100, so absolutely not. As for the manga, that was also reduced from 20 to 15. Increasing it to over 20 is also out of question, but it might go back to 20 as it was before. |
| @Half_Bl00d in the case of achievements, isn't counting volumes wrong? I mean I have manga (s?) with: - 131 chapters & 15 volumes - 67 chapters & 14 volumes - 87 chapters & 18 volumes Not every manga has the same number of chapters per volume. |
| @Wannabiteme: You don't seem to know how manga volumes (tankoubons) work. All tankoubons of all manga have a generally similar page count of ~200 pages. There are of course exceptions, but they are few. Thus it is completely natural to for them to have a different chapter count, since chapter length greatly varies between different manga. As an example you have Dogs: Bullets & Carnage and Shokugeki no Souma which have 9-10 chapters per volume of about 20 pages each (and most weekly manga in general), or you have Pandora Hearts and Kuroshitsuji which have 4-5 chapters per volume of about 40 pages each (and most monthly manga in general). Same goes for the light novels, with an example of Accel World with ~10 chapters per ~220 page volume and Black Bullet with ~3 chapters per ~220 page volume. As you can see, counting volumes is the most universally fair and correct way, since volume length is universal, regardless of the chapter count. |
| @Half_Bl00d so, 1 volume = ~200 pages, interesting. We learn something everyday. Thank you! |
| One suggestion, as I didn't see it listed, is to be able to sort/filter by genre in the listing of anime/manga when looking at your list on the site |
 |
| @elkensteyin: but you can already see which titles go towards which genre in the Favorites tab. I don't see the need to duplicate the feature. |
| In the Ratings tabs, would it be feasible to list the average episodes/chapters per title alongside highest mean and most common episode/chapter count brackets in the Ratings vs. episode/chapter count tables? |
| Why the new Yuuki Yuuna titles are still not included in the Mahou Shoujo achievement boggles my mind, considering I've seen the suggestion appear some months ago. |
 |
| @JPthugnificent: to unboggle your mind, if you haven't noticed Deiv's updates aren't really an often occurrence. We're keeping good track of the lists, just wait for a while until they're updated on the site. |
| OK, I've checked out the List of Suggestions topic and I'm really excited to see the rest from the "Approved Suggestions" implemented. Thanks for all your hard work! Now, I'm not going to suggest anything regarding genres and stuff, but I'd like to suggest something for future badges that you'll be using for the "Approved" and even the "Pending" suggestions in case they get implemented. Would it be OK if you'll use characters from newer anime to appear in the badges for future achievements? Like, for example, a badge with a picture of Rem from Re:Zero in it. (Maybe for the future achievement related to reading light novels, or something else.) So yeah, just a minor suggestion though. :P Thank you! >_< |
| @LunyRed: You're welcome. :) As far as the badges go, we usually go for the most iconic series within the theme, so they may or may not be new, but we will take it into consideration for the further ones. For the specific light novel one, as far as I personally would like to oblige to that suggestion, we already made those months ago and sent them over to Deiv, so the chances of changing them are slim, sorry. :/ |
| @Half_Bl00d: Oh I see. That's fine. :) Based from my understanding, the 3 remaining suggestions from the "Approved Suggestions" list already have their badges finalized, is that correct? In that case, that's alright. :) I'm looking forward to see those implemented soon. If changing the badges is a no-go, then maybe it would be fine to suggest the badge idea for the list from the "Pending Suggestions"? There are plenty of them, but after reading the suggestions here, I found an achievement which I think could be appropriate for a badge with Rem. Since it's still in the "Pending Suggestions" list, there might still be a chance that this one little suggestion could go into the "Approved Suggestions", and that the Rem badge could see the light of day. If this suggestion ends up getting rejected somehow, at least I'm happy that I was able to express my idea. |
LunyRemJun 19, 2017 2:47 AM
| @LunyRed: I like this one. XD As far as I remember, we haven't made any badges from the pending section yet (at least the rewatches one for sure), so I'll take this into consideration. :3 |
| @Half_Bl00d: Awesome! XD I'm glad you like my idea. ^^ I hope the Rem badge (along with this achievement) will come true someday. :3 |
| If the franchise list with titles included in them is viewable, why not add a list of titles not included in any franchise? or at least the number of titles not included in franchises? |
More topics from this board
Sticky: » Custom List MaintenanceHalf_Bl00d - Feb 28, 2017 |
11 |
by TheM4ngaMan
»»
Feb 3, 4:32 AM |
|
Sticky: » Support ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Deividas - Apr 20, 2015 |
737 |
by GaOMn03
»»
Jan 27, 3:42 AM |
|
» List of Series Used for the Achievement BadgesHalf_Bl00d - May 13, 2020 |
0 |
by Half_Bl00d
»»
May 13, 2020 6:37 AM |
|
Sticky: » Custom Lists [READ BEFORE POSTING IN CUSTOM LIST MAINTENANCE THREAD]Half_Bl00d - Mar 1, 2017 |
4 |
by Half_Bl00d
»»
Mar 1, 2017 2:32 AM |
|
Sticky: » ♦ LIST OF SUGGESTIONS [ READ BEFORE POSTING IN THE SUGGESTIONS THREAD ]Half_Bl00d - Feb 22, 2017 |
2 |
by Half_Bl00d
»»
Feb 22, 2017 4:36 AM |