❌ Invalid Challenges

CathJ said:
Ni-hiki no Sanma is not a game or unknown adaption comedy anime.

CathJ said:


- Shirayuki does not have yellow/gold eyes.

- Jinrui wa Suitai Shimashita have been started before the day of your post (Jul.15.2016)

- Naomi Sawamura wears a sport uniform (school and sports related uniforms are not valid for this requirement)

- Space☆Dandy have been started before the day of your post (Jul.15.2016)

AYOSHINA said:



Oups ! Moved it to PG-13 rating.



Oups :P One of them has been replaced by Howl no Ugoku Shiro


My bad again... I made a switch ! Now it looks like this :
Watch an anime that first aired in Spring Re:Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu
Watch an anime with the "Supernatural" tag Higurashi no Naku Koro ni


I don't remember where I read it but I'm pretty sure we can be "50 episodes short" on this challenge and I was up to date when I turned-it in... oups just realised I forgot to update MAL. I'm at 843/846 (and I was at 843/843 when I turned it in) but it was marked 820-ish so the 50 episodes rule should've worked)


OK

Akai_Shuichi said:
@AYOSHINA @AngelShiva AngelShiva is right about Conan. It is stated under the "All"Requirement in gray... you know, the small letter in the contract, lol.

orzeszka said:
Sorry for those problems, i usually delete my history from time to time because after some time I can't find things I want and I mess up everything by myself, so it's only for my convenience. I didn't think about checking and thought u look only at those days on MAL, sorry.
I will watch something new to the January Challenge as it's still open and as i can't prove i watched something on December, should I delete the post, right? Because i don't have any idea to solve this.

AYOSHINA said:


Sorry for the late reply. For whatever reason, I haven't been receiving any mention notifications T_T Anyways... like I said previously, inspectors usually check the members MAL list and history to validated entries. Since January isn't over, you still have time to complete the January Monthly Challenge and for December, unfortunately we won't be be able to awards any points so it's completely up to you if you want to delete the post or not.

CathJ said:

- Aria The Origination have been used twice (once in winter, once in fall)

DarkPasquale said:
Challenge:ONE PIECE EXTRAS CHALLENGE
Version: All
Start Date : --
End Date: 01/11/2107
Post Link: Here

Jhiday said:
Challenge: Comedy Challenge
Version: Upgrade to Hard
Start Date: 2016-10-12
End Date: 2017-01-17
Post Link: Link

Upgrading From : Medium
Upgrading To : Hard

Zenit said:

Challenge: The People Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: 20 July, 2016
End Date: 17 January, 2017
Post Link: Here

AudioTsunami said:
Challenge: Demographic Challenge
Start Date: 6/25/16
End Date: 1/18/2017
Link: here

Shanayaaa said:
Challenge: Adaptations
Version: Easy
Start date: 20/10/2016
End date: 17/01/2017
Link: Here

TahZin said:
Challenge: Historical Challenge
Version: Easy - 1st time
Start Date: Aug 17, 2016
End Date: Jan 19, 2017
Post Link: POST

Wyvern22 said:
Challenge: ⛄ Special-Per-Day Challenge ⛄
Version: Hard
Start Date: 21.12.2016
End Date: 19.01.2017
Post Link: Link

(Note: I'd always been updating every 2 or 3 days until the admin notify me that in these cases (challenges per day) i have to update every day so after that i started. That was on Jan.03.2017 so everything before that might not have the same date as i register in the post)

Felixp said:
Challenge: January 2017 Challenge
Version:
Start Date: January 1st
End Date: January 21st
Post Link: January 2017 Challenge

Phil_Murray said:
Challenge: The Comedy Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Jan 2017
End Date: Jan 2017
Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1560539&show=100#msg49398476

Phil_Murray said:
Challenge: The Fantasy Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Jan 2017
End Date: Jan 2017
Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1567953&show=100#msg49398459

Ayato said:
Challenge: Comedy Challenge
Version: Easy
Start/End Date: Before Club
Post Link: Here

purplepinapples said:
Challenge: Mecha Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Jan 21, 2017
End Date: Jan 21, 2017
Post Link: Link

purplepinapples said:
Challenge: Slice of Life Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Jan 21, 2017
End Date: Jan 21, 2017
Post Link: Link

RachelPanda said:
Challenge:The Adaptions Challenge
Version (If applicable: Easy/Medium/Hard | Winter/Spring/Summer/Fall):Easy
Start Date:Aug 30
End Date:Dec 30
Post Link: # 64


if #4 on 4-koma counts, then medium as well
Challenge:The Adaptions Challenge
Version (If applicable: Easy/Medium/Hard | Winter/Spring/Summer/Fall):Medium
Start Date:Aug 30
End Date:Dec 30
Post Link: # 64

YumeNoTsukii said:
Challenge: Special-per-day Challenge
Version: Medium first time
Start Date: Dec.06.2016
End Date: Dec.25.2016
Post Link: #43

*forgot to turn-in

Ennetsu said:
Challenge: 2016 Anime Watching Challenge 2nd Completion
Version: Easy
Start Date: 01/07/2016
End Date: 12/31/2016
Post Link: Link

AYOSHINA said:




☢ I must be blind as a bat cause I'am... Unable to located your'Easy' entry in the user completion list.

AYOSHINA said:


☢ Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex - The Laughing Man - Tachikoma no Hibi ― MAL list states that you started/completed the series on 12/17/17 instead of 12/18/17.

Ennetsu said:


No problem, it's here: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1469513&show=0#msg44080038

Part 4., 7th line :)

YumeNoTsukii said:

Ok, i think i can explain this. I've watched it on 12/18/2017, but i had problems with my internet when i wanted to add this one. So i asked a good friend of me to add the special on my list, but she doesn't have the same time zone (she's from canada, so 5 hours after me) You can confirm it with her.

CathJ said:
@AYOSHINA
Yes, I confirm. I added her special on her list, but completely forgot the time zone.

CathJ said:

- Kemeko Deluxe is adapted from a manga.

*Your link for Boku no Hero Academia leads us to the wrong anime.

CathJ said:


- Overlord: Ple Ple Pleiades (OVA) is not from Madhouse.

DarkPasquale said:
Challenge:ONE PIECE EXTRAS CHALLENGE
Version: All
Start Date : --
End Date: 01/11/2107
Post Link: Here

CathJ said:
I can not find following animes in your list:
One Piece Movie 3: Chinjuu-jima no Chopper Oukoku
One Piece Movie 7: Karakuri-jou no Mecha Kyohei
One Piece: Nenmatsu Tokubetsu Kikaku! Mugiwara no Luffy Oyabun Torimonochou
One Piece: Straw Hat Theater
One Piece: Episode of Luffy - Hand Island no Bouken
[url=https://myanimelist.net/anime/16468]One Piece: Glorious Island/url]

CathJ said:
@DarkPasquale
If you have watched them, you just have to add them in your list and it's will be okay.

CathJ said:


- Junya Sasaki doesn't have pink eyes.

CathJ said:


- REACH x Thermae Romae: Pietrada no Kekkon is not 15+ minutes long (total)
- Birthday Boy is not 15+ minutes long (total)
- Oni is not 15+ minutes long (total)

Pourmesomepink said:
Challenge: Slice of Life Challenge
Version (If applicable: Easy/Medium/Hard | Winter/Spring/Summer/Fall): Easy
Start Date: 1/2/17
End Date: 1/2/17
Post Link: ♥

Lilviscious said:
Challenge: Collections - Series Challenges: Hetalia
Version: Full version
Start date: jan.02.2017
End date: jan.03.2017
Link: Here!

Zenit said:
Challenge: The Adaptions Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: 15 June, 2016
End Date: 3 January, 2017
Post Link: Here

bloodfire00 said:
Challenge: Comedy Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date:Before club
End Date:1/3/2017
Post Link: Here

RachelPanda said:
Challenge:Sports Challenge
Version (If applicable: Easy/Medium/Hard | Winter/Spring/Summer/Fall):Easy (Style 2)
Start Date:Jul 16, 2016
End Date:01/05/17
Post Link:#46

Challenge:Sports Challenge
Version (If applicable: Easy/Medium/Hard | Winter/Spring/Summer/Fall):Medium(Style 2)
Start Date:Jul 16, 2016
End Date:01/05/17
Post Link:#46

Yveske31 said:
Challenge: January 2017 Challenge
Version N/A
Start Date: 2-1-17
End Date:5-1-17
Post Link: hatseflats

AngelShiva said:
Challenge: The Alpha-Seasonal OVA Challenge
Version : Winter/Spring/Summer/Fall
Start Date: BC
End Date: 2017/01/05
Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1530669#msg46829450

AngelShiva said:
Challenge: The Series-Per-2Days Challenge
Version : Easy
Start Date: 2016/12/19
End Date: 2017/01/07
Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1508372#msg46829613

Wyvern22 said:
Challenge: ⛄ The Fantasy Challenge ⛄
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: BC
Post Link: Link

Akai_Shuichi said:
Challenge: January 2017 Challenge
Version: -
Start Date: January 1st, 2017
End Date: January 8th, 2017
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1581137&show=50#msg49168123

Wyvern22 said:
Challenge: ⛄ The Historical Challenge ⛄
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: BC
Post Link: Link

DarkFaerie said:
Challenge: Specials Exposure Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: 1/11/2017
Post Link: Here

Note: I was grandfathered into being able to use previously watched, as I had posted my challenge before the "No previously seen allowed" rule went into effect. Here is my answered question in regard to the rule before it had gone into effect.

Dakenfromvault1 said:
Challenge:January 2017 Challenge
Start Date:01/01/2017
End Date:12/01/2017
Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1581137&show=0#post41

KenApplepi said:
Challenge: Romance Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Jan 13, 2017
End Date: Jan 13, 2017
Post Link: here

Izarapaw said:
Challenge: Comedy
Version: Easy
Start Date: 1st January 2017
End Date: 2nd January 2017
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1560539&show=100#msg49169089

Upgrading From: Easy
Upgrading To: Medium

HeatherMystic said:
Challenge: January 2017 Challenge
Version: N/A
Start Date: January 1st, 2017
End Date: January 12th, 2017
Post Link: Here

JayArcher said:
Challenge: Adaptions Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: May 30, 2016
End Date: January 13, 2017
Post Link: Link

Ferentarius said:

Wyvern22 said:
Challenge: ⛄ The Comedy Challenge ⛄
Version: Hard
Start Date: 18.12.2016
End Date: 14.01.2017
Post Link: Link

AYOSHINA said:


☢ Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu: Spinout! Sore ga Bokura no Nichijou ― not listed under the 'Adventure', 'Drama', or 'Magic' genres.
☢ Usagi Drop Specials ― series links to Watashi no Coffee Samurai: Jihanki-teki na Kareshi.
☢ Danchigai Special ― not listed under the 'Shounen' tag and is listed twice.

AYOSHINA said:
☢ Yuu☆Yuu☆Hakusho: Meikai Shitou-hen - Honoo no Kizuna ― not listed under the 'Fastasy' genre.

AYOSHINA said:
☢ Muramasa ― less than 15+ minutes.

AYOSHINA said:
☢ Neko Ramen ― your MAL list showcases that series was completed on 11/07/16 which is prior to challenge start date.

AYOSHINA said:




☢ One More Time, One More Chance ― less than 15+ minutes.
☢ Shitcom ― less than 15+ minutes.

AYOSHINA said:


☢ Your turn-in is vaild, but the post link provided doesn't link to your challenge post.



☢ Ghost in the Shell: Arise - Border:3 Ghost Tears ― MAL lists showcases that you updated this on 10/18/16 instead of 10/19/16.
☢ Ghost in the Shell: Arise - Border:4 Ghost Stands Alone ― MAL lists showcases that you updated this on 10/18/16 instead of 10/20/16.
☢ Kaze Tachinu ― MAL lists showcases that you updated this on 10/29/16 instead of 10/30/16.



☢ Vampire Hunter D ― Start/End dates says 11/20/17 but the date for the last update showcases 11/19/16.

AYOSHINA said:



☢ Kantai Collection: KanColle ― not listed as a Visual Novel or Game.

CathJ said:


- FLCL is not 2 - 5 episodes.

CathJ said:


Not invalid, just the link of following anime leads us to the wrong anime:
- Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
- Dragon Ball Z

AYOSHINA said:



☢ Hotarubi no Mori e ― your MAL list showcases that series was completed on 05/31/16 which is prior to challenge start date.
☢ Toradora! ― your MAL list showcases that series was completed on 06/19/16 which is prior to challenge start date.
☢ Brotherhood: Final Fantasy XV ― TV types, OVAs with 4+ episodes, and movies are the only types allowed.
☢ Kotonoha no Niwa ― your MAL list showcases that series was completed on 05/30/16 which is prior to challenge start date.
☢ Tonari no Totoro ― your MAL list showcases that series was completed on 06/19/16 which is prior to challenge start date.
☢ Ame-iro Cocoa ― your MAL list showcases that series was completed on 06/19/16 which is prior to challenge start date.

☢ Tanaka-kun wa Kyou mo Kedaruge ― is used twice.

RachelPanda said:
@AYOSHINA

I did my sports challenge that way because I changed the challenge type from type 1 to type 2(that wasn't offered at the time the challenge was created), after type two was made available. The 10 italicized make Easy 10/10 then I added another 10 to complete Medium 20/20. This is how the others work that are similar. Am unsure why they are not both counted.

DarkFaerie said:

Changed Baka to Test Spinout to Tegamibachi: Hikari to Ao no Gensou Yawa (Adventure).
Fixed the link for Usagi Drop Specials.
Danshi Koukousei no Nichijou link for Shounen tag fixed, no longer goes to Danchigai Special.

Edit: Entry resubmitted.

Wyvern22 said:
Alredy fixed for Shuffle!.

Alredy fixed for Hotaru no Haka.

I move some options to fill all the requierements.

Akai_Shuichi said:
@AYOSHINA You're indeed right. I had the wrong link even in my profile. Sorry for the extra trouble. For whatever's worth, I fixed my turn-in post.

KenApplepi said:


Sorry I didn't notice, I changed the entries so it should be okay now, thank you for your work :)

The_White_Wolf said:
@AYOSHINA
Hey AYOSHINA,

About that:




I don't see anything wrong here....
That's my time zone


Would you mind telling me what's the Problem?
Maybe I tinkered with the scores a little bit, but that's very unlikely, because normally I set a score once and I would only change it if I re-watched the entire series and even that never happened...
So.... I don't get it... Especially Ghost in the Shell: Arise - Border:4 Ghost Stands Alone makes no sense to me...
Anyway, thanks for checking.
Have a nice day and I hope to hear again from you.
-Wolf

Wyvern22 said:
@AYOSHINA, I was checking my turn-in challenges and i saw that you invalid my romance challenge entry and you didn't mention it in here
But after that i checked it and found what was wrong so i alredy replaced it for Tasogare Otome x Amnesia: Taima Otome.

Zenit said:

Swapped with Shingetsutan Tsukihime

Dakenfromvault1 said:
@AYOSHINA

sorry, here the correct link https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1581137&show=0#msg49167730

Yveske31 said:


☢ Brave Story ― not found on your MAL list.

Fixed it
@AYOSHINA

JayArcher said:


When I first started that challenge the start date was allowed to be any day after the challenge was created on May 2, 2016, as can be seen in some of the earlier posts in the thread, so most of those should still qualify correct? Or do I need to change them even though the "start date being the day you post" rule hadn't come into effect yet?

Final Fantasy Brotherhood was just me being unobservant though so I changed it to Bayonetta: Bloody Fate

Izarapaw said:


I'm unsure what to do because the quote says I used Tanaka-kun wa Kyou mo Kedaruge twice but actually there's small differences in the titles as one is the actual show and the other is a series of shorts (which all adds up to 15 minutes).

@AYOSHINA

AYOSHINA said:




In May 2016 the clubs 'start date being the day you post' came into effect so unfortunately I would still consider this turn-in invalid unless @riho88riho states otherwise since a lot of the older members were grandfathered in when some of the clubs rules/guidelines changed.

JayArcher said:


Sure thing. I'll wait and see if @riho88riho has anything to say as I just found a couple more of my uncompleted challenges from June 20th that also have earlier start dates and I had never seen the rule before until I came back from taking an anime break near the end of June , so it may not have been added to the older challenges at that point. Lanblade even has a post after mine in one of the challenges talking about the rule being called the July 1st rule. *Edit* I just noticed the specials exposure challenge has the "Start Date Rule" listed as taking effect as of July 1, 2016, so that is likely why my Adaptions challenge from June 20th has the earlier start date. *Edit*

And frankly I`m just lazy and don`t want to have to hunt through 30 challenges to see which anime will cause this problem again and which won`t, if I may not have to.

Rinarin said:
Challenge: Movie Timeline Challenge
Version: ---
Start Date: June 30, 2016
End Date: January 23. 2017
Post Link: Here.

Nekoutsu said:
Challenge: January 2017 Challenge
Start Date: January 1, 2017
End Date: January 26, 2017
Post Link: here

thriwien said:

Challenge: SLICE OF LIFE Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before club
End Date: January 29, 2017
Post Link: Here

Challenge: ROMANCE Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before club
End Date: January 31, 2017
Post Link: Here

Ritshiro said:
Challenge: Adaptions Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: May 31, 2016
End Date: January 29, 2017
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1506711&show=0#msg46270180

-Eien- said:
Challenge: Reviewed Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Oct 31, 2016
End Date: Jan 29, 2017
Post Link: Here

Ayato said:
Challenge: Dementia Challenge
Start Date: January 8th, 2017
End Date: January 30th, 2017
Post Link: Here

- Akatsuki no Yona is in you ''Watching'' list.

CathJ said:

- Tekken is not a movie.