| I want to know if you want idol anime where the idols have a lover just like some do in real life. I mean we already have everything in that genre from idols suffering and even going through training that is pretty much torture (and somehow they keep coming back for more almost like they have Stockholm syndrome) but we don't have any idol anime where the idols are dating some guy or gal. I just want to see this occur in anime and see what happens (probably nothing will happen), but hey at least it will prove that such an anime can be made without incident or controversy. |
 |
| Doesn't Japan have some golden rule that female idols aren't allowed to have boyfriends and have to stay virgins (or at least pretend they are)? |
Paul said: Doesn't Japan have some golden rule that female idols aren't allowed to have boyfriends and have to stay virgins (or at least pretend they are)? Some agencies don't mind as quite a few are married, but there are still are agencies that don't want them dating. |
|
| What is the point? It wouldn't gather BD DVD sales since dem idol otaku want their waifu to be pure. |
 |
| No, i prefer female characters, so them having a bf would kill the waifism lol |
   |
Hoppy said: Paul said: Doesn't Japan have some golden rule that female idols aren't allowed to have boyfriends and have to stay virgins (or at least pretend they are)? Some agencies don't mind as quite a few are married, but there are still are agencies that don't want them dating. Don't think I've ever heard of a female idol getting married while still an idol, only retired ones and males idols. |
| I would honestly love it if more female idols in anime were dating male idols. They're both idols so they're both still pure and there shouldn't be a problem with them "not being for everyone anymore" because the person they're dating is also an idol. Idols shouldn't date commoners, though. |
  |
tr1ckst3r said: What is the point? It wouldn't gather BD DVD sales since dem idol otaku want their waifu to be pure. It's better to have the anime out there than to have a good idea go to waste. zombie_pegasus said: I would honestly love it if more female idols in anime were dating male idols. They're both idols so they're both still pure and there shouldn't be a problem with them "not being for everyone anymore" because the person they're dating is also an idol. Idols shouldn't date commoners, though. I do like idea of male and female idols dating, especially since people sometimes ship them anyway, but I also want to see a common highschool or college guy dating them as well. |
|
| That strictness on being pure and single while you are an idol is pretty sad in my opinion. Girls deserve to be happy and have a life outside of the idol world... irl. In anime? To hell with human rights! I want to ship all the girls with myself and an official parter is to big of a hindrance to my fantasies |
 |
| In terms of the idea I don't care, but in the way you presented just to prove a point no. Because then it's less a relevant point in the show and more of an added on gimmick. Unlike all of the other scenarios you presented in which it shows the struggles the characters go through. So if there were an accurate scenario in which an idol gets caught dating somebody and has to say shave their head and try to work their way back up in their idol group (which is something that actually happens) that's more of an interesting idea than "why doesn't every character date somebody because they can?" |
| most agencies have dating ban rules. and even if they didn't, fans would riot if they find out their pure aidoru was with some other dude. they get mad even if they find out she had a boyfriend BEFORE joining a group. a lot of these girls can't even upload pictures hanging out with male friends. wota are terrible. but they bring in the $$$ and that's all that matters to the agency. they aren't going to change it if it means losing the fans that spend lots of money. so that's most likely not going to happen in idol anime. but i do want the dating ban rule to go away and yes i would like girls in idol anime to have boyfriends or girlfriends. if they manage that it will probably have to be a secret s/o i think... |
deimoscodeOct 12, 2016 5:39 PM
 |
| There was this manga I read a while ago.. Forgot the name but basically it was about this guy who was dating a gravure idol and they had to keep it a secret. Both ways are fine honestly, but I would prefer the reasoning behind the no boyfriend rule have less to do with a "pure" image and more to do with no time for romance. |
...better to be hated for what you are than loved for something you are not. |
| I'm a shipper so I'd like it if there are a few or so that do. But sadly that would never happen. |
| yes! if the BF is the MC. :D ................................. |
The world is cruel, ugly and pitiful. Let's watch anime and make it colorful |
| I would like it if they were real people and not pretty perfect pure princesses, yes. I miss you, Satoshi Kon. You made the one good idol anime. |
| So, something like another White Album? |
| Yes!!!! That would make idol anime watchable so hell yeah |
| It wouldn't bother me, but it's not something I'm going to advocate for or seek out. I watch idol anime for the performances and to watch the characters grow, so as long as it doesn't distract from that I don't mind. Or hey, maybe they could go the extra mile with it and make a story of forbidden love between two idols. The industry won't allow it. Their fans would never accept it. The paparazzi would never give them a moment to be together alone. Alas, all they can do to suppress their passionate feelings is to communicate through the songs they sing. The lyrics are promises to each other, to one day be together! |
 |
| Will never happen. The only thing you might get is a self-insert male mc with an idol gf/harem. |
 |
| The marketing point of idorus is that they're meant to be pure and untouchable. Otherwise, they'd just be ordinary singers. |
| Honk Honk |
Hoppy said: I want to know if you want idol anime where the idols have a lover just like some do in real life. I mean we already have everything in that genre from idols suffering and even going through training that is pretty much torture (and somehow they keep coming back for more almost like they have Stockholm syndrome) but we don't have any idol anime where the idols are dating some guy or gal. I just want to see this occur in anime and see what happens (probably nothing will happen), but hey at least it will prove that such an anime can be made without incident or controversy. I always wanted some actual romance in idol anime. Honestly, Macross Delta gave me what I wanted in that regard already even though it's not an idol anime per se. |
| As long as they're interesting characters. |
| Be thankful for the wisdom granted to you. |
EcchiLordMamster said: No, i prefer female characters, so them having a bf would kill the waifism lol But wouldn't it be fine if it's female idols and their girlfriends? |
| fuck off mate, they have to be pure. pandapandapandapanda |
╮ (. ❛ ᴗ ❛.) ╭ |
flannan said: EcchiLordMamster said: No, i prefer female characters, so them having a bf would kill the waifism lol But wouldn't it be fine if it's female idols and their girlfriends? not that into yuri, but that would definitely be fine lol.... @Fuchsia gorilla they come and kill you wit bananas ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) |
|
| I wouldn't mind if their significant other would be of the same sex ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) |
   |
| Only if they date someone from their own group |
 |
| It's harder to fap if their in a relationship. |
  ♦ Anime List ♦ Manga List ♦ Friend Request ♦ Message Me ♦ DeviantArt ♦ |
| https://myanimelist.net/manga/89608/Idol_na_Kanojo_to_Wotaku_na_Boku_to https://myanimelist.net/manga/57467/Hime-dol MAKE IT HAPPEN! i don't know about shoujo thou.. i tough they love things like this.. |
 "If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on." |
Kuma said: https://myanimelist.net/manga/89608/Idol_na_Kanojo_to_Wotaku_na_Boku_to https://myanimelist.net/manga/57467/Hime-dol MAKE IT HAPPEN! i don't know about shoujo thou.. i tough they love things like this.. I wouldn't mind one of those being adapted. |
|
| Screw the idols have to be single rule. I want my ships. They don't have to force a boy/girlfriend when it's not needed. |
| Depending whether I ship them a not or whether I feel they're a good pairing a not too. Additional points are both of their individual characters. |
 |
| If it meant that the manga and song Sarishinohara would have the chance of getting an anime adaptation, then yeah. The story was based on a scandal with one of JKT48's member being found out that she was in a romantic relationship. |
 |
BRB-kun said: I'm a shipper so I'd like it if there are a few or so that do. But sadly that would never happen. ^ Pretty much this. Outright boyfriend from the very beginning? Nah. But a ship that sets sail from the beginning to end? Yes pls. |
| of course not!! if they want one, just stop being an idol and go get a real life |
 |
More topics from this board
» Waifu War V5 (Anniversary-Edition!) (Semifinals) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Minkalex - Sep 28 |
798 |
by HebeGroomer
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» anime cutscenes or openings in gamesLittleStar - Oct 28 |
15 |
by Fario-P
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» What would you like to see in isekai? ( 1 2 )Absurdo_N - Oct 10 |
70 |
by Guilmon1
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» What's an anime you'll always defend?RealClutch - Oct 28 |
48 |
by Guilmon1
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» Engrish is dying in AnimeDragevard - Yesterday |
9 |
by JaniSIr
»»
18 minutes ago |