| https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1538132#msg47884000 Just an FYI but this https://myanimelist.net/anime/9865 is supposed to be 1 episode--just the unaired Ore-sama Nikki episode. Because the other two merely gather all the previous "bits" of their "story" already broadcasted during the main anime and puts it back to back. No new footage was made and nothing was edited down so it doesn't qualify as a part of the ep count; it doesn't even qualify under the "recap" stipulation due to everything being retained. I posted in the DB change req thread to have it corrected but mods have been slow at addressing all change reqs. |
MysticGoose said: Suggesting New Challenge/Collection Challenge Name: Hunter x Hunter Collection Points: Requirements/Rules: Same as other collections Format/Criteria:(0/8) Hunter x Hunter Hunter x Hunter OVA Hunter x Hunter: Greed Island Hunter x Hunter: Greed Island Final Hunter x Hunter Pilot Hunter x Hunter(2011) Hunter x Hunter Movie: Phantom Rouge Hunter x Hunter Movie: The Last Mission Badges:Hunter x Hunter (2011) There's already a Hunter x Hunter collection: here. o-o Also, I wanna comment @Akai_Shuichi . Amazing job on the new scoring system and thank you for the hard work! I'm just imagining the HoF scores tumbling down now. . |
KreyulSep 23, 2016 2:56 PM
| I'm so thrown off by the 4th episode in this for the Hetalia Collection. I have it marked as completed but then I noticed "Hetalia Fantasia". I found everything else for this collection perfectly fine but I cannot find this particular episode anywhere. |
 Eat your hamburgers, Apollo. |
DarkFaerie said: I'm so thrown off by the 4th episode in this for the Hetalia Collection. I have it marked as completed but then I noticed "Hetalia Fantasia". I found everything else for this collection perfectly fine but I cannot find this particular episode anywhere. i got u fam |
| A few days ago I watched this for my movie per day movie. At the time, it was tagged as a Movie that consists of 1 episode with a duration of 57 minutes (the release I watched was actually one 54-55 min long file/episode). Used to be like this. Now a few days later, it's tagged as an OVA that consists of two 28 min episodes. I've noticed this happening to some other stuff I've watched, too, but since it wasn't for per day challenges it didn't really affect me. Should I just mention this on my challenge post? It used to be tagged as a movie when I watched it and there's not much I can do now to fix it. (I'll just re-tag it as complete since I've technically watched it, they just split the entry in 2) |
Rinarin said: Yeah, just throw in a spoiler at the bottom with that image and explanation.A few days ago I watched this for my movie per day movie. At the time, it was tagged as a Movie that consists of 1 episode with a duration of 57 minutes (the release I watched was actually one 54-55 min long file/episode). Used to be like this. Now a few days later, it's tagged as an OVA that consists of two 28 min episodes. I've noticed this happening to some other stuff I've watched, too, but since it wasn't for per day challenges it didn't really affect me. Should I just mention this on my challenge post? It used to be tagged as a movie when I watched it and there's not much I can do now to fix it. (I'll just re-tag it as complete since I've technically watched it, they just split the entry in 2) Since I didn't see any other objections to the points, I'll now go ahead and update for 'em. This will be a significant decrease - as such, all banners previously made will be removed (temporarily, until the user has re-earned the points) from the HoF. |
 β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
Akai_Shuichi said: I'm just tagging everyone who's in the admin list plus a couple more users who were, without their own knowledge (haha), implied on my point counting for the different challenges, but everyone is free to voice their opinion, make suggestions or whatever. A lot of what I'm going to explain right now has subjective things, and by no means I think my opinion is absolute. I did try to think the subjective challenges a bit and make them so that they give a correct amount of points for their difficulty. ................... That's awesome akai_shuichi. Thank you very much for giving us the explanation. I'm glad this new calculation doesn't reduce my point ^^ |
chitochitoSep 26, 2016 4:35 PM
 |
abystoma2 said: Ah yes, please do! ^-^Is it okay to update the points in challenge threads now? |
β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
| By the way, I haven't forgotten about GAR points, but I'll have to think a bit for that one and I'll be especially busy until late next week, so I'd rather think about those points when I'm more free.... I don't think anyone will complete that anytime soon anyways. |
 People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
| Don't know if this has been brought up, but what about a -dere challenge? Tsundere, Himedere, and the like. The only problem is, I don't know if there is a list out of there that categorizes them, so I don't know many shows there are. |
 |
| @Astrate https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1526338#msg46816899 |
You all need to watch Nami. |
| Just a suggestion and for whenever there's time (and for whoever volunteers, not just for Riho!)... I've always thought the Shoujo Ai should have an Oniisama e... badge. I mean, it is THE series that you are forced to watch to complete the challenge... I've thought that pretty much since the challenge was created, but never actually suggested it until now that I'm watching the series. |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
| @GamerDLM About that Kindaichi Collection... I'm actually interested in watching Kindaichi because I'm a crime fiction fan, but as you said, the main series is incomplete. I've seen the Returns seasons only. When you say that it has the 150 episodes, are you counting the incomplete series? If so, sadly I think it shouldn't count as a Collection. If it manages to get to 150 episodes without incomplete material, then I would at least give a +1 to the suggestion, while leaving the incomplete material as bonus. But if it doesn't get to 150 episodes without incomplete material, sadly I have to say that I wouldn't accept it as a Collection (though it's not my decision to make). |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
Akai_Shuichi said: @GamerDLM About that Kindaichi Collection... I'm actually interested in watching Kindaichi because I'm a crime fiction fan, but as you said, the main series is incomplete. I've seen the Returns seasons only. When you say that it has the 150 episodes, are you counting the incomplete series? If so, sadly I think it shouldn't count as a Collection. If it manages to get to 150 episodes without incomplete material, then I would at least give a +1 to the suggestion, while leaving the incomplete material as bonus. But if it doesn't get to 150 episodes without incomplete material, sadly I have to say that I wouldn't accept it as a Collection (though it's not my decision to make). Yeah I was counting the incomplete series, with just the returns and the subbed specials/movie it hovers around 50 episodes with less than 10 entries. But at at the very least it could be a very far down the line collection since it releases around 10 episodes per year. It kinds of related to another collection option down the line I was thinking of submitting being Dr. Slump which recently got a weekly fansubber. But in both of those cases a delayed release until the series finishes should be fine. |
| It's kinda the same scenario than Captain Tsubasa, which I actually informally suggested a couple months ago. They'd be very valid collections, but they're incomplete in terms of subs. |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
| "Watch romance anime from a studio you know less than others " This is really subjective and I don't really know a "studio I know less than others". I think it should be changed for somehting like an 80s anime or something (plenty of romance there). |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
Akai_Shuichi said: If you use MAL graph it's pretty obvious which studios you watch less - true the checking won't be easy but I don't think its out of the range of doing."Watch romance anime from a studio you know less than others " This is really subjective and I don't really know a "studio I know less than others". I think it should be changed for somehting like an 80s anime or something (plenty of romance there). And rather than changing, could just removoe entirely lol since there are 46 requirements and only need 45 for hard |
β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
| Lol... didn't really count them. |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
| Regarding the Romance Challenge: Watch anime that has just one season (no anime related) Watch a Stand-alone anime This seems redundant to me, as they both essentially mean the same thing just worded differently. |
Eat your hamburgers, Apollo. |
| Oh yeah, I was going to comment on that but ended up forgetting. |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
DarkFaerie said: Well... >.> I could change one of 'em but I worry about how many have already done and/or turned in the challenge with those. Soooo... again, it can be the skipped one for those that don't want to watch two stand alones XD lolRegarding the Romance Challenge: Watch anime that has just one season (no anime related) Watch a Stand-alone anime This seems redundant to me, as they both essentially mean the same thing just worded differently. |
β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
| So, for the romance challenge limited time thing, does one needs to finish the hard difficulty with a 45 new series to reclaim it or it can be done by upgrading the easy difficulty that allowed previously seen? |
 |
Punkero said: Can be upgraded since I'd assume most would do that. Basically just the first five to reach 45 regardless of them starting over or upgrading lolSo, for the romance challenge limited time thing, does one needs to finish the hard difficulty with a 45 new series to reclaim it or it can be done by upgrading the easy difficulty that allowed previously seen? |
β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
| @AYOSHINA I was checking HoF and noticed that my Scavenger Hunt #02 never got added and you swapped mine and SunflowerDaisho's names around for the Romance Challenge. o: |
Kreyul said: @AYOSHINA I was checking HoF and noticed that my Scavenger Hunt #02 never got added and you swapped mine and SunflowerDaisho's names around for the Romance Challenge. o: Whoops sorry about that. I'll fix that right away |
riho88riho said: Punkero said: Can be upgraded since I'd assume most would do that. Basically just the first five to reach 45 regardless of them starting over or upgrading lolSo, for the romance challenge limited time thing, does one needs to finish the hard difficulty with a 45 new series to reclaim it or it can be done by upgrading the easy difficulty that allowed previously seen? That sucks, I was doing it with all new entries:p |
 |
Shanayaaa said: Then move those new entries over ;D that's the good thing about it, regardless of which method ya started with, ya can always switch between when the "final decision" is made haha. Aka, add 'em to ya easy as you work on upgrading it~riho88riho said: Can be upgraded since I'd assume most would do that. Basically just the first five to reach 45 regardless of them starting over or upgrading lol That sucks, I was doing it with all new entries:p |
β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
Thank you so much! ^^ |
| I also appreciate that! @SheyCroix Though right now I'm changing computers so I'm quite busy moving data... I don't think I'll be able to update my badges and stuff at least until monday. |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
riho88riho said: Punkero said: Can be upgraded since I'd assume most would do that. Basically just the first five to reach 45 regardless of them starting over or upgrading lolSo, for the romance challenge limited time thing, does one needs to finish the hard difficulty with a 45 new series to reclaim it or it can be done by upgrading the easy difficulty that allowed previously seen? Wait, we can upgrade from Easy to Hard with using the previously completed series? I thought it had to be 45 new entries this whole time lol! I assumed that since it said previously completed cannot be used for medium or hard. xD |
 |
| I've said a couple of times that's something that should be written in the rules. If I hadn't read the conversation where that was decided it was going to be that way (when we only had the magical girls challenge), I would probably also assume it would be against the rules. |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
Akai_Shuichi said: I've said a couple of times that's something that should be written in the rules. If I hadn't read the conversation where that was decided it was going to be that way (when we only had the magical girls challenge), I would probably also assume it would be against the rules. Yeah, I was definitely in the mindset that, say for a challenge that requires 20 Easy/30 Medium/40 Hard, I could use 20 I already watch for Easy, then had to watch 70 different anime for Medium and Hard. So just to be clear, we can start off with 20, then watch 10 to upgrade to Medium, and 10 more to upgrade to Hard? |
|
| That's it. @MillieAndretti90 |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
| @abystoma2 : with the new season, a bunch of creator/theme-based challenges need updating. The ones I noticed : Gundam Universe - Mobile Suit Gundam: Iron-Blooded Orphans 2nd Season is now airing and should be added to Post-Disaster subsection. - Gundam Build Fighters Try: Island Wars (formerly "Gundam Build Fighters Try OVA") has aired and should be moved from "Bonus" to the "Gundam Build Fighters" subsection Macross - Macross Δ has finished airing. Bones - Show By Rock!! Short!! has finished airing. - Show By Rock!! # & Bungou Stray Dogs 2nd Season have started airing and should be moved out of "Bonus" section. Brain's Base - Endride, Cheer Danshi!! & Servamp have finished airing. - Watashi ga Motete Dousunda is now airing and should be moved out of "Bonus" section. - Also, this recap should probably be added too. Kyoto Animation - Hibike! Euphonium Movie: Kitauji Koukou Suisougaku-bu e Youkoso has been released on disc and there are some decent subs of it, so it should probably be moved out of "Bonus". Ditto for Musaigen no Phantom World Special. - Hibike! Euphonium 2 is now airing and should also be moved out of "Bonus". noitaminA - Battery has finished airing. - Fune wo Amu is now airing. Shaft - 3-gatsu no Lion has started airing and should be added to the challenge. Thanks in advance ! |
| Slightly - you can still only use previously seen ONCE. Whether you upgrade it or leave it be is up to you, but you cannot use previously seen for easy, upgrade to medium, then start a new "easy" with previously seen - that isn't allowed. So the amount of new content you have to watch is the same - just whether you use the 20 previously seen as a stepping stone to med/hard OR to get that easy badge done and knocked out of the way is up to the user. I'll go ahead and get that ruling clarified in a bit now that the graphics are back and it isn't a mad rush to replace 'em all XD haha. |
β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
This is an awesome idea, but: Sports Challenge - Watch an anime with a character voiced by your #1 listed favorite voice actor/actress You probably meant voice actor challenge, and by "#1 listed favorite voice actor/actress" do you mean voice actor listed for the challenge or listed in you favourite people list? Since some users don't have voice actors in the 2nd 1. But the first one requires users to start the voice actor challenge itself, so maybe something more plain like "watch anime with character voiced by your favourite voice actor" might be better. For 52 Weeks Challenge maybe something like "complete a tv series within a week" might fit better. Also, what about Scum, Hint and Unrated Challenges (or others that might be missing)? Unrated with the * exception. |
| You all need to watch Nami. |
abystoma2 said: Thanks, glad ya like the idea ^-^This is an awesome idea, but: Sports Challenge - Watch an anime with a character voiced by your #1 listed favorite voice actor/actress You probably meant voice actor challenge, and by "#1 listed favorite voice actor/actress" do you mean voice actor listed for the challenge or listed in you favourite people list? Since some users don't have voice actors in the 2nd 1. But the first one requires users to start the voice actor challenge itself, so maybe something more plain like "watch anime with character voiced by your favourite voice actor" might be better. For 52 Weeks Challenge maybe something like "complete a tv series within a week" might fit better. Also, what about Scum, Hint and Unrated Challenges (or others that might be missing)? Unrated with the * exception. I fixed the VA suggestions both the challenge title and took ya suggestion for the requirement. Changed the 52 weeks to ya suggestion as well - went with 11 eps originally because the 52 weeks challenge requires the series to be over 11 episodes (with the few exceptions), but the within the week matches the challenge better =D Added Scum and Unrated. For Hint, wasn't sure how to make a requirement for this that didnt sound the same as the Recommendation challenge >.< |
β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
| "Watch anime reccomended to you by MALgraph, AniDB Hints or animerecs"? |
| You all need to watch Nami. |
| Mk ^-^ will added, thanks~! |
β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
| https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1479031#msg48295104 "Lupin III (2015): Italian Game" has not been released with English subs yet so it should be in Bonus as there are RAWs. So the new totals of 6+35+1+4=46 rather than 48 (I think the total count wasn't modified for the "Lupin III (2015) Specials" that were added as they have the New flair). Here's my turn in to show the new format to reflect that: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1479031#msg48295104 @abystoma2 |
riho88rihoOct 26, 2016 8:02 AM
| What would happen if the voting for the monthly challenge ends up in a tie? Would both people that entered the submissions win and everyone has a choice between which one they wanna do, or something like that? I'm sort of curious, seeing how this month's votes are very close. |
|
MillieAndretti90 said: Normally I have my real life friend (who's in the club but not active) vote as the tie breaker. Usually tell him which two are tied and to pick one from those two. Last time I did that I did it a few days early and it turned out to not be needed hahaWhat would happen if the voting for the monthly challenge ends up in a tie? Would both people that entered the submissions win and everyone has a choice between which one they wanna do, or something like that? I'm sort of curious, seeing how this month's votes are very close. I like the idea of giving the option of one or the other though. Might do that just to keep it fair =o we'll see where the votes are at on Monday. |
β
Scavenger Hunts β
β Hi-Score Challenge β β Represent AWC Club β β Anime Watching Challenges Club β |
| https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1538132#msg47145769 Minor corrections >>>>>-- [X] Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex 2nd GIG - Individual_Eleven there is an unneeded underscore _ between individual and eleven >>>>>Staying as a Collecting instead of upgrading to a challenge should be "Collection" rather than "Collecting" https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1538132#msg47146764 >>>>>-- [X] Urusei Yatsura: Haru da, Tobidase! Should be with the other entries. This item is subbed and is the only "Special" in the giant English subbed torrent on BakaBT for the main series (whose like the only sub group for the main series anyway). MAL has it listed as 2 eps but that's incorrect, it's just 1 hour long special with two parts. I submitted a change req for it. No idea how long it will take a mod to fix but so I left it as 2/2 on my list and will naturally correct it once MAL makes it x/1. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1479556 FYI, the code is out of date. IDK if y'all maintain it or it you need to just get rid of it. Since the code can already be found if someone just quotes the post. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1495458#msg45352524 >>>>>>>-- [X] Fate/kaleid liner PrismaβIllya (TV: 10 ep) the url links to d. gray man instead of illya @abystoma2 |
riho88rihoNov 2, 2016 12:10 PM
| Can we make the per-day challenges have no completion limit (like the 52 weeks challenge) ? It's literally my only motivation to watch extras (non tv-types).. |
| @ToosokaRin @riho88riho I think the Fantasy Challenge and the criterias look good after a quick look, but while the badges are series tagged as Fantasy, I'd use something a bit more representative of the genre... a couple of examples: Berserk Lodoss-tou Senki Slayers Claymore Juuni Kokuki Utawarerumono Tears to Tiara Densetsu Yuusha no Densetsu Ookami to Koushinryou Akatsuki no Yona Zero no Tsukaima Guin Saga |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
| https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1492223#msg45222965 >>>[X] Prince of Tennis: Pairpuri Bringing this up again. While Pairpuri has been completely subbed. Episode 3,4,5 are missing in action. The 2SE-subs! group is composed of 2 girls. The one I was able to reach via email said the other had the original files and dropped off the face of the internet years ago. So the only viable way to getting their release is some random fan from way back of the day comes forth with them. Ergo, this entry should be put into Bonus. And perhaps a little grey note: (if you have 2SE-subs!'s English subbed episode 3,4, & 5 please PM a mod). Since this is a prime location for missing-english-release awareness and someone might actually come forth since this club has exploded with the # of members since founding this year. https://myanimelist.net/anime/29697/Prince_of_Tennis__Message_in_a_Bottle Is missing from the list. It is available online with no English (only Chinese subs or no subs) so this would be good for the Bonus area too. Riho: please go ahead and make the changes, @abystoma2 <3 thanks! |
riho88rihoNov 7, 2016 5:56 AM
More topics from this board
» 100 Episodes Challenge ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )riho88riho - Apr 27, 2016 |
391 |
by KarmaSlyr
»»
28 minutes ago |
|
» π£ HiScore II γ Batch 141: MAR 14 | Sign Up B.141 until MAR 27 γ ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SheyCroix - May 1, 2021 |
6982 |
by ewhfweihvie
»»
53 minutes ago |
|
Sticky: » π Challenges Turn-Ins (v.3) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SheyCroix - Nov 1, 2021 |
8855 |
by Ultima_Oblivion
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» Scavenger Hunt #05 [Thief Set] ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )riho88riho - Sep 8, 2016 |
342 |
by EyezOfNine
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» Scavenger Hunt #08 [Thief Set] ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )riho88riho - Oct 24, 2016 |
334 |
by EyezOfNine
»»
2 hours ago |