Erased
| It's not even anime of the season, much less of the year. After all that salt of the three final episodes, is funny to read this thread.  |
 |
| Mob psycho will rekt everything |
| > Erased > Best anything KEK Sorry, no. Its a mess. An unintelligible mess that is as subtle as getting hit in the face with a shovel. Erased joins the trash like Death Parade and Parasyte as shows that had some promise and interesting concepts but ended up being completely incapable of accomplishing anything worthwhile Best anime of this season has got to be Rakugo. With KonoSuba, Sekou Boys and Galko being close behind. That's not saying much considering the rest of the shows that started this season. |
 |
| 8/10 for me. Most my favorite anime seem to come from Spring season...I'm hoping that pattern will continue. I think people that are overrating this anime are just incapable of noticing the obvious. Anime was super predictable and did some really silly things. I also think people are overrating it because most everything else this season has been pretty average. |
 |
| There are already like 3 shows from this season alone that are better imo (ajin, haikyuu 2(ep 24 was better than the whole of erased) and shouwa) |
| Don't even joke about this, seriously. Rewrite should be probably the best candidate for AOTY (If 8bit doesn't mess up) |
| Already could have predicted it at ep 4 or so, but... Anime as good as this only come every 2-3 years. So yeah for me it will be AOTY most likely. |
| Everyone who tries to impliy that Erased is AOTY is at least mildly delusional , especially considering we haven't even finished the year yet get a grip, guys |
MightyM16Mar 24, 2016 6:48 PM
| Now that it is over and I got to see the ending, it is my AOTS at least. I can't say if it will be AOTY because lots of good shows seem to be coming out the rest of this year, but ERASED is definitely going to be one of my favourites of the year. I am partial to any anime that tells a complete, succinct story in one season with a satisfying ending. So that gives it big points for me. Other people are talking about shows better than ERASED coming out, so if that is true, I look forward to hoping something dethrones it for me by the end of the year :) |
 |
Murasa22 said: Don't even joke about this, seriously. Rewrite should be probably the best candidate for AOTY (If 8bit doesn't mess up) I watched a play through of the VN it is a lot of content to be adapted From what I've been told it would need 2 and possibly 3 cours of 24-26 episodes to have a good adaptation |
 |
terminador_2397 said: Murasa22 said: Don't even joke about this, seriously. Rewrite should be probably the best candidate for AOTY (If 8bit doesn't mess up) I watched a play through of the VN it is a lot of content to be adapted From what I've been told it would need 2 and possibly 3 cours of 24-26 episodes to have a good adaptation But it has a pretty high probability of at least 1 cour of 24 episodes happening, then another one with 13 or 24 since its Aniplex + Key who is producing. Except for Air, all the previous adaptations from Key had 24+ episodes and this situation is no different at all. I've played the VN so I'm aware that it might goes bad if things get messed up with the pacing but 8BIT isn't a bad studio, they can pull this off with the right people doing the right job. Also, its pretty much confirmed that they're going with the Omnibus format for this adaptation so the chances are not low. |
Murasa22Mar 24, 2016 6:14 PM
Murasa22 said: terminador_2397 said: I watched a play through of the VN it is a lot of content to be adapted From what I've been told it would need 2 and possibly 3 cours of 24-26 episodes to have a good adaptation But it has a pretty high probability of at least 1 cour of 24 episodes happening, then another one with 13 or 24 since its Aniplex + Key who is producing. Except for Air, all the previous adaptations from Key had 24+ episodes and this situation is no different at all. I've played the VN so I'm aware that it might goes bad if things get messed up with the pacing but 8BIT isn't a bad studio, they can pull this off with the right people doing the right job. Also, its pretty much confirmed that they're going with the Omnibus format for this adaptation so the chances of are not low. Oh OK well that's another one I'm looking forward to seeing |
|
| Its not even AOTS, KonoSuba and Rakugo beats it. |
STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
ColdBreeze said: Nobody can change it anymore. Erased is the chosen anime of the season. The majority think so. And we, the minority, can only hope it's not really the best of the year. It isn't going to be, trust me |
Murasa22 said: ColdBreeze said: Nobody can change it anymore. Erased is the chosen anime of the season. The majority think so. And we, the minority, can only hope it's not really the best of the year. It isn't going to be, trust me Depends if another show can breach the top 10 or top 20 like ERASED has. That's a tall order. |
| |
| The first 8-9 episodes were very good, and followed the manga pretty faithfully. Episode 10 was fine in cutting to the culprit (since it would become painfully obvious to anime viewers if dragged out) by the end of the episode. I think there should have been 2 more episodes after episode 10 to wrap up Satoru's post-coma story. Overall, still a great anime, and deserving to be a contender of AOTS. |
| I think it's too early to say. After all, we still got a whole year worth of anime to be released! Unfortunately, I still think Shouwa Rakugo is better than Erased. |
 |
Indotakus said: I think SNK season 2 will be the best in 2016 u know it 8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15 |
ColdBreeze said: Nobody can change it anymore. Erased is the chosen anime of the season. The majority think so. And we, the minority, can only hope it's not really the best of the year. and of course the majority can never be wrong |
| Sorry Kids. Erased was a disappointment towards the end. NOT anime of the Year. Steins Gate Zero coming up in the summer will take the year by the storm. |
 |
| Boku Machi is most overrated anime of the year* would be more accurate. |
| uwotm8? This show completely derailed from its first episodes. Only the last 2 episodes are even good |
| Twitter and it's consequences had been a disaster for the human race |
ColdBreeze said: I wouldn't be surprised if they think it's the AOTY. A score of 9 is high, and maybe it will be the highest rated this year. Nvm, I don't want to believe it. They'll have forgotten it within a week, and will call something like NGNL AOTY next season. |
gabrielrroiz said: ColdBreeze said: Nobody can change it anymore. Erased is the chosen anime of the season. The majority think so. And we, the minority, can only hope it's not really the best of the year. and of course the majority can never be wrong Pretty much the reason that anime is in the rut it's in. When you can just run certain subplots or get people to watch and praise the crap out of a show just because it has certain music acts attached to it or works the faux sentimental angle for maximum and easy emotional manipulation of what I'm sorry to say are some pretty sappy people it brings the all around standard down. Then other shows that actually have good aspects that they execute well on get ignored in the mad rush to lift up mediocre series because it's not the "right ones" like a sullen girl getting beaten by their mother for the sake of a dramatic subplot. That gets me thinking, I wonder how much the live action movie emphasizes that subplot and what differences there are in approach. From what I hear it's doing way better than the TV series in about half the run time, but that's hardly surprising cause anime and the "mature block" that is noitaminA is a bloody joke. I just don't know how else to say it, but IMO the current generation of fans have some exceptionally questionable taste and don't even really seem to actually care about anything really. This show will largely be forgotten once the next hype show kicks in (probably just the one that's taking over it's time slot since noitaminA is an Aniplex hype show slot now) but it'll forever remain in the top 50 with the likes of Your Lie in April and other A-1 melodramas that worked that one angle just enough at just the right moments to manipulate enough people into giving it top notch ratings for questionable reasons. |
PeacingOutMar 26, 2016 2:26 PM
| considering the top 3 reviews of it are a 5 or less, and i gave it a 3... im gonna go with no... and you forgot that JOJOS is airing next season, so that automatically voids your statement |
| Nope. Episode 11-12 is a disaster. from 10/10 to 7/10 SnK 2 is AOTS |
 |
| Well, not for me though.. It isn't even my AOTS and considering we have several big title for the following season, so i guess it's not the best anime of 2016.. |
Reality is the lifeblood that makes a work pulse with energy. Reality itself is entertainment  |
| it isnt worth 10 in the first place. just saying the premise and cinematography make it start as 8s then keep going downfall since episode 5 and end up nothing more than average anime. |
 |
Right? This is a question that was asked way too early in the year, it's still March, almost April, there's still 8 months to go, that's 3 more seasons left this year, that's around 100 more new anime (TV and movies, no OVAs counted) until the end of the year! I couldn't agree more that this anime is FIRE, but we can't say it's the best of the year yet. Do not forget there are still many good and hyped anime to come, and that includes Shingeki no Kyojin. |
b1GZZMar 27, 2016 9:40 AM
| nah, 3rei is airing this summer so no... |
 |
| And we can't also forget that Gintama° and the second season of Haikyuu!! aired this year too, and they're better positioned in the Top Ranked chart than Boku dake ga Inai Machi, which means more people liked more them than Boku dake ga Inai Machi. So technically, according to the ratings, this isn't the best of the year already. The time that Boku dake ga Inai Machi ranked 6th is now in the past, it seems people realized it was a bit too much hype. I can't deny though, I loved this anime, for me it is truly one of the best I've ever watched. Gintama° even positioned in the SECOND spot in the ranking, which is an immensely impressive achievement. |
Gensan said: it isnt worth 10 in the first place. just saying the premise and cinematography make it start as 8s then keep going downfall since episode 5 and end up nothing more than average anime. well this is just your opinion Snk is the best action/fantasy/drama i have ever watched // erased best anime 2016? lol that anime was mediocre as fuck |
 |
tragedydesu said: well this is just your opinion Snk is the best action/fantasy/drama i have ever watched // erased best anime 2016? lol that anime was mediocre as fuck what the fuck is your taste is it b8? You have Sao Snk in favs, whatever but you bandwagon hate every other mainstream popular shit too |
| Full time redditor and fedora owner, gg |
vvvortic said: tragedydesu said: well this is just your opinion Snk is the best action/fantasy/drama i have ever watched // erased best anime 2016? lol that anime was mediocre as fuck what the fuck is your taste is it b8? people have different taste and about erased , look at the top 3 reviews they also think is shit |
|
| Wait for Berserk anime to release. The true masterpiece will replace this anime. |
| Or Attack on Titan S2 |
b1GZZ said: And we can't also forget that Gintama° and the second season of Haikyuu!! aired this year too, and they're better positioned in the Top Ranked chart than Boku dake ga Inai Machi, which means more people liked more them than Boku dake ga Inai Machi. So technically, according to the ratings, this isn't the best of the year already. The time that Boku dake ga Inai Machi ranked 6th is now in the past, it seems people realized it was a bit too much hype. I can't deny though, I loved this anime, for me it is truly one of the best I've ever watched. Gintama° even positioned in the SECOND spot in the ranking, which is an immensely impressive achievement. This show got the 5 spot in the 10 with only 7 episodes aired so i have no idea why someone would still use mal rankings to define what is the best anime of the year |
gabrielrroiz said: This show got the 5 spot in the 10 with only 7 episodes aired so i have no idea why someone would still use mal rankings to define what is the best anime of the year Well, if we're gonna say it like that then everyone is going to have a different best anime of the year, because tastes are different. What the rankings tell us is that on AVERAGE, more people liked an anime more than another, and if more people liked an anime more than another means that one anime much possibly made more money and interested more to the viewers than the other, which means it was the best. So I wouldn't see a reason why wouldn't we define the best of the year according to the rankings, if the average rating number is higher and that supposed anime has more watchers than another one, then that means if we made a poll asking what was the best, the one that would get more votes would have been the one with the better average rating and the most watchers (which are usually correlated). Am I right or not? There's some logic here. -.- Boku dake ga Inai Machi has 218k watchers and Gintamaº has almost 65k. If we made a poll, which one do you believe would be named the anime of the year? |
frequency15k said: considering the top 3 reviews of it are a 5 or less, and i gave it a 3... im gonna go with no... and you forgot that JOJOS is airing next season, so that automatically voids your statement Oh please, the review system is a joke right now. With only the option to give a, "helpful", low reviews are just pushed up from the edgelords giving it a shitty score meanwhile the more 'fair' reviews are stuck in limbo (And this goes for any anime, not just ERASED). There's no balance to it whatsoever and the admins have pretty much pushed it at the bottom of their list since its been this way for awhile. |
Touch me, you filthy casual~ |
| Coming back to this thread all I can do is laugh at the fuckery this anime became. |
| Well after all that hype the result was very disappointing, although I still consider it good with 7/10. |
| I'm feeling thank you |
| Won't even stay on the first page since it's dropping fast. It's a bit sad because the first two or three episodes were nice but after that ... nothing new. You knew who the culprit was so soon that it was impossible to be interested |
| How is it that no one else saw what this was going to become?? Extreme3708 said: Coming back to this thread all I can do is laugh at the fuckery this anime became. You and me both. |
 |
| I dont think so, the adaption is way too rush! |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Feb 4, 2016 |
769 |
by Jocku
»»
Apr 17, 10:27 AM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 24, 2016 |
1398 |
by Layreur84
»»
Apr 15, 3:50 AM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 10, 2016 |
900 |
by bakakisima
»»
Apr 12, 2:03 PM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 3, 2016 |
498 |
by bakakisima
»»
Apr 11, 1:04 PM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Feb 25, 2016 |
581 |
by bakakisima
»»
Apr 11, 12:06 PM |