Red_Keys said:
MEanimaniac1 said:
if you don't like the protagonist you'll basically hate the whole show.
This is why most harem/ecchi shows are destined for failure right from the get go.
Not necessarily because the protagonist is unlikable (although that sometimes is the case), but because the protagonist isn't the
main character.
The story isn't about
them. The story is about their experiences with various other characters of the opposite sex.
And these characters of the opposite sex get all the "attention", so to speak. They get all of the development. They get backstories. They get the most vibrant characterization. They get the most screen time.
They are the
main characters. The writers care more about them. They have the priority when it comes to characters.
But when
side characters are given more priority and attention than the
protagonist, the viewer automatically is more interested with those side characters, thus becoming bored of and not caring about the protagonist.
And if the audience doesn't care about the protagonist, than any sort of tension or drama (i.e., anything that holds the reader's interest), involving that character is instantly dissolved. And since they are the
protagonist, they are involved in
every instance of drama or tension in the story.
So ultimately, right from the start, the audience is destined to not give a damn about that story.
I'm not saying that I have a problem with secondary characters getting development, but when the "main" character has significantly
less development, or the audience cares significantly less about them than the other side characters, that character shouldn't be the main character. The ones with the most development should be the main character.
Actually, a harem anime from one of the girl's point of view would be pretty interesting. And I don't mean reverse harem, I mean like a traditional harem, but the lone guy character isn't the protagonist. He's the romantic interest, with a plethora of female romantic rivals.
In that type of story, the audience might actually
root for the main character, and actually be
happy when they get with their romantic interest, feeling satisfied and accomplished. And with lots of female love rivals, the ecchi fan-service that all the virgin perverts love could still be part of the story. Actually, with a
female protagonist, fan-service would actually be
easier to achieve (and wouldn't have the need for a male character's point of view, sparing us all the
oh so funny scenes with perverted misunderstandings and embarrassment-fueled physical abuse).
As opposed to merely watching a central character we don't care about interact with a bunch of characters we like, reducing it to picking your favorite candy out of a box of assorted chocolates.