DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this chapter. If you want to discuss future events, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
muntasir123 said: da fuck was dat ending about O.O author didn't go all the way after all the build up dissapointing.... |
 |
| WTF I don't get the ending? -.- |
| Alright. I just went through chapter 46 and the last chapter. Can't read Japanese. So, what.the.fuck.just.happened? Ayano stabbed him and a time skip occurs and the next thing, he's performing somewhere. |
 |
| A 3 year time skip?! What. And seriously, that bitch Ayano isn't behind bars? Wow. Lol, I don't even know what else to say. I'm just glad it's finally over. |
 |
| Wtf kind of an ending was that? They don't even explain why he's singing in some random place, he just is. Ok, whatever. |
| At least they ended together right? |
deprecator said: Stark700 said: A 3 year time skip?! What. And seriously, that bitch Ayano isn't behind bars? Wow. Lol, I don't even know what else to say. I'm just glad it's finally over. It wasn't a 3 year time skip after sakuta got stabbed but after they were seperated as children, so a small flashback. And yeah it amazes me aswell how she didn't get punished in the slightest after stabbing him.. just hate it that she is able to smile after what she has done Would like to see an epilogue of them getting back together after his tour but I doubt it'll happend :L No, it was a three year timeskip after he was stabbed. That was not shiroi talking about moving on and dating someone who doen't remind her of Oni-chan, it was a more grown up version of Ami. She called him Oni-chan, not Shiori. Shiroi called him Sakuta. So, three years pass; people move on; Shiori is living a healthy, respectable, and chaste life playing music for old people or teaching music to old people or something like that. Meanwhile, Sakuta is off in America living the rock star life, trying to make it on his own as a musician. Why? They both know that they cannot be together without "BEING TOGETHER", if you know what I mean... So she lives her quiet life, knowing Sakuta loves her and is out there making music, he makes his music and probably indulges in the occasional female fan who wants to "get to know the singer better", but neither will develop any lasting relationships. The only one they want is forbidden. (I expect there are occasional holidays where Shiori dresses up in the old Eve get-up and goes to meet Sakuta at some secluded cabin in the woods for a week or two of sibling bondage... I mean bonding... yeah... that's what I meant... ;> |
Now blogging at TheZenOf Mysterious Girlfriend X Anime Fan Club - It's about more than drool! Tari Tari Fan Club - Hyouka Fan Club - Chitanda Eru Fans Club~ |
zensunni said: deprecator said: Stark700 said: A 3 year time skip?! What. And seriously, that bitch Ayano isn't behind bars? Wow. Lol, I don't even know what else to say. I'm just glad it's finally over. It wasn't a 3 year time skip after sakuta got stabbed but after they were seperated as children, so a small flashback. And yeah it amazes me aswell how she didn't get punished in the slightest after stabbing him.. just hate it that she is able to smile after what she has done Would like to see an epilogue of them getting back together after his tour but I doubt it'll happend :L No, it was a three year timeskip after he was stabbed. That was not shiroi talking about moving on and dating someone who doen't remind her of Oni-chan, it was a more grown up version of Ami. She called him Oni-chan, not Shiori. Shiroi called him Sakuta. So, three years pass; people move on; Shiori is living a healthy, respectable, and chaste life playing music for old people or teaching music to old people or something like that. Meanwhile, Sakuta is off in America living the rock star life, trying to make it on his own as a musician. Why? They both know that they cannot be together without "BEING TOGETHER", if you know what I mean... So she lives her quiet life, knowing Sakuta loves her and is out there making music, he makes his music and probably indulges in the occasional female fan who wants to "get to know the singer better", but neither will develop any lasting relationships. The only one they want is forbidden. (I expect there are occasional holidays where Shiori dresses up in the old Eve get-up and goes to meet Sakuta at some secluded cabin in the woods for a week or two of sibling bondage... I mean bonding... yeah... that's what I meant... ;> Hmm your analysis made sense. So to him the incest part war too "forbidden" (I don't know the right word) so he decided to distance him self maybe well that's one way to look at the ending. I wish it would had a better ending though it felt incomplete.. |
BasaraTheSlayerMar 31, 2014 10:29 PM
 |
| This manga was so bad. |
| Rushed ending imo. Well it was an interesting read, never expected Ayano to turn yandere when I started reading this. |
 |
| How the hell is that crazy b*tch not locked up? It pissed me of seeing her smiling talking about love when she Attempted murder .The nding is annoying but realistic to be honest. They probably knew they can't be together and start a family, but they probably still love each other and date while doing their own thing. |
| Somehow I expected Ayano to turn into a yandere. What I don't get is why she wasn't arrested? |
| Fuck that Ayano bitch. I thought 2D girls were supposed to be pure? That's some 3D shit... |
| I'm a bit disappointed to see how Ayano is considered by people here and how the story turns her in a negative way. It's strange to see that the girl who wants a "normal" relation with a guy is in fact the crazy girl and normal people have a unnatural relation considered as heros. The thing is that for me Ayano suffer of mental disease and it get worst after she gave her virginity to Sakuta. That guy probably enjoyed to be with her but only for xxx business. He tried to convince himself that he loved her while he was unconsciously be attracted by his sister. Ayano probably slowly feels that Sakuta was not really in love. For example he always made a separation between her and his other friends. And that's why she turned more and more pervert! Giving her body was for her the only way she found to attract him. On most of H scenes, Sakura seems to be taking pleasure only on his own. |
| A 3 years timeskip .. nothing much ... I am just .. uh.. nevermind. Imouto grown up a fine woman !! Incest is still great !! Good for you Ayano !! Change for the better :) Shiori is still beautiful after all this years !!! Sakuta ... keep it up !!! I am glad that .. everything is really fine now :D It was a Satisfying ending .. thinking reading it again !! It was a great manga !!! although it was rushed .. Its still a remarkable one :D |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Damn, Ayano's not arrested. I was expecting her to be in some mental hospital or something together with her mom in the timeskip. What happened in chapter 43 still creeps me out. I'm disappointed with the ending. It would have been better for Sakuta and Shiori to be together, physically, as a closure. It's so boring and plain. It feels rushed and lacking. |
| I don't know why you guys are confused. Sakuta said that he'll become a man worthy of Shiori so he went overseas to start a career (and got noticed by that long hair producer). I was more surprised that the chibi Ami became such a beauty in 3 years. Puberty really does crazy things sometimes. It's a good manga, a little bit rushed at the end but enjoyable nonetheless. Didn't expect Ayano to have such a deep psychological problem (well her mom's crazy, can't really blame her) but that was a good twist. I kept wondering how it'd turn out, if it really were going down the incest route. This though, is one that I don't really mind so much (unlike Aki Sora for example). |
 |
| Why did the mangaka have to fuck up Ayano like that. She was perfect :( |
| This manga made me really sad. I feel really bad for Ayano. She was just a girl with some physiological problems who wanted to be loved by her boyfriend. As plg said she was pretty much just used for sex and for sakuta to forget about his love for his sister. She even prostituted (did she go all the way? im not sure) herself to try to buy his love. Its really just sad. There wasn't really a happy ending for anyone. Sakuta and Shiori are separated and arent even together for an unstated reason. Possibly social stigma or, as moegod said, hes trying to be a worthy man. If the later is the case, i would be much happier cause possibly in the future they could end up together after all. |
 |
| Just finished. PM if you'd like to discuss. :) |
| lol finished this whole series in one go, the manga ended in a lighter note then i'd expected. The ending itself seems so rushed, that it loses its momentum before it gets really good. The fact a time skip happens, really kills any good vibes for good or great ending, so were left with more questions or open ended questions of the "what if''s". Just somewhat glad it was a happy ending. As it comes to be, Sakuta and Ive indeed are the couple that ended together, it just they needed time to be apart so they something real together, as he told Ive that he wants to come back as a man that can accept her. Sakuta love will always be there, he took over in making music and producing income in order to help with the expenses paid on the hospital. Its the same reason Eve was pushing herself in the first place. Sadly we didn't get a indepth on Sakuta became a rock star overseas or his acquisitions to that amount of talent. If you love someone then you would what is necessary to provide for that love to grow. Good job for Sakuta to understand that and remember the reason he locked his past memory was because of the love of older sister Ive. It was truly destined for each other, the moment he loved the band "incest"(literally and as a pun). Take it for what its worth, Sakuta is living for his love and doing everything to fulfill it. Overall, I loved the manga and story premises of the manga sadly the ending and the finale seems really rushed, left more questions then answers to really close the book to the story. Thus to me this just a 6/10 for my part. Very developed main character yet left many of the side characters without any character development thus wasted of lines and roles for them. Sort of like a throw away characters not important to the development of the story. |
| The start of the manga was very appealing, but the overwhelming sexual content with Ayuno and the little to no character development from that part onwards really made the story boring and stale. The author managed to portray her in the worst possible way there was while she was such a nice and affectionate character from the very beginning to that point. The ending was really, really bad and it didn't give any satisfying feeling that you usually have when finishing a story-line. Rather than that, it was quite the contrary with the vaguely done pages. This could truly be a masterpiece, sadly it wasn't. Not regretting any time I spent on it because it had its own good points. 3/10 |
 |
psyopslayerx said: doing everything to fulfill it. This right here ... I also believe that he felt weak as he was still a high school kid and he wanted to be a strong man for his sister, to ease her burdens. That's why he left for US to become a man worthy of her. He loves her and he wants to give her all that he can. http://mangafox.me/manga/seishun_pop/v06/c046/17.html http://mangafox.me/manga/seishun_pop/v06/c046/13.html http://mangafox.me/manga/seishun_pop/v06/c046/16.html She is in love with him, she rejects all matchmaking offers because she is waiting for him to return to her after once he fulfills that promise to himself. http://mangafox.me/manga/seishun_pop/v06/c047/21.html http://mangafox.me/manga/seishun_pop/v06/c047/23.html |
| Hmm. I have a test tomorrow in my college chemistry class, but stay up till 4:26 AM reading it and had to get on MAL to see other peoples thoughts. I came across this and got hooked on the story. For the most part I thoroughly enjoyed this manga. The ending wasn't the best, but I think it was somewhat okay. Not quite sure how Ayano isn't behind bars. I feel Shiori is happy doing what she is doing and able to make a living. Sakuta all of a sudden in America about to become the next big thing, I thought that was kind of cool. They will be reunited and live happily ever after, that is for sure. Overall a good manga and would rate is 8.5/10 |
 |
Jopesanvieira said: Am I The only one who thinks that Sakuta is in a coma? When Ayano is with the doctor you can see someone in the hospital! That gig at the end could be a dream. They're not far from each other. But that can't explain the pregnancy. I don't know. I think the author forgot to draw some of the pages on the chapter 47. A lot of "explanations" are missed! Ayano is there visiting her mother who is receiving psychiatric treatment. As it's stated in that scene, yes, you are indeed the only one who thinks that. ^^ ------------------------ I actually apppreciate the timeskip since it means we get to bypass all the messy details while also giving a sense of closure. (Seriously, if the timeskip wasn't included, then the final chapter would've been him waking up in the hospital with a hole in his stomach then maybe some rehab.. and that would be about all that could fit in one chapter.) Three years is just enough time for everyone to deal with the aftermath of the last few chapters and settle in to new routines but still immediate enough that it's believable that the old gang still hangs out together even after changing careers or getting married. The "sudden" shift in Ayano was something I kinda expected tbh. I don't remember what chapter it started, but I got some serious bad vibes from her pretty early on... (But that might have to do with me having a paranoid schitzophrenic grandmother and one bonafide insane/violent ex-gf, so I'm kinda used to spotting crazy. lol) The fact that her mom was also bonkers, and that they had shared hallucinations of her father, was probably the author's way to excuse Sakuta of guilt in driving Ayano crazy since she was already far from sanity to begin with. For those who think she should've been locked up, the chances of her going to prison for what she did would be only slightly higher than having a snowball fight in Hell in most 1st-world nations. She was clinically insane at the time of the stabbing and would likely be sentenced to mental health treatment if found guilty. I also have the feeling that Sakuta probably did not press charges, which could make it difficult to prosecute especiallly given that she was legally a minor and that she only poked him once. (^^;; Seriously, the number of times DOES matter in stabbings. Lower number = less likely to do it again = more likely to not be convicted.) Since it looks like she did go through mental treatment sometime during the skip, I'm thinking that is the most likely unstated reasoning behind the result. Overall, I was pretty satisfied with how most things were wrapped up here. My interpretation of the Shiori/Sakuta relationship would be that they are still in love with each other and at least Shiori has plans to reunite at some point in the future after he's done with his tour.. Can't really say for sure since Sakuta have any related lines, but I'm guessing that is what the author intended. I am kinda skeptical of a bassist making it big solo, and he was never shown to have any talent for singing, but I can accept and move on. ... The only loose end that really has me wondering is.. what about Ayano's little brother? >_>;; Growing up surrounded by lunatics who can see/talk to an invisible Dad is probably not the best situation for a child, ya know? Far more than the 100+ texts daily from Ayano, it was his behavior/words that drove home that Ayano was scary-level crazy, and moved her out of the stereotypical manga/anime stalker-girl role and into the realm of realistic mental illness. |
 |
| Medetashi medetashi～ |
| Welp another shitty "Work over Romance" ending so fucking bad I give a 6/10 because of the wincest though, otherwise it would have been at most a 3/10 |
| Disappointing ending =/ I feel like the author was suddenly told he didn't have 10 chapters to finish the manga but 2 instead. It started out really promising but then just went all over the place later on. Out of the 3 girls seems Ami was the only relationship that might've ended in a normal romance. Bit sad they just forgot about her half way through the manga and didn't really address her feelings when she probably had the most genuine love for Sakuta. What might've worked is Ami seeing Sakuta and Ayano or Shiori making out followed by Ami declaring her feelings and running away and then Sakuta confronting her to tell her how she meant to him in a family way. Sakuta really did seem to care deeply for her so who knows maybe an ending where he ends up both sister characters or Sakuta resolving his relationship with Shiori into a normal family relationship and falling properly for Ami? I feel really sorry for Ayano but felt like she just went loopers quite quickly. Their relationship was cute until the crazy H stuff but even then it somehow seemed to be working for a while. I think there should've been some event that suddenly drove her love into a total obsession/Yandere mode. I just think she could've been more developed like adding more flirty scenes between Sakuta and Shiori after they started dating which she saw and then you could show her being bothered by it and slowly changing her, instead of her suddenly stalking him and ringing him 24/7. I glad he did dump her in the end cause the relationship had just turned really toxic, not just for Sakuta but also for Ayano as she was pretty much going into prostitution and her mind just seemed to be getting worse. Seems like she got a mostly happy ending which is nice but there was so much that could've been addressed. The ending for Shiori was really weak and didn't feel quite right. Her mum dies so she becomes really unstable and withdrawn fearing Sakuta would leave her all alone. Then suddenly she gets tricked into going on stage for a solo concert out of the blue that none of the other band members know about but media and fans do?? Why? Surely the producer would want her to be able to sing and make lots of albums and whatnot. I just can't see how it was going to turn out well for the producer aside from nuking their biggest talent. Sakuta suddenly remembering that he loved his sister when he was 5 and therefore wanted to screw her then and there felt so forced. So what if he had a crush on his sister when he was 5. I doubt he really understood much at that age and yes most people don't remember much from when they was 4 or 5. It's quite normal. I feel like it was rushed to finish the manga as the editors wanted to cancel it. They then decide that it's better to be happy and live together regardless of everything. it was established that both characters feared being alone more than everything and 3 years later they're living apart? I just don't get it. Could be the editors wouldn't allow a full incest ending like with oremo? I really wanted to see more of the relationship between them with Sakuta slowly falling for her in the aftermath of their mum dying and a proper showdown with the producer |
| Welp...it was a really enjoyable manga up until the last few chapters, especially the two last ones which was just rushed "shock" value, it's a shame because I felt like Ayano was a really good character at first I'm hesitant to try other romance manga by this author now :/ |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Seishun Pop! Chapter 37 DiscussionStark700 - Jan 20, 2014 |
10 |
by Enn00
»»
May 8, 2020 12:37 PM |
|
Poll: » Seishun Pop! Chapter 46 DiscussionStark700 - Mar 24, 2014 |
17 |
by Belle-Air
»»
Jan 26, 2020 9:51 AM |
|
Poll: » Seishun Pop! Chapter 42 DiscussionStark700 - Feb 24, 2014 |
9 |
by Farabeuf
»»
Aug 18, 2019 11:18 PM |
|
Poll: » Seishun Pop! Chapter 41 DiscussionStark700 - Feb 17, 2014 |
7 |
by Farabeuf
»»
Aug 18, 2019 12:56 PM |
|
Poll: » Seishun Pop! Chapter 35 DiscussionStark700 - Jan 6, 2014 |
9 |
by Farabeuf
»»
Aug 13, 2019 1:33 PM |