Otaking87 said: You did put a lot of work into making it, but not conveying it so people could understand. It should probably be like this.LordSenate said: Otaking87 said: read my sig to see how i rate I refuse to read that jumble of crap.. i put alot of work in to my system i rate critically not like most here or like this My 11 main things i rate on
Though I don't know what a "Ka" is. And what is the "stuff" that it shifts, also your music section(11) is confusing. |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| My mean score is only 5.37 because I use the full ten point rating scale and legitimately dislike a lot of shows. Heck, if I was watching more mediocre anime each season or didn't rate relative to the quality of an average anime, it'd be somewhere in the 4.00 - 4.99 region. Better to only give out high scores when they're deserved, no? |
 |
| people think they're cool because they give lower scores or something tbh if you go to movie sites no one scores that harshly tho but cause of all of the wannabe tryhard reviewers who think their opinion matters people on mal score stuff lower |
| ~"The place to improve the world is first in one's own heart and head and hands." (Pirsig) |
Sic said: My way of rating goes; plot/characters/theme = enjoyment/feels = some number to express said enjoyment and feels. Naturally with a heavy bias, since I only finish stuff that can hold my narrow attention span. Yeah. Homolust said: means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?lrn 2 10 point rating scale if you have a mean score higher than 5.99 then you're doing it rong This^ |
 If you really want to fit in, just put Legend of the Galactic Heroes in your top 5 and have it be the only 10-rated anime in your list. |
| I put more importance to story in my rating, enjoyment and all the rest of stuff you could as a basis for a rating don't play such a big role. I'm not obsessed with my ratings looking critical or as if no anime could meet my standards, with a low mean scores and their "full scale" rants. |
 |
Otaking87 said: Oh ok, now I get it.IntroverTurtle said: Otaking87 said: You did put a lot of work into making it, but not conveying it so people could understand. It should probably be like this.LordSenate said: Otaking87 said: read my sig to see how i rate I refuse to read that jumble of crap.. i put alot of work in to my system i rate critically not like most here or like this My 11 main things i rate on
Though I don't know what a "Ka" is. And what is the "stuff" that it shifts, also your music section(11) is confusing. Stuff = Merch Ka = Shorten version of manga ka |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| Like most? people here, I rate based on how much I enjoyed it. |
  |
gigglingidiot said: *I dunno if this thread has been done before. Searched for it, but didn't see anything too similar. Not sure if... |
LoneWolf said: @Josh makes me sad to call myself Canadian. |
Otaking87 said: If it's because of the word limit, then you could have made it a picture. You're allowed a 600px x 150px and 300kb picture and one line of words.IntroverTurtle said: Otaking87 said: Oh ok, now I get it.IntroverTurtle said: Otaking87 said: You did put a lot of work into making it, but not conveying it so people could understand. It should probably be like this.LordSenate said: Otaking87 said: read my sig to see how i rate I refuse to read that jumble of crap.. i put alot of work in to my system i rate critically not like most here or like this My 11 main things i rate on
Though I don't know what a "Ka" is. And what is the "stuff" that it shifts, also your music section(11) is confusing. Stuff = Merch Ka = Shorten version of manga ka and just to say i tried to covery it with more neetness but lacked sapce in sig |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| I go by whatever rating standards the site sets, so for this site everything I rate above 5 is enjoyable to some degree and vice versa. I look to ratings as a portrayal of the things a person enjoys and dislikes, so when people start mixing in objective factors like popularity, then that's hard to judge. |
| I rate based on my taste, how I liked it and my overall enjoyment. If I enjoyed it very much and the story is very good in my taste it easily gets a 10. I'm a pretty generous rating of 10's... |
Sic said: My way of rating goes; plot/characters/theme = enjoyment/feels = some number to express said enjoyment and feels. Naturally with a heavy bias, since I only finish stuff that can hold my narrow attention span. Yeah. Homolust said: means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?lrn 2 10 point rating scale if you have a mean score higher than 5.99 then you're doing it rong How does having a mean score of 5.99 mean you watch "more shit"? I don't know about you, but I also rate dropped series, rate short specials and I enjoy my 5's. |
rederoin said: How does having a mean score of 5.99 mean you watch "more shit"? I don't know about you, but I also rate dropped series, rate short specials and I enjoy my 5's. Or maybe you're just reading too much into it. You can even enjoy 2's, though I certainly don't enjoy my below 5's as much as I enjoy my 7's and 8's. These days I don't even bother to watch anything that would fall below a 7, with the exception of hilariously bad series. |
Sic said: rederoin said: How does having a mean score of 5.99 mean you watch "more shit"? I don't know about you, but I also rate dropped series, rate short specials and I enjoy my 5's. Or maybe you're just reading too much into it. You can even enjoy 2's, though I certainly don't enjoy my below 5's as much as I enjoy my 7's and 8's. These days I don't even bother to watch anything that would fall below a 7, with the exception of hilariously bad series. Reading to much into? how? I was just commenting on the fact that you seem to think that having a mean score of 5.99 means you watch more shit than good shows. |
rederoin said: Sic said: rederoin said: How does having a mean score of 5.99 mean you watch "more shit"? I don't know about you, but I also rate dropped series, rate short specials and I enjoy my 5's. Or maybe you're just reading too much into it. You can even enjoy 2's, though I certainly don't enjoy my below 5's as much as I enjoy my 7's and 8's. These days I don't even bother to watch anything that would fall below a 7, with the exception of hilariously bad series. Reading to much into? how? I was just commenting on the fact that you seem to think that having a mean score of 5.99 means you watch more shit than good shows. According to my own scale of rating, it would definitely be the case. Which's why I don't watch shit below my average. |
Sic said: rederoin said: Sic said: rederoin said: How does having a mean score of 5.99 mean you watch "more shit"? I don't know about you, but I also rate dropped series, rate short specials and I enjoy my 5's. Or maybe you're just reading too much into it. You can even enjoy 2's, though I certainly don't enjoy my below 5's as much as I enjoy my 7's and 8's. These days I don't even bother to watch anything that would fall below a 7, with the exception of hilariously bad series. Reading to much into? how? I was just commenting on the fact that you seem to think that having a mean score of 5.99 means you watch more shit than good shows. According to my own scale of rating, it would definitely be the case. Which's why I don't watch shit below my average. And everybody uses the same scale as you do? |
rederoin said: And everybody uses the same scale as you do? See me claiming that everyone does? |
Sic said: rederoin said: And everybody uses the same scale as you do? See me claiming that everyone does? "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. |
rederoin said: Sic said: rederoin said: And everybody uses the same scale as you do? See me claiming that everyone does? "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. That's to counter the point that everyone who's got above 5.99 'do it wrong', and so I speak for myself. Your point? |
Sic said: rederoin said: Sic said: rederoin said: And everybody uses the same scale as you do? See me claiming that everyone does? "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. That's to counter the point that everyone who's got above 5.99 'do it wrong', and so I speak for myself. Your point? That both your and his points are wrong. Its not a counter if the "counter statement" is also incorrect. |
rederoin said: That both your and his points are wrong. Its not a counter if the "counter statement" is also incorrect. Well, you've really convinced me. |
| This is the scale i adopted when i came across it a while ago. 10/10: All time favorite. The kind of anime that is stuck in my head constantly, that I would go back and rewatch more than happily. Impacted me more than anything, even outside of anime and in terms of all storytelling mediums I've experienced. It's impossible to express how much I loved an anime with this rating. It's something that you need to watch right away no matter what is going on in your life. It's something that should never, ever be skipped under any circumstance. 9/10: Holy shit. Stunning in every sense of the word. Beautiful, amazing. Tears may have been shed. This is the kind of anime that impacted me in such a way that I was thinking of it for many months after and which possibly even changed my mindset in some way. Everybody should watch this anime no matter who they are. It's nearly impossible to get any better than this. 8/10: Great anime, love it. Would recommend to absolutely anybody who has taste in anime and wants to have a good time. It's virtually flawless from a critical perspective and immensely entertaining. 7/10: Pretty good. An anime that I enjoyed a lot and would definitely suggest to anybody who is interested. At this rating I become a fan of the show and would give it an easy thumb up. It's not perfect by any stretch and it's not amazing, but it's either a lot of fun to watch or contains very few flaws. 6/10: A decent anime. It's not something I would openly recommend to other people but if you are interested in the style, genre, or premise of it then it couldn't do you any harm. There's some good moments here and there and it's still worth watching if you have the time to spare, though don't expect anything especially good. 5/10: The middle ground. It's essentially a huge "meh", either failing to entertain or being laden with problems. I don't hate an anime with this rating but it means that I didn't like it either. It's the lowest rating something can be given from which I can derive any semblance of enjoyment. 4/10: Bad, poor. Highly suggested to avoid. Unless you are watching to make fun of it then steer clear. The flaws outweigh anything good and the entire product is weak. 3/10: Horrible. An anime that gets this low of a rating is impossible to enjoy even ironically, being full of so many problems that you can't succinctly mention just one or two. The entire thing is a huge, stinking mess. 2/10: What the flying fuck is this shit? Words can't even properly express how painful it is to watch an anime this close to the bottom. Cringeworthy, terrible. I'd rather stab myself in the knee than watch another episode. 1/10: PLEASE, PLEASE, OH GOD KILL ME NOW. PLEASE END MY SUFFERING. PLEASE, JUST KILL ME. |
Homolust said: If you have a mean score of lower than 6, then you're not screening your anime right. If I sense that a series is about to suck big time, I drop it, which is why my mean score is 7.if you have a mean score higher than 5.99 then you're doing it rong |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
rederoin said: Sic said: rederoin said: And everybody uses the same scale as you do? See me claiming that everyone does? "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. "Shit" used in this context is slang (e.g. "That shit is the bomb." Hint: No actual shit or bombs are involved in the previous statement). Learn to read. |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
Ginko13 said: In summary:This is the scale i adopted when i came across it a while ago. 10: Simply the Best 9: Stunning 8: Great 7: Pretty Good 6: Decent 5: Middle Ground 4-1: Shit Average, how does it work? |
LoneWolf said: @Josh makes me sad to call myself Canadian. |
katsucats said: rederoin said: Sic said: rederoin said: And everybody uses the same scale as you do? See me claiming that everyone does? "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. "Shit" used in this context is slang (e.g. "That shit is the bomb." Hint: No actual shit or bombs are involved in the previous statement). Learn to read. Shit was used as something bad in that context. katsucats said: Homolust said: If you have a mean score of lower than 6, then you're not screening your anime right. If I sense that a series is about to suck big time, I drop it, which is why my mean score is 7.if you have a mean score higher than 5.99 then you're doing it rong Some people rate there dropped anime. and not everybody is using whatever rating system you're using. |
rederoinNov 10, 2012 3:27 PM
katsucats said: rederoin said: "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. "Shit" used in this context is slang (e.g. "That shit is the bomb." Hint: No actual shit or bombs are involved in the previous statement). Learn to read. Thought this was common sense, no wonder it made no sense. Props for clearing that up. |
Sic said: katsucats said: rederoin said: "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. "Shit" used in this context is slang (e.g. "That shit is the bomb." Hint: No actual shit or bombs are involved in the previous statement). Learn to read. Thought this was common sense, no wonder it made no sense. Props for clearing that up. Common sense that the word shit is not a negative word?(unless used of in the context of that the shit). Its not my fault you think everybody understands when you misuse words like that. |
rederoin said: Sic said: katsucats said: rederoin said: "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. "Shit" used in this context is slang (e.g. "That shit is the bomb." Hint: No actual shit or bombs are involved in the previous statement). Learn to read. Thought this was common sense, no wonder it made no sense. Props for clearing that up. Common sense that the word shit is not a negative word?(unless used of in the context of that the shit). Its not my fault you think everybody understands when you misuse words like that. No offense, but either English is not your first language, or you've missed out on the last 30 years of pop culture... |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
katsucats said: rederoin said: Sic said: katsucats said: rederoin said: "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. "Shit" used in this context is slang (e.g. "That shit is the bomb." Hint: No actual shit or bombs are involved in the previous statement). Learn to read. Thought this was common sense, no wonder it made no sense. Props for clearing that up. Common sense that the word shit is not a negative word?(unless used of in the context of that the shit). Its not my fault you think everybody understands when you misuse words like that. No offense, but either English is not your first language, or you've missed out on the last 30 years of pop culture... Since when was "shit" not a negative? unless its used in the context I mentioned before(that movie was the shit). Shit obviously means its a bad show or whatever. |
rederoin said: Sic said: katsucats said: rederoin said: "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. "Shit" used in this context is slang (e.g. "That shit is the bomb." Hint: No actual shit or bombs are involved in the previous statement). Learn to read. Thought this was common sense, no wonder it made no sense. Props for clearing that up. Common sense that the word shit is not a negative word?(unless used of in the context of that the shit). Its not my fault you think everybody understands when you misuse words like that. You should check this shit out, http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Shit&defid=1532411 |
| I definitely have superpowers. I can feel it in my balls. |
| It's alright, shit happens. |
| It's good shit when we all come to an understanding. |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
Karhu said: rederoin said: Sic said: katsucats said: rederoin said: "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. "Shit" used in this context is slang (e.g. "That shit is the bomb." Hint: No actual shit or bombs are involved in the previous statement). Learn to read. Thought this was common sense, no wonder it made no sense. Props for clearing that up. Common sense that the word shit is not a negative word?(unless used of in the context of that the shit). Its not my fault you think everybody understands when you misuse words like that. You should check this shit out, http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Shit&defid=1532411 So watching shit is a not a bad thing? How the godamn hell can watching shit be be a good thing? how the godamn fuck? fucking retarded bullshit |
| I'm aware people do it, but using shit in a positive context has always been, and will always be, stupid. |
LoneWolf said: @Josh makes me sad to call myself Canadian. |
| When ye watchin' shit ya really enjoy, dat shit be awesome. |
rederoin said: Well, shit...katsucats said: It's good shit when we all come to an understanding. You call this is an understanding? I call it retarded bullshit. Next time you go to a blues concert and the singer says, "Let's play this shit so funky you could smell it." Then you could revel in the fact that you're probably the only person there that's so perplexed... |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
rederoin said: Karhu said: rederoin said: Sic said: katsucats said: rederoin said: "means yer watchin' more shit ya really enjoy, whodunit wrong?" I was referring to that part, you where implying somebody with a mean score of around 6 would watch more shit than decent anime. "Shit" used in this context is slang (e.g. "That shit is the bomb." Hint: No actual shit or bombs are involved in the previous statement). Learn to read. Thought this was common sense, no wonder it made no sense. Props for clearing that up. Common sense that the word shit is not a negative word?(unless used of in the context of that the shit). Its not my fault you think everybody understands when you misuse words like that. You should check this shit out, http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Shit&defid=1532411 So watching shit is a not a bad thing? How the godamn hell can watching shit be be a good thing? how the godamn fuck? fucking retarded bullshit "This shit is my favorite anime of all time" is a sentence of honor and respect. Man, you need to go deeper. You are now just assuming that shit is shit while that's not the case. Shit can be pretty much anything. Understanding its specific meaning in different cases shouldn't be harder than understanding sarcasm. |
| I definitely have superpowers. I can feel it in my balls. |
| I automatically got more criticizing with anime as I grew sick of generic shit, which I think most people will grow tired of (not all though, of course...). |
 |
| I rate for enjoyment. There are people who do consider every little aspect of the anime when they rate, but I feel like that just takes all the fun out of watching anime. When I watch anime, I do it to get away from all the stress of school work and writing essays and analyzing things. I have no idea why people would want to do more of that than they already have to. |
Nordhau5 said: Ginko13 said: In summary:This is the scale i adopted when i came across it a while ago. 10: Simply the Best 9: Stunning 8: Great 7: Pretty Good 6: Decent 5: Middle Ground 4-1: Shit Average, how does it work? Average i would consider is your expectations and enjoyment for the genre you are watching. Like they say, its all in your opinion. To me, average would be a watchable but ultimately forgettable series. Anime that is cliche, unoriginal in concept, lacks excellence in music or art, but is enjoyable at the least is average in my opinion, which easily earns a 6 or 7. |
| i always rate based on enjoyment which can be made up of appreciation for art/music/story but certainly isnt limited to them. some stuff cannot be measured by strictly traditional means like hype, cute, or like fight scenes and such. at the end of the day enjoying a show is the most important part lol so whatever floats your boat |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Do you pay attention to forum signatures?PostMahouShoujo - 9 hours ago |
13 |
by Spunkert
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» For everyone who has signed up to this site using Protonmail, and doesn't use that address for anything elsevasipi4946 - 11 hours ago |
3 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
17 minutes ago |
|
» Plushies_Nette_ - 5 hours ago |
1 |
by KitsuFrost
»»
18 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » the future of AI girlfriend technologydeg - Yesterday |
21 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
19 minutes ago |
|
» Would you ever be interested in going on a blind date?Thy-Veseveia - Yesterday |
11 |
by LoveYourEyes
»»
44 minutes ago |