You have a variety of types in your list, and you don't give for completed shows ratings under 5, which is I think a good thing.
I can't ignore your love for Yu Yu Hakusho though, I've put it on my PTW. You could try Hunter x Hunter, it is made by the same mangaka, 1999 version is darker, bloodier, but slow and they changed lots of thing from the manga, not to mention fillers. the 2011 version is more colorful, can be dark when it needs to, more faithful to the manga and might continue to cover what the old version didn't. Both are enjoyable.
You don't seem to have a specific preference. You've watch more older series than recent. You having Natsume Yuujinchou in your favorites, as a background and you have Nyanko-sensei as a avater, but not planning to watch the rest of the series? Since you've only seen up to Zoku.
High compatibility so I'm guessing we have very similar tastes. You never stick to one genre and like a variety of genres. The main one being shounen (especially those with darker tones) but also anime with psychological thrillers and cool/bishie protagonists. Sometimes, you also switch to a more light hearted romance anime/manga.
Edit: lol ninja'd twice
Hard to tell with the short list but you seem to enjoy shounen anime with some sort of romance on the side. You also like tsundere heroines and badass characters.
Has a 76.1% compatibility with me which I suppose means you enjoy fantasy like I do. And aside from the hentai seems to watch a pretty large variety of stuff. Probably what you might call a "true anime fan" in the sense that you seem to watch just about everything. Definitely a good thing.
A very short list, that means you're fairly new to anime. You tend to watch more fantasy and some school anime here and there. You're greatly willing to branch out for other series, though it mostly consists of fantasy, romance and school anime. There's plenty I'd reccomend.
I'll give it a shot - Obviously a gamer, for one. :P You are slightly analytical about the anime you watch and appreciate anime that manage to emotionally affect you/make you think. You like anime in the supernatural, action, adventure genres.
This sort of hard. :3 Don't slap me for being too wrong.