| Erm... ' ' The number stated outside next to the name is 4, but: Nominated by : Edea_Sorceress (p43) For: songstar13 (p55) Face_Faith (p56) ahmed_great2005 (p58) MeNaK (p61) Meister (p62) |
| Sorry I took so long to reply! I read Last Game and while the lead is definately different then most shoujo heroines, she's still totally oblivious to the feelings the guy has for her. So for now, there has really been any scenes to judge her on points 3, 4 & 5 (when she'll be aware of either's emotions). I'm pretty sure that she'll turn into a cliché when she becomes aware of either his or her own feelings. That being said, she does not (currently) abide by any of the rules so I'm adding her but she can always be challenged here later on. |
 |
| I don't think that Momozono, Nanami fits the club. I've read up to chapter 41. I will try to read until recent chapters, so I won't misjudge. But so far she breaks rule #1, #4, #8. |
QualmOct 3, 2012 8:07 AM
 |
-Rollin- said: I don't think that Momozono, Nanami fits the club. I've read up to chapter 41. I will try to read until recent chapters, so I won't misjudge. But so far she breaks rule #1, #4, #8. If a character breaks any rules, reagrdless of chapter, she is disqualified. Also, 41 chapters is a lot of damn chapters. |
| Eh, I understand #8 (although she cannot really do anything if gods to something to her while she's only a human being ô.o), but #1 and #4? Not really... |
| I agree with Face_faith. Although #8 is definitely applicable, Gods or not. But hear me out: She did fight the ... erh it's been a while since I read it so bare with me... she fought the protector of that weird dude/lady neighboor by standing up to it.... Well, she does come across to me as a bit of a cliché but I also get the feeling that as stories are told, we'll get to know her better and realize she isn't. Meanwhile, I'm counting votes but it's one of those we'll have to wait till the end to truly know. Therefore, she gets 5 votes : she's in but applicable for debate later on if she becomes a cliché  Alynitca said: If a character breaks any rules, reagrdless of chapter, she is disqualified. Also, 41 chapters is a lot of damn chapters. Well, it happens that a heroine starts off as a cliché but going through hardships, she becomes stronger and those are allowed in the club but she has to become less of a stereotype slowly but from the start!! It has to be sort of a plot tool. That being said, 41 chapters is a hell of a lot of chapters and I would consider that way too (fucking) long for her character to evolve. ;) |
-BlackRabbit-Oct 4, 2012 5:04 PM
|
| Okay, I think that I'm being tough. Then, It's better to read until recent chapters OR wait till the end. |
QualmOct 5, 2012 2:18 AM
|
| One vote for Kizuna Etou from Torikagosou no Kyou mo Nemutai Juunintachi, please. The reason why I want to vote for Etou... if I may quote from Orulyon (one of the reviewer of the manga): The characters are the best. Kizuna is not a girl with a trauma, she is not enraged with life, does not have a mother or father complex. She accepts her loneliness without being too emo. She is not a crybaby and she is not a tsundere. Just a plain normal girl without being clumsy that has very realistic characteristics on her personality. you will love her straightforwardness at times, and she shows a very common type of person nowadays, which is, a person that desires money, yet, her good nature balances her character, making her not superficial, but a realistic protagonist. Admitting her mistakes, makes her very unique. Also, not the type of girl to fall in love at first sight, and does not show the"delicacy" of the typical japanese women. Not the cliché usual shoujo protagonist. I think she pretty said everything I wanted to say. Other than that, never mind. |
Edea_SorceressOct 5, 2012 5:59 PM
| I upvote Beauty Pop. |
-BlackRabbit- said: Well, she does come across to me as a bit of a cliché but I also get the feeling that as stories are told, we'll get to know her better and realize she isn't. How many chapters are you waiting for her to evolve? -BlackRabbit- said: Meanwhile, I'm counting votes but it's one of those we'll have to wait till the end to truly know. Therefore, she gets 5 votes : she's in but applicable for debate later on if she becomes a cliché That's fair. -BlackRabbit- said: Well, it happens that a heroine starts off as a cliché but going through hardships, she becomes stronger and those are allowed in the club but she has to become less of a stereotype slowly but from the start!! It has to be sort of a plot tool. Well, I've never read it before, so I won't argue. But that is some slow as hell development. -BlackRabbit- said: That being said, 41 chapters is a hell of a lot of chapters and I would consider that way too (fucking) long for her character to evolve. ;) Lol, yeah. Honestly, it amazes me how long people think it takes to get a feel for a manga. In my opinion, once you hit ten chapters or so, you've given a story more than enough time to impress you. |
Alynitca said: -BlackRabbit- said: Well, she does come across to me as a bit of a cliché but I also get the feeling that as stories are told, we'll get to know her better and realize she isn't. How many chapters are you waiting for her to evolve? I rarely judge by chapter count for this club. In my personal appreciation/evaluation, I do. I don't even give 10, I usually give 5 ch. But for this club it depends. Quite often, the leads suggested are oblivious to their own feelings. For those, I usually wait to see how she reacts when she notices her own emotions. When that happens if she starts blushing for no reason, starts crying for the littlest things, become an over cooked noodle in times of crisis and so on; well obviously, she's out. ================================ In the case of Momozono: #1_ she is not a damsel in distress (although we're led to think that because that's how the guy pictures her). But she isn't. #4_ As far as I can tell, she doesn't fall in love with the guy just because he can protect her but she hasn't fully developed her feelings just yet (hence why I want to wait). #8_ As I said before, she does get kidnap easily at first, the whole Gods and mystics being new to her but that turns around slowly when she starts catching her footing. She starts to fight back and tries to see what she "can" do given she has no clue what she's doing. Sorry for the long reply but I felt it important to mention that I don't judge after xx amount of chapter but I judge when certain things happen. Like when the lead is aware of her own feelings or in the case of cross dressing manga, they focus for so long on the cross dressing that romance usually takes a while to pop; but the post-romance behavior is the most important (also where most fail). Anyway, feel free to ask if I'm not clear :p |
-BlackRabbit-Oct 7, 2012 3:42 PM
|
-BlackRabbit- said: I rarely judge by chapter count for this club. In my personal appreciation/evaluation, I do. I don't even give 10, I usually give 5 ch. But for this club it depends. Quite often, the leads suggested are oblivious to their own feelings. For those, I usually wait to see how she reacts when she notices her own emotions. When that happens if she starts blushing for no reason, starts crying for the littlest things, become an over cooked noodle in times of crisis and so on; well obviously, she's out. ================================ In the case of Momozono: #1_ she is not a damsel in distress (although we're led to think that because that's how the guy pictures her). But she isn't. #4_ As far as I can tell, she doesn't fall in love with the guy just because he can protect her but she hasn't fully developed her feelings just yet (hence why I want to wait). #8_ As I said before, she does get kidnap easily at first, the whole Gods and mystics being new to her but that turns around slowly when she starts catching her footing. She starts to fight back and tries to see what she "can" do given she has no clue what she's doing. Sorry for the long reply but I felt it important to mention that I don't judge after xx amount of chapter but I judge when certain things happen. Like when the lead is aware of her own feelings or in the case of cross dressing manga, they focus for so long on the cross dressing that romance usually takes a while to pop; but the post-romance behavior is the most important (also where most fail). Anyway, feel free to ask if I'm not clear :p Oh, I understand. But the thing is that I don't want to wait 78 chapters to see how a heroine reacts to falling in love. There is a lot of slow-ass shoujo out there, and I just don't have the patience. Again, I'm not trying to argue; I don't know anything about this manga. I'm sure you're right. |
Alynitca said: Oh, I understand. But the thing is that I don't want to wait 78 chapters to see how a heroine reacts to falling in love. There is a lot of slow-ass shoujo out there, and I just don't have the patience. Again, I'm not trying to argue; I don't know anything about this manga. I'm sure you're right. Yeah I understand, same here... but what can I do? I'm effin dedicated to this club!  Hehe, so you can leave me a note in the admin section if you stumble on one of those manga; I'll pick it up in your stead ;D *high-5 for teamwork*  |
|
| It has been a long time since my last post,isn't it?. Have I nominated Liddell, Alice from Heart no Kuni no Alice: Wonderful Wonder World before?If not then I would like to. Also I up vote for:- Seiyuu ka Tonari no kaibutsu kun Down vote for:- No one:D |
 |
| I have a recommendation for the paranormal section, actually. How about Tokyo ESP? oAo The character is faaaar from a cliche shoujo girl- she is a complete bad ass in a good way. |
 |
| I nominate Fujoshi Kanojo. |
| My nominations: - Tanaka Kanata (14-sai no Koi) - Takamiya Naho (orange) - Kino Hime (Seiyuu Ka!) - Hori Kyouko (Horimiya) - Mizutani Shizuku (Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun) |
 |
| Thanks guys!! I'll look at your nominations soon enough :) Bare with me till xmas vacations (which in my case is probably January) - Your devoted Admin |
|
Katsura_da said: My nominations: - Tanaka Kanata (14-sai no Koi) - Takamiya Naho (orange) - Kino Hime (Seiyuu Ka!) - Hori Kyouko (Horimiya) - Mizutani Shizuku (Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun) No!!!! I wanted to nominate Takamiya Naho from Orange...I guess I will vote for her then. Other heroines I up vote for are:- 1) Ayu Tateishi(Ultra Maniac) 2)Kurata Sana(Kodomo no Omocha) |
| |
ahmed_great2005 said: It has been a long time since my last post,isn't it?. Have I nominated Liddell, Alice from Heart no Kuni no Alice: Wonderful Wonder World before?If not then I would like to. ^^ Seconded!! Can I nominate Sumiyoshi, Nobara? At first she starts off seeming kind of weak, I thought, but she gets significantly stronger as the series progresses. I vote for: Yukino from Kare Kano Sana from Kodocha Shizuku from Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun Keito from Cat Street Sachie from Arakure Naka from Nousatsu Junkie Haruna from Saruyama I downvote: Midori from Uwasa no Midori kun for a little bit of #1, #8 definitely though. Tsubaki from Kyou koi wo Hajimasu for reasons aforementioned. Ida from He's Dedicated to Roses for reasons aforementioned and Meru from Fly High for #2 |
| Still open for candidates? :) In that case, I'd like to nominate Yona, from Akatsuki no Yona [http://myanimelist.net/character/43814/Yona] Who may start out as the typical spoiled princess, but takes a proactive part in reclaiming her kingdom. Evyione [http://myanimelist.net/character/33145/Evyione] Likewise a princess, but more politically savvy, and a sholar rather than fighter. Tsukimi, from Princess Jellyfish [http://myanimelist.net/character/34973/Tsukimi_Kurashita] Haruko Nanase, from Atashi no Bambi [http://myanimelist.net/character/69371/Haruko_Nanase] and from the one-shot [http://myanimelist.net/manga/36437/Sekai_de_Ichiban_Utsukushii_Namae I'd also like to upvote Vanilla Ice's Teahee, Han as well as Kamisama Hajimemashita's Momozono, Nanami. |
 |
| I'd like to nominate: Sakashita Nanase of hanagimi to koisuru watashi .. :) Its a good read. :) |
| I want to add up: Yosano, Suzume of Hirunaka no Ryuusei |
| Hi guys, sorry for being away for so long.. Here are the club's latest additions:
Refused: Momo - Not focused on the love story (is there one?) Sekai de Ichiban Utsukushii Namae #5 and a little #2 |
-BlackRabbit-Aug 19, 2013 3:16 PM
|
| Ok, so I'm a bit of a spaz at this but I have a bunch of potential nominations I'd like to submit without wasting anyone's time. To that end, is there a spot where I can view the full list of the "currently nominated but not yet accepted or refused mangas/characters" so I can vote them up or down or do I need to parse through this entire thread? Also, is there a spot to view a full list of mangas/characters that were voted out so I don't go ahead and renominate one (I know I can see the accepted ones listed in the right column of the home page). Thank and, psyched to find this group...these types of heroines, and the mangas in which they appear are my favorites! |
| Welcome mangamaven! Glad to have you on board :) Yes, both those lists are the first post of this thread (right here) Check under the spoiler tabs :) THANK YOU SO MUCH for being willing to vote :D I'll be looking forward to your own recommendations :) |
-BlackRabbit-Aug 19, 2013 3:24 PM
|
| If you downvote, be sure to mention which rules they break (the 8 rules are listed on the image in the first post) Added:
|
|
| OK, I think I did this the right way so here we go: Manga I Nominate (add to nomination list): Shin Bia (http://myanimelist.net/character/33719/Shin_Bia) from Crazy Girl Shin Bia (http://myanimelist.net/manga/12837/Crazy_Girl_Shin_Bia) - this is not labeled shouju on MAL, but is on MangaFox (http://mangafox.me/manga/crazy_girl_shin_bia/). Hana Suzuki (Special Skill: Can go to the bathroom while asleep - lol) (http://myanimelist.net/character/13562/Hana_Suzuki) from Gokuraku Seishun Hockey Club (http://myanimelist.net/manga/350/Gokuraku_Seishun_Hockey_Club) Lee Le Ting from Steel Rose (http://myanimelist.net/manga/10818/Steel_Rose) Asuka Hirayama (http://myanimelist.net/character/41733/Asuka_Hirayama) from Kingyo Sou (http://myanimelist.net/manga/5029/Kingyo_Sou) Hanayu "Hana" Ashitaba (http://myanimelist.net/character/23251/Hanayu_Ashitaba) from Mixed Vegetables (http://myanimelist.net/manga/8573/Mixed_Vegetables) Eisul Kim (http://myanimelist.net/character/16395/Eisul_Kim) from Red Lion (http://myanimelist.net/manga/3926/Red_Lion) Lena "Ley" Ha (http://myanimelist.net/character/18818/Lena_Ha) from Saver (http://myanimelist.net/manga/514/Saver) Kobato Uehara (http://myanimelist.net/character/37767/Kobato_Uehara) from Teppen! (http://myanimelist.net/manga/10776/Teppen!) Hina "Princess" Asou (http://myanimelist.net/character/13903/Hina_Asou) from FIVE (http://myanimelist.net/manga/3140/FIVE) - I could go either way on Hina: she starts out strong but is she getting a little more stereotypical? Would love to hear what you guys think. Subaru Ooji (http://myanimelist.net/character/47481/Subaru_Ooji) from Ouji to Majo to Himegimi to (http://myanimelist.net/manga/19809/Ouji_to_Majo_to_Himegimi_to) Vote For (already on nomination list): Tachibana, Meru from Fly_High! En Nonomiya from Shiritsu! Bijinzaka Joshi Kouko Choi, Ida from He Dedicated to Roses Aoyama, Keito from Cat Street Yusa, Chiemi from Junai Tokkou Taichou Neiro Sonoda from Obaka-chan Koigatariki Nana from Othello (even if she is an alternate personality) Kino, Hime from Seiyuu Ka! Vote Against (already on nomination list): Momozono, Nanami from Kamisama Hajimemashita - love the manga, but she's kinda gone downhill since she realized she was in love. Hibino, Tsubaki from Kyou, Koi wo Hajimamasu - she's so unsure of herself and easily pushed around by her sister and others. That's all I can get to tonight. Enjoy! |
| You aced it!! :D I counted your votes... it's like Christmas! :D Cat Street only needs 2 more votes AND Seiyuu-ka ONE more vote :O Currently processing your recommendations to be added to the list :) Thank you my dear, dear, DEAR member! |
-BlackRabbit-Aug 21, 2013 7:20 PM
|
| :) |
| Have you guys seen "Hime Doll" yet (http://mangafox.me/manga/hime_doll/)? It's still early, but Samejima Alto, the delinquent main character, may be a good addition to the list. |
Selphie64 said: Yona, from Akatsuki no Yona [http://myanimelist.net/character/43814/Yona] Who may start out as the typical spoiled princess, but takes a proactive part in reclaiming her kingdom mangamaven said: Hana Suzuki (Special Skill: Can go to the bathroom while asleep - lol) (http://myanimelist.net/character/13562/Hana_Suzuki) from Gokuraku Seishun Hockey Club (http://myanimelist.net/manga/350/Gokuraku_Seishun_Hockey_Club) Hanayu "Hana" Ashitaba (http://myanimelist.net/character/23251/Hanayu_Ashitaba) from Mixed Vegetables (http://myanimelist.net/manga/8573/Mixed_Vegetables I second all of the above!! ^^ -BlackRabbit- said: Cat Street only needs 2 more votes AND Seiyuu-ka ONE more vote :O Oh goodness I haven't voted for Seiyuu-ka yet! I shall be the one more vote then! :D More votes: Hyun-Bin from Love in the Mask Machika from Immortal Rain Kajika from Hanasakeru Seishounen |
-BlackRabbit-Feb 15, 2014 5:47 AM
| Hey there! :) Hime Doll only has 2 ch... I'm willing to nominate her but there's no way I can make it pass/fail or even personally vote on it with so little material... Nominated Oupsi... no shoujo tag sweetheart ;) Note that you can request such tags here : http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=60876&show=0 For tag definition : http://myanimelist.net/info.php?go=genre Thanks MeNak, your votes have been counted. <3 Annnnd, Seiyuu-ka is IN! :D  ~Love In The Mask needs only 2 more votes~ You guys are great  |
-BlackRabbit-Feb 15, 2014 5:44 AM
|
| Nominate: Moe ( http://myanimelist.net/character/76444/Moe ), from Tomodachi no Hanashi ( http://myanimelist.net/manga/24821/Tomodachi_no_Hanashi ). She's a strong girl, and always looks out for her best friend Eiko. She is slightly possesive of Eiko, but never cries, and isn't naive. Ma Ri Baek ( http://myanimelist.net/character/87487/Ma_Ri_Baek ), from Orange Marmalade ( http://myanimelist.net/manga/54897/Orange_Marmalade ). Rarely cries. Stands tall despite all the indirect criticism she is given. Secretly a vampire. Didn't break down despite all she went through. Vote for: Yoshioka Futaba, from Ao Haru Ride Yona, from Akatsuki no Yona Kou Shuurei, from Saiunkoku Monogatari Yosano Suzume, from Hirunaka no Ryuusei Hana Suzuki, from Gokuraku Seishun Hockey Club Tachibana Meru, from Fly High! Machika, from Immortal Rain Lena "Ley" Ha, from Saver Shirayuki, from Akagami no Shirayuki Hime Nanase Haruko, from Atashi no Bambi Asou Hina, from FIVE Lys Lily, from Hanatsukihime Tsukimi Kurashita, from Kuragehime Nako Yoshino, from NanaKo Robin Naho Takamiya, from Orange Subaru Ooji, from Ouji to Majo to Himegimi Nakaba, from Reimei no Arcana |
PinkShippudenSep 21, 2013 2:05 AM
| PinkShippuden (づ｡◕‿‿◕｡)づ ╾━╤デ╦︻(രᴗര ) |
PinkShippuden said: I STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS NOMINATION. Nominate: Ma Ri Baek ( http://myanimelist.net/character/87487/Ma_Ri_Baek ), from Orange Marmalade ( http://myanimelist.net/manga/54897/Orange_Marmalade ). Rarely cries. Stands tall despite all the indirect criticism she is given. Secretly a vampire. Didn't break down despite all she went through.
|
-BlackRabbit-Feb 15, 2014 6:00 AM
| Sorry PinkShippuden & Tiffanyhng but Orange Marmelade isn't Shojo nor Josei :( Note that you can request such tags here : http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=60876&show=0 For tag definition : http://myanimelist.net/info.php?go=genre I'm ready to make an exception like I did for Crazy Girl Shin Bia but you have to convince me :) tiffanyhng : thanks for the votes and recs, I finally got around to adding your recommendations and there's one or two that really peak my interest! :O Guys it would be awesome if you could get more people to vote on these recs so we can have more Club Relations. Arigato! |
|
| I would like to nominate for Orange Marmalade because it is tagged as shoujo on other websites. I already sent a request to tag it as shoujo on MAL. Orange Marmalade is tagged shoujo on MangaHere, MangaPark, mangawall, AND stated on an MAL review as a "shoujo manga" by Kitsune-no-Yuubi. I would also like to nominate Lee Ji Woo (no MAL page yet) from Cheonsaeng Yeonbun. She is a totally strong woman. Her grandfather wanted her to settle down and get married but she wanted to work in her grandpa's company. She even went so far as crossdressing as a guy in order to work there. She never gave up her dream on becoming an independent company woman. She HAS to be part of this club. |
| Upvote for Shuurei from Saiunkoku Monogatari! She fits this club's standards pretty well I think. She's a strong young woman who takes no shit from anyone. Feminist all the way, and vying to become the nation's first female official. The only time you get to see her tears is when she's having a breakdown, and even when that rarely happens it's more jusified considering the hardships she has to endure. Shuurei and Saiunkoku Monogatari are inspiring and they both deserve to be here!! |
 (Source) |
| All counted. From the List Mania Thread : inzaratha said: Love in the Mask - gender bender Hana no Kishi - gender bender Happy! - sports Steel Rose - sports / romance Wedding - historical Spirit of the Ocean - historical Counted the 3 votes, Happy! isn't shoujo, other were added. |
-BlackRabbit-Feb 23, 2014 4:09 AM
|
| From the List Mania Thread : DorahYuki said: Saver ~ Gender Bender, Historical Love in the Mask ~ Gender Bender Votes counted |
-BlackRabbit-Feb 23, 2014 4:13 AM
|
| From the List Mania Thread : Both added. |
|
| Votes counted! Thanks a million! |
|
| Hi, I just join this club and want to recommend a character from manga I've always like since elementary. She's Sei Tominaga from Kaze Hikaru. I'm pretty surprised the manga hasn't been added since it's a pretty popular shouju manga (I think?) in Japan and has once won an award. It's been months since I last read it and my memory might not be that reliable. All I remember was she's an independent strong-willed girl who dressed up as boy to join Shinsengumi for reason not romance related. Sometimes the manga might get a little bit reverse harem-vibe but as a harem-hater I wasn't as repulsed by it as compared to others because it's not unrealistic and doesn't get all in your face, but don't take my word on it, I'm probably just biased because I just really like Taeko Watanabe. And it's not like there are many people who actually like Sei romantically (maybe three tops??? I don't really remember), just bunch of guys in Shinsengumi admiring and teasing her as a pretty boy. What I like is how serious Taeko Watanabe did her research of Japan History as the story can be pretty detailed about the war, politic, culture and the overall condition ofJapan in Bakumatsu period instead of just hot guys in Shinsengumi uniform being hot doing their job slashing bad guys. All the characters, good or bad, actually felt realistic and down-to-earth on and have their own share of ideologies and stories. But there are also lots of cute moments in the manga that make me go awww which is pretty great because the politic part of the manga might get some of the reader bored if they aren't paying attention and only looking for some romance. Uhh, I really wasn't planning to make this post as long as a review haha. The point is I really like this manga, the protagonist and the mangaka. And it's an important manga for me growing up so I hope I can give it more recognition. |
| I nominate Shakuya from Ryuu no Hanawazurai. She can get herself out of tough situations, and even though she can't really fight with weapons, she uses her own (powerful) skills. I initially thought that she was going to rely on the main guys too much, but it turned out that she was quite strong (character development, yay!). More votes: Nako from NanaKo Robin Eisul from Red Lion Suzume from Hirunaka no Ryuusei Futaba from Ao Haru Ride Shirayuki from Akagami no Shirayuki Hime Chouko from Hana no Namae Naho from Orange |
| I'll put in a vote for Saiunkoku Monogatari as well. :) That should put it one vote short of membership. |
|
More topics from this board
» Cross-dressing-BlackRabbit- - Jan 22, 2012 |
5 |
by nekoolit
»»
Jul 25, 2016 9:52 PM |
|
» RECRUITING! [GFX position OPEN]-BlackRabbit- - Feb 2, 2012 |
11 |
by editing
»»
Sep 21, 2015 12:40 AM |
|
Sticky: Poll: » Newsletter Sign-up!-BlackRabbit- - Jan 19, 2012 |
42 |
by mymarie
»»
Mar 1, 2015 12:07 AM |
|
» School Manga-BlackRabbit- - Jan 16, 2012 |
11 |
by -BlackRabbit-
»»
Sep 4, 2014 1:58 PM |
|
» Yakuza/Delinquent-BlackRabbit- - Jan 22, 2012 |
8 |
by -BlackRabbit-
»»
Sep 4, 2014 1:51 PM |