| Basically is how I wnjoy the anime, and if it has good animation, story, etc. |
| As for me, there is nothing definite, I rate according to what number feels right. That may sound dumb, but rather than putting each of them into numbers to get the score for the anime all in all, I'm already subconsciously affected by factors such as story and characters. I wouldn't rate an anime I liked less than 7 (and thus one I disliked higher than 6), though. In the first place, I watch anime to enjoy it, therefore thinking so much about rating is a bit... ^^° Even though I'm neither into writing nor reading reviews, I've come across many reviewers who rate many separate things before arriving at a conclusion, but translating (parts of) an anime into numbers doesn't feel right. |
| Whatever feels right. |
| how you should. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Yvese said: Pretty much sums it all.Shuhan said: Neane1993 said: Enjoyment. |
| I use a sorting algorithm that differentiates between anime by comparing the quality of various components, including the aesthetics and audio, the coherence and intrigue of the plot and it's progression, the amiability of the characters and the their evolving social framework, and the natural bias that has no identifiable reason behind it. Or I just use comparison. |
Neane1993 said: Enjoyment. this. The rating(I use a 100/1000-number rating scale) depends on how much I enjoyed it compared to other anime. 2 examples : If I like it more than the Haruhi movie(8.5) but less than gosick(8.6) it becomes a 8.55. Or if I liked it more than Gungrave(6.3) but less than Genshiken(6.5) it becomes a 6.4 A 5 is neutral, above means I liked it(5.1 or higher), below means I disliked it(4.9 or lower). |
| How much I enjoy it + plot + one point because I'm usually too harsh. |
| Just by how much I enjoyed it. But...I'm bad at rating things xD |
| Anyway back to the main point. How do you rate your anime? I go with the 5 minute rule. If the show doesn't have one element I require in an anime in 5 minutes sorry not interested. Because with several hundred shows being released every year it seems, no one needs to spend all season just to realize 'hey that show sucked'. |
| While not technically anime, currently I am a big fan of Hatsune Miku. At least I can go see her in concert. |
Lesley_Roberta said: Anyway back to the main point. How do you rate your anime? But you're not answering the question "How do you rate your anime", you're answering the question "How do you decide to drop or watch an anime?". |
| I usually like every anime,it's just i'm to lazy to watch them all,I rate them by the Animation,and if it's funny. If not i'll probaly like it anyway. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the General Forum Guidelines. |
| Characters and Plot that fit my likings making it enjoyable ! Cool or nice Art ! Sound doesn't matter so much |
| Enjoyment only (which has plot, music, characters and rest of it of course) from 1-9 - ok 5-9 as I drop series that could get something from 1-5 I don't give 10 in first watch all of 10's come from rewatching |
| 1-4 is bad, 5 is average, 6-8 is good, 9-10 awesome. |
 "Your sight, my delight. Will you marry me?" |
| I rate the animes based on the overall enjoyment. What enjoys me best will depend on the plot, sound animation and credibility in some cases (drama and/or psychological animes, for example). |
| "Ouvis? Falai vós cortês! Vós, fidalgo, cuidareis que estais na vossa pousada? Dar-vos-ei tanta pancada com um remo que renegueis!" Auto da Barca do Inferno, Gil Vicente Ignorância gera violência, nela nunca procurei abrigo Cultivo a paz pela subsistência da existência deste universo onde resido. Se estás a um passo do abismo pensa bem, Não queiras para os outros o que não queres para ti também. Sala 101 - Dealema |
| I rate mine by the words next to the numbers :L Mostly 6-10 usually from "fine" to "very good" since I struggle to find an anime I dislike. But If the story drew me in and I completely loved the anime and couldn't stop watching then I'll consider a "masterpiece". |
----------------------------- |
| Enjoyment/Plot and most important of all the Ending! |
LordSenate said: Enjoyment/Plot and most important of all the Ending! |
| As anime watching for me is solely for entertainment, then I rate it based on how much I enjoyed it. I leave breakdown of elements to critics. |
| I take a fairly simple approach. I will directly rate an anime based on how much I enjoyed it, which is obviously going to be influenced by serious other factors such as a complex and interesting plot, great art and animation as well as the characters themselves. When it does come right down to it though, enjoyment trumps all. Many people have favorites that they are willing to give perfect scores even if the anime has series issues as an anime from an objective perspective. Two significant examples I can think of for this are the Code Geass and Haruhi Suzimiya franchises. Both animes had their issues as an anime, Geass with pacing and a few others and Haruhi with a much less complex plot than the show would like to admit and the endless eight. Regardless, I see many people giving them perfect scores simply because of the fact that they enjoyed it that much. |
 |
| However I want. |
| tfw no gf tfw i keep getting the banhammer on here tfw Koleare keeps banning me every other day tfw I'm misunderstood by le mod |
| Story, Theme & Style are pretty synonymous factors I take into account when watching series and they're the criterias I go by when rating anime. Story, premise and direction being the primary reasons for me to even bother. Theme (element) being secondary as good storytelling can work around anything. And overall style (animation & art), with respect to the story and theme, seals the deal when it comes to watching anime. I try to keep it balanced with different genres and elements, but generally it all boils down to a personal bias of whether I like the anime or not. |
| Enjoyment Animation/Art Characters Plot that's it usually |
| "You're making too much of me. All I am these days, is the poor owner of a small time candy store."-Kisuke Urahara |
| - Plot - Art - Enjoyment That's about it :p |
| it needs to move me - elicit emotions - happy, sad, etc. besides that, narrative & characters enjoyment is a given ^^ |
| It's my personal philosophy that it is impossible to judge any art form objectively, so enjoyment is the only criterion I take into consideration as all other things are contained within it. Besides that, I don't go by the MAL ratings i.e. 10 being "Masterpiece", 9 being "Great", etc. For me a 10 is an anime that is near to my favorites, and then all other ratings are just my enjoyment of said series relative to what I decided to rate a 10. |
| 私のホバークラフトは鰻でいっぱいです |
| Characters are the most important part for me. I mean it could have the best written story ever, but with boring characters I wouldn't give a damn; but on the other hand, it could have the most generic story, but really fleshed out and enjoyable characters and I'd love it. Soundtrack is second. Background music really sets the scene. And enjoyment, but that really goes hand and hand with the above. |
 |
Angel_Beats said: enjoyment/plot |
| I rate my anime shows based on the impact it gave me emotionally and metaphysically. I know that may seem strange, but I don't usually pay attention to detail on a show's technical properties unless it really shows through my interest. Notice how I only have 2 shows with perfect scores. The bigger the impact the higher the score. But I do think an interesting plot is one of the big things that are important for me in a show. |
 |
| I'm similar to the above post. I like shows that gives me an impact - deep plots and strong characters will get highly rated. Doesn't matter if the anime is old if it's fantastic it will get a high rating same goes for animation. It doesn't have to be the best it's the story and the characters that makes the show for me. I also like good music as it can really set the mood. I rate according to: 1. Enjoyment and impact 2. Deep plots and strong characters |
| A house is made from bricks and stones but a home is made from love alone! |
| I just overrated everything. (Mainly with 9s and 10s) Regardless if its good or terrible. As long I enjoyed it is all that matters. (Also some of them are there to keep track of my favourites) |
Shaonova said: I take a fairly simple approach. I will directly rate an anime based on how much I enjoyed it, which is obviously going to be influenced by serious other factors such as a complex and interesting plot, great art and animation as well as the characters themselves. When it does come right down to it though, enjoyment trumps all. Many people have favorites that they are willing to give perfect scores even if the anime has series issues as an anime from an objective perspective. Same here and I agree. You have put it better than I was going to. |
| Anything above 5 is good, anything below 5 is bad. Things that give it a better rating Fan Service + Things that prevents it from getting a good rating Not enough Fan Service - |
| Come visit my town // I apologize in advance for my second-rate English Join my fan club // Improve the transport network |
| 8-10 Not so sexist 6-8 Sexist 4-6 Very sexist 0-4 Get this trash out from my sight! |
| Enjoyment and/or plot. |
 |
| by how I feel. if I feel that it's a damn masterpiece then it's a masterpiece. so yea enjoyment |
Kairen said: I just overrated everything. (Mainly with 9s and 10s) Regardless if its good or terrible. As long I enjoyed it is all that matters. (Also some of them are there to keep track of my favourites) At least you can admit it? |
LoneWolf said: @Josh makes me sad to call myself Canadian. |
| Story, music, characters, pacing, and entertained I was after the last episode. |
| Animation, OST, characters and above all enjoyment. |
 |
| 1.Enjoyment 2.Ending assuming its actually the last episode and will not be continued later. |
| Everything - enjoyment, animation, music, art style, VAs, the little things dependent on the genre (eg comedy for SOLs) length, pacing, characters, beginning, ending. |
More topics from this board
» How often do you rewatch anime?Destinesia - 20 minutes ago |
3 |
by M_MASTER
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Spring 2024 my fav anime lineup yet! What is your fav series that is going under the radar?rohan121 - 9 hours ago |
14 |
by LNW_R92CP
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» Describe your anime watching as one sentence.LenRea - Apr 11 |
39 |
by ryzxgum
»»
25 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » has the majority of people (here) seen the big 3 ? ( 1 2 3 4 )ame - Apr 16 |
161 |
by Otakupervert890
»»
27 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Does your first ever favourite anime(s) still holds a place in your favs?NubFix - 10 hours ago |
38 |
by InsomniacBastard
»»
34 minutes ago |