Reply to Deathko
https://myanimelist.net/character/748/Anthy_Himemiya
https://myanimelist.net/character/6141/Wakaba_Shinohara
https://myanimelist.net/character/752/Juri_Arisugawa
https://myanimelist.net/character/754/Nanami_Kiryuu
https://myanimelist.net/character/4363/Kozue_Kaoru
Was about to mention some Magical Doremi characters, but screw this, Utena masterrace.
edit: Wait, if I post a transformation sequence I can nominate characters from shows without the mahou shoujo tag?
Because if I can, lets do that instead:
https://myanimelist.net/character/83797/Ryuuko_Matoi
https://myanimelist.net/character/91675/Mako_Mankanshoku
https://myanimelist.net/character/748/Anthy_Himemiya
https://myanimelist.net/character/6141/Wakaba_Shinohara
https://myanimelist.net/character/752/Juri_Arisugawa
DON'T LOOOOSE YOOOOUUUUR WAAAAAAAAAY!!!
https://myanimelist.net/character/6141/Wakaba_Shinohara
https://myanimelist.net/character/752/Juri_Arisugawa
https://myanimelist.net/character/754/Nanami_Kiryuu
https://myanimelist.net/character/4363/Kozue_Kaoru
Was about to mention some Magical Doremi characters, but screw this, Utena masterrace.
edit: Wait, if I post a transformation sequence I can nominate characters from shows without the mahou shoujo tag?
Because if I can, lets do that instead:
https://myanimelist.net/character/83797/Ryuuko_Matoi
https://myanimelist.net/character/91675/Mako_Mankanshoku
https://myanimelist.net/character/748/Anthy_Himemiya
https://myanimelist.net/character/6141/Wakaba_Shinohara
https://myanimelist.net/character/752/Juri_Arisugawa
DON'T LOOOOSE YOOOOUUUUR WAAAAAAAAAY!!!
| @Deathko if you want to, I saw that MAL and me have different standards when it comes to Mahou Shoujo. |
| Since Kill la Kill is allowed, I'd like to add Satsuki Kiryuin https://myanimelist.net/character/83799/Satsuki_Kiryuuin |
 |
| https://myanimelist.net/character/21740/Sally_Yumeno https://myanimelist.net/character/19323/Tickle_Komori https://myanimelist.net/character/20197/Momo https://myanimelist.net/character/167526/Lala_Hagoromo https://myanimelist.net/character/141960/Mori_no_Ongakuka_Cranberry I judge Tickle to be eligible based on the title of the show, "majokko." This is how magical girls were known before Lalabel coined "mahou shoujo." I would choose characters from Mai-Hime if I were allowed more nominations. |
| その目だれの目？ |
Reply to Sheol01
Would Ryoko from Tenchi Muyo! Qualify?
| @Sheol01 She can transform as far as I know. So if you want her in, sure. |
| No Corrector Yui character was nominated yet, so I will nominate all of them: Yui Kasuga/Corrector Yui Haruna Kisaragi/Corrector Haruna Ai Shinozaki/Corrector Ai |
| I'm gonna nominate some Pretty Cures: Haruka Haruno/Cure Flora (THE BEST) Ciel Kirahoshi/Cure Parfait Uta Sakura/Cure Idol Kokoro Shigure/Cure Kyun-Kyun And I'm also gonna nominate Minamo Sorano/Princess Ripple from Princession Orchestra. I would've nominated Sakura Kinomoto (ALSO THE BEST) and Nodoka Hanadera too, but they're already nominated! =) We need a magical boy contest too so that Pikario (ALSO ALSO THE BEST) and Tsubasa Yuunagi/Cure Wing also get a chance to shine |
~Saeryen~Cure Cantata~ Invoke love, invoke hope, please heal everything! |
| Custom images: |
| Ruler from Mahou Shoujo Ikusei Keikaku Hotaru Tomoe from Sailor Moon Haruka Tenou from Sailor Moon Setsuna Meiou from Sailor Moon Princess Tutu from Princess Tutu |
gigaparsecJun 6, 2:46 PM
 The scorched earth, tuition to all your fear She said mercy is only reserved for the weak And you will find nothing here. |
| Gotta put the classic Honey from Cutie Honey |
 Dreams are worth fighting for |
| Okay, in ca. 15 hours I will end the nomination phase, then Round 1 will begin :D We've got 109 nominations, I try to expand the first Round 1 with 128 participants, but let's see who else want to join the fun, maybe I don't need to. |
TheMinkalexJun 6, 11:56 PM
Reply to butahime
| @butahime Persia is already nominated, do you want to choose another one? ^^ |
| @MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"? |
TheMinkalex said: Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"? Please use "Phantom Thief Jeanne" for Maron Kusakabe. |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
| @TheMinkalex Persona for Cure Grace, real names for the Geahs. |
 |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
| @TheMinkalex May as well use her real name, since both contain "Honey" anyway |
| Dreams are worth fighting for |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
| @TheMinkalex Sayo - Magia Azul Utena - Magia Baiser Sayaka, Madoka, Kiwi real names |
| If transformation sequences like Kill la Kill's count, then I'd like to nominate the lovely, beautiful women of Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt. Edit: Oops, sorry, I had an old tab open. I see now that Zarutaku nominated the first two sisters. But I'd still like to put forward the demon sisters. |
 Another hero? Oh, please! You're a god-damn philistine. |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
TheMinkalex said: For my nominees, I prefer to have their real names in all but one cases. It's not a big deal for most of them, however, Karin Kokubu might also have "Buurin" in her name, due to her role and nature of her transformation.Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"? If I may suggest custom images for some of my nominees, here they are (both on MAL): https://cdn.myanimelist.net/images/characters/9/102554.jpg (one of images from Pictures) for Hikaru Shidou https://cdn.myanimelist.net/images/anime/3/21131l.jpg (anime poster featuring the main character) for Karin "Buurin" Kokubu |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
| @TheMinkalex I always refer to superheroes by their personas. |
| その目だれの目？ |
TheMinkalex said: Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"? I would prefer them by their personas |
 |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
| @TheMinkalex Maybe persona if its more recognizable Also I'd like for this image to be used for Venus since its my favorite one on her page.  |
 |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
| @TheMinkalex Persona. This goes especially for Berry Blossom (Kaju Noichigo), since her given name doesn't get brought up that much in-series. |
MelodyOfMemoryJun 7, 8:48 AM
   Time...it will not wait...no matter...how hard you hold on...it escapes you... |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
TheMinkalex said: Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"? Their persona please! I feel they're more recognizable to everyone that way |
The scorched earth, tuition to all your fear She said mercy is only reserved for the weak And you will find nothing here. |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
| @TheMinkalex Real name is fine, thank you |
~Saeryen~Cure Cantata~ Invoke love, invoke hope, please heal everything! |
| okay, the nomination phase is over. It's time to get serious. |
Reply to TheMinkalex
@MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @JaniSIr
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
Do you want to use the real names of the characters or do you want to use their "persona"?
| @TheMinkalex The persona, I guess it makes more sense that way. |
Round 1 Anthy Himemiya vs Kurumin   Kaoruko Tenkawa vs Nanoha Takamachi   Sumi Kuroi vs Hibiki Tachibana   Aya Asagiri vs Amu Hinamori   Minamo Sorano vs Momo Chiyoda   Asuka Ootorii vs Uta Sakura   Sailor Mars vs Cocona Cocomine   Princess Tutu vs Tsubasa Kazanari   Makoto Kino vs Yachiyo Nanami   Panty Anarchy vs Tail Red   Komugi Nakahara vs Corrector Yui   Karin Hanazono vs Onpu Segawa   Hibana Kagari vs Pudding   Mimori Tougou vs Sailor Pluto   Anarchy vs Ciel Kirahoshi   Hana Nono vs Michiru Kaiou   Shingetsu Ernesta Fukami vs Kikko Hoshino   Dark Illya vs Ryuuko Matoi   Ruler vs Sasami Iwakura   Fate Testarossa vs Princess Zeal   Natsuki Kuga vs Teana Lanster   Magia Baiser vs Honoka Yukishiro   Tickle Komori vs Cure Butterfly   Sailor Saturn vs Kneesocks Demon   Doremi Harukaze vs Illyasviel von Einzbern   Sonoko Nogi vs Yuuna Yuuki   Zakuro Fujiwara vs Sailor Mercury   Momoko Akatsutsumi vs Miyako Gotokuji   Sakura Kinomoto vs Cure Wink   Mami Tomoe vs Hibiki Houjou   Ichigo Momomiya vs Karin "Buurin" Kokubu   Yayoi Kise vs Kurumi Mugen   Rem Ayanokouji vs Cure Sky   Cure Scarlet vs Princess Meteor   Homura Akemi vs Momo   Stocking Anarchy vs Chacha   Sayaka Miki vs Byakuya Mimori   Papika vs Yume Hinata   Kokoro Shigure vs Yui Nitta   Nagisa Misumi vs Fuu Hououji   Cranberry vs Utena Tenjou   Rin Tohsaka vs Nagisa Momoe   Michiko Tanaka vs Kaoru Matsubara   Ryouko Hakubi vs Subaru Nakajima   Corrector Ai vs Kiwi Araga   Hayate Yagami vs Erika Kuramoto   Miyu Edelfelt vs Corrector Haruna   Rena Minami vs Magia Azul   Sailor Venus vs Sayuka Koenji   Juri Arisugawa vs Chris Yukine   Umi Ryuuzaki vs Haruka Hanabishi   Sailor Moon vs Persia Hayami   Pretty Sammy vs Itsuki Inubouzaki   Wakaba Shinohara vs Kirika Akatsuki   Cure Milky vs Madoka Kaname   Mako Mankanshoku vs Haruka Haruno   Hikaru Shidou vs Cure Grace   Nina Yamada vs Cure La Mer   Karin Miyoshi vs Phantom Thief Jeanne   Kyouko Sakura vs Satsuki Kiryuuin   Berry Blossom vs Scanty Demon   Setsuna Higashi vs Sally Yumeno   Sailor Uranus vs Honey Kisaragi   Shirabe Tsukuyomi vs Megu Kanzaki   Episode 1: I'm a Magical Girl?! @MelodyOfMemory @Soraveth_ @Razecube @Vini310 @Timeline_man @nirererin @Zarutaku @stickyfingersx @WaterMage @RainyEvenings @niconiconii27 @Szczelajo @Deathko @Supersonic_Pain @MinakoBestGirl @IpreferEcchi |
TheMinkalexJun 9, 12:32 AM
| @Lain2357 @Shyshima @Adnash @Lucifrost @gigaparsec @Retro8bit @valico @Saeryen @minzera @MitsukiHimeka @-YaoiBoy- @LeonhartAugust @Sheol01 @JaniSIr @CC @animegamer245 @TFDPaddy |
TheMinkalexJun 7, 4:55 PM
| Kurumin Nanoha Takamachi Hibiki Tachibana Amu Hinamori Momo Chiyoda Asuka Ootorii Sailor Mars Princess Tutu Makoto Kino Tail Red Corrector Yui Karin Hanazono Hibana Kagari Sailor Pluto Anarchy Michiru Kaiou Kikko Hoshino Dark Illya Ruler Fate Testarossa Natsuki Kuga Magia Baiser Cure Butterfly Sailor Saturn Illyasviel Einzbern Sonoko Nogi Sailor Mercury Momoko Akatsutsumi Sakura Kinomoto Hibiki Houjou Ichigo Momomiya Kurumi Mugen Rem Ayanokouji Princess Meteor Homura Akemi Stocking Anarchy Byakuya Mimori Yume Hinata Yui Nitta Nagisa Misumi Cranberry Nagisa Momoe Kaoru Matsubara Ryouko Hakubi Corrector Ai Hayate Yagami Miyu Edelfelt Rena Minami Sailor Venus Chris Yukine Haruka Hanabishi Sailor Moon Pretty Sammy Kirika Akatsuki Madoka Kaname Haruka Haruno Cure Grace Nina Yamada Phantom Thief Jeanne Kyouko Sakura Berry Blossom Setsuna Higashi Sailor Uranus Shirabe Tsukuyomi |
|
| 1 - Anthy Himemiya 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - Sailor Mars 8 - 9 - Makoto Kino 10 - Panty 11 - 12 - Onpu Segawa 13 - 14 - Sailor Pluto 15 - 16 - Michiru Kaiou 17 - 18 - Ryuuko Matoi 19 - 20 - 21 - 22 - 23 - 24 - Kneesocks 25 - Doremi 26 - 27 - Sailor Mercury 28 - 29 - 30 - 31 - 32 - 33 - 34 - 35 - 36 - Stocking 37 - 38 - Papika 39 - 40 - 41 - Utena 42 - 43 - 44 - 45 - 46 - 47 - 48 - 49 - Sailor Venus 50 - Juri 51 - 52 - Sailor Moon 53 - 54- Wakaba 55 - 56 - Mako 57 - 58 - 59 - 60 - Satsuki 61 - Scanty 62 - 63 - Sailor Uranus (really tough one) 64 - @TheMinkalex You might want to number them in your post, this was hell :p |
Prophetess of the Golden Era  |
| Minamo Sorano Uta Sakura (💖💖) Ciel Kirahoshi (💖💖) Princess Zeal Honoka Yukishiro Cure Butterfly Zakuro Fujiwara Sakura Kinomoto (💖💖💖) (what a hard choice, but Sakura is one of the bestest) Hibiki Houjou Ichigo Momomiya Yayoi Kise Cure Sky Cure Scarlet (again, haaard) Yume Hinata Kokoro Shigure (💖💖) Nagisa Misumi Cure Milky Haruka Haruno (💖💖💖) Cure Grace (💖💖) Cure La Mer Berry Blossom Promotion time! THESE TWO THESE TWO THESE TWO They're the best. Vote for them! |
~Saeryen~Cure Cantata~ Invoke love, invoke hope, please heal everything! |
| Aw, boo I would've said to give Sailor Jupiter her persona That's what I get for playing Street Fighter all day, haha Anthy Himemiya Nanoha Takamachi Hibiki Tachibana Aya Asagiri Momo Chiyoda Asuka Ootorii Sailor Mars Tsubasa Kazanari Makoto Kino Panty Anarchy Corrector Yui Karin Hanazono Hibana Kagari Sailor Pluto Anarchy Michiru Kaiou Kikko Hoshino Ryuuko Matoi Sasami Iwakura Fate Testarossa Natsuki Kuga Honoka Yukishiro Cure Butterfly Kneesocks Demon (good shout, I forgot about the Daemons) Illyasviel von Einzbern Yuuna Yuuki Sailor Mercury Momoko Akatsutsumi Sakura Kinomoto Mami Tomoe Ichigo Momomiya Kurumi Mugen Rem Ayanokouji Cure Scarlet Homura Akemi Stocking Anarchy Sayaka Miki Yume Hinata Yui Nitta Fuu Hououji Utena Tenjou Rin Tohsaka Kaoru Matsubara Subaru Nakajima Corrector Ai Erika Kuramoto Miyu Edelfelt Rena Minami Sailor Venus Juri Arisugawa Haruka Hanabishi Sailor Moon Itsuki Inubouzaki Wakaba Shinohara Madoka Kaname Mako Mankanshoku Cure Grace Nina Yamada Phantom Thief Jeanne Satsuki Kiryuuin (tough competitor tho) Scanty Demon Setsuna Higashi Sailor Uranus Shirabe Tsukuyomi |
|
| Many of those aren't magical girls. I vote against them out of principal. The reality of the popularity contest has dawned on me as I realize that my nominations have no chance of winning. 1. Kurumi Tokisaki 3. Hibiki Tachibana 4. Amu Hinamori 7. Sailor Mars 8. Princess Tutu 9. Sailor Jupiter 12. Onpu Segawa 14. Sailor Pluto 16. Cure Yell 19. Ruler 21. Natsuki Kuga 22. Cure White 23. Tickle 24. Sailor Saturn 25. Illya 26. Sonoko Nogi 27. Sailor Mercury 28. Bubbles 29. Cardcaptor Sakura 30. Cure Melody 33. Dream Hunter Rem 35. Minky Momo 36. Akazukin Chacha 40. Cure Black 41. Cranberry 49. Sailor Venus 50. Chris Yukine 51. Umi Ryuuzaki 52. Sailor Moon 53. Pretty Sammy 54. Kirika Akatsuki 55. Cure Milky 56. Cure Flora 57. Hikaru Shidou 58. Cure La Mer 59. Karin Miyoshi 60. Kyouko Sakura 61. Berry Blossom 62. Sally Yumeno 63. Cutey Honey 64. Shirabe Tsukuyomi |
| その目だれの目？ |
| Mermaid Melody: Lucia Nanami, Hanon Houshou, and Rina Touin. |
MoonBunny9297Jun 8, 8:14 AM
 Code Lyoko, we'll reset it all Code Lyoko, be there when you call Code Lyoko, we will stand real tall Code Lyoko, stronger after all |
| @Lucifrost I'm going to assume you're talking about P&S, Kill la Kill and Utena here. Which is fine, cool, I can underst- Cutey Honey Excuse me sir but what the fuck? You're going full mahou shoujo purist but voting for Cutey Honey wich is quite possibly the furthest from mahou shoujo out of the 128 characters we had to chose from - at least the furthest from the post-Sailor Moon definition we use nowadays? No magic, no mascot, no sentai elements? I feel like a clarification regarding what you consider mahou shoujo is in order, because right now it's not very clear. |
DeathkoJun 7, 8:48 PM
Prophetess of the Golden Era |
More topics from this board
» Minkalex Waifu War V4 (Nomination phase)TheMinkalex - Today |
37 |
by Shinku05
»»
33 seconds ago |
|
» Why do some people give out so many 10s? ( 1 2 )Bananaman2345 - Yesterday |
55 |
by Yuu_Kanzaki
»»
48 seconds ago |
|
» If you can't watch shows with ridiculous amounts of fanservice, you don't deserve to watch anime.ComeInReiAsuka - 11 hours ago |
40 |
by KittenCuddler
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Would you prefer to be a fan of manga?Rally- - 11 minutes ago |
1 |
by Yuu_Kanzaki
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Approximately how many Anime have you watched so far? Only 100 or more (poll) ( 1 2 3 )ReMightyRon - Jul 16 |
124 |
by SignsOfSuicide
»»
12 minutes ago |