Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Apr 17, 9:01 AM
#1

Offline
Oct 2020
1866
(⁠ ⁠╹⁠▽⁠╹⁠ ⁠) This ain't hating anymore. It's hating with passion. LMAO.
WISHED I COULD ALSO GET TRANSPORTED TO A WORLD FULL OF MAGIC And DUNGEONS, please take me there too if you could (⁠ ⁠◜⁠‿⁠◝⁠ ⁠)⁠
Apr 17, 9:24 AM
#2
Online
Oct 2024
42
Anayan_Kashyap said:
(⁠ ⁠╹⁠▽⁠╹⁠ ⁠) This ain't hating anymore. It's hating with passion. LMAO.

True yesterday it was 6.47 on an website now it’s literally 5.2 😂
Apr 17, 9:25 AM
#3

Online
Jul 2023
5074
To be honest, the animation is worse than Uzumaki's. The story is good enough for a decent rating, but the animators have already done their part.



𝓕𝓸𝓻𝔀𝓪𝓻𝓭 𝓲𝓼
𝓽𝓱𝓮 𝔀𝓪𝔂.....

Apr 17, 9:40 AM
#4
Offline
Nov 2022
183
Anayan_Kashyap said:
(⁠ ⁠╹⁠▽⁠╹⁠ ⁠) This ain't hating anymore. It's hating with passion. LMAO.

would've been better if this wasn't animated
Apr 17, 9:48 AM
#5
Offline
Nov 2021
134
There are those who think that such a low rating is entirely the fault of the animations... No, it's not like that, Arifureta has 6.72, Blue lock season 2 has 7.56, Berserk has 6.57, they are obviously low ratings (7.56 seems good but given how the user rating works it is just above sufficiency) but never as low as the current rating of tbate which is 5.76... So why is it so low? I'll explain.
Of course, the animations have had a big impact on this rating, but as already said it's not enough, I think the other factors that have caused tbate to sink into the top 11000 of the site are:

1: The story is banal and badly written, some say that it improves later, but honestly the narrative flaws are so many that it seems more likely to me that there were 1/2 good scenes (original? I don't know, given how the author works they could come from who knows what book he stole them from) and the fans cling to those, ignoring the mediocrity of everything else.

2: Too much hype, mainly fueled by the fan base that advertised this series as "Solo leveling killer" and "Mushoku tensei killer", raising the expectations of the public, who, finding themselves in front of mediocre stuff, rightly demolished it (personally, if someone came to me telling me this kind of thing, I wouldn't even listen to him, because someone who comes to me saying "this series is better than the others" instead of telling me an interesting incipit, I wouldn't take him seriously)

3: Clear plagiarism, fans continue to say no, but it is clear that many scenes and characters were stolen from other series (is everything copied? No, obviously not, but it copied some scenes, and the public noticed it immediately) and therefore the anime suffered the obvious consequences.

Personally, I feel sorry for some fans (not all, many that I see writing have too childish an attitude to make me feel sorry for them, but many others were people who were also pleasant to talk to) but if the author suffers a fair drop in his patreon subscriptions I'd say he could at least learn a lesson (I hope, if he writes something that doesn't make me think of other series every 5 minutes, I'll at least give him another look, despite tbate's disappointment)
Apr 17, 10:14 AM
#6
Offline
Jul 2024
200
Anayan_Kashyap said:
(⁠ ⁠╹⁠▽⁠╹⁠ ⁠) This ain't hating anymore. It's hating with passion. LMAO.

oh my god it has cgi it's going yo be epic
Apr 17, 10:52 AM
#7
Offline
Oct 2024
14
It took me an hour to finish this episode, because I was so bored that I kept pausing to browse Instagram. That whole dialogue and that short relationship with the CGI dragon was so lame. Did that also fall flat in the LN ?
Apr 17, 11:16 AM
#8
Offline
Jan 2020
332
and even so, Uzumaki animation manages to be superior but TBATE has a better story
Apr 17, 11:34 AM
#9
Offline
Nov 2021
134
Reply to Mike-Mike
It took me an hour to finish this episode, because I was so bored that I kept pausing to browse Instagram. That whole dialogue and that short relationship with the CGI dragon was so lame. Did that also fall flat in the LN ?
@Mike-Mike I can't tell you about the LN (and I don't actually think there is a LN version, it should be a web novel) but from what I remember of the manhwa...Yes, it was so flat there too, there were a few more pieces and they spent more time together (a few months) but honestly it wasn't more or less identical
Apr 17, 12:24 PM

Offline
Oct 2020
1866
Reply to Geracchio
There are those who think that such a low rating is entirely the fault of the animations... No, it's not like that, Arifureta has 6.72, Blue lock season 2 has 7.56, Berserk has 6.57, they are obviously low ratings (7.56 seems good but given how the user rating works it is just above sufficiency) but never as low as the current rating of tbate which is 5.76... So why is it so low? I'll explain.
Of course, the animations have had a big impact on this rating, but as already said it's not enough, I think the other factors that have caused tbate to sink into the top 11000 of the site are:

1: The story is banal and badly written, some say that it improves later, but honestly the narrative flaws are so many that it seems more likely to me that there were 1/2 good scenes (original? I don't know, given how the author works they could come from who knows what book he stole them from) and the fans cling to those, ignoring the mediocrity of everything else.

2: Too much hype, mainly fueled by the fan base that advertised this series as "Solo leveling killer" and "Mushoku tensei killer", raising the expectations of the public, who, finding themselves in front of mediocre stuff, rightly demolished it (personally, if someone came to me telling me this kind of thing, I wouldn't even listen to him, because someone who comes to me saying "this series is better than the others" instead of telling me an interesting incipit, I wouldn't take him seriously)

3: Clear plagiarism, fans continue to say no, but it is clear that many scenes and characters were stolen from other series (is everything copied? No, obviously not, but it copied some scenes, and the public noticed it immediately) and therefore the anime suffered the obvious consequences.

Personally, I feel sorry for some fans (not all, many that I see writing have too childish an attitude to make me feel sorry for them, but many others were people who were also pleasant to talk to) but if the author suffers a fair drop in his patreon subscriptions I'd say he could at least learn a lesson (I hope, if he writes something that doesn't make me think of other series every 5 minutes, I'll at least give him another look, despite tbate's disappointment)
@Geracchio just 2 Eps in. Take a Deep Breath.
WISHED I COULD ALSO GET TRANSPORTED TO A WORLD FULL OF MAGIC And DUNGEONS, please take me there too if you could (⁠ ⁠◜⁠‿⁠◝⁠ ⁠)⁠
Apr 17, 12:36 PM

Offline
Oct 2020
1866
Reply to Mike-Mike
It took me an hour to finish this episode, because I was so bored that I kept pausing to browse Instagram. That whole dialogue and that short relationship with the CGI dragon was so lame. Did that also fall flat in the LN ?
@Mike-Mike Another Kid spotted. If you say you're born before 2008, you're insulting this generation of youth.
Can't blame you. You must have insanely Low attention span, one of those Mole Rats hiding in Insta Pit-hole scrolling their brain cells out one by one, who can't even sit through a movie, but want some spicy every second.
Sorry brother, your problem ain't the episode being boring, bt your habit. You don't get to complain.

Animation is one thing. So are the similarities with other shows. But Judging the way you describe it, DiU & Stein's Gate should be the worst show ever with how Uninteresting it gets eps by eps until a certain point.
WISHED I COULD ALSO GET TRANSPORTED TO A WORLD FULL OF MAGIC And DUNGEONS, please take me there too if you could (⁠ ⁠◜⁠‿⁠◝⁠ ⁠)⁠
Apr 17, 2:06 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
134
Reply to Anayan_Kashyap
@Geracchio just 2 Eps in. Take a Deep Breath.
@Anayan_Kashyap I'm literally talking about the reasons that led to this rating, the current rating is linked to these 3 episodes, so why should it be a problem?

P.S. I read the manhwa years ago up to chapter 60 (about) I already made up my mind about the series and it's not positive at all.
Apr 17, 2:21 PM
The Shrike

Offline
Nov 2009
11810
The hate this is getting is ridiculous and by now it's just a bunch of sheep following the herd Yes, the animation is bad, story has been seen before and the writing and characterizations are not memorable. But there are worse shows every season, with no positives whatsoever that get scores in the 7 range. But, hey enjoy your punching bag of the season kids.
"Perhaps there is a universal, absolute truth. Perhaps it justifies every question. But that's beyond the reach of these small hands." Mamoru Oshii

There is a cult of ignorance (...) nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that “my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.” Isaac Asimov

Apr 17, 3:59 PM
Offline
Oct 2024
14
All your cringy crashouts make me want to give the show an even lower rating. Accept that you got done dirty with this trash adaptation and watch Mushoku Tensei. ✌️
Apr 17, 4:21 PM
Offline
Oct 2022
604
Lol. The Internet never loses. If your adaptation of a property they like doesn't entertain them, the meta-entertainment of the show failing still might.
Apr 17, 4:26 PM
Offline
Mar 2018
44
Regardless of how this anime came out compared to what it was expected, this evaluation is way biased!
I watched many animes worse than this and yet had a higher rating
My impression is that the preoccupied fans with higher expectations were shocked and pushing it down!
TBH Obviously, it is not great or very good, but I would say I can watch it and enjoy it, hoping for more details to come
You would have more fun if you stopped comparing it to the manhua or solo leveling !
emo82Apr 17, 4:50 PM
Apr 17, 5:38 PM

Offline
Oct 2020
1866
Reply to Geracchio
@Anayan_Kashyap I'm literally talking about the reasons that led to this rating, the current rating is linked to these 3 episodes, so why should it be a problem?

P.S. I read the manhwa years ago up to chapter 60 (about) I already made up my mind about the series and it's not positive at all.
@Geracchio Except for the 2nd Point. Your Reasons Might've made sense a few more eps in, but with only 2 eps I don't think, talking about Good writing or Narrative Flaws make any sense, when it's a long show. The premise might make people look at it as a copy of MT, true, but 100s of cut-paste SAO Trash isekais has more positive reception. True, it's in the Nosferatu situation rn but I don't think people would've cared if it had good animation.
The animation is the only reason it's hated for at the moment.
WISHED I COULD ALSO GET TRANSPORTED TO A WORLD FULL OF MAGIC And DUNGEONS, please take me there too if you could (⁠ ⁠◜⁠‿⁠◝⁠ ⁠)⁠
Apr 17, 6:08 PM

Offline
Sep 2013
454
I'm afraid it might go down below 5.0. People's reactions are apparently getting worse every week.
Apr 17, 7:43 PM

Offline
Apr 2021
68
Geracchio said:
There are those who think that such a low rating is entirely the fault of the animations... No, it's not like that, Arifureta has 6.72, Blue lock season 2 has 7.56, Berserk has 6.57, they are obviously low ratings (7.56 seems good but given how the user rating works it is just above sufficiency) but never as low as the current rating of tbate which is 5.76... So why is it so low? I'll explain.
Of course, the animations have had a big impact on this rating, but as already said it's not enough, I think the other factors that have caused tbate to sink into the top 11000 of the site are:

1: The story is banal and badly written, some say that it improves later, but honestly the narrative flaws are so many that it seems more likely to me that there were 1/2 good scenes (original? I don't know, given how the author works they could come from who knows what book he stole them from) and the fans cling to those, ignoring the mediocrity of everything else.

2: Too much hype, mainly fueled by the fan base that advertised this series as "Solo leveling killer" and "Mushoku tensei killer", raising the expectations of the public, who, finding themselves in front of mediocre stuff, rightly demolished it (personally, if someone came to me telling me this kind of thing, I wouldn't even listen to him, because someone who comes to me saying "this series is better than the others" instead of telling me an interesting incipit, I wouldn't take him seriously)

3: Clear plagiarism, fans continue to say no, but it is clear that many scenes and characters were stolen from other series (is everything copied? No, obviously not, but it copied some scenes, and the public noticed it immediately) and therefore the anime suffered the obvious consequences.

Personally, I feel sorry for some fans (not all, many that I see writing have too childish an attitude to make me feel sorry for them, but many others were people who were also pleasant to talk to) but if the author suffers a fair drop in his patreon subscriptions I'd say he could at least learn a lesson (I hope, if he writes something that doesn't make me think of other series every 5 minutes, I'll at least give him another look, despite tbate's disappointment)

you Said tbate stole alot of things, but what things?

most ppl say mushoku i have read tbate and mushoku, only the first chapter is similar, when tessia arc strats this history show their Bright, mushoku is the only inspiration and its only in first chapter, i havent read all mangas soo if your are realy talking seriosly say One, i enjoyed tbate soo i maybe enjoy that too.

You also talk about the story is mediucre, like Thats not bc you don t like the history is mediucre, like i can t enjoy dandandan, Thats not bc the history is "mediucre" Thats just not my type of comedy/Shonen.
Its the 2 most sold mawha, give it some respect.
blood898ptApr 17, 7:58 PM

Apr 17, 8:12 PM
Offline
Jan 2021
9
emo82 said:
Regardless of how this anime came out compared to what it was expected, this evaluation is way biased!
I watched many animes worse than this and yet had a higher rating
My impression is that the preoccupied fans with higher expectations were shocked and pushing it down!
TBH Obviously, it is not great or very good, but I would say I can watch it and enjoy it, hoping for more details to come
You would have more fun if you stopped comparing it to the manhua or solo leveling !

I’ve watched my fair share of anime. Some of the animation in this show is pretty damn bad. Not sure if it was the site I was using but the inconsistency in the frames is poor as well. I’d much prefer atrocious cgi to that.
Apr 17, 11:21 PM
Offline
Feb 2024
1
But everyone watched
Apr 17, 11:51 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
134
Reply to Anayan_Kashyap
@Geracchio Except for the 2nd Point. Your Reasons Might've made sense a few more eps in, but with only 2 eps I don't think, talking about Good writing or Narrative Flaws make any sense, when it's a long show. The premise might make people look at it as a copy of MT, true, but 100s of cut-paste SAO Trash isekais has more positive reception. True, it's in the Nosferatu situation rn but I don't think people would've cared if it had good animation.
The animation is the only reason it's hated for at the moment.
@Anayan_Kashyap Eh, but as I wrote there are many products with equally ugly animations but which have much higher ratings (between 5.70 and 6.70 there is only one point of difference, so it seems little, but in reality it is a huge difference) so it was not just a problem of animations, there were also other factors, which in my opinion are the ones I listed.
Apr 18, 12:27 AM
Offline
Nov 2021
134
Reply to blood898pt
Geracchio said:
There are those who think that such a low rating is entirely the fault of the animations... No, it's not like that, Arifureta has 6.72, Blue lock season 2 has 7.56, Berserk has 6.57, they are obviously low ratings (7.56 seems good but given how the user rating works it is just above sufficiency) but never as low as the current rating of tbate which is 5.76... So why is it so low? I'll explain.
Of course, the animations have had a big impact on this rating, but as already said it's not enough, I think the other factors that have caused tbate to sink into the top 11000 of the site are:

1: The story is banal and badly written, some say that it improves later, but honestly the narrative flaws are so many that it seems more likely to me that there were 1/2 good scenes (original? I don't know, given how the author works they could come from who knows what book he stole them from) and the fans cling to those, ignoring the mediocrity of everything else.

2: Too much hype, mainly fueled by the fan base that advertised this series as "Solo leveling killer" and "Mushoku tensei killer", raising the expectations of the public, who, finding themselves in front of mediocre stuff, rightly demolished it (personally, if someone came to me telling me this kind of thing, I wouldn't even listen to him, because someone who comes to me saying "this series is better than the others" instead of telling me an interesting incipit, I wouldn't take him seriously)

3: Clear plagiarism, fans continue to say no, but it is clear that many scenes and characters were stolen from other series (is everything copied? No, obviously not, but it copied some scenes, and the public noticed it immediately) and therefore the anime suffered the obvious consequences.

Personally, I feel sorry for some fans (not all, many that I see writing have too childish an attitude to make me feel sorry for them, but many others were people who were also pleasant to talk to) but if the author suffers a fair drop in his patreon subscriptions I'd say he could at least learn a lesson (I hope, if he writes something that doesn't make me think of other series every 5 minutes, I'll at least give him another look, despite tbate's disappointment)

you Said tbate stole alot of things, but what things?

most ppl say mushoku i have read tbate and mushoku, only the first chapter is similar, when tessia arc strats this history show their Bright, mushoku is the only inspiration and its only in first chapter, i havent read all mangas soo if your are realy talking seriosly say One, i enjoyed tbate soo i maybe enjoy that too.

You also talk about the story is mediucre, like Thats not bc you don t like the history is mediucre, like i can t enjoy dandandan, Thats not bc the history is "mediucre" Thats just not my type of comedy/Shonen.
Its the 2 most sold mawha, give it some respect.
@blood898pt I've already written a lot of times how much he took from Eragon, if you want to go deeper search a bit among the posts about the series, but to rewrite it briefly, Sylvie has the same personality, role, and way of behaving as Saphira (Eragon's dragon), even the relationship between the two characters is the same, their bond allows Arthur to have special powers, the rest is spoiler so if you don't want to know skip the next paragraph.

One of Arthur's trainings is very similar to the one Eragon does going to the elves, their master has the same personality, at a certain point Arthur is reborn in a new half-human body, as happens to Eragon, and their reaction to the event is practically identical.

The beginning is obviously the most evident part as far as mushoku tensei is concerned, one can say "but reincarnation is not a unique concept of Mushoku tensei" and it is very true, but there were a thousand alternatives to "reborn as the son of two former adventurers, a healer mother and a warrior father (I define him as a warrior, even if he uses magic to strengthen himself, simply because the way of fighting is that of a warrior, among other things also in Mushoku tensei the warriors use magic to strengthen themselves), he discovers that this world is interesting because he sees his mother use magic to heal his father and he is fascinated by it (in the manhwa the mother cures him who hurt his knee... As happens to Rudeus in the manga version) he studies a book of magic in secret and at a certain point he sells part of the house (in the manhwa he demolished it all, in the web comic I have no idea)... And this is the first episode, of course as we go on the similarities decrease, but they continue to be there, literally the only difference is that Arthur is not Rudeus...Eh, but Arthur is not an interesting character, he should literally be a despot in the body of a child and his thoughts are already "I have to protect these people at the cost of my life" narratively it makes no sense, as well as many other things.

Anyway, if you want to read Mushoku tensei, many would advise you against the manga (fans consider it the worst version, in my opinion it is not horrible but it is definitely the least detailed version) but they would advise you the Light novel, personally I would tell you, watch the anime (it flows faster and even if it skips many things it is still a great adaptation) and if you like the series then recover the Light novel to see the world building details and the cut parts.

On the "mediocre story" part yes, obviously personal taste has a huge impact, but there are many "narrative frivolities" in this series that shouldn't be in a product that is defined as high quality, for many it's not a problem, for me it definitely is, to give you an example, in dandadan a lot of similar bullshit happens, but you accept it because the mood is clearly that of a totally crazy series, so you ignore these problems because of the context (I think that those who follow dandadan for the plot have seen a different series than the one I saw, because it's a case in which the plot is just an excuse to show fights and crazy stuff) if the same things happened in... I don't know, Frieren, in that case they would definitely be mistakes.
As for sales, honestly it's a fact that I never consider, simply because for me it's certainly not synonymous with "better", Harry Potter sold extremely more than Lotr, just as many battle shonen sell much more than Berserk
Apr 18, 12:48 AM
Offline
Sep 2021
1224
the fans deserve this btw
Apr 18, 7:59 AM
Online
Jun 2022
28
Geracchio said:
There are those who think that such a low rating is entirely the fault of the animations... No, it's not like that, Arifureta has 6.72, Blue lock season 2 has 7.56, Berserk has 6.57, they are obviously low ratings (7.56 seems good but given how the user rating works it is just above sufficiency) but never as low as the current rating of tbate which is 5.76... So why is it so low? I'll explain.
Of course, the animations have had a big impact on this rating, but as already said it's not enough, I think the other factors that have caused tbate to sink into the top 11000 of the site are:

1: The story is banal and badly written, some say that it improves later, but honestly the narrative flaws are so many that it seems more likely to me that there were 1/2 good scenes (original? I don't know, given how the author works they could come from who knows what book he stole them from) and the fans cling to those, ignoring the mediocrity of everything else.

2: Too much hype, mainly fueled by the fan base that advertised this series as "Solo leveling killer" and "Mushoku tensei killer", raising the expectations of the public, who, finding themselves in front of mediocre stuff, rightly demolished it (personally, if someone came to me telling me this kind of thing, I wouldn't even listen to him, because someone who comes to me saying "this series is better than the others" instead of telling me an interesting incipit, I wouldn't take him seriously)

3: Clear plagiarism, fans continue to say no, but it is clear that many scenes and characters were stolen from other series (is everything copied? No, obviously not, but it copied some scenes, and the public noticed it immediately) and therefore the anime suffered the obvious consequences.

Personally, I feel sorry for some fans (not all, many that I see writing have too childish an attitude to make me feel sorry for them, but many others were people who were also pleasant to talk to) but if the author suffers a fair drop in his patreon subscriptions I'd say he could at least learn a lesson (I hope, if he writes something that doesn't make me think of other series every 5 minutes, I'll at least give him another look, despite tbate's disappointment)

I personally think it's not that. There's always a lot of mid and generic isekai anime every season with very average rates. With the recently new season of solo leveling, with a very good animation, fans of tbate that compare it with solo leveling were expecting a lot more. It's clear that the bad rating are from people who read the original material, because those who didn't, don't have a reason to give this a chance or think this is just mid and generic.
Apr 18, 10:07 AM
Offline
Nov 2021
134
Reply to Yumi_Karoni
Geracchio said:
There are those who think that such a low rating is entirely the fault of the animations... No, it's not like that, Arifureta has 6.72, Blue lock season 2 has 7.56, Berserk has 6.57, they are obviously low ratings (7.56 seems good but given how the user rating works it is just above sufficiency) but never as low as the current rating of tbate which is 5.76... So why is it so low? I'll explain.
Of course, the animations have had a big impact on this rating, but as already said it's not enough, I think the other factors that have caused tbate to sink into the top 11000 of the site are:

1: The story is banal and badly written, some say that it improves later, but honestly the narrative flaws are so many that it seems more likely to me that there were 1/2 good scenes (original? I don't know, given how the author works they could come from who knows what book he stole them from) and the fans cling to those, ignoring the mediocrity of everything else.

2: Too much hype, mainly fueled by the fan base that advertised this series as "Solo leveling killer" and "Mushoku tensei killer", raising the expectations of the public, who, finding themselves in front of mediocre stuff, rightly demolished it (personally, if someone came to me telling me this kind of thing, I wouldn't even listen to him, because someone who comes to me saying "this series is better than the others" instead of telling me an interesting incipit, I wouldn't take him seriously)

3: Clear plagiarism, fans continue to say no, but it is clear that many scenes and characters were stolen from other series (is everything copied? No, obviously not, but it copied some scenes, and the public noticed it immediately) and therefore the anime suffered the obvious consequences.

Personally, I feel sorry for some fans (not all, many that I see writing have too childish an attitude to make me feel sorry for them, but many others were people who were also pleasant to talk to) but if the author suffers a fair drop in his patreon subscriptions I'd say he could at least learn a lesson (I hope, if he writes something that doesn't make me think of other series every 5 minutes, I'll at least give him another look, despite tbate's disappointment)

I personally think it's not that. There's always a lot of mid and generic isekai anime every season with very average rates. With the recently new season of solo leveling, with a very good animation, fans of tbate that compare it with solo leveling were expecting a lot more. It's clear that the bad rating are from people who read the original material, because those who didn't, don't have a reason to give this a chance or think this is just mid and generic.
@Yumi_Karoni The fans may have had a slight influence, but keep in mind that even though it's a popular series in America, it's not that well-known in the rest of the world, and most importantly, the audience for novels and manhwa is much smaller than the anime audience, so it doesn't really influence the rating that much.
Apr 18, 10:19 AM

Offline
Feb 2024
2637
TBATE is an OEL based on a web novel, not a manhwa. That's why MAL doesn't add the comic to the database.
Apr 18, 10:21 AM
Offline
Jan 2018
4901
Almost the same score as biscuit hammer
Apr 18, 12:57 PM

Offline
Feb 2014
7960
Jeez, last week it was at around 6.60, but now is at 5.68, what happened?
Even if the show is legitimately terrible, a drop that drastic is not normal here on MAL.
Apr 18, 1:05 PM

Offline
Feb 2024
2637
Reply to Punkero
Jeez, last week it was at around 6.60, but now is at 5.68, what happened?
Even if the show is legitimately terrible, a drop that drastic is not normal here on MAL.
@Punkero

Probably bot accounts created to drop the rating. Teh ratings dont really natter until the show ends anyway.
Apr 18, 2:22 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
134
Reply to Punkero
Jeez, last week it was at around 6.60, but now is at 5.68, what happened?
Even if the show is legitimately terrible, a drop that drastic is not normal here on MAL.
@Punkero It is literally one of the worst anime of the last 20 years, not only for the animations, but also the plot, the characters are banal and no one in the audience liked them, add to that the fan base that insults the other series because they are annoyed by the failure, and the obvious stolen scenes, and there you have it, the 5.67 explained.
Apr 18, 3:52 PM
Offline
Mar 2019
360
animation is good though people can't think for themselves anymore they agree with a YouTuber opinion blindly and now they are creating accounts to review bomb this show if frieren had the same animation people would praise it hypocrites.
Apr 18, 5:37 PM

Offline
Oct 2020
1866
Reply to Geracchio
@Punkero It is literally one of the worst anime of the last 20 years, not only for the animations, but also the plot, the characters are banal and no one in the audience liked them, add to that the fan base that insults the other series because they are annoyed by the failure, and the obvious stolen scenes, and there you have it, the 5.67 explained.
Geracchio said:
literally one of the worst anime of the last 20 years, not only for the animations, but also the plot, the characters

now you're just being a Obnoxious that's all. Hello? Get a Life bro/Bot?
I thought you had some brain, since you were ranting about Novels earlier how it plagiarise from other works. That's absolutely not the case, you're just being an unreasonable hater. Or you're just under a Huge rock, being Oblivious.
WISHED I COULD ALSO GET TRANSPORTED TO A WORLD FULL OF MAGIC And DUNGEONS, please take me there too if you could (⁠ ⁠◜⁠‿⁠◝⁠ ⁠)⁠
Apr 18, 11:45 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
134
Reply to Anayan_Kashyap
Geracchio said:
literally one of the worst anime of the last 20 years, not only for the animations, but also the plot, the characters

now you're just being a Obnoxious that's all. Hello? Get a Life bro/Bot?
I thought you had some brain, since you were ranting about Novels earlier how it plagiarise from other works. That's absolutely not the case, you're just being an unreasonable hater. Or you're just under a Huge rock, being Oblivious.
@Anayan_Kashyap "bro/bot" have you come to believe this? XD
"Oh my god, the series I like has totally flopped, it's definitely the fault of the bots, it's not that practically no one liked it"
Come on, you can't really believe it, have you ever seen what happens to a series that is targeted by bots?
1: The rating would already be much lower (for example, for the movie "eternals" 500 1-star reviews were made... And this was before it even came out, and the rating at the beginning was close to 4, and by the beginning I mean the first week).
2:...You can see the number of people who voted for the anime, and the numbers are very normal, if you go and watch other series with the same number of episodes they have more or less the same numbers.

I understand that you were disappointed, but getting to the point of inventing things just to justify this failure doesn't seem like the best thing to me...

P.S. And instead you're right! I reveal the mask, I am not a person, I am the most advanced form of AI created by man. (I hope you understand that this was a joke.XD)
Apr 19, 12:27 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
2313
As a fan of the webcomic and webnovel, this is sad fr.
5.66????? broooo. 😭😭😭😭💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
Apr 19, 1:09 AM

Offline
Dec 2020
1575
everytime i look at it the rating has gone down more lol
Apr 19, 5:46 AM

Offline
Oct 2020
1866
@Geracchio It's not your fault. I am not blaming you, neither those who aren't in good terms with the adaptation. It's fair. Your opinion wouldn't make it any better/worse. It's a failure, true; but not up to how you exaggerate it.
What I honourably meant to say is, Stop your Nonsense shitposts. Your watch list is totally Biased, even tho that ain't a problem, enjoyment is subjective. But that makes your Opinions trivial for me to even comment on.
WISHED I COULD ALSO GET TRANSPORTED TO A WORLD FULL OF MAGIC And DUNGEONS, please take me there too if you could (⁠ ⁠◜⁠‿⁠◝⁠ ⁠)⁠
Apr 19, 11:19 AM
Offline
Nov 2021
134
Reply to Anayan_Kashyap
@Geracchio It's not your fault. I am not blaming you, neither those who aren't in good terms with the adaptation. It's fair. Your opinion wouldn't make it any better/worse. It's a failure, true; but not up to how you exaggerate it.
What I honourably meant to say is, Stop your Nonsense shitposts. Your watch list is totally Biased, even tho that ain't a problem, enjoyment is subjective. But that makes your Opinions trivial for me to even comment on.
@Anayan_Kashyap I must say that the list of things I marked as "seen" is a very small part of what I actually saw (I'll be honest, I don't have the patience to mark them all, when I tried I started from the top anime and marked some things I saw... But I did like 20 and then I gave up) you say it's a failure but not as serious as I exaggerate... I don't know, maybe you're right, but I've never seen such a serious flop in this sector (maybe Berserk 2016 comes close, but the public's reaction didn't seem that serious to me).

And no, I won't stop posting, my opinion on the series is extremely negative, I have my parameters for which I judged it as such and I don't see the problem, I didn't evaluate it based on nothing, I tried to read it (the manhwa) I didn't like it.
Apr 19, 4:18 PM
Offline
Jan 2025
2
So you mean that one of the most childish communities of all time is babyraging? Shocker
Apr 19, 4:22 PM
Offline
Jan 2025
2
Reply to Geracchio
@Anayan_Kashyap I must say that the list of things I marked as "seen" is a very small part of what I actually saw (I'll be honest, I don't have the patience to mark them all, when I tried I started from the top anime and marked some things I saw... But I did like 20 and then I gave up) you say it's a failure but not as serious as I exaggerate... I don't know, maybe you're right, but I've never seen such a serious flop in this sector (maybe Berserk 2016 comes close, but the public's reaction didn't seem that serious to me).

And no, I won't stop posting, my opinion on the series is extremely negative, I have my parameters for which I judged it as such and I don't see the problem, I didn't evaluate it based on nothing, I tried to read it (the manhwa) I didn't like it.
@Geracchio Dnno man. When I was in the hospital for quite some years I watched almost 900+ shows. I can tell you there's quite some garbage out there. Even if some of it is enjoyable garbage
Apr 19, 6:26 PM
Offline
Apr 2019
314
Geracchio said:
@Punkero It is literally one of the worst anime of the last 20 years, not only for the animations, but also the plot, the characters are banal and no one in the audience liked them, add to that the fan base that insults the other series because they are annoyed by the failure, and the obvious stolen scenes, and there you have it, the 5.67 explained.

Agree with this. Strongly think that the story is its biggest fault. It doesn’t seem that good and anything that’s kinda good feels like a straight copy from better anime.

Don’t understand why people were hyping this up so much
Apr 20, 1:15 AM
Offline
Nov 2021
134
Reply to MoimoiWa
@Geracchio Dnno man. When I was in the hospital for quite some years I watched almost 900+ shows. I can tell you there's quite some garbage out there. Even if some of it is enjoyable garbage
@MoimoiWa There's definitely a lot worse stuff in terms of story, but I think that from this point of view the problem is... I don't know if I'll be able to explain it well... Let's say the context of how the story was presented to the public, I'll try to give an example, if I go to see a film, and before seeing it it's presented to me as "a crazy film in the style of "The naked gun". " I will already start with a certain mentality, which leads me to accept practically everything, and even to laugh at any defects, but if the same film is presented to me as "one of the masterpieces of cinema" I will start with a different mentality, that is, I will expect to see an extremely well thought out film, and I will not judge it with the same parameters as a normal film, I don't know if I explained myself well, and obviously not everyone does this, but some do it even unconsciously.
Apr 20, 10:08 AM

Offline
May 2024
11
The animation has not been grate but still for it to fall this low. The fanbase just had too high of expectations for this adaptation which clearly did not deliver.

More topics from this board

Poll: » Saikyou no Ousama, Nidome no Jinsei wa Nani wo Suru? Episode 11 Discussion

Stark700 - Jun 11

41 by ineser »»
19 minutes ago

» What up with the producer crew

2mkpyro - Jun 12

15 by Ryun91 »»
4 hours ago

Poll: » Saikyou no Ousama, Nidome no Jinsei wa Nani wo Suru? Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - May 21

65 by akiraly »»
Yesterday, 4:37 PM

Poll: » Saikyou no Ousama, Nidome no Jinsei wa Nani wo Suru? Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Jun 4

81 by Geracchio »»
Yesterday, 10:53 AM

» Season 2 Confirmed + Trailer

hypexleaks - Jun 11

15 by Ethercruiser »»
Yesterday, 10:29 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login