Now that's a name I have not heard in a long time.
And yet it took me about a minute to find something
absolutely idiotic Digibro said about deconstruction.
What you ask for cannot exist within this institution, which exists to encourage incessant blather and various bad forms of engagement and argument, to flatter the unskilled while hiding from them their lack of skill, and to maintain a capitalist apparatus of consumers and money flows. All varieties of elitism that arise in such a system are a sham, because its foundations don't allow anything besides manipulative
post hoc justifications of analyses. As long as the sentiments—all of which are false consciousness—"taste is subjective," "don't watch it if you don't like it," "everyone is biased," "art is interesting because there is no consensus," or that criticism is "fighting over nothing," reign in your social space where you want to analyze art, nothing will result but more of the same forum muck. And it is in the interest of anyone who benefits from plugging into this system and using it as intended for it to continue making actual analysis impossible. I mean, look!: "I Was Browsing MAL As Usual Then I Realized My Web Novel Could Become Manga."
Skill in criticism generally comes from humanities departments. People who actually have this skill have spent enough time with it that they would rather do more serious things than unclog a helpless cesspool. And those like Digibro, who know only the spectacular forms of analysis and thus don't invest the time or seriousness necessary to become actual critics, can only become manipulative faux-intellectuals. I don't care what degree or lack thereof Digibro has; he is not good enough. The only anime critic I've come across who even comes close to knowing what he's talking about is Nick Creamer, and he's allowed his own political delusions to devour him like
capitalism ate critical theory in the 60s and 70s. Per MacIntyre, "Moral judgments are linguistic survivals from the practices of classical theism which have lost the context provided by these practices"; in the same way asking for real criticism in the anime community is like asking why the apes in
2001: A Space Odyssey didn't just go to Jupiter themselves.
Jupiter is beyond you, and nobody is coming to help you get there. All you can do if you actually appreciate the humanities and also like anime is huddle in small circles like the Albertian Order of Leibowitz. Doing so requires disowning almost all the regnant beliefs about art held by the anime community, which means nobody listening to you.