Reply to GinInYourJuice
@JaniSIr I think there are some longtime anime watchers/veterans that still prefer battle shounen over most other genres, but there are also those who only got into anime and battle shounen because their friends have an interest in them, and because it’s considered safe and acceptable to like lol. But yeah, I think a lot of battle shounen lovers either quit anime altogether shortly after, or they continue to watch anime but grow out of battle shounen over time.
| @GinInYourJuice I’ve seen a lot of “underrated” and non shounen anime and I still prefer battle shounen😅 |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Reply to Kenzolo-folk
@GinInYourJuice
I’ve seen a lot of “underrated” and non shounen anime and I still prefer battle shounen😅
I’ve seen a lot of “underrated” and non shounen anime and I still prefer battle shounen😅
| @Kenzolo-folk oh that's nice 👌 I personally don't see anything wrong with that at all @JaniSIr yeah that is pretty true |
Reply to alshu
DigiCat said:
no lying
no lying
Hummm.
DigiCat said:
I'll say it again
I'll say it again
No, you didn't formulated it exactly like that before. Now it makes sense.
DigiCat said:
more themes than just bullying and revenge on ojisa
more themes than just bullying and revenge on ojisa
Aren't those themes somehow adjacent tho?
Like because character X was bullied they took certain actions and ended up in even worst situation ect.
This is why I wrote at one stage that those two usually are "the roots" of what is happening...
DigiCat said:
So is giving one's opinion considered trashing now?
So is giving one's opinion considered trashing now?
No, but you just happened to trash one of my favourites, Congratulations!
DigiCat said:
Did i ever accuse you of trashing my favorites just because you feel they're shallow?
Did i ever accuse you of trashing my favorites just because you feel they're shallow?
Why wasting so much time responding to me than? You could diss me once or twice and forget the whole thing.
DigiCat said:
Did i ever go around saying "99% of shoujo are nothing but melodrama for the sake of shocking the audience"
Did i ever go around saying "99% of shoujo are nothing but melodrama for the sake of shocking the audience"
Why would I care even if you said that?
alshu said: No, you didn't formulated it exactly like that before. Now it makes sense. So you need things to be repeayed word for word exactly as they are to understand that i'm saying the same thing? Ok? I don't really get it though since the reason i formulated it differently is cuz you didn't understnd what i was saying in the first place alshu said: Aren't those themes somehow adjacent tho? Like because character X was bullied they took certain actions and ended up in even worst situation ect. This is why I wrote at one stage that those two usually are "the roots" of what is happening... No, not always alshu said: No, but you just happened to trash one of my favourites, Congratulations! So, if that is what you consider trashing, are you ready to admit trashing my fav shows too? Cuz what i said about your fav isn't that different from what you said about mine |
DigiCat said: So you need things to be repeayed word for word exactly No, you words at one point could mean something different (like which was the objective stuff). DigiCat said: are you ready to admit trashing my fav shows too? I didn't do it because those were your favourites (if at all, since the last time you kind of hinted that there aren't favourites of yours in this list), it (eventually) happened randomly. DigiCat said: Cuz what i said about your fav isn't that different from what you said about mine Maybe you did it to make it clear, that you see it in the same light? |
Reply to alshu
DigiCat said:
So you need things to be repeayed word for word exactly
So you need things to be repeayed word for word exactly
No, you words at one point could mean something different (like which was the objective stuff).
DigiCat said:
are you ready to admit trashing my fav shows too?
are you ready to admit trashing my fav shows too?
I didn't do it because those were your favourites (if at all, since the last time you kind of hinted that there aren't favourites of yours in this list), it (eventually) happened randomly.
DigiCat said:
Cuz what i said about your fav isn't that different from what you said about mine
Cuz what i said about your fav isn't that different from what you said about mine
Maybe you did it to make it clear, that you see it in the same light?
alshu said: No, you words at one point could mean something different (like which was the objective stuff) How am i saying anything different? I specified what was subjective and what objective from the very beginning, i can only assume you're either ignoring it cuz it doesn't fit your narrative, or are really that thick you can't tell the difference alshu said: I didn't do it because those were your favourites (if at all, since the last time you kind of hinted that there aren't favourites of yours in this list), it (eventually) happened randomly. 1) When did i hint that? 2) This is laugheble, you and i said almost identical things about the shounen i listet and Oooku respectively, yet when i say it it's trashing and when you say it it's not? alshu said: Maybe you did it to make it clear, that you see it in the same light? Yes i see it in the same light, and i do not consider finding someone else's fav melodramatic as trashing |
DigiCat said: when you say it it's not? It was trashing, but it wasn't personal favorite trashing...this is how I see most of battle shounen, Was that clear or I must elaborate more? |
Reply to alshu
DigiCat said:
when you say it it's not?
when you say it it's not?
It was trashing, but it wasn't personal favorite trashing...this is how I see most of battle shounen,
Was that clear or I must elaborate more?
| @alshu The way you're trying to twist things around by making out what i said is worse just because Oooku is one of your favs (which you mentioned after i supposidely trashed it) is frankly pathetic I'll say again, not liking something and giving a personal opinion on why is NOT trashing, but you seem to have trouble accepting opinions that differ from your own |
DigiCat said: The way you're trying to twist things around The way you are trying to transform my simple remarks into drama... |
Reply to LoveYourSmile
That's hilarious: 9 pages of two-screen long posts (on my mobile) discussing battle shonen, and in the end we find out there is no agreement on what battle shonen is.
| @LoveYourSmile And to think that the easiest way to solve all those problems would be just going back in time to the roots of this genre: Ring ni Kakero, the first series eligible to be called battle shounen, and Kinnikuman, the second one. I think that a lot of people discussing in this thread make the whole concept of a battle shounen show more complicated than it's in reality. But after seeing countless discussions on the topic of "what is a shounen, what is a seinen?!", I shouldn't be surprised, kekw. |
Reply to alshu
DigiCat said:
The way you're trying to twist things around
The way you're trying to twist things around
The way you are trying to transform my simple remarks into drama...
| @alshu Interesting, the one thing you have done yourself you do not want to take credit for |
DigiCat said: the one thing you have done yourself If you take my posts as drama, no wonder you see battle shounen as deep...you are overexaggerating on everything by default. |
| In just one word, I would say : Pedantry. |
Reply to alshu
DigiCat said:
the one thing you have done yourself
the one thing you have done yourself
If you take my posts as drama, no wonder you see battle shounen as deep...you are overexaggerating on everything by default.
| @alshu 🤭 nice projection there... |
DigiCat said: nice projection there Too lazy to come out with actual answer so - I am rubber you are glue. |
More topics from this board
» If you rarely rate any anime below 5/10, are you rating things wrong?thewiru - 2 hours ago |
16 |
by thewiru
»»
20 seconds ago |
|
» Why are chapter/episode comments stupid 90% of the time?ImNotAnOtaku1 - Oct 13 |
32 |
by ImNotAnOtaku1
»»
27 seconds ago |
|
» Who has a personal waifu who isn't a popular or relevant character known by many?fallout45 - 36 minutes ago |
4 |
by BigBoyAdvance
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» why are women being so unseen as audience ? ( 1 2 3 )ame - Oct 13 |
133 |
by Lucifrost
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» How do you express your love to your waifu?Zakatsuki_ - Today |
18 |
by FanofAction
»»
7 minutes ago |