Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Jul 8, 2024 10:12 PM
#1
Offline
Nov 2022
220
From the start of the series, Pirate is the main cour of the series.
(Although idk how they can be called pirate to begin with as they don't do pirate things, like … pirate = a person who sails on the sea and attacks and steals from other ships. So Blackbeard could be the only one to be called Pirate. Let's assume oda Sensei's Pirate means Sailors)
There's been about 0 pirate fights

I'm no one piece hater. When I read it again it sounds like I'm a hater, but I'm also a fellow Op fan and I love One Piece.

I just want to say how cool it would be if fights are done in Ship.
In that way, every Strawhat character can be utilized .
Jul 8, 2024 10:56 PM
#2
Offline
Aug 2021
65
chukesh007 said:
From the start of the series, Pirate is the main cour of the series.
(Although idk how they can be called pirate to begin with as they don't do pirate things, like … pirate = a person who sails on the sea and attacks and steals from other ships. So Blackbeard could be the only one to be called Pirate. Let's assume oda Sensei's Pirate means Sailors)
There's been about 0 pirate fights

I'm no one piece hater. When I read it again it sounds like I'm a hater, but I'm also a fellow Op fan and I love One Piece.

I just want to say how cool it would be if fights are done in Ship.
In that way, every Strawhat character can be utilized .

lol bro๐Ÿ™‚๐Ÿ”ชi have also noticed that
Jul 8, 2024 11:44 PM
#3
Online
Jun 2022
371
chukesh007 said:
From the start of the series, Pirate is the main cour of the series.
(Although idk how they can be called pirate to begin with as they don't do pirate things, like … pirate = a person who sails on the sea and attacks and steals from other ships. So Blackbeard could be the only one to be called Pirate. Let's assume oda Sensei's Pirate means Sailors)
There's been about 0 pirate fights

I'm no one piece hater. When I read it again it sounds like I'm a hater, but I'm also a fellow Op fan and I love One Piece.

I just want to say how cool it would be if fights are done in Ship.
In that way, every Strawhat character can be utilized .

in one piece, Pirates are referred to as people who do not abide by the law and do not follow the ways of the world government. so they set sail with motivation to seek freedom and a goal of discovering the one piece out of their own curiosity but everyone is not the same — there are good people and bad people who all set sail. in the eyes of world government, they are all outlaws —so they are Pirates.


P.S. In One Piece world, People who are outlaws,I.e., the ones who cannot pay tax to the world government, are either captured as slaves or are on the run and so they are deemed Pirates.
So being a pirate in one piece doesn't always have to have the so-called pirate looting villages and attacking others sort of thing
My 2024 Maloween candies:
Jul 9, 2024 2:33 AM
#4
Offline
Aug 2022
514
Plenty of ship battles against the Marines. I agree with you though, facing another crew on the high seas far from land would be awesome.
Jul 9, 2024 4:03 AM
#5
Online
Dec 2023
272
In One Piece World, According to World Government, any person who sails in the seas with pirate flag is a Pirate. It doesn't mateer if they are good or bad, that's why there motto is "Absolute Justice". Anyone who seeks freedom and sails to Sea is a Pirate and criminal(good or bad).

So by that definition there's been a lot of pirate fights. Luffy vs Alvida, Buggy, Don Krieg, Arlong, Crocodile etc. The list is endless. It's just rarely happens on seas because most of the Big Pirates and those whose stories we see are devil Fruit Eaters, so no pirate prefers to fight in sea. And we have seen endless fights on land
Jul 9, 2024 4:09 AM
#6

Offline
May 2014
3442
Pirates in One Piece aren't exactly the same as real ones. It still follows the one shot rules of peace-mains and morganeers.
Jul 9, 2024 5:01 AM
#7
Offline
Jan 2022
17
Reply to Ruthless_Lord
In One Piece World, According to World Government, any person who sails in the seas with pirate flag is a Pirate. It doesn't mateer if they are good or bad, that's why there motto is "Absolute Justice". Anyone who seeks freedom and sails to Sea is a Pirate and criminal(good or bad).

So by that definition there's been a lot of pirate fights. Luffy vs Alvida, Buggy, Don Krieg, Arlong, Crocodile etc. The list is endless. It's just rarely happens on seas because most of the Big Pirates and those whose stories we see are devil Fruit Eaters, so no pirate prefers to fight in sea. And we have seen endless fights on land
@Ruthless_Lord I just love how everyone is trying to make a differentiation between good and bad when even straw hat crew is full of bad people. Luffy is the worst of his crew. He breaks stuff when he goes anywhere that has other people. Nami is a thief and a loan shark that practices more than 100% loan fees. Sanji is a womanizer and reckless thug that resorts to violence quite often. Ussop is a world class liar that does nothing but lie in order to cover himself of make himself look good. I think the only one in their crew that doesn't blatantly break the law or causes inconveniences for every single normal person in the vicinity is Zoro and maybe Chopper.
Jul 9, 2024 5:06 AM
#8
Offline
Jan 2021
21
chukesh007 said:
From the start of the series, Pirate is the main cour of the series.
(Although idk how they can be called pirate to begin with as they don't do pirate things, like … pirate = a person who sails on the sea and attacks and steals from other ships. So Blackbeard could be the only one to be called Pirate. Let's assume oda Sensei's Pirate means Sailors)
There's been about 0 pirate fights

I'm no one piece hater. When I read it again it sounds like I'm a hater, but I'm also a fellow Op fan and I love One Piece.

I just want to say how cool it would be if fights are done in Ship.
In that way, every Strawhat character can be utilized .

I would love a few more fights on ships, like you said baratie is all that comes to mind. The issue now is the majority of characters are too strong that even a small fight would demolish the ships. So that ship has already sailed!
Jul 9, 2024 5:15 AM
#9

Offline
Sep 2016
17546
In One Piece pirates are outlaws on sea, the straw hats are outlaws, so your claim isn't true.
Jul 9, 2024 6:34 AM
Online
Dec 2023
272
doesntmatter93 said:
@Ruthless_Lord I just love how everyone is trying to make a differentiation between good and bad when even straw hat crew is full of bad people. Luffy is the worst of his crew. He breaks stuff when he goes anywhere that has other people. Nami is a thief and a loan shark that practices more than 100% loan fees. Sanji is a womanizer and reckless thug that resorts to violence quite often. Ussop is a world class liar that does nothing but lie in order to cover himself of make himself look good. I think the only one in their crew that doesn't blatantly break the law or causes inconveniences for every single normal person in the vicinity is Zoro and maybe Chopper.

I agree with you totally, I don't like either when someone says good or bad in One Piece, It's a gray and complex world, whether it's Navy or Pirates no side is just good or bad and that's one of the things that I love about One Piece. But most of things that you listed are for comic relief and doesn't have any serious negative effect on people. But even Luffy doesn't likes to see himself a hero. He would rather be a Pirate.
Jul 9, 2024 9:17 AM

Offline
Apr 2020
3719
Wait.... So you're saying One Piece isn't a realistic depiction of piracy then?

Damn, that's interesting.
Jul 9, 2024 9:31 AM
Offline
Nov 2019
4
Thats a nice catch, would be awesome if they could have fights like these and it would be fun to see how they use their powers fighting on a ship without damaging the ship and with water all around. fights would def be much more complex
Jul 9, 2024 9:35 AM
Isekai Trucker

Offline
Oct 2015
2551
In the early beginnings and up to like 300 episodes or so, there were great funny fights against marine ships and stations and funny arcs but now it's just boring.
Feels like the series is trying to be funny but it's not. I'd love more of the stuff from the earliest arcs rather than the series becoming more serious... with boring fights.
"You only realize the real value of something you discarded when you get the chance to pick it up again." - Rudeus Greyrat

Jul 9, 2024 9:41 AM
Offline
Sep 2021
720
chukesh007 said:
From the start of the series, Pirate is the main cour of the series.
(Although idk how they can be called pirate to begin with as they don't do pirate things, like … pirate = a person who sails on the sea and attacks and steals from other ships. So Blackbeard could be the only one to be called Pirate. Let's assume oda Sensei's Pirate means Sailors)
There's been about 0 pirate fights

I'm no one piece hater. When I read it again it sounds like I'm a hater, but I'm also a fellow Op fan and I love One Piece.

I just want to say how cool it would be if fights are done in Ship.
In that way, every Strawhat character can be utilized .

That's partly because Oda's definition of being a "pirate" is a bit "different" than the typical definition.

Please refer/see: Oda's One Shot Romance Dawn.

And tbf, Whole Cake Island had somewhat/so to say "naval battles".

But also, as far as I know, it's partly because of the power levels.

Oda himself made a comment about this around 2020.

"I want to draw a sea battle, but it's tough because there's guys on the boat more powerful than cannons." – Oda's comment from chapter 976.
Jul 9, 2024 2:34 PM
Offline
Apr 2019
21
This is similar to the bounty problem, nami always gets worried that pirates are going to hunt them, but the only time it has happened was in Jaya (in land) thanks to overconfidence as Luffys 100M bounty was overlooked lol so yeah, you can blame bounties for being a showstopper in regards to in-sea battles or persecution among pirates.

Also consider that while the series is over 25yo they have been only saling for less than a year so most of the arc time has been spend on land...
Jul 10, 2024 4:01 PM
Offline
Apr 2023
29
chukesh007 said:
From the start of the series, Pirate is the main cour of the series.
(Although idk how they can be called pirate to begin with as they don't do pirate things, like … pirate = a person who sails on the sea and attacks and steals from other ships. So Blackbeard could be the only one to be called Pirate. Let's assume oda Sensei's Pirate means Sailors)
There's been about 0 pirate fights

I'm no one piece hater. When I read it again it sounds like I'm a hater, but I'm also a fellow Op fan and I love One Piece.

I just want to say how cool it would be if fights are done in Ship.
In that way, every Strawhat character can be utilized .

Roger pirates vs WB pirates
Red hair pirates vs Kidd pirates
Heart pirates vs BB pirates
Technically Luffy vs Alvida
Strawhat pirates vs Don Krieg pirates vs Mihawk
Strawhat pirates vs 2 baroque works members (pretty sure inside Laboon)
Straw hats vs Big Mom
Strawhat pirates vs Thriller Bark (some people forget it’s a ship๐Ÿ’€)

Not on the sea:
Strawhat pirates vs Donquiote family
Strawhat pirates vs Foxy pirates
Strawhat pirates vs Buggy pirates
Strawhat pirates vs Kuro crew
Strawhat pirates vs Arlong pirates
Strawhat pirates vs Baroque works
Strawhat pirates + samurai + Marco + Otama who made the gifters join their side vs Beast pirates
BB pirates vs Kuja pirates + Rayleigh vs marines
Luffy vs Bellamy
Luffy vs Usopp
Zoro vs Killer
Dory vs Mory (the little garden giants)
Strawhat pirates vs Wapol pirates
Luffy vs BB in impel down

Questionable:
Rocks pirates vs Roger pirates + Garp
Strawhat pirates vs Hordy Jones’ pirates (it was in the sea)

These are all the fights where pirates fought each other for as far as I remember. Pretty sure you only talk about the ones on water tho
Jul 10, 2024 5:52 PM
Offline
Apr 2015
200
yeah I wish ship battles were a thing, but at a point you run into guys like Ace or Wapol that make ship fighting...not fun. heck, even the Pirates of the Carribean movies had to stretch things to ludicrous degrees to keep ship fights good.
Jul 11, 2024 10:00 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
468
chukesh007 said:
From the start of the series, Pirate is the main cour of the series.
(Although idk how they can be called pirate to begin with as they don't do pirate things, like … pirate = a person who sails on the sea and attacks and steals from other ships. So Blackbeard could be the only one to be called Pirate. Let's assume oda Sensei's Pirate means Sailors)
There's been about 0 pirate fights

I'm no one piece hater. When I read it again it sounds like I'm a hater, but I'm also a fellow Op fan and I love One Piece.

I just want to say how cool it would be if fights are done in Ship.
In that way, every Strawhat character can be utilized .

yeah as it stands we go literal years between seeing the crew on board the ship, hell they all split up on dressrosa and didnt all get on the merry until wanos ending. thats like 9 years.
Jul 13, 2024 6:31 AM
Offline
Nov 2022
220
MORExWINS said:
Thats a nice catch, would be awesome if they could have fights like these and it would be fun to see how they use their powers fighting on a ship without damaging the ship and with water all around. fights would def be much more complex

Yup that's what I'm trying to say, ships can't handle the fights so there have some members to protect ship and some to fight and some to Invade Like Real pirates do . Well it's hard to imagine how it could happen as how powerful pirates are now . Still hope to see one or two major fights with Ship in future .
Jul 13, 2024 6:48 AM
Offline
Jul 2015
215
Didn't they have a fight on ship with the sanji lookalike?
Jul 13, 2024 6:55 AM
Offline
Nov 2022
220
Stevewonder07 said:
Didn't they have a fight on ship with the sanji lookalike?

wth you saying .well I'm taking about ship to ship, crew to crew fight
And if you talking about Duval, they fight in Land ๐Ÿคท he was riding a bull or something .
Jul 13, 2024 7:40 AM

Offline
Aug 2019
2565
Ship battles are lame though; how many times have we seen the Marines attack pirate ships with cannonballs? Having pirates do that to each other would be just as bland. Having a battle on a ship just isn't visually interesting given the limited space.
Jul 13, 2024 3:50 PM
Offline
Sep 2021
720
chukesh007 said:
Stevewonder07 said:
Didn't they have a fight on ship with the sanji lookalike?

wth you saying .well I'm taking about ship to ship, crew to crew fight
And if you talking about Duval, they fight in Land ๐Ÿคท he was riding a bull or something .

What about the Big Mom pirates vs. the strawhats on Whole Cake Island? ๐Ÿค”
Jul 13, 2024 3:56 PM

Offline
Jun 2024
1793
The only real pirates are the ones without Devil Fruits.
Jul 13, 2024 8:36 PM
Offline
Nov 2022
220
Loaf_dontcare said:
chukesh007 said:

wth you saying .well I'm taking about ship to ship, crew to crew fight
And if you talking about Duval, they fight in Land ๐Ÿคท he was riding a bull or something .

What about the Big Mom pirates vs. the strawhats on Whole Cake Island? ๐Ÿค”

Nice catch, I hadn't thought about that .
But still that was an escape event, not head to head fight plus Captain wasn't on Ship .
And it's focused on others ongoing stuffs then ship fight .

There is a opening or something in which it shows Strawhat pirate vs 3 admiral on ship .

here I found it ;

https://youtu.be/nFF2m6VQVOM?si=SsiJgkWUIN_aK8QP

watch from 0:15

that's like a small teaser of how Ship fight would be
Jul 13, 2024 8:41 PM
Offline
Nov 2022
220
Early_Morning said:
Ship battles are lame though; how many times have we seen the Marines attack pirate ships with cannonballs? Having pirates do that to each other would be just as bland. Having a battle on a ship just isn't visually interesting given the limited space.

you just can't imagine .
I have a raw idea in my head
well watch this video featuring Strawhat vs Admirals ;

https://youtu.be/nFF2m6VQVOM?si=SsiJgkWUIN_aK8QP

watch from 0:15
Jul 14, 2024 8:27 AM
Offline
Sep 2021
720
chukesh007 said:
Loaf_dontcare said:

What about the Big Mom pirates vs. the strawhats on Whole Cake Island? ๐Ÿค”

Nice catch, I hadn't thought about that .
But still that was an escape event, not head to head fight plus Captain wasn't on Ship .
And it's focused on others ongoing stuffs then ship fight .

There is a opening or something in which it shows Strawhat pirate vs 3 admiral on ship .

here I found it ;

https://youtu.be/nFF2m6VQVOM?si=SsiJgkWUIN_aK8QP

watch from 0:15

that's like a small teaser of how Ship fight would be


I know that opening.
That's not very realistic, tho. (As far as realistic goes, lol)

Look up Oda's author comment from chapter 976.
(It's not a spoiler, it's from a chapter in Wano)

Edited.
Jul 14, 2024 9:29 AM
Offline
Nov 2022
220
Loaf_dontcare said:
chukesh007 said:

Nice catch, I hadn't thought about that .
But still that was an escape event, not head to head fight plus Captain wasn't on Ship .
And it's focused on others ongoing stuffs then ship fight .

There is a opening or something in which it shows Strawhat pirate vs 3 admiral on ship .

here I found it ;

https://youtu.be/nFF2m6VQVOM?si=SsiJgkWUIN_aK8QP

watch from 0:15

that's like a small teaser of how Ship fight would be


I know that opening.
That's not very realistic, tho. (As far as realistic goes, lol)

Look up Oda's author comment from chapter 976.
(It's not a spoiler, it's from a chapter in Wano)

Edited.

How about it
They know if they go all out they'll wreak the ship So they'll try to Hold back their power like in Dragon ball .

Anyways
Recent manga chapter fights technically can be called Ship fight . Isn't that Awesome .
Aug 4, 2024 4:45 PM
Offline
Jan 2022
17
Reply to Ruthless_Lord
doesntmatter93 said:
@Ruthless_Lord I just love how everyone is trying to make a differentiation between good and bad when even straw hat crew is full of bad people. Luffy is the worst of his crew. He breaks stuff when he goes anywhere that has other people. Nami is a thief and a loan shark that practices more than 100% loan fees. Sanji is a womanizer and reckless thug that resorts to violence quite often. Ussop is a world class liar that does nothing but lie in order to cover himself of make himself look good. I think the only one in their crew that doesn't blatantly break the law or causes inconveniences for every single normal person in the vicinity is Zoro and maybe Chopper.

I agree with you totally, I don't like either when someone says good or bad in One Piece, It's a gray and complex world, whether it's Navy or Pirates no side is just good or bad and that's one of the things that I love about One Piece. But most of things that you listed are for comic relief and doesn't have any serious negative effect on people. But even Luffy doesn't likes to see himself a hero. He would rather be a Pirate.
Ruthless_Lord said:
I agree with you totally, I don't like either when someone says good or bad in One Piece, It's a gray and complex world, whether it's Navy or Pirates no side is just good or bad and that's one of the things that I love about One Piece. But most of things that you listed are for comic relief and doesn't have any serious negative effect on people. But even Luffy doesn't likes to see himself a hero. He would rather be a Pirate.


The thing is they do differentiate between good and bad, for example people Luffy approves of are considered good. People he doesn't are considered bad.

And you might think that all his actions are for comic relief but then everything in the show is unimpactful because everything happens for dramapoints or comic relief... Whenever Luffy breaks a few walls while people are inside those homes it is comedic relief but when some "bad" pirate does it the show presents it as such an important and condemnable action (first Buggy arc). And it is not like the characters are flawed but in time they learn or grow out of doing bad things, from their point of view their actions and decisions are not even on the "bad" spectrum. Som yeah I would say the pirates in the world of OP are the real bad guys, the government might be bad but the pirates are worse. Also keep in mind that a lot of the bad things the government does is either in response or because of pirates.
Jun 7, 11:59 PM

Online
Jul 2023
5188
"There's no Pirate Fights"

There's human



๐“•๐“ธ๐“ป๐”€๐“ช๐“ป๐“ญ ๐“ฒ๐“ผ
๐“ฝ๐“ฑ๐“ฎ ๐”€๐“ช๐”‚.....

More topics from this board

» Oda should not redeem the celestial dragons

Youbamii - Jun 10

12 by Loaf_dontcare »»
36 minutes ago

Poll: » One Piece Episode 1132 Discussion

FMmatron - Jun 8

41 by Elyshion »»
41 minutes ago

Poll: » One Piece Episode 836 Discussion ( 1 2 )

SamBlack - May 12, 2018

56 by Titanfan93 »»
3 hours ago

Poll: » One Piece Episode 629 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

LunyRem - Jan 18, 2014

105 by Darkzepheran »»
3 hours ago

» Song Name [Spoilers]

infinite_Shadows - Jun 9

3 by Lanarde »»
4 hours ago
Itโ€™s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login