None of the above. The first three points are just opinions/preferences, the fourth doesn't really exist or, to be more precise, most of the times i've seen people accused of this they were actually just discussing as it's normal in a discussion group. You need to realize that NO ONE (really, no one) cares about your taste. That being said i could be interested in the reasons WHY you disliked or liked something. So why wouldn't you discuss taste? What exactly is "toxic" about it? I find more toxic to shut down every discussion with "it's just my taste touch grass" than actually criticizing other people taste, as long as said criticism is done in a thougthful manner.
I dislike:
1- the one spreading disinformation and misleading concepts, usually out of a refusal to accept that their "western fan lens" doesn't always apply to japan culture and anime industry. Some examples: the budget myth, studio culture (studio culture = the idea that studios have their personal "style" or that which studio makes the anime influence the quality)
2- the ones talking about anime as a sort of "genre" or separated medium. Those are usually the people saying stuff like "anime and cartoons are different things" (or, probably even worse: "I know they are technically the same but ackthually anime have different targets/a different art-style/whatever bullshit stereotypical reason") and also the same persons that in 2023 still feel the need to write essays about why anime aren't for children (usually looking very childish in the process), or recently the new hip thing to say is that "anime is better than western entertainment because there's no wOkE cUlTuRe/le evil SJW". This cathegory is also the reason why a lot of people not-watching anime are convinced that anime are all similar, likely either perverted or childish.
3- This is not really an "anime fan" thing, but seems very prominent in anime fandom: people that autonomously decide that a genre or a branch of the medium is trash without ever seeing anything of it or even worse: maybe they've seen something, liked it a lot, but they decided that's "not like other in the genre" for no reason at all. Classic examples are mecha and majokko, i'd say CGDCT (i genuinely don't like the genre much too but i've actually tried to watch at least the most revered shows in it, like K-On and Euphonium, and i even liked Bocchi a lot, but still i wouldn't say something as stupid as "Bocchi is soo different from the rest of the genre" because i genuinely don't know much about it)
EDIT:
4- (thanks people for reminding me of that weird subgenre of anime fans) the reactionary ones believing anime somehow confirm their reactionary bullshit (often even when talking about shows with literally the opposite message, for example Gundam. There's specifically a dumbfuck YT channel i have in mind, i don't want to publicize that idiot by saying his name but if you've seen some of his video you know who i'm talking about)
Oznerol7Feb 3, 7:40 AM