| It's been discussed before quiet frequently but yeah can't do much about it, nor do i care much though. It's kinda sad that people are "defending" their "favourite" shows in such a way just cause they want it to stay at the top of a relatively niche website. Anyway i polled together the 1/10 score % for any of the current "top 10" anime on the site incase anyone is intrested cause i kinda wanted to see for myself. 1/10 = 2.0% (39347 votes) - Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood - 9.11 1/10 = 4.2% (3441 votes) - Bleach: TYBW - 9.10 1/10 = 2.5% (9359 votes) - Kaguya-sama: LiW S3 - 9.09 1/10 = 0.7% (8752 votes) - Steins;Gate - 9.08 1/10 = 3.4% (7638 votes) - Gintama° - 9.07 1/10 = 0.8% (11324 votes) - Attack on Titan Season 3 Part 2 - 9.06 1/10 = 1.9% (4071 votes) - Gintama' - 9.05 1/10 = 5.2% (2937 votes)- Gintama: The Final - 9.05 1/10 = 1.8% (2785 votes) - Gintama': Enchousen - 9.04 1/10 = 0.4% (6186 votes) - Hunter x Hunter (2011) - 9.04 I mean say whatever u want about these shows really, but at the end of the day whilst i may not like LiW or Bleach in general and even after watching them. I wouldn't ever rate them a 1/10 they aren't a traumatic experience. |
NotT5JDec 5, 2022 1:54 PM
| read Kingdom, read all of When They Cry and play Muv-Luv + Integrate if that ever releases or die |
| FMAB isn't my favourite, but I am fine with it being on top compared to other nonsense sequels like Bleach that almost nobody rates except the fans. |
 |
| can't relate, all the anime that i "stan" have average to low ratings. |
| Superiority. Inserting Dominance. Elitism. Etc. |
| Rosa Umineko Drip The Witch of Badassery. |
Igreja said: Superiority. Inserting Dominance. Elitism. Etc. > Elitism  "Haha I have ergo proxy aku no hana lain nhk textolytitties in my favorite your taste sucks" |
Cnut_the_GreatDec 5, 2022 1:47 PM
The_Xicko said: Yet you made a discussion thread about it.Deago said: FMAB isn't my favourite, but I am fine with it being on top compared to other nonsense sequels like Bleach that almost nobody rates except the fans. I don't really care about anything being at the top |
|
5ika said: NotT5J said: It's been discussed before quiet frequently but yeah can't do much about it, nor do i care much though. It's kinda sad that people are "defending" their "favourite" shows in such a way just cause they want it to stay at the top of a relatively niche website. Anyway i polled together the 1/10 score % for any of the current "top 10" anime on the site incase anyone is intrested cause i kinda wanted to see for myself. 1/10 = 2.0% - Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood - 9.11 1/10 = 4.2% - Bleach: TYBW - 9.10 1/10 = 2.5% - Kaguya-sama: LiW S3 - 9.09 1/10 = 0.7% - Steins;Gate - 9.08 1/10 = 3.4% - Gintama° - 9.07 1/10 = 0.8% - Attack on Titan Season 3 Part 2 - 9.06 1/10 = 1.9% - Gintama' - 9.05 1/10 = 5.2% - Gintama: The Final - 9.05 1/10 = 1.8% - Gintama': Enchousen - 9.04 1/10 = 0.4% - Hunter x Hunter (2011) - 9.04 I mean say whatever u want about these shows really, but at the end of the day whilst i may not like LiW or Bleach in general and even after watching them. I wouldn't ever rate them a 1/10 they aren't a traumatic experience. The percentage of 1/10 votes is pretty bad metric to show review bombing because popular shows will seem less affected. FMAB's 2% has more 1/10 votes (39k) than any other you mentioned for eample Gintama final has under 3k even if it shows as 5.2% since the show is less popular. Otherwise you are completely right about the fact that none of the 1/10 ratings are deserved. I'll edit numbers to it soonish when i have some time, i forgot about that mb! |
| read Kingdom, read all of When They Cry and play Muv-Luv + Integrate if that ever releases or die |
| Has anyone ever stopped to consider that it's not this elusive boogeyman of "FMA:B fans" (a title which I highly doubt has enough of a dedicated fanbase to act as rabid over something as inconsequential as MAL ratings anyways), and instead is just an average brigade of trolls that review bombs anything that shoots up the ratings quickly, especially bigger name battle shonen that are known to have fans locked in constant flame wars (i.e CSM, Bleach, JJK, KnY, and any other battle shonen that's exploded in popularity recently)? No? Ok then. |
RyiebeJan 12, 2023 1:06 PM
 |
| To be fair, Bleach: Sennen Kessen-hen has around 305,000 members. And FMAB has over 3 million members. This arc of Bleach just came out recently, so it only makes sense that as more people watch it and form their opinions upon the anime, not everyone is going to be upvoting it a 9 or a 10 |
 Tipsy and giddy, away with all the riddles Unbeknown and unconsumed they shine The heart of the fire rekindles Without needing to cross any line |
| Your post is gonna get locked. Bleach twerkers probably did the same. Also Kaguya twerkers,Gintama twerkers, Death note twerkers. If you think about it, everyone is just twerking aimlessly for their favorite show on this website. Also, it's always weird to see one arc out of a fairly low-rated series rated so highly. It's a huge outlier from the series as a whole and that kind of thing is almost always a result of immense hype. I probably won't watch Bleach in a few years so I can't give my verdict on whether that hype is justified or not. |
samsince04Dec 5, 2022 2:59 PM
  Arteta's Tricky Reds!   |
| Is it still relevant? As far as I remember, the admins came up with some kind of thing that neutralizes formal ratings. |
 |
| Aa long as it's not one piece at the #1 place, I don't care. |
| . |
The_Xicko said: RobertBobert said: Is it still relevant? As far as I remember, the admins came up with some kind of thing that neutralizes formal ratings. What would the neutralization of formal ratings do Not really quite sure what you mean by formal ratings tbh How long have you been on this site? This topic has already been discussed several times and the admins have introduced a system that, according to their assurances, does not allow such ratings to affect the overall rating. |
|
5ika said: NotT5J said: It's been discussed before quiet frequently but yeah can't do much about it, nor do i care much though. It's kinda sad that people are "defending" their "favourite" shows in such a way just cause they want it to stay at the top of a relatively niche website. Anyway i polled together the 1/10 score % for any of the current "top 10" anime on the site incase anyone is intrested cause i kinda wanted to see for myself. 1/10 = 2.0% - Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood - 9.11 1/10 = 4.2% - Bleach: TYBW - 9.10 1/10 = 2.5% - Kaguya-sama: LiW S3 - 9.09 1/10 = 0.7% - Steins;Gate - 9.08 1/10 = 3.4% - Gintama° - 9.07 1/10 = 0.8% - Attack on Titan Season 3 Part 2 - 9.06 1/10 = 1.9% - Gintama' - 9.05 1/10 = 5.2% - Gintama: The Final - 9.05 1/10 = 1.8% - Gintama': Enchousen - 9.04 1/10 = 0.4% - Hunter x Hunter (2011) - 9.04 I mean say whatever u want about these shows really, but at the end of the day whilst i may not like LiW or Bleach in general and even after watching them. I wouldn't ever rate them a 1/10 they aren't a traumatic experience. The percentage of 1/10 votes is pretty bad metric to show review bombing because popular shows will seem less affected. FMAB's 2% has more 1/10 votes (39k) than any other you mentioned for eample Gintama final has under 3k even if it shows as 5.2% since the show is less popular. Otherwise you are completely right about the fact that none of the 1/10 ratings are deserved. The Alchemist has simply been on this list for the longest time and moreover, he has participated in various rating wars for the longest time. The number of negative ratings he really has little meaning in the context. |
|
The_Xicko said: RobertBobert said: How long have you been on this site? This topic has already been discussed several times and the admins have introduced a system that, according to their assurances, does not allow such ratings to affect the overall rating. Haven't been active on here since like 2021 probably. How can there be a system that prevents people from giving shows a 1/10? Again. A system that does not allow you to influence the rating by random 1/10 put by new accounts. Don't just give ratings like that. |
|
| Interspecies reviewers almost beat it until Mal changed the rules. Too bad really. |
| My waifu is the most wonderful waifu. Mai Valentine. |
The_Xicko said: RobertBobert said: Again. A system that does not allow you to influence the rating by random 1/10 put by new accounts. Don't just give ratings like that. Okay? People can still just give the 1/10s on their legit accounts. Even if this somehow completely doesn't allow for the rating to be affected that wasn't the point of the thread. The point was to shit on the people who do it. Believe me, even the fans of this show are tired of these people. Because they have to prove that they don't exist, lol. |
|
tchitchouan said: can't relate, all the anime that i "stan" have average to low ratings.  <This is what you see when you look in the mirror.^ |
 Cats see demons and I'm done pretending they don't. What do you think they are looking at when they stare at the abyss, when staring at the corner of the room? There's something threatening us, something we can't to see. Why do you think cats have 9 Lives? They have them to protect the likes of you and me, they fight the demons around us at night and sometimes lose their lives, but they have 9 so they can protect you until their last life is consumed. Thank you. |
The_Xicko said: RobertBobert said: Believe me, even the fans of this show are tired of these people. Because they have to prove that they don't exist, lol. In what world do they not exist lmao? Am I supposed to explain even such a simple pun? |
|
| MAL top ranks are like 90% sequels and recency bias so who the fuck even cares about that shitty list and what is on top of it? |
The_Xicko said: What else could that have meant but people downvoting shows to keep FMA B at the top don't exist And that fans of the show have to prove it Okay, I'll spread it on my fingers. People get annoyed by someone's existence because they have to prove that someone doesn't exist. Got it? |
|
The_Xicko said: RobertBobert said: Okay, I'll spread it on my fingers. People get annoyed by someone's existence because they have to prove that someone doesn't exist. Got it? Isn't that actually what I just said You make's me feel myself very drunk. |
|
| Giving them attention for it is exactly what they want. People know this, right? |
| I am sure there's a word for the psychological phenomenon that causes people to behave this way. The anime community is chock full of people who parents failed them. |
 |
| It's more like people just don't want or think new anime which ends up reaching the #1 spot rather than caring so much to keep FMAB up there. No one is too worried if FMAB stays up there or not since there has been times iirc when it wasn't #1 for sometime while Gintama was #1 unless I'm remembering it wrong. Most new anime don't deserve the #1 spot, let alone sequels which returned after years when people already forgot about Bleach. |
The_Xicko said: FanofAction said: Giving them attention for it is exactly what they want. People know this, right? Okay I just won't criticize or shit on anyone from now on seems fun Not the point. The point is people wonder why this is still a thing, threads like this is part of the reason why. People are free to poke fun at it as much as they want, I think its hilarious personally, but all this does is feed the cycle. |
| Thread locked for not encouraging discussion. Anime Discussion Rules 2: Please refrain from creating threads that do not encourage discussion. e. MAL community data
e.g. Saying that series X should have a higher/lower score/count e.g. Specific reviews, moderation of data/community content/reviews, etc. |
More topics from this board
» which antagonist is your fave and which one you cannot JUST TAKE SERIOUSLY ?ame - 7 hours ago |
14 |
by Zarutaku
»»
47 seconds ago |
|
» Is it over for newcomer boomers?LenRea - 6 hours ago |
13 |
by Nemo_Niemand
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» ❄️ Anime Winter 2024 Male Characters Tournament ( 1 2 3 4 5 )ISeeLifePeople - Apr 14 |
203 |
by Coaghim
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » How do you watch anime?RobertBobert - Yesterday |
25 |
by Atashi_Agatha
»»
20 minutes ago |
|
» Do you watch anything else besides anime? ( 1 2 )Alpha_1_Zero - Apr 21 |
83 |
by Atashi_Agatha
»»
23 minutes ago |