The final episode itself had it's moments, and I can't say I hate it, but it'd be hard to call myself a fan. I assume Adam Smasher's appearance here is really cool for those who played the game, but I didn't feel the earlier mention of him was enough build up to make this encounter feel truly hype for me. And while I liked most of the cast, the only death that actually made me feel sad was Rebecca's. In part because in the last few episodes she developed herself into probably my favourite character of the bunch, and in part because of how unceremonious it was. But Kiwi's and David's didn't really hit me at all, the former for her recent betrayals and the latter for how much of a blatant foregone conclusion it was. I also don't think the inclusion of flashbacks to earlier episodes worked all that well here. A few of them managed to connect, but most of them kind of felt like padding, or just a cheap trick to make this feel sadder without really being earned.
I started watching this show entirely because in a youtube video completely unrelated to Cyberpunk, they used the song "I Really Want to Stay at Your House", and I fell in love instantly with many of the comments in the video hyping up it's inclusion in Cyberpunk. Which brings me to a quasi-complaint, I kinda think using the song twice in a row was a bit overkill. Like, it felt like they were using the song itself as a crutch, and the reason it's a quasi-complaint and not a complaint is because well, it does work. I did get emotional during the scenes it play, not to tears or anything but it was effective, and it was effective because of the song. "I Really Want to Stay at Your House" did all the heavy lifting, in truth I never fully bought into Lucy & David's relationship. Which I think is more of a fault of the limited episode run.
As a whole, and an unpopular opinion, but episode 3 with the car chase caper remained my favourite episode, and I feel it would've benefitted the series to have more showcases like that. A fun caper where the characters got to play off each-other. There's not much depth afforded to the crew, but they were all likable and I truly feel the series was at it's best when it was playing off their dynamic, for example Rebecca and David's walk in episode 8. Having more time with them would've allowed moments like their deaths to hit much harder, even if it was just two more episodes it would've done a lot. The pacing here is fittingly breakneck like David himself, but it does leave a lot of the emotional aspect pretty hollow for me.
This series based on story & characters would've probably gotten a 6, maybe even a 5 from me, but Edgerunners is supported by strong visuals and a fantastic score. Like I said, I love "I Really Want to Stay at Your House" so much I basically watched this show entirely for the song, but the rest of the soundtrack were often highlights. I think many of them originating from the game itself, I'll have to look into it. And the visuals speak for themselves. I really like how graphic the violence is willing to get, even if that's often the only thing about the action I like, and there's a strong style to the visual aesthetic, like text covering the screen like when David needed to start the car in episode 3 or when "Lucy" convinced David to put on the cyberskeleton in episode 9. And I'm honestly surprised how much I enjoyed those call chats with the little screens popping up, think it helped sell the setting.
So ultimately, 7/10. Oh, last thing I'll say is I generally liked the dub, don't regret choosing it over the subs. Rebecca probably had the strongest performance. |