| I just finished watching this anime today. I went to it with no expectation. To my Suprise this anime was Good! 8/10! Animation and Art syle - 8/10 Its Definitely above average and there are scene that looks really great! The Premise is Unique, its like Bruce Almighty Anime Version. I have read in this forum why so many people seems to dislike this anime Its seems it was Overhype and the creator of this anime said This is the saddest Anime and when it did not reach their expecation they hate it to so much. Some said they hate the slapstick comedy, Well Gintana almost all of its Jokes is slapstick comedy, I dont see people complaining to it. and lastly some say the ending seems rush, well it kinda a little rush but overall I think it got its job done so no complain in my part. Overall if you are reading this and thinking of watching this anime Give it a Try, Its really Good! |
| This anime is what I call "anime with high potential but ended with wrong execution" |
 Nanami Hiromachi  Anna Mochizuki  |
Yamada_desu said: Not hating your taste about anime, But you give The Way of the House Husband a 9! and that anime is just slide/power point presentation. The Day I Became God is Objectively better.it's not good , I gave him 5/10 |
| i gave The Anime a Chance it is still a 4/10 For me. |
soulguard said: kinda sad to hear that, For me I did not find any real bad thing about it. Like I said the animation and art style is above average, The Premise is Unique/Interesting, the Comedy is subjective it did not make me laugh out loud, But it keep me from being bored.i gave The Anime a Chance it is still a 4/10 For me. |
RjtheGreat14 said: Yamada_desu said: Not hating your taste about anime, But you give The Way of the House Husband a 9! and that anime is just slide/power point presentation. The Day I Became God is Objectively better.it's not good , I gave him 5/10 Each person has a different taste. And I also gave the anime an 8/10 because it is short but very entertaining and funny and also shows true scenes. You really don't have to try to force your opinion on everyone.... |
| It was a solid show. Not as good as other Madea's works, but still. Why won't just write a review? |
 |
soulguard said: RjtheGreat14 said: Not hating your taste about anime, But you give The Way of the House Husband a 9! and that anime is just slide/power point presentation. The Day I Became God is Objectively better. Each person has a different taste. And I also gave the anime an 8/10 because it is short but very entertaining and funny and also shows true scenes. You really don't have to try to force your opinion on everyone.... Again Not hating about your taste in anime, I am just questioning it. You Gave Redo a Healer a 9/10. and The Day I Became God only 4/10? I know they are diffrent genre but cmon. |
Yamada_desu said: RjtheGreat14 said: Not hating your taste about anime, But you give The Way of the House Husband a 9! and that anime is just slide/power point presentation. The Day I Became God is Objectively better. You watched the way of the house husband??? I just watched 1 episode, when I seen the almost power point/slide show presentation, I dropped it. |
| The show's ending was just basically a remake of a classic anime scene in AIR without sufficient character development in its buildup. The last few episodes literally had me laughing because everything just didn't make sense at all. For example, there was a sudden development of a romantic relationship between Hina and Youta when previously they acted like family towards each other. It became more ridiculous when you realised that Youta liked Izanami at first and the change in feelings just wasn't explained at all. Maeda apparently wrote this in tribute of his previous works such as AIR and Clannad but I feel that this was kind of an insult to those classics? It's obvious that he has ran out of ideas sadly. I would say the comedy in the first few episodes were okay but the ending was just dumpster fire. |
firemint149Sep 6, 2022 6:02 AM
firemint149 said: The show's ending was just basically a remake of a classic anime scene in AIR without sufficient character development in its buildup. The last few episodes literally had me laughing because everything just didn't make sense at all. For example, there was a sudden development of a romantic relationship between Hina and Youta when previously they acted like family towards each other. It became more ridiculous when you realised that Youta liked Izanami at first and the change in feelings just wasn't explained at all. Maeda apparently wrote this in tribute of his previous works such as AIR and Clannad but I feel that this was kind of an insult to those classics? It's obvious that he has ran out of ideas sadly. I would say the comedy in the first few episodes were okay but the ending was just dumpster fire. What do you mean the last episode does not make any sense? It clear state that Hina have a quantum computer in her brain that help her somehow to recover from her sickness and it also able her to have near ominiscent power. To be Honest since you said about clannad, Clannad Ending didn't make sense at all!!! From Being a True to life story about a single father raising a her daughter then suddenly it became steins gate??? If you need to watch a Youtube video just to undestand clannad ending that's just BAD! (This is not Darksouls level of story telling!) I have to agree the romantic feelings of Youta and Hina is underdeveloped, But there are scenes in the anime hinted that Hina is Jealous when Youta is talking to her Crush. The Day I Became God is not a Masterpiece, But I think it deserve more. |
RjtheGreat14 said: firemint149 said: The show's ending was just basically a remake of a classic anime scene in AIR without sufficient character development in its buildup. The last few episodes literally had me laughing because everything just didn't make sense at all. For example, there was a sudden development of a romantic relationship between Hina and Youta when previously they acted like family towards each other. It became more ridiculous when you realised that Youta liked Izanami at first and the change in feelings just wasn't explained at all. Maeda apparently wrote this in tribute of his previous works such as AIR and Clannad but I feel that this was kind of an insult to those classics? It's obvious that he has ran out of ideas sadly. I would say the comedy in the first few episodes were okay but the ending was just dumpster fire. What do you mean the last episode does not make any sense? It clear state that Hina have a quantum computer in her brain that help her somehow to recover from her sickness and it also able her to have near ominiscent power. To be Honest since you said about clannad, Clannad Ending didn't make sense at all!!! From Being a True to life story about a single father raising a her daughter then suddenly it became steins gate??? If you need to watch a Youtube video just to undestand clannad ending that's just BAD! (This is not Darksouls level of story telling!) I have to agree the romantic feelings of Youta and Hina is underdeveloped, But there are scenes in the anime hinted that Hina is Jealous when Youta is talking to her Crush. The Day I Became God is not a Masterpiece, But I think it deserve more. Lol. Play the original galgame of Clannad before commenting on its ending. I am not going to explain it here. #19 explained it a little as well, there were also hints throughout the series. And I don't agree that an anime that requires a Youtube video to understand its ending is necessarily bad, but that is to each their own. I have seen worse animes out there with an ending that is harder to understand than Clannad, and still sounds ridiculous/weak even with a Youtube video/Reddit post to explain it e.g. Glasslip, Mahou Sensou, etc. At least I felt that Clannad's ending was justified after having it explained to me. Sure, the plot of having a quantum computer in Hina's brain might have worked with proper development of the plot through the 12 episodes. But instead, Maeda wasted like 7(?) episodes on his usual slapstick comedy without any actual major progression on the main plot. The sudden change of tone of the series (and the underdevelopment of Hina and Youta's romantic relationship) was what made this anime fail. |
firemint149Sep 6, 2022 8:04 AM
SuntProstMare said: firemint149 said: Lol. Play the original galgame of Clannad before commenting on its ending. I am not going to explain it here. #19 explained it a little as well, there were also hints throughout the series. And I don't agree that an anime that requires a Youtube video to understand its ending is necessarily bad, but that is to each their own. I have seen worse animes out there with an ending that is harder to understand than Clannad, and still sounds ridiculous/weak even with a Youtube video/Reddit post to explain it e.g. Glasslip, Mahou Sensou, etc. At least I felt that Clannad's ending was justified after having it explained to me. Sure, the plot of having a quantum computer in Hina's brain might have worked with proper development of the plot through the 12 episodes. But instead, Maeda wasted like 7(?) episodes on his usual slapstick comedy without any actual major progression on the main plot. The sudden change of tone of the series (and the underdevelopment of Hina and Youta's romantic relationship) was what made this anime fail. many times when there is a YouTube video that explain the ending many times make you love even more a series, depends on the series, the Only thing that you said that i didn't like was that you Need to plaid a galgame to understand more the ending, that is kinda bad to do but whatever. I might have sounded a little harsh there so apologies. But my point was that Clannad's anime ending was certainly not out of the blue as stated by the OP. So there's that. :) |
SuntProstMare said: firemint149 said: I might have sounded a little harsh there so apologies. But my point was that Clannad's anime ending was certainly not out of the blue as stated by the OP. So there's that. :) don't worry, I was more talking about how a Company did a galgame to finish an anime😅 The galgame was the original work actually. But they are similar in terms of the ending and it shouldn't matter which one you choose as long as you understood it. (Except the anime did not show Ryou's true route actually) |
firemint149Sep 6, 2022 10:41 AM
Soupisekaitrash said: Just watch irodoku, same studio, similar art, better I already watched Iroduko, It was a bland anime just like its MC. It much better if her Grandmother Kohaku is the MC. and I dont get it why the MC need to time travel just to have friends and have a fun time with them? Can she not do it in her own timeline??? it not even that sad. |
firemint149 said: RjtheGreat14 said: What do you mean the last episode does not make any sense? It clear state that Hina have a quantum computer in her brain that help her somehow to recover from her sickness and it also able her to have near ominiscent power. To be Honest since you said about clannad, Clannad Ending didn't make sense at all!!! From Being a True to life story about a single father raising a her daughter then suddenly it became steins gate??? If you need to watch a Youtube video just to undestand clannad ending that's just BAD! (This is not Darksouls level of story telling!) I have to agree the romantic feelings of Youta and Hina is underdeveloped, But there are scenes in the anime hinted that Hina is Jealous when Youta is talking to her Crush. The Day I Became God is not a Masterpiece, But I think it deserve more. Lol. Play the original galgame of Clannad before commenting on its ending. I am not going to explain it here. #19 explained it a little as well, there were also hints throughout the series. And I don't agree that an anime that requires a Youtube video to understand its ending is necessarily bad, but that is to each their own. I have seen worse animes out there with an ending that is harder to understand than Clannad, and still sounds ridiculous/weak even with a Youtube video/Reddit post to explain it e.g. Glasslip, Mahou Sensou, etc. At least I felt that Clannad's ending was justified after having it explained to me. Sure, the plot of having a quantum computer in Hina's brain might have worked with proper development of the plot through the 12 episodes. But instead, Maeda wasted like 7(?) episodes on his usual slapstick comedy without any actual major progression on the main plot. The sudden change of tone of the series (and the underdevelopment of Hina and Youta's romantic relationship) was what made this anime fail. I did not play the Visual Novel of Clannad, I just watched the anime, and based on the anime its Ending really is ridiculous too. okay even we give the benefit of the doubt that clannad have given some justification in the steins gate ending by showing some scene of a girl and robot in a parallel world. Its still Bad, travelling from a parallel world and Time travel/Steins gate is 2 completly different thing! Steins gate dedicated atleast more than 10 episode to explain the logic of their time travel, here its just random scene of a girl and robot basically doing nothing and that justify the time travel??? Yeah I also know the ball of light thing that granted wishes and that justify the time travel?? For an anime such clannad especially the after story which focus its main theme about a grounded story of a single father suffering from the death of her wife and raising her daugther, then suddenly in the final episode it became steins gate is just ridiculous. I am rolling my eyes when I see that ending. Why not the wish fullfilling magic ball just cure her daugther of her sickness, that's more believable than suddenly going steins gate at the last episode!! why did you say that Youta getting access into the facility without getting caught for so many days is ridiculous?? The guy with the white hair who is good in hacking help him to create a fake identity, You can see this troupe in many movie and tv series its more realistic than the steins gate ending of clannad! |
RjtheGreat14Sep 6, 2022 4:20 PM
RjtheGreat14 said: firemint149 said: Lol. Play the original galgame of Clannad before commenting on its ending. I am not going to explain it here. #19 explained it a little as well, there were also hints throughout the series. And I don't agree that an anime that requires a Youtube video to understand its ending is necessarily bad, but that is to each their own. I have seen worse animes out there with an ending that is harder to understand than Clannad, and still sounds ridiculous/weak even with a Youtube video/Reddit post to explain it e.g. Glasslip, Mahou Sensou, etc. At least I felt that Clannad's ending was justified after having it explained to me. Sure, the plot of having a quantum computer in Hina's brain might have worked with proper development of the plot through the 12 episodes. But instead, Maeda wasted like 7(?) episodes on his usual slapstick comedy without any actual major progression on the main plot. The sudden change of tone of the series (and the underdevelopment of Hina and Youta's romantic relationship) was what made this anime fail. I did not play the Visual Novel of Clannad, I just watched the anime, and based on the anime its Ending really is ridiculous too. okay even we give the benefit of the doubt that clannad have given some justification in the steins gate ending by showing some scene of a girl and robot in a parallel world. Its still Bad, travelling from a parallel world and Time travel/Steins gate is 2 completly different thing! Steins gate dedicated atleast more than 10 episode to explain the logic of their time travel, here its just random scene of a girl and robot basically doing nothing and that justify the time travel??? Yeah I also know the ball of light thing that granted wishes and that justify the time travel?? For an anime such clannad especially the after story which focus its main theme about a grounded story of a single father suffering from the death of her wife and raising her daugther, then suddenly in the final episode it became steins gate is just ridiculous. I am rolling my eyes when I see that ending. Why not the wish fullfilling magic ball just cure her daugther of her sickness, that's more believable than suddenly going steins gate at the last episode!! why did you say that Youta getting access into the facility without getting caught for so many days is ridiculous?? The guy with the white hair who is good in hacking help him to create a fake identity, You can see this troupe in many movie and tv series its more realistic than the steins gate ending of clannad! I disagree with everything that you have said. But that is just a personal opinion so let's just agree to disagree. Bye. |
| Hina Sato made this entire anime unbearable. Even Makoto Itou and Malty S Melromarc are more likeable characters than her. |
firemint149 said: The show's ending was just basically a remake of a classic anime scene in AIR without sufficient character development in its buildup. The last few episodes literally had me laughing because everything just didn't make sense at all. For example, there was a sudden development of a romantic relationship between Hina and Youta when previously they acted like family towards each other. It became more ridiculous when you realised that Youta liked Izanami at first and the change in feelings just wasn't explained at all. Maeda apparently wrote this in tribute of his previous works such as AIR and Clannad but I feel that this was kind of an insult to those classics? It's obvious that he has ran out of ideas sadly. I would say the comedy in the first few episodes were okay but the ending was just dumpster fire. Let's be brutally honest, AIR wasn't a very good show already. Why riff on it? Maeda peaked in CLANNAD. |
 |
| Tbh, if I could rate this show zero I would. The ending was pure second hand embarrassment for me. |
anizawa89 said: firemint149 said: The show's ending was just basically a remake of a classic anime scene in AIR without sufficient character development in its buildup. The last few episodes literally had me laughing because everything just didn't make sense at all. For example, there was a sudden development of a romantic relationship between Hina and Youta when previously they acted like family towards each other. It became more ridiculous when you realised that Youta liked Izanami at first and the change in feelings just wasn't explained at all. Maeda apparently wrote this in tribute of his previous works such as AIR and Clannad but I feel that this was kind of an insult to those classics? It's obvious that he has ran out of ideas sadly. I would say the comedy in the first few episodes were okay but the ending was just dumpster fire. Let's be brutally honest, AIR wasn't a very good show already. Why riff on it? Maeda peaked in CLANNAD. That's just your own personal opinion? I did not really rate it that highly either, but the objective fact out there is that it is a classic for many, especially in Japan. The fact that Maeda even tried to pay tribute to it in this anime speaks volumes. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Nov 7, 2020 |
196 |
by euphoricoddball
»»
Feb 1, 5:32 PM |
|
Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )KANLen09 - Dec 26, 2020 |
304 |
by DELLspencer
»»
Jan 7, 11:48 AM |
|
» Why do people dislike this anime ? ( 1 2 )kaiki_fan_boy - Dec 29, 2020 |
92 |
by HabteG
»»
Nov 24, 2023 3:43 PM |
|
Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Dec 19, 2020 |
171 |
by ggultra2764
»»
Nov 21, 2023 11:26 AM |
|
» Does anybody else really hate Hina?BirbSMB - Jun 28, 2023 |
16 |
by kyuteillusion21
»»
Jul 1, 2023 7:21 AM |