Naruto Shippuden or Fairy Tail

VaggPe said:
Fairy tail is garbage. Shippuden is at least decent. So save your time and don't watch fairy tail.

Potatoboy11 said:
I'd say drop them both and watch gintama. But that's just me

Haroldinho07 said:


Personally I think of Gintama as too boring!!!
Every episode makes me sleep!!

Kelly32723 said:
none of the big 3 are really anywhere near my favorites due to stuff like plot holes, bad execution, and stuff, but I’d put them all pretty far above Fairy Tail. I give Fairy Tail a 3, then Naruto and Shippuden a 7, Bleach a 6, and One Piece a 5

Potatoboy11 said:
I'd say drop them both and watch gintama. But that's just me

Potatoboy11 said:

Try reaching ep 60,then decide whether it's boring or not.

AwokenStroken said:


Dang like... that's kinda far in tho. I mean if it takes that long for it to really get good it probably wasn't worth it to begin with.

Cestlavie_ said:

But why is it the anime with the most plot holes and poor execution the highest u rated here😂 Bleach had filler but didn't have plot holes, OP has very minimal, I love Naruto but I can't defend the plot holes at the end

Kelly32723 said:

The ending was absolutely horrible and almost unbearable to watch, I agree. But overall, Naruto and Bleach have more memorable and enjoyable moments to me. And I’m saying this even though One Piece would probably be the most nostalgic one for me since I started it in like 5th/6th grade I don’t remember. One Piece is just less exciting and has a completely unrelatable and uninteresting mc imo. There are also major plot holes, like how Ace and everybody else didn’t know about the Commander-in-Chief of the Revolutionary Army lead by the most wanted man and the biggest threat to the world government. Also, the marine fodder members’ clone trooper aim (like how are they unable to land any shots on people running in straight lines, even the non-superhuman members who are literally running like normal ppl, like Nami and Usopp). Also, despite the extremely high danger level a world like one piece would have, even the fodder important characters manage to almost always make it through. It’s very rare for an important character to die, although I’ll admit it’s been becoming more common, especially since the Whole Cake Island arc. But it’s still not nearly realistic enough. The power-ups in the ends of the arcs are also too conveniently linear. Like, no one really passes anyone else up in the Straw Hats. There’s basically no relevant rivalry. I definitely think the manga deserves at least a mid-range 8+ rating, but it most definitely doesn’t deserve anywhere near a 9, and especially not 3rd place behind what almost everyone calls the 2 unbeatable masterpieces of Japanese manga, Berserk and Steel Ball Run (I haven’t read either of those top 2 though, so I don’t have much of an opinion on those). There’s also the fact that a man with the devil fruit of light couldn’t hit a pretty huge submarine underwater with his barrage of light beams at the Marineford. If Naruto didn’t have that absolutely horrible last arc, I would say that it’s debatable which one is more cheesy or has more plot armor, but yeah, I do agree that one piece has the least inconsistencies and plot armor out of the big 3. It also has some of the best worldbuilding and power systems in anime. But it’s just not as memorable or exciting as those other 2 I think. A lot of characters in one piece are pretty unrelatable and just feel purely like plot tools tbh, so Ig that gives the story a lot less charisma than Naruto and Bleach (Bleach has a brick wall mc though and overall pretty solid cast besides that, and Naruto has bad female characters, and I started liking Naruto as a character a lot less in the war arc). Doflamingo is a very solid villain though and deserves the praise. But still, the cast is somewhat more relatable in those 2, and they are way better at building up hype. As for villains, they have Pain (Naruto) and Aizen (Bleach). And Kurotsuchi from Bleach is one of my top 10 characters, at least for now. So overall, I just don’t like one piece much, I give the anime a 5 and would probably give the manga a 7 (I’ve read some parts while waiting for the anime to catch up, like the whole Katakuri vs Luffy fight). I highly doubt an 8 or higher. None of the big 3 deserve an 8 just for me imo. Although I’m fine with them getting rated an 8+ overall because of the ridiculous amount of far worse anime, like demon slayer getting bombed with high ratings

Kelly32723 said:

The ending was absolutely horrible and almost unbearable to watch, I agree. But overall, Naruto and Bleach have more memorable and enjoyable moments to me. And I’m saying this even though One Piece would probably be the most nostalgic one for me since I started it in like 5th/6th grade I don’t remember. One Piece is just less exciting and has a completely unrelatable and uninteresting mc imo. There are also major plot holes, like how Ace and everybody else didn’t know about the Commander-in-Chief of the Revolutionary Army lead by the most wanted man and the biggest threat to the world government. Also, the marine fodder members’ clone trooper aim (like how are they unable to land any shots on people running in straight lines, even the non-superhuman members who are literally running like normal ppl, like Nami and Usopp). Also, despite the extremely high danger level a world like one piece would have, even the fodder important characters manage to almost always make it through. It’s very rare for an important character to die, although I’ll admit it’s been becoming more common, especially since the Whole Cake Island arc. But it’s still not nearly realistic enough. The power-ups in the ends of the arcs are also too conveniently linear. Like, no one really passes anyone else up in the Straw Hats. There’s basically no relevant rivalry. I definitely think the manga deserves at least a mid-range 8+ rating, but it most definitely doesn’t deserve anywhere near a 9, and especially not 3rd place behind what almost everyone calls the 2 unbeatable masterpieces of Japanese manga, Berserk and Steel Ball Run (I haven’t read either of those top 2 though, so I don’t have much of an opinion on those). There’s also the fact that a man with the devil fruit of light couldn’t hit a pretty huge submarine underwater with his barrage of light beams at the Marineford. If Naruto didn’t have that absolutely horrible last arc, I would say that it’s debatable which one is more cheesy or has more plot armor, but yeah, I do agree that one piece has the least inconsistencies and plot armor out of the big 3. It also has some of the best worldbuilding and power systems in anime. But it’s just not as memorable or exciting as those other 2 I think. A lot of characters in one piece are pretty unrelatable and just feel purely like plot tools tbh, so Ig that gives the story a lot less charisma than Naruto and Bleach (Bleach has a brick wall mc though and overall pretty solid cast besides that, and Naruto has bad female characters, and I started liking Naruto as a character a lot less in the war arc). Doflamingo is a very solid villain though and deserves the praise. But still, the cast is somewhat more relatable in those 2, and they are way better at building up hype. As for villains, they have Pain (Naruto) and Aizen (Bleach). And Kurotsuchi from Bleach is one of my top 10 characters, at least for now. So overall, I just don’t like one piece much, I give the anime a 5 and would probably give the manga a 7 (I’ve read some parts while waiting for the anime to catch up, like the whole Katakuri vs Luffy fight). I highly doubt an 8 or higher. None of the big 3 deserve an 8 just for me imo. Although I’m fine with them getting rated an 8+ overall because of the ridiculous amount of far worse anime, like demon slayer getting bombed with high ratings. That turned out a lot longer than I expected, wow
Edit: Bleach most definitely has plot holes lol, the author just makes so many asspulls to give Ichigo power-ups, like he just conveniently has all this history that lets him gain access to like every power, it feels forced. There is also the question of how a somewhat above average highschool kid is beating centuries-old prodigies (Toshiro, Byakuya, Aizen, Kenpachi, Ulquiorra, Stark, Kyoraku, etc.)

uhboof said:
I cannot believe this one piece slander(not obvious sarcasm), realism argument doesn’t work here though and any argument wouldn’t work because its my fav anime😂

Cestlavie_ said:


I read and understand your points, i do enjoy each of the big 3 well bleach is debatable i related to the other two more ,like the anime adaptation of bleach is so bad imo compared to the manga, like in the heuco Mundo arc the pacing reached toei level,
Your points for One piece made sense i just accept it as it is I can't deny all that u said, i know not everyone is like me that can brush off some of those little things like Kizaru , just felt the plot armor was necessary there, so Luffy could escape death.

but I think the one piece cast was more memorable than bleach with all the back stories they got, even though the bleach characters are more relatable,


All in All i believe the big 3 should deserve a rating above 8 with the ways they introduced new things to the Shonen genre and inspired other anime after it, like i believe with the lows they have are bad but I don't think most shonen can reach them at their highs.

Potatoboy11 said:
I'd say drop them both and watch gintama. But that's just me

Potatoboy11 said:
I'd say drop them both and watch gintama. But that's just me