Forum Settings
Forums

MAL Secret Santa 2021: Manga Edition - Sign Up!

New
This topic has been locked and is no longer available for discussion.
Pages (10) « First ... « 3 4 [5] 6 7 » ... Last »
Nov 23, 2021 2:54 AM
Offline
May 2020
101
Min-Max length: Any length is fine.
Likes: Reincarnation (isekai), Action, Adventure, Mystery, Psychological, Horror, Suspense, Supernatural, Fantasy, Sci Fi, Gore (violent mangas too)
** I am a huge manhwa and manhua fan too (korean and chinese comics) so, I would be happy to get recommendations on these too :D
Dislikes: Slice of Life, Drama, Comedy, Mecha, Military
Any availability restrictions?: No
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 35
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: Dark Axgel

As I have mentioned that I like manhwas and all, if you notice in MAL, there isnt many manhwa and manhuas present to add to your list. So I decided to make an AniList account and to update my mangas over there coz all the manhwas are available there.

This is my AniList manga list -> Dark Axgel

Sorry for the discomfort :)

(I dont frequently update my MAL anime list so it would be of a great help if you check out my AniList manga list and give me recommendations)

Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange!
Nov 23, 2021 3:36 AM

Offline
Jun 2016
39
Min-Max length: No particular preference.
Likes: I thoroughly enjoy mature series', genres I really like include psychological, historical, music, mystery and thriller. I really enjoy philosophical themes in series' and I love slice of life series', especially those that also fall within the realm of iyashikei.
Dislikes: I generally dislike most battle shounen, especially those that heavily follow shounen tropes.
Any availability restrictions?: None.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 756
Does your list include everything you've read?: It should do.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Height
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 23, 2021 5:04 AM

Offline
Jul 2016
736
Min-Max length: 0 to ~20 Volumes
Likes: My favorite genre are Shoujo Ai and Romantic Comedy, but I'm open to literally everthing. Manhwa and Manhua are fine as well.
Dislikes: I don't really like 4-koma style manga too much.
Any availability restrictions?: Translated into english or german; Must be finished.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 89
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/extremeplant
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf Gift

Nov 23, 2021 5:12 AM

Offline
May 2020
23
Min-Max length: 1 - 200 chapters, prefer shorter running mangas
Likes: fantasy, romance, sports, action, gourmet and supernatural; frankly, I don't mind if the pages are doused in blood or if it is some light-hearted series
Dislikes: superficial drama, Japanese horror, yaoi, "bully" humor, abusive relationships/friendships, still ongoing mangas
Any availability restrictions?: no
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 100
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Huskkay
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): gift exchange
Nov 23, 2021 6:27 AM

Offline
Apr 2016
20
Min-Max length:
Anything goes!


Likes:
Psychological/drama and comedy/parodies. An isekai with a feel good vibe.


Dislikes:
Excessive ecchi and gore


Any availability restrictions?:
No


Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):
No


Number of Completed entries on your manga list:
37


Does your list include everything you've read?:
Yes


Link to manga list:
https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Mizxuki?status=2


Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge):
Gift Exchange!
Nov 23, 2021 6:32 AM
Offline
Dec 2020
3
❅ Min-Max length: No preference but it'd be nice if it's less than 200 chapters. (Would prefer a completed manga)
❅ Likes: RomCom, Coming-of-Age, Psychological, Art-related, Music
❅ Dislikes: Harem, Isekai, Hentai
❅ Any availability restrictions?: As long as it's been translated into English it's good!
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes (I don't have any on my plan to read list)
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 27
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: Mostly yes (the ones I remember reading)
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/_ireneko
❅ Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 23, 2021 6:55 AM

Offline
Mar 2021
138
Min-Max length: 1(One-shot)-120 chapters.
Likes: Adventure, story-driven, comedy, yaoi/BL, suspense/mind games, different looking art-styles.
Dislikes: Ecchi, harem, isekai, too action or drama-focused, gore and violence without purpose.
Any availability restrictions?: Must be fully available online for free.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 31.
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes, except the yaoi.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Yakazi?
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf Gift.

Nov 23, 2021 12:03 PM
Offline
Sep 2020
6
Min-Max length: Doesn't matter
Likes: Anything similar to my favourites
Dislikes: Mecha BL / Yoai
Any availability restrictions?: Nope
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 11
Does your list include everything you've read?:
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Ahkross
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf Gift
Nov 23, 2021 12:09 PM
Offline
Sep 2020
8
❅ Min-Max length: None
❅ Likes: Slice of life, romance, action, comedy. Pretty much anything.
❅ Dislikes: Yaoi
❅ Any availability restrictions?: No
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 14
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Lumen16
❅ Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf gift
Nov 23, 2021 1:35 PM

Offline
Aug 2018
135
Min-Max length: Literally anything. Completed or ongoing is fine.
Likes: Complicated plots with political intrigue, or cute slice of life and romance.
Dislikes: Manga with nothing but fanservice.
Any availability restrictions?: Somewhere on the internet.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 210 (258 reading though)
Does your list include everything you've read?: no, I also read a lot manwha and manhua, although that isn't listed anywhere.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Furl
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift exchange
Nov 23, 2021 2:16 PM

Offline
May 2020
192
Min-Max length: No hard limit but preferably no more than a 2-3 hundred chapters.
Likes: Sci-fi, psychological, comedy, but prioritize your likes in picking something.
Dislikes: Not huge on slice of life.
Any availability restrictions?: Nope.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Totally.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 10
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/DavidWilsea?
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange!!
Nov 23, 2021 2:31 PM
Offline
Oct 2020
3
Min-Max length: none
Likes: op character trope and romance manga
Dislikes: nothing in particular
Any availability restrictions?: no
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 11
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/BorisBV
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 23, 2021 2:33 PM

Offline
Dec 2009
1004
Min-Max length: 25-80chapters
Likes: isekai, villainess, over powered characters, but would like something that is more focused on adventure
Dislikes: not too picky, though nothing that is romance heavy especially shoujo, and would prefer something that isn't shounen either.
Any availability restrictions?: needs to have an English translation that is up to date on what has been officially released. Would prefer something that is completed.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 229
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/breathesunshine
Choose one— Elf Gift :
breathesunshineNov 23, 2021 2:41 PM

     
Nov 23, 2021 2:51 PM

Offline
Mar 2020
476
Min-Max length: over 60 chapters if possible, i usually get caught in the story and end up binge reading
Likes: romcoms, action, adventure, anything similar with tatsuki fujimoto's works, psychological, something easy to read
Dislikes: ecchi, yaoi, sports
Any availability restrictions?: no but prefer digital
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 7
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/lordkagetane
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 23, 2021 3:28 PM
Offline
Aug 2020
1
[b]Min-Max length: [/doesnt matter]
[b]Likes: [/tragedy and psyhological]
[b]Dislikes: [/yaoi,plot armour]
[b]Any availability restrictions?: [/doesnt matter]
[b]Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): [/doesnt matter]
[b]Number of Completed entries on your manga list: [/25]
[b]Does your list include everything you've read?: [/yes]
[b]Link to manga list: [/https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/nikolastolba]
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge):
Nov 23, 2021 3:55 PM

Offline
Jan 2019
23
❅ Minimum-maximum length: that does not exceed 50-60 chapters, I am generally fine with 3-6 volumes (it will depend on if it really interests me, it can be extended)
❅ I like: Shoujo, Josei, Seinen, Psychological, drama / romance, Yaoi, School life or later, Slice of Life, even some ecchi-smut, mature themes and the like.
❅ Dislikes: Action, Sci-Fi, Harem / NTR, Shounen (may vary), Yuri, shotacon / lolicon, Fantasy, Powers or things like that (and better if it does not have meaningless tragedies or abrupt endings). Preferably not ongoing. Not manhwa, manhua or webtoon.
❅ Any restrictions on availability?: Fully translated into English or Spanish and available online.
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to read list? (Yes or no): No, because I have almost nothing added to my list. You can recommend me whatever you think is to my liking (I am not very demanding in that regard)
❅ Number of complete entries in your manga list: 931 (complete section and updated reading manga combined). Anyway, 664 were completed at this time.
❅ Does your list include everything you have read?: Not in fact. It would be necessary to add some one-shot, manhwa / manhua and a few from webtoon that are not found in MAL.
My (practically) complete list is in my Anime-planet profile (link in my profile)
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/samimomo
❅ Choose one: Gift Exchange (give a gift, get a gift, get a badge) or Elf Gift (get only one gift, without a badge): Gift exchange
Nov 23, 2021 3:58 PM
Offline
Feb 2019
6
Min-Max length: I don't mind the length. It can be as long or short as you want
Likes: romance (the more cheesey the better) , action, drama, fantasy. Also would be prefered if the manga isn't too text heavy
Dislikes: hentai, ecchi, isekai
Any availability restrictions?: No
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 42 (of 24/11/2021)
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Midvalkyrie56
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): gift exchange
Nov 23, 2021 6:55 PM
:O <º))))><

Offline
Sep 2017
29
Min-Max length: Anything!
Likes: Surprise me.
Dislikes: BL, harem,
Any availability restrictions?: Preferably something completed
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes, such as it is.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 9,215
Does your list include everything you've read?: Alas, yes.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Startlefish?status=2
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift exchange
Nov 23, 2021 10:40 PM

Offline
Aug 2021
13
Min-Max length: I dont mind long mangas :)
Likes: fantasy, psychological, seinen and josei.
Dislikes: ecchi, harem, shoujo.
Any availability restrictions?: nope :)
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): ye sure
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 17 (as of nov. 24th)
Does your list include everything you've read?: I havent added any of my manhwas and manhuas here but other than that, yes.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Rizhao
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): ELF GIFT (list too small for gift exchange :( )


I gaslight myself 24/7 <3
Nov 23, 2021 11:10 PM
Offline
Apr 2020
33
Min-Max length: No restriction, but I would prefer >50 (weekly) chapters
Likes: Action, Psychological, Fantasy, Adventure, Some Ecchi
Dislikes: BL
Any availability restrictions?: Nope
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 18
Does your list include everything you've read?: No, but the AniList one does (Manhwa and stuff that aren't on MAL)
Link to manga list: My Full Manga List
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 23, 2021 11:43 PM
Offline
May 2020
1
Min-Max length: -
Likes: boys love, action with a plot/purpose
Dislikes: ecchi, harem, violence without reason
Any availability restrictions?: no
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 8
Does your list include everything you've read?: more or less
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/zavagex?status=7
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): gift exchange
Nov 24, 2021 12:25 AM

Offline
Jan 2012
160
Min-Max length: 1-50 volumes
Likes: Yuri, Adventure, Slice of Life, Shounen, Seinen. Must be completed manga (not ongoing, cancelled, on hiatus, etc.)
Dislikes: Gender bender, Webtoon (you know, those that you read by scrolling down, whatever it's called)
Any availability restrictions?: Nope
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 91
Does your list include everything you've read?: I think so
Link to manga list: Here it is
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 24, 2021 12:30 AM
Offline
Nov 2021
1
Min-Max length: not more than 50 volumes please 🙂
❅ Likes: I like mangas of genre horror, psychological and supernatural. Especially manga with great artwork. Don’t know why but I’m super into mangas with vampires in them and when people turn into vampires. Eg: like happiness by Shizo Otsumi
❅ Dislikes: bad art, bad endings.
❅ Any availability restrictions?: No.
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? Haven’t made one yet so yeah.
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: I have finished reading uzumaki, Tomie, happiness, death note, all you need is kill. I KNOW IM A NOOB.
❅ Does your MAL list include everything you've read?: already added it above
❅ Link to manga list: don’t have one. Sorry.
❅ Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): gift exchange or elf gift. Fine with both. Preferably the first one.
Nov 24, 2021 1:08 AM

Offline
Mar 2018
189
❅ Min-Max length: Any length
❅ Likes: Psychological, Drama (seinen or josei) are preferable, but any genre is fine
❅ Dislikes: -
❅ Any availability restrictions?: No restrictions
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list?: Yes (Do not recommend me anything on my "Dropped" list)
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 47
❅ Does your MAL list include everything you've read?: Yes
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Misery_xD
❅ Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Misery_xDNov 28, 2021 12:48 AM
Nov 24, 2021 2:24 AM
Offline
Sep 2020
1
Min-Max length: No restrictions. Would prefer for them to be fully translated/scanlated
Likes: fights, shounen, action, fantasy, martial arts, super powers
Dislikes: I'm pretty open to anything just not cheesy romance or BL or ecchi type stuff.
Any availability restrictions?: Want to be able to find it online and fully translated.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Preferably not.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 5
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Ja_ce
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gfit Exchange
Nov 24, 2021 6:00 AM

Offline
Dec 2020
190
❅ Min-Max length: Any as long as it is fully translated and gets published weekly/monthly
❅ Likes: Sci-fi, Horror, Psychological, Thriller, Mystery. I'm a bit choosy with art style so only recommend the ones with *top tier* art.
❅ Dislikes: Ecchi/Hentai, Romance, Rom-com, Fantasy.
❅ Any availability restrictions?: None
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 2
❅ Does your MAL list include everything you've read?: Missed a couple but not necessary
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Scorpius_99
❅ Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
                                                                                                                                                                                      My reviews
                                                                                                                                                                                
Nov 24, 2021 6:28 AM

Offline
Nov 2014
303
Min-Max length: Anything goes, longer are often better, but not always!
Likes: Slice of Life, Drama, Comedy, Romance, Shoujo, Seinen, Shounen, Gourmet, Sports. Both things that warm your heart or get it pumping are good. Characters and relationships are often more important than plot. Cute family bonding or important friendships are GREAT. Clean lines are a bonus.
Dislikes: Josei, Horror, Sci-Fi especially time travel, gore, and not a huge fan of Ecchi
Any availability restrictions?: Completed and fully translated please
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes, but avoid things in my anime list if possible (especially in my Dropped)
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 792
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yep
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/fraideii
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
fraideiiNov 24, 2021 6:39 AM
Nov 24, 2021 9:21 AM

Offline
Aug 2018
6
Min-Max length: Any!! (Maybe finished if possible)
Likes: Seinen, Psychological, Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, Romance, Action
Dislikes: Ecchi (Everything in moderation), ISEKAI, School, Shoujo, Yuri
Any availability restrictions?: No!
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes!
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 157
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes (Except webtoons)
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Nixxan
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange!!! :DD
Nov 24, 2021 9:31 AM

Offline
Sep 2020
318
Min-Max length: Anything is fine, I would say keep it below 300 chapters but if it's good I'm willing to read a lot.
Likes: Comedies mostly, but I also like action adventure and slice of life.
Dislikes: I don't want a popular manga, so a lower rank than top 100.
Any availability restrictions?: No.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 26.
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes.
Link to manga list: Here
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange



Nov 24, 2021 11:03 AM

Offline
Aug 2015
808
Min-Max length: Any length is fine
Likes: Psychological, Thriller and Seinen are my faves, but anything is fine with me
Dislikes: Nothing really
Any availability restrictions?: Would like it all to be translated in English (can be in physical copy - in which case OOP stuff is fine - or digital)
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes. Please check this first though as I own a lot of Manga I haven't read yet
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 185
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: List
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 24, 2021 11:17 AM
Offline
May 2015
20
Min-Max length (volumes): At least something substantial, not like 10-20 chapters.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Anything not listed below. Has to have above 7.5 score.
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Harem, Ecchi, Gag, Extreme Drama (ie. Scum's Wish), Isekai, Mecha, Horror, Gore, 4-koma (for the most part). Avoid some Shojuo with very shojuo like troupes (ex. of good shojuo manga imo: Machida, Wake Up Sleeping Beauty, Akatsuki no Yona). Ordered from most important to least important.
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): : None.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No. Also please don't recommend a manga that has an anime that I've already watched (ie. FMAB, I've seen the anime but haven't read the manga).
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 201, I include manga I am currently reading though. Otherwise 71.
Does your list include everything you've read?: Nope, I don't add a lot of trash Isekai or trash romance if I read it. Also, not a lot of mahuwa/webtoons I like a lot (Beginning of the End, Black Haze, etc.) because its not on MAL.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Avajou
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Of course, give and take in equal proportions. (Gift Exchange)
AvajouNov 24, 2021 11:20 AM
Nov 24, 2021 12:35 PM
Offline
Mar 2021
2
Min-Max length: 30+ Chapters
Likes: adventure, psychological, horror, drama, and action.
Dislikes: a lot of fantasy and poorly written characters. Also no manga with heavy school and romance themes.
Any availability restrictions?: no
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 5
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/profile/Chambers0918
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): elf gift
Nov 24, 2021 2:50 PM
Offline
Jan 2018
12
Min-Max length: No longer than 30 Volumes.
Likes: I like most stuff, mainly seinen though. Might be best to check my favs for ideas. Willing to try shorter light novels too.
Dislikes: Not really feeling like reading mecha atm, not into ecchi either so I'd prefer something with little or none of that.
Any availability restrictions?: As long as it's in English.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): It can but I'd rather it be something new.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 61
Does your list include everything you've read?: Only thing missing is Berserk spin off novel.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Thomas_Morgan
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Thomas_MorganNov 24, 2021 2:54 PM
Nov 24, 2021 3:11 PM

Offline
May 2020
251
Min-Max length: Anything really. A long series that's not too much filler or a shorter series that still has some good substance. Even an amazing oneshot if applicable.
Likes: Romance, school, slice of life, harem, drama, comedy
Dislikes: hentai, yaoi/yuri, generic shoujo romance or shonen action, horror.
Any availability restrictions?: Need English scans available to be found
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 24
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Ragerrodent
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Is Blue Box my favorite manga? Not yet...Yes. Yes it is. 

Nov 24, 2021 4:15 PM

Offline
Jan 2021
113
Min-Max length: any length is fine
Likes: girls love/shoujo ai, shoujo, romance, manga with lgbtqia+ characters (for reference stuff like the anime stars align), manga where the mc is a villain, morally grey mc, strong female leads, psychological, horror, gory stuff,
Dislikes: ecchi, hentai, harem (reverse harem is ok), incest (that includes relationships between step siblings or cousins) , anything with sexualization of minors, weird age gaps between adults and minors (other age gaps are ok), do not recommend citrus
Any availability restrictions?: nope Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 363
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: my manga list :)
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): gift exchange

Nov 24, 2021 4:56 PM

Offline
Jan 2016
3268
Min-Max length: 2 volume min, 20 volume max, completed please
Likes: drama (not melodrama), action, seinen, comedy, slice of life, historical, romance, mystery, fantasy
Dislikes: ecchi, lots of sexual content, rape, horror, tragedy, gore, large age gaps. Please don't rec something I've seen the anime to.
Any availability restrictions?: can be found in English somewhere
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 57
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: Click Here!
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
SuperComicGeekNov 24, 2021 5:00 PM
Nov 24, 2021 6:28 PM
Offline
Jul 2021
3
Min-Max length: Anything is fine, as long as it can maintain my interest etc!
Likes: Romance,Comedy, Slice of Life,Drama etc would be great!
Dislikes: Horror,suspense,r@pe etc for the most part
Any availability restrictions?: Only manga that has been translated to english please
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes, but I haven't read much manga!
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 7
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/PurpleReaper9
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf Gift
Nov 24, 2021 6:38 PM

Offline
Jan 2021
85
Min-Max length: Fine with anything.
Likes: Series about cute animals (I’m desperately trying to find something about birds). Comedy, whether dark or lighthearted (I’m okay with offensive humor). Stuff that makes you think long after you’ve finished it, or is complex and funny at the same time. I love “hidden depth”. Art that isn’t just good but is unique, expressive, or well-purposed. Supernatural elements. Found family. Good character chemistry. Emotional destruction (that comes from emotional investment). Series where you can see the author’s personality shine through a lot (like golden kamuy and chainsaw man). I would say good LGBT+ rep (it’s fine it it’s flawed but interesting), but I have much higher standards than most people, so if you have similar favs & dislikes to mine…please try to impress me; if not, don’t bother.
Dislikes: Melodrama. Most horror (doesn’t really affect me). Communication issues & drama just for plot convenience or for the sake of having a conflict. Pacing that is way too fast/hard to follow. Stuff that’s dark for the sake of being dark/annoying audiences who can’t relate/making some kind of statement that is going to go over most people’s heads, especially if they think it’s good (so basically, *please* no Inio Asano; he is 100% off-limits). Weird fetishy stuff, sexualisation of minors, questionable age gaps. Relationships that happen too fast. Humor that’s too ridiculous to laugh at. Most ecchi, harems, straight up romance (though I have enjoyed some romcoms). I haven’t liked much shōjo I’ve read, but I really want to find good ones. Last but not least, please don’t rec Berserk or Jojos because I don’t want to read them until I stop hearing about them everywhere I go.
Any availability restrictions?: Has to be available in English or Spanish. Other than that, nothing that I can think of. Anything that requires an online subscription other than Shonen Jump (e.g. futekiya) will be difficult, though.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes, but if it is, try to sell it to me (if you feel like it)
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 45
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: here
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
skylucarioNov 24, 2021 6:59 PM
_________________________________

Before you try revolutionizing the country, why don’t you revolutionize yourself first? - 土方十四郎
Nov 24, 2021 8:18 PM
Offline
Apr 2021
16
Min-Max length: maximum 10 volumes
Likes: Anything would work
Dislikes: Hentai and Top 100
Any availability restrictions?: Must be available in English
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 23(as of posting)
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/kat1111
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf Gift
Nov 24, 2021 8:53 PM

Offline
Jan 2020
12
Min-Max length: Many Chapter the More Preferable Like 50+ Chapter
Likes: Comedy,Romance
Dislikes: Yaoi,Mecha,Sports
Any availability restrictions?: Must be available in English/Bahasa Indonesia
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes if thats good
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 4
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/YukimuraChieri
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf Gift
YukimuraChieriNov 24, 2021 9:00 PM
Nov 25, 2021 3:16 AM
Offline
Jul 2020
23
Min-Max length: Any
Likes: Psychological/Thriller but also like SOL/rom-com so any genre is fine tbh
Dislikes: Yaoi or the sort, or extremely ecchi with no real plot
Any availability restrictions?: No
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes, but have the main recomm be not from it
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 285
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/DarkOverLord926
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 25, 2021 3:24 AM

Offline
Nov 2019
10
Min-Max length: I would prefer something around 100 chapters, though I would say 50 minimum and 400 maximum.
Likes: Yuri, mystery, horror, ecchi, romance, supernatural, shounen, adventure, action. fantasy. I haven't read a ton of manga so I don't think I've fully honed in my tastes yet, but that is a general idea of what I'm into and I'm opened to anything new. I would like something with more of an emotional story as well, or something that "hits harder" so to speak, but I wouldn't be upset with something more light-hearted.
Dislikes: Mecha, technological, cars, mechanics. Besides those genres I am opened to pretty much anything plot-wise.
Any availability restrictions?: They must be fully translated in English, I am from the USA. And I would ideally like them to be physically printed, however I don't mind if they are out of print or only available online.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):. No, but there's not much on my plan to read
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 18 Completed. 2 Dropped.
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/ParadoxalSeer?status=7
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange.
ParadoxalSeerNov 25, 2021 3:28 AM
Nov 25, 2021 5:03 AM
Offline
Mar 2019
60
Min-Max length: I'm reading One Piece, I can take anything you throw at me.
Likes: I want to read some shoujo, I basically just read shounen. Maybe something really cute.
Dislikes: I don't like ecchi or hentai.
Any availability restrictions?: I'll figure it out.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 39
Does your list include everything you've read?: Not quite, but nearly.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Jo_March?status=7
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 25, 2021 5:10 AM

Offline
Jan 2018
115
Min-Max length: up to 10 volumes
Likes: Shoujo, josei, romance (can be lgbtq+, can be not - optional), slice of life - everything of that sort. It's okay if something like demons or other fantasy-themed elements are in, too. I'd prefer it to take place in a real world, but time and place are up to Santa!
Dislikes: not a fan of ecchi, parody, isekai, sci-fi and sports manga
Any availability restrictions?: nope
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 32 (as of 25.11.2021)
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes!
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/yukyuuu?
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf Gift


Don't despair. Now's not the time for that.
But there's no way to turn back time.
Nov 25, 2021 6:48 AM

Offline
Jan 2020
7
Min-Max length: The longer the better, but i don't mind smaller mangas either if they are good
Likes: Romance,Comedy(paired up with Romance if possible), Thriller, Gore, Drama, Psychological, Thriller, Sci-Fi Post-apocalyptic, Vampires/Zombies/Monsters, good world building, in-depth character development, relationships that feel natural, FINISHED STORY with ending where you can see what happens in the future(if it is the case for example in romances-wedding,adulthood or aftermath of the action)
Dislikes: fighting based manga(fighting manhwa or manhua is fine, but i can't follow fights really well in manga), cheating/ntr(unless the person who did it gets what it deserves), mangas that are still in release(even though they are good, i'd hate to wait for new chapters to release, especially if the manga is good)
Any availability restrictions?: preferably has good scanlations on mangadex/mangakakalot or whatever other sites there are( i don't have access to physical manga/manhwa). Some good mangas have bad scanlations which has deterred me to read them, i only want it to not be blurry and have readable clean text and characters
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 30
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/mitzone
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 25, 2021 6:53 AM

Offline
Nov 2011
640
Min-Max length: 3 to 10 volumes ~
Likes: SoL, romance, lgbt, comedy, fantasy ~
Dislikes: Inio Asano, when the characters suffer too much, love triangles, hentai, sports, mecha ~
Any availability restrictions?: Nope
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 173
Does your list include everything you've read?: everything that's disponible on MAL ~
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Char
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf gift ~
Nov 25, 2021 8:01 AM

Offline
Nov 2019
5
Min-Max length: No limit
Likes: Dementia, Psychological, Drama, Avant Garde
Dislikes: Shonen, Harem, Sports, Ecchi
Any availability restrictions?: Must be available as physical English volume
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 7
Does your list include everything you've read?: No
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/KingPeli
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 25, 2021 11:21 AM

Offline
Jun 2017
15
Min-Max length: min: 60 chapters - max: 800 chapters, must be finished
Likes: Psychological, philosophical, seinen, original concept/creative, folkloric/traditional, science fiction, detailed art
something that consider fields like biology, gray morality or multiple moral values
(whatever you recommend me doesn't have to include all of these)
My Favorite anime and manga should be a good guide
Dislikes: isekai, comedy (not feeling like it right now, it can have a little bit of comedy), moe, romance (it can have a little bit of romance as long as it's not the main focus), very well known (top 150), shojo, sports, dragon ball-like power levels, ecchi, harem, dumb characters, plot holes/bad writing, nothing that is being published
Any availability restrictions?: none
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 20
Does your list include everything you've read?: no, but most of what's registered on this site
Link to manga list: My list: https://myanimelist.net/profile/capricuernos
The things that i plan to watch: https://myanimelist.net/profile/YakisobaDish
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange
Nov 25, 2021 11:52 AM
Offline
May 2021
9
Min-Max length: need like 300 chapters
Likes: seinen,shounen (need something like berserk)
Dislikes: ecchi
Any availability restrictions?: nah
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no need
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 2
Does your list include everything you've read?: no dounjins btw
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/luckylukezzz
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Gift Exchange!
Nov 25, 2021 12:10 PM

Offline
Mar 2013
236
Min-Max length: none
Likes: For standard MAL genres: action, adventure, avant garde, fantasy, mystery, sci-fi, supernatural (and superpowers in general, not necessarily part of the genre), suspense, martial arts, psychological, superpower. Other genres: cyberpunk, virtual reality, otaku culture, JRPG elements, computer technology (and technology in general), fashion design, battle shounen, art, manga creation, japanese fashion subcultures, deconstruction,
Dislikes: boys love, girls love, horror, sports, ecchi, erotica, hentai, any manga adaptation of studio trigger anime
Any availability restrictions?: preferably available physically, as long is officially licensed in spain, mexico and/or argentina and there must be at least 1 publisher from any of the mentioned countries who has completed it or currently publishing it. if the final recommendation is not licensed in any of these 3 countries, maybe but only maybe can accept it but please, prioritize what I said first.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):no
Number of Completed entries on your manga list:3
Does your list include everything you've read?:yes
Link to manga list:https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Eternal-Destiny
Choose one—Gift Exchange (make gift, get gift, get badge) or Elf Gift (get gift only, no badge): Elf Gift
Eternal-DestinyNov 27, 2021 5:36 AM
I know your PTW list is bigger than your completed list.
This topic has been locked and is no longer available for discussion.
Pages (10) « First ... « 3 4 [5] 6 7 » ... Last »

More topics from this board

» | OPEN | Best Profile Design (June 2025) NOMINATIONS

Phraze - Jun 8

3 by nirererin »»
Jun 8, 11:55 PM

» Best Profile Design (May 2025) WINNER

Phraze - Jun 8

3 by nirererin »»
Jun 8, 11:51 PM

» | CLOSED | Best Profile Design (May 2025) VOTING

Phraze - May 21

18 by Retro8bit »»
Jun 4, 10:48 PM

» Best Profile Design (April 2025) WINNER

Phraze - May 1

7 by nirererin »»
May 31, 6:35 AM

» | CLOSED | Best Profile Design (May 2025) NOMINATIONS

Phraze - May 1

7 by Shino »»
May 13, 8:39 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login