Aot 139 really bad as people say

Alvacka97 said:
Jesus, are you this dense? Really?
Or maybe you just didn't read the whole thread. What, got bored halfway?
Here is a list of his accomplishments: Paradis got bombed at least 100 years after the rumbling, which means, Eren's generation had long since died of old age, so Eren did manage to protect his friends and give them long lives, decades after Mikasa dying of old age, a modern Paradis is embroiled in war. The reasons are unexplained because they are again unimportant, this is just a commentary on human nature. Erwin’s words ring true as the cycle of conflict continues onto further generations. Of course Eren’s actions didn’t solve world peace forever & that wasn’t even his goal. Saying eren may aswell have done nothing is also just as ridiculous. Were Alexander the Great’s achievements meaningless because his empire collapsed upon his death? Is all of humanity meaningless because the sun will one day explode? It’s redundant.

Also, it's very likely that Eldians migrated to other parts of the world, to build cities, make their nation bigger, etc. Considering how Eren wiped out 80%, it seems rather obvious that Eldians would repopulate many of the places that had become barren. So Eren did manage to save the Eldian race, even if Paradis island got destroyed, we do not know the exact reason and never will, so it's up to us to interpret and fill in the gaps, art is all about interpretation, after all.
So Eldians managed to exist alongside the remains of the world population for a century, thanks to the alliance's peace decree, which means Eldians could still exist around the world, in many places, and will remain existing.

Pandem0nium said:


Eren accomplishment just a burden for the next generation to keep fighting against other nation, Eldian already seen as a threat for humanity outside paradis before rumbling, did you forgot what the rest of the world was doing ? they was declaring war against paradis even though they are not doing anything when they were inside paradis, eren kill 80% population just build more hatred towards paradis , does eren actions solve the hatred of the remaining population towards eldians? no he just create more problem i said already eren just an idiot who choose his friends over his parents and his people if he completed the rumbling he save paradis and even though they will be war between eldians thats because another conflict not the same like the ending where the hatred remains between paradis and the outside paradis.

you dare to compared eren to Alexander the Great what an idiot, eren literally a god who can finish the conflict with his own hand but he choose to lose to save few people, Alexander the Great is a normal human being who have a strong will to accomplished what he wanted and the fall of his empire because its beyond his reach, Eren have the founding titan power which is capable of creating a beneficial for building a civilization for paradis in the future, its seems most of ending defender were an idiot humanity will be wiped out ofc because the end of the day will come and no one will live to tell a story after that event its unrelevant if you linked my conclusion to that.

Eldians very likely build a nation bigger than that? lmao why there is no panel to tell that story.