| It does get a lot of criticism from some people but personally, I enjoyed it too |
 |
| I liked the last episode a lot, I think it was done well but it could have been done a lot better. Charlotte was a great show, it was way too short though unfortunately |
| I was greatly surprised by the last episodes according to all the negative things I have heard about it. I think this show was pretty mid from the beggining to the conclusion. Jun Maeda has done better but it's still enjoyable and the length makes it really accessible. |
[center][img]signature.png[/img][/center] |
| This show is overhated by wannabe critics. The show being enjoyable is what that count the most. Fast pacing is not always a bad thing given that it was what made Charlotte so much fun to watch. |
Hrybami said: This show is overhated by wannabe critics. The show being enjoyable is what that count the most. Many people enjoy objectively good pieces of work, dissecting how it was written, animated and composed as well as commenting on every nuance and detail. And they can just as easily say that those that liked Charlotte don't have standards. Talking about standards, this might just be the reason many people didn't enjoy this, whenever a KEY Studios show is announced, expectations are high considering their track record, this one specifically had Angels Beats' shoes to fill, even people who liked Charlotte will most likely admit the quality drop compared to PA Works+Jun Maeda previous show. |
  Nanachi's wisdom: "Watch the Monogatari Series following the Novel Order." |
VelosBR said: Hrybami said: This show is overhated by wannabe critics. The show being enjoyable is what that count the most. Many people enjoy objectively good pieces of work, dissecting how it was written, animated and composed as well as commenting on every nuance and detail. And they can just as easily say that those that liked Charlotte don't have standards. Talking about standards, this might just be the reason many people didn't enjoy this, whenever a KEY Studios show is announced, expectations are high considering their track record, this one specifically had Angels Beats' shoes to fill, even people who liked Charlotte will most likely admit the quality drop compared to PA Works+Jun Maeda previous show. "Objectively good piece of works" People still believe in that lie? Imagine having so little standard that you have to take the ones from someone else. In case you didn't know yet, everyone is a critic. The ability to voice your thoughts don't make your taste better than another person. That's why I call those who think they have superior taste as "wannabe critic". |
| I mean, unless you tell me there's no difference in quality between Redo of Healer and Clannad After Story, that's no lie. There's nothing wrong with enjoying a bad show and there's also nothing wrong with enjoying a good show. People should be proud of their taste, and stop caring about scores and other people not enjoying the same things they do. Hrybami said: But if peolple didn't enjoy it, why would they praise it? We all end up hating on somthing we don't like, on different levels but it's hate the same way. What you call "Overhating" might just be a ton of people that didn't enjoy it, and because it's agreat number of people, their voices are heard considerably more.That's why I call those who think they have superior taste as "wannabe critic". |
Nanachi's wisdom: "Watch the Monogatari Series following the Novel Order." |
VelosBR said: I mean, unless you tell me there's no difference in quality between Redo of Healer and Clannad After Story, that's no lie. There's nothing wrong with enjoying a bad show and there's also nothing wrong with enjoying a good show. People should be proud of their taste, and stop caring about scores and other people not enjoying the same things they do. The quality here is so abstract and could refer to a thousand of different and subjective things that it doesn't make any sense to call something "objectively good". I agree that people should be proud of their taste and stop caring on scores. Hrybami said: But if peolple didn't enjoy it, why would they praise it? We all end up hating on somthing we don't like, on different levels but it's hate the same way. What you call "Overhating" might just be a ton of people that didn't enjoy it, and because it's agreat number of people, their voices are heard considerably more.That's why I call those who think they have superior taste as "wannabe critic". This world is not as fair as you think. There's more reasons for saying that something is shit than just straight up not liking it. Maeda Jun? Hates it. Good animation? The animation carried the whole show. Something left not fully explained? Plot holes! I've seen all the excuses for not liking a show that it doesn't surprise me anymore. I'm not saying people aren't allowed to dislike it. However, the wannabe critics that are fully convinced it's a bad anime don't make the best arguments. I think the fact that this show was hated since its announcement could tell how unfairly hated this anime is. Some anime get cursed with a bad reputation while other anime are receiving the opposite reception although they both are somewhat similar. |
| I enjoyed this series too but the last episode kinda made me disappointed. I gave it a good score since the episodes other than the last are enjoyable to me. |
-Kazuma_Apr 17, 2021 9:19 PM
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Are we just judging the first 4 eps here? Becuase the rest was awful, it was full of plot holes and sudden 180s until they got to a point where they realised they couldn’t do a 2nd season, so they stuffed it all in the last ep. I guess it’ll be remembered becuase it’s Jun Maeda, but man was it a letdown for sure. |
| I agree it was a pretty good show for me too... Wish there was more... T_T |
 |
| It's okay. Would've been better if it was a 24-episode show |
 |
| I understand that the creator of this is the same as angel beats and kamisama ni natta hi. please tell me this is different from those two shows. |
 a wise user of MAL said: Just to clarify, adaptations should absolutely stand on their own |
| I really liked it at first but the ending felt rushed imo. |
 just wanna feel wanted by someone other than the police š« |
| To be honest it was the first anime I watched the storyline was interesting and I enjoyed it but it was short |
| Hella rushed at the end. Would’ve been better if it was 24 episodes. |
under”Mebius” is my salvation  |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Charlotte Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Aug 29, 2015 |
649 |
by MsBorsh
»»
Apr 21, 11:49 AM |
|
» Yuu's AbilityPenguinLam - Apr 18 |
37 |
by Yeshaiah2015yesh
»»
Apr 21, 8:27 AM |
|
Poll: » Charlotte Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Sakaitsu - Jul 4, 2015 |
652 |
by MsBorsh
»»
Apr 21, 4:34 AM |
|
Poll: » Charlotte Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 26, 2015 |
886 |
by KumaGetsu
»»
Apr 18, 10:21 PM |
|
Poll: » Charlotte Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Aug 22, 2015 |
459 |
by Tsunamii_
»»
Apr 6, 4:08 AM |