| Almost same like you: Good animation I have lots of enjoyment from it no boring episode no trashtalkings about nothing no annoying characteristics of MC when I have sometimes goosebumps during watching lastly if it is action anime - no fights skipping (I mean when most of fights end in 2 secs or with 1 magic spell/punch/kick it isn't action for me) |
| What you just listed can apply for any show that's rated a 7, 8 or 9 IMO. 10/10 shows resonate with my soul and leave a long lasting impact in my anime-enjoying experience. Animation and art has to be wonderful (in the context of when it aired). The story and world building is deep and intriguing and well thought out. The characters are compelling, likeable, and well-written and developed. The music (OSTs, OPs/EDs) should be used properly and are memorable. |
| A 10 for me is sonething that keep me glue to the tv and got: 1.good story telling 2. good characters 3. good plot 4. nice animation and above im not picky about my 10 but i give 10 to the ones who got me hyped and connected with the mc and the show. |
| Don't fuck up the present, it's connected to your future! |
| if a show can bait me with core concepts, make me enjoy it enough with it's execution, and give me enough twists to keep my interests, all while making me overlook any flaws I'd spot anywhere else, that's a 10/10. |
| 馬鹿γγε«ηγε ¨ι¨γ¬γ©γ―γΏγ§ |
| I don't believe there is a 10/10 animu |
  |
| Stuff that pushed the boundaries of what I thought I could experience from fiction/art. Usually when I give a show the 'masterpiece' pass, it has affected me as a person one way or another. That being said, I don't give 10s often. It has to excel in everything. Major aspects like animation, music, story and voice acting have to be top-notch. Sometimes that may not be the case for one category but the others are so fantastically done that they carry it through. |
 Kal'tsit: Is that... really worth it? Amiya... Amiya: Even if no one understands me... I'll keep going on the path I choose. Maybe it will incinerate me to dust... But if I don't do it, no one can. Arknights β΅ Crylix#0810 |
| Interesting plot + well written characters + enjoyed it from the first episode till the last one + feels. |
| A significantly high level of entertainment and/or sentimental value that's greater than the sum of a show's or movie's parts. |
 |
| A) Something which appeals to me sufficiently at the intellectual level B) Something which appeals to me sufficiently at the emotional level C) Something which appeals to me sufficiently at the sensory level D) Ideally, all of the above The more it adequately introduces and deftly marries and blends thought-provoking ideas, concepts, and themes which exhibit novelty and inspire curiosity and wonder, and is immersive almost at the base physiological level, the better. This can be achieved in one way through deep character writing and well-placed/organically-integrated substantive exposition which is evocative of a tangible and visceral sense of time, place, movement, interpersonal exchange, etc. |
WatchTillTandavaJul 10, 2020 11:18 PM
| For me a 9 is a flawless anime/manga. So a 10 is reserved for those pieces of media which really connected with me, the ones I would dare to say that identify me. |
 |
| If i enjoy the fuck outta it, i give it a 10. Never would have thought i would give Haikyuu 10. God damn that anime is an absolute fire. |
 |
| It's not as big of a deal for me. It should just be a show I really, really like that I genuinely think is really, really good. Yeah, but I still don't like handing out 10s like a few peeps and to an extent value that spot |
MistaAshJul 10, 2020 11:38 PM
| while animation, art style, ost, etc all play a factor into what goes into a 10, the two main things for me would be 1. Regardless of the show's re-watch-ability, it left an impression so strong it becomes a show I hold to a standard to other shows of that genre (not too harshly of course), and 2. The re-watch-ability... if a show can be watched over and over without ever tiring or getting bored of I believe that alone is worth a 10. |
Dragonland04 said: i gave 10 what i think deserved a 10 but in this 10 there are some that i liked more so will i give the rest 9 because of that? no i will give what i like 10 and i know what really is a masterpiece in all this 10.LvChoKer said: A 10 for me is sonething that keep me glue to the tv and got: 1.good story telling 2. good characters 3. good plot 4. nice animation and above im not picky about my 10 but i give 10 to the ones who got me hyped and connected with the mc and the show. considering you have 101 animes with a rating of 10 , you don't see it something as a masterpiece but a good anime , the criterias you mentioned are just a 8 or 9 for me but in no way a 10 tho 101 its alot i wasnt even aware of that |
| Don't fuck up the present, it's connected to your future! |
| Anything that I would be willing and have the material to write several extended analytical essays about, the vast majority of which is not bashing it. |
| Looking at the two 10s I've given they're both boring anime starring adults so I guess that's the criteria |
| MEA·MENTVLA·INGENS·EST |
Dragonland04 said: I can say that for sure that i made some mistakes with my 10 and i will correct this later but like i said if something keeps me glued to the tv never wanting to miss a single moment can count between 10 and 9 now i can say that 101 is alot and i was surprise because i know theres no way for me to actually find that in this much shows and thank you for pointing out my mistakeLvChoKer said: i gave 10 what i think deserved a 10 but in this 10 there are some that i liked more so will i give the rest 9 because of that? no i will give what i like 10 and i know what really is a masterpiece in all this 10 you know what really is a masterpiece ? that statement is a literal contradiction of your anime list considering 1/4 of the animes you have watched , you have rated 10 , it does not seem to me that those animes are something special for you |
| Don't fuck up the present, it's connected to your future! |
| Assuming all other mentioned things have been satisfied, the only time I qualify something to a 10 is if the story has a good conclusion that wraps the plot in a cohesive manner. Else, it just stays at a 9. |
 Truly a Divine Comedy  |
| Something entertaining and very close to my heart to sum it up briefly. I look at technical factors when giving a score as well, but if I feel like an anime truly deserves a 10 I will give it one. |
   |
| - I enjoyed it very much - It kept me engaged meaning it is something I would watch rather than sleep - Likable characters - Good art - Touched me emotionally |
| I gave a 10 to two animes (almost all their seasons): Gintama and Saiki K. Gintama, because it's the best anime I've watched, even though it's not flawless, I love it so much, it deserves a 10. Saiki Kusuo no Psi Nan because I think it's flawless. So well a 10 has to make me feel like THIS IS THE BEST. |
"If you accept everything you're told without question, you'll lose your ability to think. Even if you reached the same conclusion, it would still be worth analysing the reasons behind it." - Lacie Baskerville, Pandora Hearts |
| For me: • Memorable characters • Good OSTs • Moments which make me say "hell yeah!" or almost make me cry • It keeps me hooked. |
| For the most part, the anime needs to have a certain degree of quality throughout (visuals, characters, plot development, ending) and I enjoyed it a lot. I don't have any issues with very minor flaws, since nothing can really be perfect. Fulfilling these general requirements gets a 9 from me. To get a 10, it needs to also be exceptional in one way or another, and I classify them into four different categories. If an anime has multiple seasons, I give 10 only to the one that appealed to me the most, the rest gets a 9 at best. The first is for those which hooked me into watching anime, but this does not encompass all of the anime I watched early on, only those which were done really well and made me want to look for more. Namely, Spirited Away, Hyouka, Gintama° and SKET Dance. The second is for those which tried to do something different, and did so successfully. This includes Monogatari Second Season and High Score Girl. Now for High Score Girl, it actually defies the general guidelines I mentioned at the start, but I love arcade games and it's a nice peek into the arcade culture in those times. Season 2 barely touched on the arcade games and focused more on the love story, making it more of a generic anime but with that off-putting 3DCG, which is why I disliked it a lot more. The third is for those which resonate with me especially well. The ones in this category are Fruits Basket (2019), Koe no Katachi, Perfect Blue and Bunny Girl Senpai. For Fruits Basket, I haven't watched the second season yet. The last category is for those which are extremely impressive from a technical standpoint. Belonging to this category are Kimetsu no Yaiba, Tenki no Ko and Violet Evergarden Gaiden. |
| I only want my cute girls. I can accept a support male if he is only in the background .And he can NEVER step over the line. The girls are MY beloved little property and I dont share MY girls with stupid anime males. Leave MY angels the hell alone! Pureness are a extremely important factor for me. And my females cant talk or show any kind of interest towards males either. I dont like that. I only accept pure lesbians So the anime need to be pure and gay. If I consider the anime to be impure it cant get full points. The 10s on my list are reserved for my well behaved little lesbian angels . They are so damn cute and therefore deserves to get 10 IMO  |
Yuri-CrusaderJul 11, 2020 3:33 AM
 |
| It can have whatever flaws it wants, everyone else can hate it. It might not be perfect but a 10 is perfect for me |
| Always trust yer tummy! |
| Story Characters Osts and also visual quality of the show And most importantly is the enjoyment ^^ Rarely I can find one anime has all of them together |
| It usually comes down to the combination of most of the factors mentioned above plus my own emotional investment to the story, characters, well, the anime/manga as a whole. That's what breaks shows and manga into the 10 zone for me, though I wish the way I rate things were always that consistent. |
FreyJul 11, 2020 4:11 AM
 |
| - Maximum enjoyment. - Good plot/story. - Good MC. - Good characters. - Great ending. - No irritating characters. - No disappointing outcomes. - Good art style and animation. But most importantly it has to be one of a kind. |
TheBerserkerJul 11, 2020 6:20 AM
| enjoyed the most fucking character minimum limit so i give extra letters this has nothing to do with the actual post |
| yum riceballs i just want a baccano! season 2 |
| if i like it enough to favorite it lol |
| - Stellar quality (animation, music, etc...) - An easy watch with a satisfying story that captures my attention for the entire anime - Makes me feel something - Likeable characters It’s usually the second criteria that prevents me from scoring some of the best anime I’ve watched as 10s. |
 |
| It's a personal thing, I can't explain. |
| Imagine how boring this world would be without Japan - a comment at youtube |
| For me 10 is a favourite anime, so I guess I just need to like it a lot. That includes enjoyment (first and foremost), story, characters, emotional aspect, voice acting, music, and sounds. I'm super not picky about the art style and animation so, although I will appreciate them when done well, I won't rate anime lower if the visuals are the only downside. |
 |
More topics from this board
» Is it weird that I wish strong female characters would get sad ending?Sanjay63773 - 5 hours ago |
12 |
by Rhaelynne
»»
5 seconds ago |
|
Poll: » How do you watch anime?RobertBobert - 41 minutes ago |
8 |
by Zarutaku
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Bare feet or pantyhoses?Absurdo_N - Yesterday |
29 |
by Absurdo_N
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Do you fantasize about anime while you sleep?Alpha_1_Zero - 2 hours ago |
13 |
by Rhaelynne
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Early-mid 2000s anime β what are your thoughts?Haneken2086 - Yesterday |
26 |
by FedeMetal
»»
11 minutes ago |