Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Apr 22, 2020 7:39 AM
#1
Offline
Jul 2016
500
So the last episode was a bit weak if u ask me.... For starters i dont like how she just gets magic powers out of the blue...or rather she can use magic powers, while it was established that commoners can't use magic even if they have mana.

Secondly i don't like how the Blue Priest acted there. It would have been better if he straight out acted kindly from the start and overruled the High Priest. Like if he is a good guy it would have been better if he was good from the start. In the current situation , what he did seems more like he was forced to do it...idk i am a bit dissapointed in the execution.

Thirdly, why did they get overwhelmed by the girl? Sure she has alot of mana, but they were Nobles, why not use magic themselves? All nobles have magic right? Surely they should be able to handle a little girl....If they have impenetrable shields for a library they should have some sort of decent magic for protection at least.

Forthly did she realy need to get overwhelming magic power? She allredy had a strong point in being rly smart due to her previous life, but now she has overwhelming magic power..... i am a bit salty not gonna lie.
May 2, 2020 9:18 AM
#2
Offline
Jan 2018
4901
She didn't use any magic her mana/aura was overwhelming her due to anger she had no control of it,


Ferdinand is outranked by the high priest I don't think he can just overraul him


Don't remember it saying ALL Noble's use magic, it said only nobles can use magic properly,

mains case is different other commeners such as her would have died ages ago , which is why hardly or not any commeners have magic


@Zefyris I know your more knowledgeable about this then me, can you correct me if I'm wrong
Mattinator95May 2, 2020 10:04 AM
May 2, 2020 10:13 AM
#3

Offline
Apr 2013
7989
@Mattinator95
@SinOfSlothKing

Oh? I missed that thread completely.
Let's see.. It 's a bit complicated to answer part of this without spoiling parts of the world building that have yet to be revealed but I'll try to avoid spoiling as much as possible.

1) This is merely throwing raw mana to the others while being under strong emotions. It's mostly harmless to nobles, and is seen a " child's tantrum" because that's something noble young children will do from time to time when they get too upset. like the head priest said, this is something noble children that haven't learned how to control their emotion will do. It's mostly harmful to the child doing it in fact.
So that's not really using magic. it's also not the fist time she used that, she did it too when she was angry after her clay tablet were destroyed. Commoner usually don't have mana, and even if they have they don't have the tools and knowledge to use it. Throwing a tantrum to intimidate peoples is not seen as "using magic" by the nobles.

2) This is a bit complex and if you want to see why you should watch the second part really. It's kind of partially answered already. But no, short answer is he can't. And even if he tried this would have political consequences that would benefit no one in here. He took the matter into his own hands after the high priest "conveniently retired" from the negotiation. As long as the high priest was here he would just have said no to it.

3) No, the grey robes are just commoners orphans. The High priest as a blue robe (well, his robe is white but he's still a blue robe) is someone that was rejected from the noble's society for having too little mana to meet the standard of his own family. So he didn't get the tools to use mana, nor the knowledge either. Ferdinand(head priest) actually got both despite being a blue robe and was the only one in the room in that situation. Ferdinand wasn't overwelmed by Myne's mana, he just bite his lips (creating pain) to avoid the effect on his mind. He could have knocked her out any time but he wanted a peaceful solution to that mess. So only a "half noble old geezer" and "normal commoners" got affected by what Myne did.

4) I mean the reason the original Myne died, and her sickness is all due to that. If she didn't had that, original Myne wouldn't have died, Motosu Urano wouldn't be in her body, she wouldn't be bedridden all the time, wouldn't create lots of stuff and make money, wouldn't be learning merchant stuff, the church wouldn't want her so we would not get any story at all from start to finish.
So the question "did she need magical power" well yes she needed that mana or no story at all.




To rectify a few things (the following covers with more detail the world building on those points, but some part could be felt spoilerish for those who like to discover the world little by little through Mayne's eyes. There is no plot spoiler though)




ZefyrisMay 2, 2020 10:19 AM
May 2, 2020 10:42 AM
#4
Offline
Jan 2018
4901
Zefyris said:
@Mattinator95
@SinOfSlothKing

Oh? I missed that thread completely.
Let's see.. It 's a bit complicated to answer part of this without spoiling parts of the world building that have yet to be revealed but I'll try to avoid spoiling as much as possible.

1) This is merely throwing raw mana to the others while being under strong emotions. It's mostly harmless to nobles, and is seen a " child's tantrum" because that's something noble young children will do from time to time when they get too upset. like the head priest said, this is something noble children that haven't learned how to control their emotion will do. It's mostly harmful to the child doing it in fact.
So that's not really using magic. it's also not the fist time she used that, she did it too when she was angry after her clay tablet were destroyed. Commoner usually don't have mana, and even if they have they don't have the tools and knowledge to use it. Throwing a tantrum to intimidate peoples is not seen as "using magic" by the nobles.

2) This is a bit complex and if you want to see why you should watch the second part really. It's kind of partially answered already. But no, short answer is he can't. And even if he tried this would have political consequences that would benefit no one in here. He took the matter into his own hands after the high priest "conveniently retired" from the negotiation. As long as the high priest was here he would just have said no to it.

3) No, the grey robes are just commoners orphans. The High priest as a blue robe (well, his robe is white but he's still a blue robe) is someone that was rejected from the noble's society for having too little mana to meet the standard of his own family. So he didn't get the tools to use mana, nor the knowledge either. Ferdinand(head priest) actually got both despite being a blue robe and was the only one in the room in that situation. Ferdinand wasn't overwelmed by Myne's mana, he just bite his lips (creating pain) to avoid the effect on his mind. He could have knocked her out any time but he wanted a peaceful solution to that mess. So only a "half noble old geezer" and "normal commoners" got affected by what Myne did.

4) I mean the reason the original Myne died, and her sickness is all due to that. If she didn't had that, original Myne wouldn't have died, Motosu Urano wouldn't be in her body, she wouldn't be bedridden all the time, wouldn't create lots of stuff and make money, wouldn't be learning merchant stuff, the church wouldn't want her so we would not get any story at all from start to finish.
So the question "did she need magical power" well yes she needed that mana or no story at all.




To rectify a few things (the following covers with more detail the world building on those points, but some part could be felt spoilerish for those who like to discover the world little by little through Mayne's eyes. There is no plot spoiler though)




Zefyris said:
@Mattinator95
@SinOfSlothKing

Oh? I missed that thread completely.
Let's see.. It 's a bit complicated to answer part of this without spoiling parts of the world building that have yet to be revealed but I'll try to avoid spoiling as much as possible.

1) This is merely throwing raw mana to the others while being under strong emotions. It's mostly harmless to nobles, and is seen a " child's tantrum" because that's something noble young children will do from time to time when they get too upset. like the head priest said, this is something noble children that haven't learned how to control their emotion will do. It's mostly harmful to the child doing it in fact.
So that's not really using magic. it's also not the fist time she used that, she did it too when she was angry after her clay tablet were destroyed. Commoner usually don't have mana, and even if they have they don't have the tools and knowledge to use it. Throwing a tantrum to intimidate peoples is not seen as "using magic" by the nobles.

2) This is a bit complex and if you want to see why you should watch the second part really. It's kind of partially answered already. But no, short answer is he can't. And even if he tried this would have political consequences that would benefit no one in here. He took the matter into his own hands after the high priest "conveniently retired" from the negotiation. As long as the high priest was here he would just have said no to it.

3) No, the grey robes are just commoners orphans. The High priest as a blue robe (well, his robe is white but he's still a blue robe) is someone that was rejected from the noble's society for having too little mana to meet the standard of his own family. So he didn't get the tools to use mana, nor the knowledge either. Ferdinand(head priest) actually got both despite being a blue robe and was the only one in the room in that situation. Ferdinand wasn't overwelmed by Myne's mana, he just bite his lips (creating pain) to avoid the effect on his mind. He could have knocked her out any time but he wanted a peaceful solution to that mess. So only a "half noble old geezer" and "normal commoners" got affected by what Myne did.

4) I mean the reason the original Myne died, and her sickness is all due to that. If she didn't had that, original Myne wouldn't have died, Motosu Urano wouldn't be in her body, she wouldn't be bedridden all the time, wouldn't create lots of stuff and make money, wouldn't be learning merchant stuff, the church wouldn't want her so we would not get any story at all from start to finish.
So the question "did she need magical power" well yes she needed that mana or no story at all.




To rectify a few things (the following covers with more detail the world building on those points, but some part could be felt spoilerish for those who like to discover the world little by little through Mayne's eyes. There is no plot spoiler though)







Reading a Better explanation gave me better understanding and a reminder, thanks for that

orginally I read the part 1 of the manga but forgot a few of the details, haven't got round to reading the LN yet, as I have too many to read


PS. No clue why it quoted you twice , stupid phone
Mattinator95May 2, 2020 11:00 AM
May 3, 2020 12:52 AM
#5
Offline
Jul 2016
500


Guess i will have to marathon s2 when its over.

More topics from this board

Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Nov 20, 2019

96 by Mortz1904 »»
Jun 3, 7:27 PM

Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen Episode 14 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Stark700 - Dec 25, 2019

192 by Dan_VS_Anime »»
May 6, 2:00 PM

Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Stark700 - Sep 12, 2019

165 by TheSeductive »»
Feb 11, 6:41 AM

Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Dec 11, 2019

99 by hanakocheeks »»
Sep 11, 2024 12:42 PM

Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Nov 13, 2019

66 by hanakocheeks »»
Sep 11, 2024 8:23 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login