DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| I remember the live action movie, which was alright, and this too is just alright. Either the adaptions have butchered this series or the manga does not deserve the score it has, I wonder which it is. That aside, the episode and fight was a mess and it felt like a bad version Monogatari, as was the ridiculous pseudo philosophical talk between the two ladies that made absolutely no sense on either side but particularly the villain's. |
YautjaOct 18, 2019 6:06 PM
 |
| I really enjoy the fight scenes. The cuts are quick and brutal. It really reminds me of reading the manga back in the day. The music and sound also really add perfectly to the atmosphere. Makie is an amazing woman. I'm very curious what's to become of her... |
| This was pretty meh i literally slept in the middle of the episode just woke up and finished it i don't know what to say about this just flat :v |
Yautja said: I remember the live action movie, which was alright, and this too is just alright. Either the adaptions have butchered this series or the manga does not deserve the score it has, I wonder which it is. That aside, the episode and fight was a mess and it felt like a bad version Monogatari, as was the ridiculous pseudo philosophical talk between the two ladies that made absolutely no sense on either side but particularly the villain's. It seems far too artsy for mine. Almost feels like a Japanese anime made for pretentious white kids. |
| A nice episode, I liked it. I haven't read Blade of the Immortal yet but I am enjoying this "adaptation" so far. Cheap action scenes and rushed story telling with Rin being a pendule character, with little or none personality to me, but expected less. Hope it gets better. |
| Bloody hell. Hamasaki's directing is stunning. He's completely in his element here, having done Shigurui in the past. Shigurui was incredibly perverse, crude, and grotesquely violent though, of which BotI is not. Thankfully. Much more subtle here, and Lidenfilms' average budget/animation is fortunately being overpowered by Hamasaki's directorial flair. They certainly picked the correct director. I thoroughly enjoyed all three episodes, even if it's disappointing to hear from manga readers that it's been rushed so far. I at least got the gist of Makie's story and she is a well-realized character. Really like her a lot. And I'm desperate to watch the next episode. |
| what service is this airing on |
 |
Yukikaze_sama said: THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- 3rd episode and I still don't get this anime. Nice atmosphere, but kinda hard to follow. this x 100. Everything is a 8/10 but the story is hard to follow. battles are wack. hoping it gets better. |
 |
| You know, if you WERE immortal, taking off an arm to become lighter would be a good tactic... well, as long as you handle the new balance. Although if you store weapons in that sleeve, losing them would be an ass. Also, not to mention if the limb is lost in somewhere like a river. That'd suck. Or half-knawed off by an animal. I'm enjoying it still. Sure, like most here, I can feel there's something off, but it's not enough to kill my enjoyment. Although, I might read the manga after it finishes and see if my opinion changes |
| "You know you've reached peak quality when a doujin is better than the actual source series." (Eg. To LOVE-Ru) Just to list a couple of biases. Likes: A good story, characters, writing, romance, a good plot twist or something that breaks expectations (In a good way), 'backstory' and justice. Dislikes: Bad romance, too much fanservice, the harem genre, yuri, yaoi, and bad writing. |
Zaugr said: Does being born with an amazing ability, not naturally imply that it's your duty and purpose to follow it? Does choosing another way of life not mean being truly selfish and ignoring the rare gift you've been given--to ignore a way out of the difficult circumstances so many others find themselves hopelessly trapped in? How does one find, and then be happy with, their purpose in life? Does the answer lie in where you were born? The abilities and talents you were born with? Your parents guidance and wisdom...? Or is the answer perhaps none of these things, and a purpose you can be content with is something you can only ever get through careful reflection of your own experiences, values and feelings? Through asking the question to yourself - and only to yourself? And what is worse, living an undignified way of life, or a truly ugly way of life? What is the difference between those? What an amazing episode. The ideas were very beautifully, and very fully, explored. It gives so much to think about. What a great and interesting character that woman was. This is how you do a self-contained episode! Also the direction and art... And the soundtrack too... God damn are they going all-out. I'm finding myself replaying so many sequences in awe. This show is so captivating. EDIT: For the people complaining about it being "jumpy" or" hard to follow" with the edits and general direction - I get what you mean, though I hope you realise that it's the byproduct of a very much intended stylistic choice--one you might not be appreciating. This show's direction prioritises very heavily the feeling over the action. For example instead of showing an action from start to finish, and prioritising the basic clarity of that movement, it'll instead maybe focus on showing specific imagery to better invoke the core points and feelings of the sequence (or, for example, just the unnatural speed of a fight between two masters). Instead of spending two seconds focusing on showing a swing from start to finish, it might spend one second on both the draw and the resulting impact, and spend the rest on other things that can perhaps better emphasize and convey the power, speed or emotion behind and in it. In a fight scene you'd definitely be better not trying to follow each and every movement from (and exchange of blows between) characters, but rather just the general flow of the fight and the changes in mood--absorbing the imagery as it comes. This show is focusing its time very carefully on only the important things, and emphasising those; respecting you the viewer enough to pay attention and to not need to be heavy-handed in making sure you're following the flow. This isn't an uncommon directing-style. Certainly not in Japanese cinema. I'm pretty sure there's an especially long and storied history with it (that signature focus on very explicit symobilism and very rapid, flashing, provoking imagery) and samurai films. Thank you very much for a very well thought out and clearly written post. You really nail the spirit and intention behind the directors choices for this show. I hope you don't mind if I heavily borrow some of your words in the neverending future debates about how this show is playing things a little bit differently. I can understand why this show is so polarizing. If you're coming from the likes of Sword Art Online or FATE, the way action and plot are presented here must be confusing. While it's source material is the manga, this show leans itself much more upon Japanese cinematic and theatre tradition. It's not a classic "anime" anime if you understand my meaning. |
| "Perhaps there is a universal, absolute truth. Perhaps it justifies every question. But that's beyond the reach of these small hands." Mamoru Oshii There is a cult of ignorance (...) nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that “my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.” Isaac Asimov |
| Manji is actually a horrible swordsman. Thank goodness he's immortal. |
 "Are you intoxicated, or just insane?" |
| Hmmm he's too weak!! If he's not immortal he can be easily defeated even by a girl! |
 |
| super bored with this. giving it 1-2 more episodes before dropping it |
| I have the same issues with the other episodes but this time the action scenes which I loved before felt awkward. I didn’t understand the complaints before this but here the montage of images that we were given felt odd and not effective. I also found the least amount of enjoyment in this episode thanks to the pacing. Even when not trying to grasp every detail and rather watch for the feeling, it focuses too much on the exposition. I watched some Texhnolyze which was hard to follow but in its lack of abrasive dialogue and that’s far more suited for my tastes. I just don’t get time to sit with Makie or Rin, there isn’t a sense of quietness anywhere to be seen, their stories don’t end up gaining my empathy or intrigue. Rin in particular doesn’t feel like a person to me. I’m sure if there was more time with her it would feel like we were seeing many sides of a complex person but with the way we don’t see her transition from these sides, it feels uncanny. Her determination and pain in episode 1, her desperation for the sword and her instant stomaching of that desire and then her little sister act in episode 2, and this time doing the instant cut to her pouting and cut away doesn’t imbue these together in my mind as a person fluctuating in their mood. They aren’t close enough together, it's often like she can only show one emotion per scene and the scenes blast by, like I said early, with a lack of quietness. That is actually why my favorite part of the episode was her saving Manji. It felt like they finally converged, her care and appreciation for Manji and her determination despite her lack in skills, saving his life. It was a really nice moment. It was also cool to see Manji's sense of pride coming out! |
| I wish they used a little bit less jumpcuts in the fighting animation and also didn't ommit Makie's past Dammit Manji, almost everybody so far had more skills in sword fighting... |
 |
| As the post counts is the highest of all the episodes, this episode would be the most impressive one. Actually, it's a cool battle sequence that the girl ambushed the enemy from a spear stubbed high on the wall. Although the choreography as a whole was beautiful, the animation needed much more frames. Her indecisive and unconvincing behavior was also a flaw. Her background should be told in more detail. |
| I feel like I should probably read the manga, however, I find the art extremely pleasing to the eye. I don't think that it's hard to follow, I just feel like there are some things that are just being left out. All in all, I think it's a great anime. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Mugen no Juunin: Immortal Episode 4 DiscussionRider9530 - Oct 23, 2019 |
38 |
by Apreggi
»»
Apr 21, 10:36 AM |
|
Poll: » Mugen no Juunin: Immortal Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 )Joseahfer - Oct 9, 2019 |
61 |
by Apreggi
»»
Apr 19, 11:28 PM |
|
Poll: » Mugen no Juunin: Immortal Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 )Joseahfer - Oct 9, 2019 |
81 |
by Apreggi
»»
Apr 19, 1:04 AM |
|
Poll: » Mugen no Juunin: Immortal Episode 9 DiscussionHatsuyuki - Nov 27, 2019 |
27 |
by BrianaBird
»»
Apr 8, 8:42 PM |
|
Poll: » Mugen no Juunin: Immortal Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 )KANLen09 - Mar 25, 2020 |
53 |
by FedeMetal
»»
Mar 30, 9:40 AM |