Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
#1
Jul 23, 5:33 AM
Offline
Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 15
If FMAB were separated into seasons what would you think it’s rating on MAL gonna be for each?

For example;

1st season ep1-26 (First 2 cour)
2nd seasom ep27-50 (next 2 cour)
3rd season ep51-64 (last cour)

Just wondering if anybody thinks its 10/10 all the way from the start. This is because I heard somewhere that FMAB got that high rating only because it has many episodes compared to its competitors who had to divide its rating between seasons.
 
#2
Jul 23, 4:07 PM
Offline
Joined: Dec 2018
Posts: 193
Shukrin said:
If FMAB were separated into seasons what would you think it’s rating on MAL gonna be for each?

For example;

1st season ep1-26 (First 2 cour)
2nd season ep27-50 (next 2 cour)
3rd season ep51-64 (last cour)

Just wondering if anybody thinks its 10/10 from the start. This is because I heard somewhere that FMAB got that high rating only because it has many episodes compared to its competitors who had to divide its rating between seasons.

I think it was mentioned in an Attack on Titan Season 3 Part 2 thread ("To all the people that think this doesn't deserve top spot" was the title of the thread)
I don't know, I am only at episode 8 of FMAB but I don't think is the best anime I have ever seen (please don't kill me, it's just an opinion since I am still watching), but people told me it gets better so I can't say
 
#3
Jul 23, 4:31 PM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 3264
I definitely think the 1st part would be much lower rated, that's usually the part a lot of people say is pretty boring. Final part though I can see it being even higher rated than it currently is since it's basically SnK S3 P2, except with a proper ending and not prepping for another season
'On-Hold' is another way for a completionist to say 'Dropped'


 
#4
Jul 23, 4:49 PM
Offline
Joined: Dec 2013
Posts: 19
Short_Circut said:
I definitely think the 1st part would be much lower rated, that's usually the part a lot of people say is pretty boring. Final part though I can see it being even higher rated than it currently is since it's basically SnK S3 P2, except with a proper ending and not prepping for another season


Essentially this ^
 
#5
Jul 23, 8:57 PM
Offline
Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 66
I know people are going to argue it but for me each and every single part of this show is a 10/10. It's still the best anime I've ever watched and my list of anime is pretty extensive even if I do say so myself.
 
#6
Jul 24, 8:00 AM
Offline
Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 15
For me also, the early 1-20 episodes are not quite as good as the later episodes but they are still good and there are lots of highlights in that period that deserves 10/10. But as they approach 25-26 it peaked to 10/10 and stayed at that level to the end. Last 14 episodes is the most epic moment I ever seen in anime.
 
#7
Aug 5, 4:02 PM
Offline
Joined: Mar 2018
Posts: 24
In my opinion each part deserves 10/10 but what you said about it being this highly rated because it is just one season is wrong because if you look at most anime usually only people who liked it will stay for the later seasons so the score gets higher because less people give lower scores while with long shows the lower scores given from people who didn’t like it are for the whole show
 
#8
Aug 5, 5:01 PM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 561
First 2 cour - 6/10 or 7/10
Next 2 cour - 8/10 or 9/10
Last cour - 10/10

I think overall it deserves my 9/10, but yeah, it ain't a masterpiece from the start. Also, this type of rating would made me give a really lower rating to some arcs of HxH
Modified by thiago52192, Dec 4, 9:10 AM
 
#9
Aug 5, 5:05 PM
Offline
Joined: Mar 2018
Posts: 39
I know this is just theoretical, but this would be extremely stupid, considering FMAB is treated as this giant story that has a huge finish where everything is tied together very nicely, i cant see you separating any part of fma at all
 
Aug 5, 5:24 PM
Offline
Joined: Dec 2018
Posts: 795
Shukrin said:
If FMAB were separated into seasons what would you think it’s rating on MAL gonna be for each?

For example;

1st season ep1-26 (First 2 cour)
2nd seasom ep27-50 (next 2 cour)
3rd season ep51-64 (last cour)

Just wondering if anybody thinks its 10/10 all the way from the start. This is because I heard somewhere that FMAB got that high rating only because it has many episodes compared to its competitors who had to divide its rating between seasons.

The ending is awesome but the middle would get like 6.5 lmao
 
Aug 5, 6:02 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 42
Rasti_m23 said:
I know people are going to argue it but for me each and every single part of this show is a 10/10. It's still the best anime I've ever watched and my list of anime is pretty extensive even if I do say so myself.


Dude, so you have SnK 1 and SnK 2 both 10 rated but somehow so disappointed in SnK 3P2 to rate it with 1? Don't you find it looks kinda... well... weird?

FMAB is great show but its' fanboys are just worst
 
Aug 6, 2:19 AM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2019
Posts: 315
Nandor said:
Rasti_m23 said:
I know people are going to argue it but for me each and every single part of this show is a 10/10. It's still the best anime I've ever watched and my list of anime is pretty extensive even if I do say so myself.


Dude, so you have SnK 1 and SnK 2 both 10 rated but somehow so disappointed in SnK 3P2 to rate it with 1? Don't you find it looks kinda... well... weird?

FMAB is great show but its' fanboys are just worst
yep. It is weird because watching s3p2 before season 3 part 1 and straight up rating snks3p2 a 1. It is most likely a down voting.
Should I troll in the troll bait threads? It is kinda idiotic to be logical in the troll bait threads. Well, it will depend on my mood.
 
Aug 6, 3:00 AM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 129
Nandor said:
Rasti_m23 said:
I know people are going to argue it but for me each and every single part of this show is a 10/10. It's still the best anime I've ever watched and my list of anime is pretty extensive even if I do say so myself.


Dude, so you have SnK 1 and SnK 2 both 10 rated but somehow so disappointed in SnK 3P2 to rate it with 1? Don't you find it looks kinda... well... weird?

FMAB is great show but its' fanboys are just worst


I just noticed that too. What makes if even more funny is that fact that he has Attack On Titan in his "Animes I gave a 9-10" section. Really disappointing to see this amount of toxicity from this community, simply because their favourite anime was dethroned from the top spot due to a glitch.
 
Aug 6, 7:47 AM
Offline
Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 15
Nandor said:
Rasti_m23 said:
I know people are going to argue it but for me each and every single part of this show is a 10/10. It's still the best anime I've ever watched and my list of anime is pretty extensive even if I do say so myself.


Dude, so you have SnK 1 and SnK 2 both 10 rated but somehow so disappointed in SnK 3P2 to rate it with 1? Don't you find it looks kinda... well... weird?

FMAB is great show but its' fanboys are just worst


Nah. The worst fanboys to me definitely goes to HxH. Last time I rated the show low because i don’t like it even after watching nearly half the episodes. Its not even a day passed, my account got flooded by comments and messages by the fanboys asking me why i rate it that way. I tried to give them answers then I realised they will never accept what ever answer I gave them. They just kept on asking which episodes is this?, which episode is that?. Then I just gave up replying to them.

Even if you go to r/anime or youtube comments about anime video, it is literally full of the fanboys telling HxH is the best anime evar...! and everybody should watch it.
Modified by Shukrin, Aug 6, 7:58 AM
 
Aug 6, 10:29 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2018
Posts: 725
First 2 cour 7.9
3. cour 7.3
Last cour 7.6

Not a huge fan of the series but i have to say its rock solid, by far one of the best shounens.
Modified by Mullerio, Aug 6, 12:11 PM
 
Aug 6, 11:51 AM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2019
Posts: 125
I dropped this show so my opinion is maybe not relevant, but i think it's a kind of respect that I don't go and trolling the Hell out of it because almost everyone else love this show more Than AoT. Community has to grow up.
Merciful lies or painful truth?
 
Aug 6, 12:05 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2015
Posts: 476
I would give
First Season: 7
Second Season: 8
Third Season: 6
I don't like first and last 12-13 episodes of FMAB.
 
Aug 7, 1:05 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2016
Posts: 1506
9/10, 9/10 and 8/10 for me. And the comedy is gold.
 
Aug 7, 1:21 PM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 1956
The last part for me is definitely 10/10 but the first part and second part really don't know, probably both of them 9/10
 
Aug 7, 8:48 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 115
For part 2 and 3, I would give a 10 out of 10. Not sure on part one though. The first 13 episodes were really rushed, and I honestly think the very first episode was confusing to new viewers. But, at the same time, it was probable that they did this, considering they already went through all that stuff in the 2003 series. It was only a 5 year gap til the remake, so it also makes sense for them to do an anime only "welcome back" episode, although I personally think that was a bad decision. So with that in mind, I'd say part 1 would be a solid 8.
 
Aug 8, 1:29 AM
Offline
Joined: Feb 2018
Posts: 106
If u really want to divide like this than the last 1-2 cour would be 9.3+ easily!!

Amd yeah the ending really influences the score. A crap ending to a brilliant show is off putting, while a brilliant ending to a mediocre show can propel it to 8.5 something (from 8 something). Take steins gate as example, last 5-6 eps propelled rating from 7.9 to 9.1
 
Aug 8, 2:05 PM
Offline
Joined: Aug 2015
Posts: 293
I actually think all the scores would be lower.
Really, FMAB is nothing that amazing, but what makes it what it is, is how consistent it managed to be, as a whole. Seperately, I would rate each part 8, but together they're a 9 to me, somehow
 
Nov 16, 6:16 AM
Offline
Joined: Dec 2018
Posts: 134
Since I've not watched the complete show, basing my judgement on the first 5,6 episodes, I'll give it 7, which is the lowest I've ever given to an anime. I didn't find it confusing, just boring. The only thing I found confusing is how it manged to get top spot. But I guess the ratings are not based considering the initial episodes. I think a day will come when I'll complete the show, but I guess I'm going to be disappointed since I expect a lot from a show at the top, and the initial episodes are something I'd call, disappointment. It might be an amazing show as a whole, but I'm just afraid to pick it up.

The last Shonen anime I watched after being recommended to me was MHA, and it really disappointed me.
 
Nov 16, 7:22 AM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2016
Posts: 737
If I’ve to give score to the separated cours, I’d given:
- first cour: 7/8
- second cour: 8/9
- last cour: 6
 
Nov 19, 9:02 AM
Offline
Joined: Aug 2019
Posts: 1
justasadguy said:
Shukrin said:
If FMAB were separated into seasons what would you think it’s rating on MAL gonna be for each?

For example;

1st season ep1-26 (First 2 cour)
2nd season ep27-50 (next 2 cour)
3rd season ep51-64 (last cour)

Just wondering if anybody thinks its 10/10 from the start. This is because I heard somewhere that FMAB got that high rating only because it has many episodes compared to its competitors who had to divide its rating between seasons.

I think it was mentioned in an Attack on Titan Season 3 Part 2 thread ("To all the people that think this doesn't deserve top spot" was the title of the thread)
I don't know, I am only at episode 8 of FMAB but I don't think is the best anime I have ever seen (please don't kill me, it's just an opinion since I am still watching), but people told me it gets better so I can't say
m I think that if thet separated Fullmetal it would take more time but it will be a good idea to remake Fullmetal maybe in 10 years but it most ikely wouldn't be as good as the first one because is a masterpice and if they seperat full metal into 3 seasons I think the first season will get a 7.8 and the sacond will get a 8.4 but the last season will get a 9.3 because the last day arec was soo good Fullmetal gets better by time and its a masterpiece
 
Dec 1, 7:36 AM

Offline
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 5346
Shukrin said:
If FMAB were separated into seasons what would you think it’s rating on MAL gonna be for each?

For example;

1st season ep1-26 (First 2 cour)
2nd seasom ep27-50 (next 2 cour)
3rd season ep51-64 (last cour)

Just wondering if anybody thinks its 10/10 all the way from the start. This is because I heard somewhere that FMAB got that high rating only because it has many episodes compared to its competitors who had to divide its rating between seasons.

Why would it be separated? It aired continously week after week (with exceptions of X-Mas breaks).
 
Dec 1, 7:52 AM

Offline
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 172
Knowing FMAs fanbase they would probably push all 3 seasons to be no1 and only allow the next season to overtake the previous one.

Personally
s1 - 6/10
s2- 8/10
s3 - 7/10
 
Dec 1, 8:15 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 2911
The only thing I see is the top 10 filled with only FMA and Gintama
 
Dec 1, 8:16 AM
Offline
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 49462
the first season will definitely be out of the top 10 ranking imo
 
Dec 3, 12:18 PM
Offline
Joined: Apr 2017
Posts: 120
1st season ep1-26 9/10
2nd season ep27-50 10/10
3rd season ep51-64 11/10
 
11 hours ago
Offline
Joined: Nov 2016
Posts: 55
I think it's unfair to compare the first episodes with the last ones because the climax of any story should be the best part.
 
Top