Attack on Titan
Can Aot Make it to number #1?
Yes
44.5%
175
No
55.5%
218
393 votes
| People could be crazy enough to make it happen, but it's eventually gonna cool down and end up somewhere around 10 or 15 anyway. Not that I feel FMA:B deserves first place either. |
| No, it can't. FMA:B got this title through a near perfect adaption from beginning to end, from a manga that is just as well received through all demographics. But other than that: AoT S3P2 certainly deserves a spot in the all time 100, and that rightfully as it adapts the most hype part up to the current stories point. While being a well received show itself. More importantly, what's in people's minds creating all those threads one after another? Care to ellaborate, OP? "Omg, the score is rising again. Quick, gotta create a "unique" thread about it." |
Mattinator95 said: No .im suprised the score it's still high it will drop next episode surprised it hasn't dropped yet currently Considering what's happend For reference, the score has actually gone up a lot since the release of episode 6 to my surprise. The last time I check the stats was hours before the airing of episode 6 it had 49.6% rated it a 10/10, I have just checked it now and it's rising at a blistering pace at 50.6% 10/10. Mal takes a while before it updates the score so in reality its score should be around 9.17/18 at this moment, so expect an increase every day. I honestly was not expecting so many persons to love this episode, but they did base on the upvotes, so at this point I don't know how anime only will feel about next episode, we shall see. |
For anyone that is interested.  |
| For a short period of time? Yes. Your Name achieved that as well. But stay? I doubt it. First because of the Fmab fanboys that won't let anything get close to their perfect anime. And second, don't forget SNK is hated by a lot of people here. For now, I'm happy the show is getting the recognition it deserves |
 |
| "Hey, a thread about "Can AOT reach the 2nd place in MAL?" Is already got taken down by the mods, how about we make another thread about "can AOT reach the 1st place in MAL?", Sounds good right?" |
 |
| Number 3 is already way to high in my opinion, its not a bad show by any means and its hype as hell but no where near as political as LOTGH or as emotional as shouwa genroku rakugo shinjuu or 3-gatsu (to name some examples),its not complex it has not much depth and no wear near top 10,30 or even 40 worthy Characters, it should be top 30 or 20 but not more in my opinion (or at least everything before Season 4), to come back to your question i actually doubt it its still airing so it will go down for sure. |
 |
| yea the stat distribution is almost the same as FMA's but it won't happen because haters are gonna hate lmao |
You son of a .. turtle  |
| I can see it happening for a brief time but not forever.~ |
 サディスティックな考え "JUST KILL ME." サディスティックマインド |
| I probably will never understand why people care so much about mal scores. Just watch the show and enjoy it. Everyone will rate it how they want and making another thread about 'if my favorite show can be number #2 or #1 or whatever' doesn't change anything. |
| Everyone talk about between AoT & FMAB, but neither look on the movie that reach top 3 spot before & now...and if hyped is real like that movie, the future movie that come from the same director is also coming next month, so that maybe we have another challenger for top anime in MAL database, at least... |
I was talking about the anime, i read the manga and i agree after Chapter 90 it improves a lot with one of the best war arcs in manga history but prior to that i dont think it "deserves" a spot in the top 3. |
|
Lucette_C said: AOT is now at no.2, with a score of 9.14. it's score increased by nearly 0.1 in the past two weeks, so if the next few episodes are as good or better, it's not unrealistic for further increases. But I do agree that it's likely to drop after it finishes airing. Many people are waiting for it to finish before watching or voting, so we'll likely to see some score changes after the season finishes airing. At this very moment, I don't think its likely to drop at this moment unless the last 4 episodes disappoint fans, because if fans love what happen in the last 4 episode, then it will only go up further. Plus 45k voters is a good enough sample size to determine that the score would not change much if all those people started to score the series. If you ask a 10k sample size of people a question like, which super hero you like more, between superman and Wonder woman and you have 9k of those persons voting for superman, then no matter if you add 50k more or even 100k more person the difference would still be close to the 90% of folks who voted for superman. |
| I hope this trash will never be in top 10 for a long timespan but the score growth after episode 6 is a proof that most of the voters are complete idiots and rankings dont matter at all |
 |
FuegoIndigo2 said: Snkmasterpiece said: Aot no depth or complexity? Yeah you disnt even pay attention. It certainly has more than fmab lol. Where exactly did you find depth in AoT exactly? It never was about depth it was purely on suspense and spectacle which it delivered in spades but at the cost of well-written characters (of course some exceptions exist) and a well-written story. It always had depth, it just wasn't in your face, snk is a very subtle series that most don't realise, but don't you worry, once the basement secrets is reveal, the pandora box will be open and you will see exactly what this series is really about. |
| "Over my dead body" every other FMA:B fan. Look what happened to Gintama°. It was rated 9.34 after the SA and FS arcs which are unparalleled to anything to date I have seen. Also, this thread gonna be locked. |
| Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
| It probably will but only for a short amount of time imo. MrBluebear said: True. I guess it's kinda silly, but I'm looking forward to what score tenki no ko ends up having here.Everyone talk about between AoT & FMAB, but neither look on the movie that reach top 3 spot before & now...and if hyped is real like that movie, the future movie that come from the same director is also coming next month, so that maybe we have another challenger for top anime in MAL database, at least... |
 |
| No. I think it's about reached its peak at this point. Will be difficult to get any higher than it currently is. It'll probably slowly drop off a bit, then jump up a little again with the 1/5 boost when it ends, followed by another slow drop off period when it's finally over |
  |
nekoeren said: even though i would like to see that happen i feel the gap is just way too big It was at 9.06 just last week and its now at 9.14, its going up really fast. HaXXspetten said: No. I think it's about reached its peak at this point. Will be difficult to get any higher than it currently is. It'll probably slowly drop off a bit, then jump up a little again with the 1/5 boost when it ends, followed by another slow drop off period when it's finally over Prepare to be blown away, it should actually be at 9.18 at this moment but mal updates take a while to update its score. 3 hours ago it was at 50.6% as you can see in my earlier post with the comparison with fmab now its at 50.8% 10/10 votes. It is going up so fast mal algorithm ranking can't keep up. Don't be surprise by time the next episode reaches it will be at 9.20. I've been predicting where it would be every week and I have been spot on. |
keragamming said: You can't just look at it like that: Kimi no Na wa has more 10/10s in percentage than SnK does too and only a third as many 1/10s yet it's still at 9.13 only. I guess one could technically do the math with the actual score formula if you want but eh I'll just wait and see what happens lolnekoeren said: even though i would like to see that happen i feel the gap is just way too big It was at 9.06 just last week and its now at 9.14, its going up really fast. HaXXspetten said: No. I think it's about reached its peak at this point. Will be difficult to get any higher than it currently is. It'll probably slowly drop off a bit, then jump up a little again with the 1/5 boost when it ends, followed by another slow drop off period when it's finally over Prepare to be blown away, it should actually be at 9.18 at this moment but mal updates take a while to update its score. 3 hours ago it was at 50.6% as you can see in my earlier post with the comparison with fmab now its at 50.8% 10/10 votes. It is going up so fast mal algorithm ranking can't keep up. Don't be surprise by time the next episode reaches it will be at 9.20. I've been predicting where it would be every week and I have been spot on. |
| |
keragamming said: Maybe AOT surpass FMA:B in a while, but with the time the score goes down... Or maybe not, we dont know yetnekoeren said: even though i would like to see that happen i feel the gap is just way too big It was at 9.06 just last week and its now at 9.14, its going up really fast. HaXXspetten said: No. I think it's about reached its peak at this point. Will be difficult to get any higher than it currently is. It'll probably slowly drop off a bit, then jump up a little again with the 1/5 boost when it ends, followed by another slow drop off period when it's finally over Prepare to be blown away, it should actually be at 9.18 at this moment but mal updates take a while to update its score. 3 hours ago it was at 50.6% as you can see in my earlier post with the comparison with fmab now its at 50.8% 10/10 votes. It is going up so fast mal algorithm ranking can't keep up. Don't be surprise by time the next episode reaches it will be at 9.20. I've been predicting where it would be every week and I have been spot on. |
| I keep moving forward |
HaXXspetten said: keragamming said: You can't just look at it like that: Kimi no Na wa has more 10/10s in percentage than SnK does too and only a third as many 1/10s yet it's still at 9.13 only. I guess one could technically do the math with the actual score formula if you want but eh I'll just wait and see what happens lolIt was at 9.06 just last week and its now at 9.14, its going up really fast. Prepare to be blown away, it should actually be at 9.18 at this moment but mal updates take a while to update its score. 3 hours ago it was at 50.6% as you can see in my earlier post with the comparison with fmab now its at 50.8% 10/10 votes. It is going up so fast mal algorithm ranking can't keep up. Don't be surprise by time the next episode reaches it will be at 9.20. I've been predicting where it would be every week and I have been spot on. I get what you are saying, but that is not what I base my assumption from. I've been paying closer attention to the stats and not the score itself, say snk was at 49.5% 10/10 votes, by time it reaches 49.7% it would increase, I'm not sure how long mal scores takes to update but base off what I've seen it happens every 15 hours or so. The point I'm making is that the 10/10 votes are increasing so fast that mal will always be behind unless it slow down. Episode 6 was release yesterday it was 49.9% at 9.12 now do you notice today it jump to 9.13 and then 9.14 a few hours later? It shows that that the algorithm is trying to catch up to the the amount of upvotes its getting. It took about 2 days for snk to jump from 9.12 to 13, but only a couple of hours to jump to 9.14. Thinking about it now, it seems the faster the 10/10 score the quicker the score goes up. episode 5 boost lost it steam and episode 6 took over and imo is even boosting the series score even faster than episode 5. @WarFirel I know, but I find it interesting to follow its score and to see how far it has come from. |
keragammingJun 3, 2019 12:36 PM
thiago52192 said: For a short period of time? Yes. Your Name achieved that as well. But stay? I doubt it. First because of the Fmab fanboys that won't let anything get close to their perfect anime. And second, don't forget SNK is hated by a lot of people here. For now, I'm happy the show is getting the recognition it deserves Its funny to me how you call everyone who loves FMAB a fanboy. And I don't say its a perfect anime nothing is perfect but is it the closest thing to perfect hell yeah it is and that is why it will stay at number 1 for a long time to come. |
| Greed has poisoned men’s souls, has barricaded the world with hate, has goose-stepped us into misery and bloodshed. |
| HxH is the one deserve first place, fuck FMAB.. |
| “You should enjoy the little detours to the fullest. Because that's where you'll find the things more important than what you want.” |
| With booster accounts, the score gonna be increase. |
 |
| So far I prefer this arc to FMA:B, but that's the problem, we're comparing a random arc of AoT to the entirety of FMA:B with its ups and downs. For that reason, I hope FMA:B will stay up front. It's a bit ridiculous to have a season of AoT as number 1 when the others are not even top 100 especially when all in all, it's really the same story and only stupid people would start Season 3 part 2 without watching the rest. But unfortythat's how MAL rankings work |
Mullerio said: Number 3 is already way to high in my opinion, its not a bad show by any means and its hype as hell but no where near as political as LOTGH or as emotional as shouwa genroku rakugo shinjuu or 3-gatsu (to name some examples),its not complex it has not much depth and no wear near top 10,30 or even 40 worthy Characters, it should be top 30 or 20 but not more in my opinion (or at least everything before Season 4), to come back to your question i actually doubt it its still airing so it will go down for sure. That is your opinion. IMO shouwa genroku and 3gatsu are very much overrated, overdramatic boring shows. So which one of us is right now? To be on topic, if this had the popularity of season1 it could get NO1, but since much less people add it to their list, the ppl who give it a 1/10 out of hate will have a bigger impact, so it will probly be 2. after fma, which has over 1 million members. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 16, 2019 |
548 |
by ARTisANexplosion
»»
4 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 2, 2019 |
802 |
by jebras
»»
Apr 23, 10:08 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 30, 2019 |
668 |
by Beqapapi
»»
Apr 12, 1:14 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Thorf - May 26, 2019 |
734 |
by lightning19
»»
Apr 12, 7:59 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 19, 2019 |
345 |
by JoestarEISH_020
»»
Mar 31, 8:10 AM |