Choke_Me_Zaddy said: Allot of people tend to focus on the animation, without realizing that the animation compared to the writing is small potatoes. Those people giving it a low score are animation snobs and nothing more. definitely amigo, everyone knows an action show is all about the writing and not the animation |
keragamming said: StufedAnmalQueen said: It's a 7.95. According to MAL, a 7 still means good. For mal, a 7 is mediocre and anything less than 7 is complete trash. This is base off the ratings, did you know that majority of users here give anime they think were just "ok" a 7/10? you learn a new thing everyday |
Amazinc said: people really be spamming 1s just because of the animation? Wow I support policies where some users have more rating weight than others, and this is the reason why. |
あなたは誰？ |
sunnykappa said: Amazinc said: people really be spamming 1s just because of the animation? Wow WelL this is MAL afterall A site filled with degenerate American weeb Nice way to put it sunnykappa-san. |
 |
Choke_Me_Zaddy said: Allot of people tend to focus on the animation, without realizing that the animation compared to the writing is small potatoes. Those people giving it a low score are animation snobs and nothing more. Not sure if trolling or just sub slug intelligence. |
on 
| it still pisses me off that literal pussies get overly upset because the animation isn't as crisp as the first season, then make the season look bad by spamming 1's. It's retarded |
 |
Anime_Biscuit said: it still pisses me off that literal pussies get overly upset because the animation isn't as crisp as the first season, then make the season look bad by spamming 1's. It's retarded It's almost as if Art and Animation are a huge deal breaking/making factor in an action anime that literally wouldn't be a fraction as popular in the mainstream without the first season's 10/10 animation quality and fight choreography or something... |
| "OPM Season 2 starts below an 8.00 wow that is pretty bad" because mal rating dictates everything about how good a show is (and 7.95 is practically 8 anyway) |
AnimeFreak-San said: is this a male gender issure...human issue...mental illness perhaps? |
photophobic said: "OPM Season 2 starts below an 8.00 wow that is pretty bad" because mal rating dictates everything about how good a show is (and 7.95 is practically 8 anyway) That is true, but it does give you a overall impression on what general viewers think of the series, just like the votes for each episode discussion and base on those its a mix reaction. |
| And it's only gonna get worse from here on out..... |
| bad animation, that's basically all it needs to be bad. |
Sasori_Nagashi said: Anime_Biscuit said: it still pisses me off that literal pussies get overly upset because the animation isn't as crisp as the first season, then make the season look bad by spamming 1's. It's retarded It's almost as if Art and Animation are a huge deal breaking/making factor in an action anime that literally wouldn't be a fraction as popular in the mainstream without the first season's 10/10 animation quality and fight choreography or something... keep thinking that. I actually enjoy things |
|
Anime_Biscuit said: Sasori_Nagashi said: It's almost as if Art and Animation are a huge deal breaking/making factor in an action anime that literally wouldn't be a fraction as popular in the mainstream without the first season's 10/10 animation quality and fight choreography or something... keep thinking that. I actually enjoy things I actually enjoy GOOD things. I couldn't imagine just turning my brain off and just enjoying any old trash regardless of it's merits. That's literally muting yourself to the brilliance of higher quality media and just reducing everything to a bland sameness that would not even improve poor quality media but ruin higher quality media entirely. |
Sasori_NagashiApr 10, 2019 12:18 AM
Sasori_Nagashi said: I actually enjoy GOOD things. I couldn't imagine just turning my brain off and just enjoying any old trash regardless of it's merits. That's literally muting yourself to the brilliance of higher quality media and just reducing everything to a bland sameness that would not even improve poor quality media but ruin higher quality media entirely. You realize that the one punch man story is still good right. To turn off any attention to the show and its merits because it doesnt have incredible animation is silly |
|
Sasori_Nagashi said: Choke_Me_Zaddy said: Allot of people tend to focus on the animation, without realizing that the animation compared to the writing is small potatoes. Those people giving it a low score are animation snobs and nothing more. Not sure if trolling or just sub slug intelligence. Ok sweetheart, you can believe whatever u want to believe. |
Anime_Biscuit said: Sasori_Nagashi said: I actually enjoy GOOD things. I couldn't imagine just turning my brain off and just enjoying any old trash regardless of it's merits. That's literally muting yourself to the brilliance of higher quality media and just reducing everything to a bland sameness that would not even improve poor quality media but ruin higher quality media entirely. You realize that the one punch man story is still good right. To turn off any attention to the show and its merits because it doesnt have incredible animation is silly I read the webcomic. I know it has a great story, fantastic dialog, loveable characters ETC. However you can't just ignore bad elements in favour of good elements. The animation in season one was truly breathtaking and season two's animation is not only poorer in comparison, but poorer than the industry standard for action anime. The idea you should accept inferior quality and still rate it high is like saying you should thank a chef who serves you dollar-store frozen mince meat when you ordered fillet mignon. |
Thememetrap said: Considering this first episodes are what J.C staff has done ahead of time im really scared of what episode 4 or 5 is gonna be like I guess we have to wait and see before saying which episodes are gonna be low quality ones. By the way, I think that slightly after I started watching OPM Season 2, the score was a little bit above 8.00/10.00 (if I remember correctly of course), so heh, at least for a short period of time it started with 8.00. :P It will be cool if later, after releasement of next episodes, the score goes higher rather than lower compared to the current state. |
Sasori_Nagashi said: Anime_Biscuit said: You realize that the one punch man story is still good right. To turn off any attention to the show and its merits because it doesnt have incredible animation is silly I read the webcomic. I know it has a great story, fantastic dialog, loveable characters ETC. However you can't just ignore bad elements in favour of good elements. The animation in season one was truly breathtaking and season two's animation is not only poorer in comparison, but poorer than the industry standard for action anime. The idea you should accept inferior quality and still rate it high is like saying you should thank a chef who serves you dollar-store frozen mince meat when you ordered fillet mignon. Yes but I just dont agree that the animation ofseason 2 so far hasnt even beenthat bad and is quite fine for an action anime. I dont see what has bothered you so much with it. And it's only been one singular episode. So we dont even know the extent of what they are doing |
|
Anime_Biscuit said: Sasori_Nagashi said: I read the webcomic. I know it has a great story, fantastic dialog, loveable characters ETC. However you can't just ignore bad elements in favour of good elements. The animation in season one was truly breathtaking and season two's animation is not only poorer in comparison, but poorer than the industry standard for action anime. The idea you should accept inferior quality and still rate it high is like saying you should thank a chef who serves you dollar-store frozen mince meat when you ordered fillet mignon. Yes but I just dont agree that the animation ofseason 2 so far hasnt even beenthat bad and is quite fine for an action anime. I dont see what has bothered you so much with it. And it's only been one singular episode. So we dont even know the extent of what they are doing With a lot of anime the quality tapers off the longer it runs as they are rushing more and more to hit a deadline with less prep. Also more than anything the trailer is what concerns me. It was far worse than 1st ep and it was showing off some fight scenes that should be a lot higher quality. |
Sasori_Nagashi said: Anime_Biscuit said: Yes but I just dont agree that the animation ofseason 2 so far hasnt even beenthat bad and is quite fine for an action anime. I dont see what has bothered you so much with it. And it's only been one singular episode. So we dont even know the extent of what they are doing With a lot of anime the quality tapers off the longer it runs as they are rushing more and more to hit a deadline with less prep. Also more than anything the trailer is what concerns me. It was far worse than 1st ep and it was showing off some fight scenes that should be a lot higher quality. If I remember it correctly the trailer showed off footage only from episode 1. So what you saw in that trailer you saw in ep 1. Which wasnt so bad in the end. It may get better or worse. It's still too early to tell. But at least try to enjoy opm for opm. NNot just as an action anime. |
|
Anime_Biscuit said: Sasori_Nagashi said: With a lot of anime the quality tapers off the longer it runs as they are rushing more and more to hit a deadline with less prep. Also more than anything the trailer is what concerns me. It was far worse than 1st ep and it was showing off some fight scenes that should be a lot higher quality. If I remember it correctly the trailer showed off footage only from episode 1. So what you saw in that trailer you saw in ep 1. Which wasnt so bad in the end. It may get better or worse. It's still too early to tell. But at least try to enjoy opm for opm. NNot just as an action anime. Perhaps they had time to touch it up quite a bit from the trailer version then, because there was some really jarring things in that trailer lol. Either way it's still quite a bit worse than Season 1 and I just can't stand people making excuses that "animation doesn't matter" as it's the opposite extreme from the 1 raters. I'm thinking a 7 to season one's 9 personally so far. |
| I think people should just calm down a bit and wait for more,tbh it's not that bad really, i feel like J.C actually puts some efforts compared to Index 3... sigh people... |
Sasori_Nagashi said: Anime_Biscuit said: If I remember it correctly the trailer showed off footage only from episode 1. So what you saw in that trailer you saw in ep 1. Which wasnt so bad in the end. It may get better or worse. It's still too early to tell. But at least try to enjoy opm for opm. NNot just as an action anime. Perhaps they had time to touch it up quite a bit from the trailer version then, because there was some really jarring things in that trailer lol. Either way it's still quite a bit worse than Season 1 and I just can't stand people making excuses that "animation doesn't matter" as it's the opposite extreme from the 1 raters. I'm thinking a 7 to season one's 9 personally so far. We will have to see if that score rises as the season goes on. I have faith that it will since one punch man is just so fun. I really liked the first ep tho |
|
| Still higher than what I gave S1 |
  |
Arkab said: Proving once again what are the top priorities of modern anime fans: visual quality and number of pixels in the image. Yeah, God forbid people care about animation in an ANIME... |
 |
| Both season's are still crap compared to the manga's art quality. Hopefully S2 at least does Garou some justice with his key moments. |
 |
| It was to be expected. |
 |
| Thread locked for not encouraging discussion. Threads about scores just encourage flame wars between people who like the show and people who dislike it. They don't promote any kind of actual discussion. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Punch Man 2nd Season Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jul 2, 2019 |
389 |
by THEBIGNOODLER
»»
Apr 10, 2:30 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man 2nd Season Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )xShinigami3125 - Jun 25, 2019 |
200 |
by Craneface
»»
Mar 28, 2:52 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man 2nd Season Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )xShinigami3125 - May 7, 2019 |
244 |
by scorpioniclibra
»»
Mar 14, 3:26 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man 2nd Season Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )xShinigami3125 - Apr 23, 2019 |
367 |
by Dr_tardo
»»
Feb 21, 6:24 PM |
|
» Bro deadass nearly diedMei-o_Scarlett - Jan 17 |
3 |
by Mei-o_Scarlett
»»
Jan 17, 3:07 AM |