Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
Feb 11, 2019 11:12 AM
Offline
Joined: Sep 2016
Posts: 499
Mattinator95 said:
I read like the first few chapters of the first vol and can already tell that anime has done a shit job at adating and portraying it . Well that madhouse for you . I think deen would have been a better choice as they adapt monogatri pretty great

Monogatari is adapted by Shaft (which is also not perfect....reference to how badly they handled fate/extra)

Deen...hell no. That studio actively tried to ruin fate/stay night and ruined umineko
At least rakugo got a good team behind it. Madhouse is doing a trash job but anything but deen :(
1.1.Six
 
Feb 11, 2019 12:10 PM
Offline
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 2642
JudoJD said:
Mattinator95 said:
I read like the first few chapters of the first vol and can already tell that anime has done a shit job at adating and portraying it . Well that madhouse for you . I think deen would have been a better choice as they adapt monogatri pretty great

Monogatari is adapted by Shaft (which is also not perfect....reference to how badly they handled fate/extra)

Deen...hell no. That studio actively tried to ruin fate/stay night and ruined umineko
At least rakugo got a good team behind it. Madhouse is doing a trash job but anything but deen :(



Ahh shaft right for some reason I thought it was deen.

It's not really shafts fault with fate extra that series was a anime original mess based on a video game thats all down to the fate writer
 
Feb 11, 2019 2:02 PM
Offline
Joined: Sep 2016
Posts: 499
Mattinator95 said:
JudoJD said:

Monogatari is adapted by Shaft (which is also not perfect....reference to how badly they handled fate/extra)

Deen...hell no. That studio actively tried to ruin fate/stay night and ruined umineko
At least rakugo got a good team behind it. Madhouse is doing a trash job but anything but deen :(



Ahh shaft right for some reason I thought it was deen.

It's not really shafts fault with fate extra that series was a anime original mess based on a video game thats all down to the fate writer

1. It wasn't a game adaptation...its ctually anime original...I wish it was (that could have been better...that story's good)
2. It's already come out they cut out a lot of his ideas but he's playing nice as much as he let it slip out at times.
3. The garbage execution Shaft gave it...some of the animation was just cringe and the copy paste bland lazy attempt at monogatari-nizing it was pathetic because God forbid they actually put some thought into a series individual aesthetic.

the same thing should have been given to ufotable cause the guys working there at least show they care about the source material, being fans of it. For Shaft it was just a throwaway project they thought they could get away with.
Wish ufotable picks up boogiepop, fate/extra and umineko some day...they deserve better

(we won't go into mekakucity actors)
Modified by JudoJD, Feb 11, 2019 2:17 PM
1.1.Six
 
Feb 11, 2019 2:21 PM
Offline
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 2642
JudoJD said:
Mattinator95 said:



Ahh shaft right for some reason I thought it was deen.

It's not really shafts fault with fate extra that series was a anime original mess based on a video game thats all down to the fate writer

1. It wasn't a game adaptation...I wish it was (that could have been better...that stpry's good)
2. It's already come out they cut out a lot of his ideas but his being nice as much as he lets it slip out at times
3. The garbage execution Shaft gave it...some of the animation was just cringe and the copy paste bland lazy attempt at monogatari-nizing it was pathetic

the same thing should have been given to ufotable cause the guys working there at least show they care about the source material, being fans of it. For Shaft it was just a throwaway project they thought they could get away with.
Wish ufotable picks up boogiepop, fate/extra and umineko some day...they deserve better

(we won't go into mekakucity actors)



I didn't say it was a game adaption I said it was a anime original mess BASED on a video game which it was. It was supposed to be "friendly" to people who hadn't played the game before but it wasn't it was more confusing then boogiepop is
 
Feb 11, 2019 8:10 PM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 247
I guess some people are just not really paying attention? Like, in watching all of these you really have to be focused on the events for you to follow the timeline of this. And when you get confused on a part, the following event would be spoon feeding you the answer. :o
 
Top
Pages (2) « 1 [2]