So, I decided to do a research in order to fully grasp what's going on in the series.
(THAT WAS A LIE! this man only wanted an excuse to reread the manga)
To acomplish that, I collected all the results of each chapter and summed them to see the ranking within the series. Even if it is not that accurate (because, for example, we had 4 "Everyone but Kaguya wins" and I'm prettty sure Iino was in the Council on one of them, but I decided not to count it for her), we can see the overall that has no significance whatsoever.
The "+number" are results I would add. Results like "Japonese School wins" and "Red Team wins" I added acordingly. And without further ado.
Shirogane - 28 Wins +4 / 20 Losses +4
Kaguya - 19 Wins +2 / 16 Losses +4 / 1 Looking for everyone
Fujiwara - 13 Wins / 7 Losses +1
Ishigami - 8 Wins +1 / 5 Losses +1
Iino - 4 Wins +1 / 5 Losses
Hayasaka - 3 Wins +1 / 2 Losses (I think she was on the red team...)
Tsundere-senpai - 3 Wins +1 (knowing her luck she was not on the red team)
Osaragi - 3 Wins +1
Kashiwagi - 2 Wins +1 /1 Surrender / 1 Loss (was she on the red team? I couldn't tell)
Kei-chan - 1 Win +1 / 1 Loss
Draw - 4
Undecided - 1
Pass - 1
N/A - 4
No score - 33
Cat ears bans - 2
Mutual victory I
Both win I (bonus)
Both lose IV + cruel defeat (+2 on my book)
Shirogane wins XIII
Shirogane loses X
Kaguya wins XI
Flying Ace Kaguya victory I
Kaguya loses VIII
Fujiwara wins IV
Fujiwara loses II
Fujiwara Defeat I
Kashiwagi victory I
Kashiwagi surrender I
Kashiwagi loss I
Iino victory I
Iino loss II
Hayasaka victory I
Hayasaka loss II
Maki Shijo Victory II
Ishigami loses I
Kei Shirogane loss I
Osaragi victory I
Shirogane and Fujiwara win II (she raised that boy well)
Fujiwara and Shirogane loss I
Kaguya and Shirogane victory II
Kaguya and Shirogane Loss II
Shirogane and Iino Victory I
Ishigami and Iino loss I
Everyone but Fujiwara Victory I
Everyone victory except Kaguya IV
Shirogane, Ishigami and Fujiwara Loss and Iino Loss I
Iino, Fujiwara and Ishigami loss I (it felt like Shirogane lost too, but, whatever)
Shirogane Party Victory I
Red Team great victory I
Japonese school wins I
Student Council loss I
Undecided I
Pass I (Shirogane win on my book ch8)
Tie II
Draw II
N/A IV
Failure I (35)
Lose-Lose I
Artistic lincense only goes so far I
No confession I (Kaguya loss)
Ishigami did not get his alone time I (Yuu-kun loss)
Avoided a Bloodbath I (everyone but Fujiwara wins)
Result of today's Kaguya: she is looking for everyone I (65)
Negociations result: Failed I (not used)
Bellmark contest: 1º Shirogane (Shirogane +1)
Editor's note: their plan never came to fruition (hence table-top gaming club loses therefore everyone at the festival victory)
Screw you Shueisha I (bonus)
Cat ears bans II
That are a lot of "no score/to be continued" that we could add to the according continuation, since most of them are from story arcs, but I refrained from doing that, at least for now.
So, should we keep updating it? What are your thoughts?