| well, amazing article but again i feel that lacked content there are so many other things you could've talked new and amazing world of one piece the morality and destruction in the world of HUNTERxHUNTER the importance of heroes and villains in BNHA and so so so much more.... but hey, at least you talked about Haikyuu if a great show like that gets the attention it deserves i'll be happy |
HILrebellion said: well, amazing article but again i feel that lacked content there are so many other things you could've talked new and amazing world of one piece the morality and destruction in the world of HUNTERxHUNTER the importance of heroes and villains in BNHA and so so so much more.... but hey, at least you talked about Haikyuu if a great show like that gets the attention it deserves i'll be happy One does not simply talk about every single anime that exists in under 2000 words. |
HILrebellion said: well, amazing article but again i feel that lacked content there are so many other things you could've talked new and amazing world of one piece the morality and destruction in the world of HUNTERxHUNTER the importance of heroes and villains in BNHA and so so so much more.... but hey, at least you talked about Haikyuu if a great show like that gets the attention it deserves i'll be happy These nitpicks seem to be about the examples rather than the content of the article itself... |
 |
| @Shymander @Skittles i'm in no way telling it's a bad thing to not talk about the series i've mention the only thing i wanna convey is that why talk about an inferior series with bad examples when you can talk about a superior one with better examples. he completely ignores the shonen-battle genre talking about isekai and sports i agree the comparison between code geass and guilty crown was good. but why stop there, he could've drawn comparison between attack on titan and kabenari, one piece, hunterxhunter, bnha, even god-damned Naruto has more to talk about tan the series he has mentioned |
| @HILrebellion Looking at shounen anime would be a viable option, as would a number of other anime and genres of equal value, but once again you can very rarely talk about every possible example in an article. The identification of what's superior and inferior and comparing them to highlight the superiority of one over the other is a far more effective method than just listing superior examples. It allows for the reader to expand their understanding of where and how worldbuilding is done well and how it isn't, rather than just where it's done well. @Skittles Sweet forum set, bro <3 |
| Well It is a fine article. Although I think it would have been better if you went a bit more in depth with the examples. I here have yet another example of bad world building: Chivalry of a Failed knight has a huge one. The whole series is about Magical knights but they never explained the magic nor what Role Magical Knights play in Society. So the worldbuilding is there is missing 2 basic needs for world building. Something that Naruto, Bleach and One Piece just Nailed it. |
| @Bourmegar that's exactly what i meant he took up weak examples when there are more flourishing one's like naruto, one piece, aot, hxh |
HILrebellion said: @Bourmegar that's exactly what i meant he took up weak examples when there are more flourishing one's like naruto, one piece, aot, hxh Bourmegar said: Ya’ know, here’s the thing:Well It is a fine article. Although I think it would have been better if you went a bit more in depth with the examples. I here have yet another example of bad world building: Chivalry of a Failed knight has a huge one. The whole series is about Magical knights but they never explained the magic nor what Role Magical Knights play in Society. So the worldbuilding is there is missing 2 basic needs for world building. Something that Naruto, Bleach and One Piece just Nailed it. Idc if the anime I choose to write about, of which are all in the top 100 most popular series on mal, don’t fly with every single person on mal. What I did wasn’t gush about shows. I decided what the keys are to good world building in anime, and I chose one good show and one bad show to illustrate that point. If you’d rather me write an article called “The Amazing Worlds of Shounen Anime” (Like seriously, an article about HxH, Natuto, Bleach, One Piece and AoT is just an article about shounen), well too bad, cuz idc about most of those shows. Code Geass, Guilty Crown, Log Horizon and Haikyuu are all shows I have strong feelings for, positive or negative. Besides, who in the anime community at all needs an article to draw attention to those shows? P.S. My examples are better than those examples anyway imo 🤷♂️ |
ParkyouMay 9, 2018 9:28 AM
Parkyou said: HILrebellion said: @Bourmegar that's exactly what i meant he took up weak examples when there are more flourishing one's like naruto, one piece, aot, hxh Bourmegar said: Ya’ know, here’s the thing:Well It is a fine article. Although I think it would have been better if you went a bit more in depth with the examples. I here have yet another example of bad world building: Chivalry of a Failed knight has a huge one. The whole series is about Magical knights but they never explained the magic nor what Role Magical Knights play in Society. So the worldbuilding is there is missing 2 basic needs for world building. Something that Naruto, Bleach and One Piece just Nailed it. Idc if the anime I choose to write about, of which are all in the top 100 most popular series on mal, don’t fly with every single person on mal. What I did wasn’t gush about shows. I decided what the keys are to good world building in anime, and I chose one good show and one bad show to illustrate that point. If you’d rather me write an article called “The Amazing Worlds of Shounen Anime” (Like seriously, an article about HxH, Natuto, Bleach, One Piece and AoT is just an article about shounen), well too bad, cuz idc about most of those shows. Code Geass, Guilty Crown, Log Horizon and Haikyuu are all shows I have strong feelings for, positive or negative. Besides, who in the anime community at all needs an article to draw attention to those shows? P.S. My examples are better than those examples anyway imo 🤷♂️ @HILrebelion ok I believe that I have to clear up something. I was more about going in depth with the Given Examples, like how Haikyuu made you understand the sports more than Yuri on Ice did. NOT ABOUT WHICH SERIES GOT MENTIONED BECAUSE THE EXAMPLES WEREN'NT WEAK AT ALL! |
Bourmegar said: I mean, that's literally exactly what I said. Nothing to go "more in depth" with.Parkyou said: Ya’ know, here’s the thing: Idc if the anime I choose to write about, of which are all in the top 100 most popular series on mal, don’t fly with every single person on mal. What I did wasn’t gush about shows. I decided what the keys are to good world building in anime, and I chose one good show and one bad show to illustrate that point. If you’d rather me write an article called “The Amazing Worlds of Shounen Anime” (Like seriously, an article about HxH, Natuto, Bleach, One Piece and AoT is just an article about shounen), well too bad, cuz idc about most of those shows. Code Geass, Guilty Crown, Log Horizon and Haikyuu are all shows I have strong feelings for, positive or negative. Besides, who in the anime community at all needs an article to draw attention to those shows? P.S. My examples are better than those examples anyway imo 🤷♂️ @HILrebelion ok I believe that I have to clear up something. I was more about going in depth with the Given Examples, like how Haikyuu made you understand the sports more than Yuri on Ice did. NOT ABOUT WHICH SERIES GOT MENTIONED BECAUSE THE EXAMPLES WEREN'NT WEAK AT ALL! |
| Great article :) i agree that worldbuilding is very important in anime. Speaking about world building, Narita Ryougo and Mamare Touno's works came out in my mind instantly. This article made me realize more the importance of their works' world building. There is also one manga title (Tsukikage Baby) that i only realized why i have been captivated by it. i couldnt answer it before, but after reading this article, now i know. It's the world building. Thanks for the article, it's really enjoyable and educational ~ |
More topics from this board
» Technical Quality vs. Enjoyment: A Strange Discrepancy - Feedback and CommentsMAL_Articles - Mar 1, 2018 |
8 |
by removed-user
»»
May 11, 2022 4:12 PM |
|
» Black, White, and Gray: What Makes an Antihero Work - Feedback and CommentsMAL_Articles - Aug 23, 2018 |
4 |
by utopica
»»
Sep 1, 2021 5:23 PM |
|
» Can an OP Character Be a Good Main Character? - Feedback and CommentsMAL_Articles - Apr 13, 2018 |
11 |
by WaifuMaster17
»»
Mar 8, 2020 12:19 PM |
|
» Why Incest Appears So Often In Anime - Feedback and CommentsMAL_Articles - Jan 21, 2018 |
10 |
by AnchientProphet2
»»
Apr 3, 2019 8:26 AM |
|
» Cowboy Bebop: Meaning Behind the Madness - Feedback and CommentsMAL_Articles - May 14, 2018 |
2 |
by TomDay
»»
Sep 14, 2018 6:25 PM |