Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (8) « 1 [2] 3 4 » ... Last »
Jan 24, 2018 5:46 PM

Offline
Mar 2012
128
The scene where he reads the letter was just too good. The music was so right on for it.
Jan 24, 2018 5:46 PM

Offline
Jun 2017
532
this is the first sign of promise this show has shown so far

perhaps it will be worth the watch

...Ah but the only thing that bothered me was that she was able to graduate with just that little bit. That letter showed her potential to, rather than the proficiency to capture feelings, so it's kind of weird that was all it took.
Snot-nosed_BratJan 24, 2018 5:50 PM
Jan 24, 2018 6:04 PM
Offline
Nov 2017
1102
Good episode for sure. It's a good first step, and I wonder what happens next, if she will become known for short letters. But that scene at night with the brother was touching af.
Jan 24, 2018 6:09 PM

Offline
Oct 2014
673
I'm really enjoying this so far.

Violet finally learned how to convey emotion thanks to Luculia. It was interesting seeing her story and how it compared to Violet's. She's had a tough life so I'm not surprised she has so much emotion to contemplate. I hope going forward Violet will continue to grow from those few lines she managed to get down in her best letter yet.

I feel like this show has been moving pretty quickly despite each episode taking place over a short period of time. Kyoani really stuffed in as much detail as they could. And it shows too because so far it has been very engaging to watch.
Jan 24, 2018 6:13 PM
Offline
Jan 2018
18
I think this is the best episode yet the other two were pretty boring and bland mostly but this one was decent hopefully it keeps getting better from here i feel like they finally went somewhere with this episode instead of just giving eachother bleak angsty looks for 30 mins
Jan 24, 2018 6:14 PM

Offline
Jul 2016
420
I quite enjoyed this episode. Slow buildup, satisfying conclusions. Amazing side characters. It's so much better than that other show...

I'm slowly feeling the hype.

Jan 24, 2018 6:26 PM

Offline
Aug 2017
11947
Another filler episode. Every character besides the fillers and Violet are the only worth of watching. 2/5
NurguburuJan 29, 2018 2:25 PM
BANZAI NIPPON. Nippon is the Land of freedom. Nippon is the Land of Peace. Nippon is the Land of Justice and Prosperity.

In Nippon, we trust.

We love Nippon, we love Anime. Anime love us, Nippon love us. 日本
Jan 24, 2018 6:34 PM
News Team
YEEHAW

Offline
Nov 2014
9998
Lmao.. graduating just like that. thats pretty bullshit.

Also, the OP song is nice but goddamn the visuals are disappointing.
Jan 24, 2018 6:37 PM

Offline
Oct 2017
66
I really like this episode seeing violet taking her first step to learn human emotions and feelings. Yea, it is different than the novel but it doesn't necessarily means it is bad it might be different than the original novel but I am welcome to learn more about the new side characters stories which also connected to Violet development. The story is simple, everyone can understand what the episode wanna deliver and more details on the Background of Violet Evergarden. It's pretty much like the after wartimes of WW1 tho
Overall, the music is well on point and the OP is nicely done! it really fits into the anime


The point is not about the graduate for writing one good letter, but violet taking her first step learning human emotions, she said she taking the first step and "May you be an exemplary doll"
KonnoYuukiSenpaiJan 24, 2018 6:41 PM

“It's okay to live, even if there's no greater point to living. -” Konno Yuuki

“God would never put us through all this suffering if he didn't think we could bear it.” -Konno Yuuki

“Life is not a game of luck. If you wanna win, work hard.” – Sora

Jan 24, 2018 7:09 PM

Offline
Oct 2017
2755
A good episode, but my criticism being this school lacks professionalism lolz..

Like one decent letter gets a graduation XD...
And previous episode no-one check the letter's contents before sending lolz..
Seriously, those dolls should all get fired .
Jan 24, 2018 7:10 PM

Offline
Oct 2017
2755
SalmonSandwich said:
Another lovely episode.

Really like how Kyoto Animation is fleshing out not only Violet's beginning but also the world itself these past 3 episodes. Really enjoyed the side character story and how it explored the life for veterans of the war outside of Violet herself since the novel didn't really cover that. The school for the auto memory dolls was a nice addition as well.

However i'm really struggling with the direction they are doing with this adaptation versus what they had in the novel. At this point it really is a re-imagining rather then a faithful adaptation which honestly I don't actually have a problem with that aspect! However the problem I have is the pacing...

The novels greatest strength and weakness is that it keeps everything concise and simple but at the detriment of losing out on world building. So Kyoto Animation changing the story is actually a welcome addition, but i'm worried it would be at the cost of losing out on some spectacular episodic stories later down the line because they were fleshing out Violet's beginnings. The pacing is super slow, like it feels like a 2-cour pacing, but at the same time since its a 1-cour everything feels rushed by the end and we don't get a satisfying narrative conclusion.

Overall I'll have to wait and see how the adaptation turns out, i'm enjoying the changes but worried about the direction TLDR.

Also super bare bone and boring opening. Really did not expect such an empty opening. I expected a slow paced opening after listening to the song previously but wow really bare bone...


Can you specify so far up to ep3, what're the difference?
Really curious though. Haven't read the novel.
Jan 24, 2018 7:27 PM
Offline
Mar 2015
13996
Did you ever stop to think that this is an antiwar show? This last episode showed in great detail what happens to the survivors of the war Those who fought and the families of those who fought were all hurt.
It had nothing to do with writing a letter. It had to do with Violet learning to understand how to feel. She was trained to be a weapon. The major developed feelings for her even though she was just a weapon.
Now that the major is gone she is trying to understand the feelings that the major had for her In other words, she is trying to learn what it means to be human
Jan 24, 2018 7:36 PM
Offline
May 2016
2
Liked the episode, its a build up to what violet would become in the first volume of the novel.
Still, i would preferred if the pacing is a little faster so we get to see the clients in the novel, because thats where the hard-hitting tearjerking part is.
I mean we already at 3/14 episodes, only 11 more episodes left to cover two books.
It will be sad if they have to cut out content for time...
Any readers of the novel in this forums?
sakerterJan 24, 2018 7:40 PM
Jan 24, 2018 7:51 PM

Offline
Jul 2015
5112
The OP is pretty ehh tbh.

I would call this episode a step up from the very underwhelming first two, but I really don't get how Violet passed those studies after writing one short message... which honestly still felt off considering her "quality" so far, I would have rather seen her fail and improve outside of that.

The story this episode was still pretty good tho, I hope it's a step in the right direction.
Jan 24, 2018 7:51 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
433
Great episode. The OST helped the emotional climax immensely. As I predicted, this series will be a bunch of short stories that Violet encounters which will slowly teach her about feelings/emotions.

Also, am I the only one bugged by the back of Violet's dress? It's like her dress is stuck on her panties after bathroom.
Jan 24, 2018 8:19 PM

Offline
Jun 2014
523
Lelouch0202 said:
Definitely the best episode till date.

I took a real liking to Luculia, I hope she's a recurring character.

The part where Violet gives Luculia's brother her ghostwritten letter made me tear up, that was a really well done scene.

Violet is finally beginning to understand the human heart. :)

The final scene with Luculia helping her brother back to place with the scenic view was great and congratulations to Violet for graduating.
It's often the simplest and most straightforward words that have the most powerful resonance within people. :)


I agree with you 100%!

Maybe its because I never read the novel this is based on, but I am loving this anime! I think the story telling is very good and we are seeing Violet develop from an emotionless, almost robotic-like soldier into possibly becoming more human. She is actually learning to understand what human emotions are.
So glad that I'm not a huge manga reader, because the manga readers WHINE WAY TOO MUCH and have to RUIN every adapted anime for the ANIME ONLY WATCHERS!
Jan 24, 2018 8:31 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
23091
1idd0kun said:
RobertBobert said:
Lol, never thought that they would add a redhead Reina, to create a little bit of yuri :D. But if seriously, I enjoyed this episode, especially thanks to the development of Violet and her interaction with new characters.


This. Some novel readers will complain that's different from the novel but I think the anime needed to show how Violet starts becoming more emphatic to the people around her, and this episode managed to do just that and did it pretty well.


Well, I did not read the original novel, but I was told that adaptation basically broadens it, and does not distort or change it.
Jan 24, 2018 8:46 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
3522
There ya go Violet! She's starting to somewhat understand human emotions, will she ever feel them herself? Probably not. But can she convey someone else's feelings? Kind of lol
“I love heroes, but I don't want to be one. Do you even know what a hero is!? For example, you have some meat. Pirates will feast on the meat, but the hero will distribute it among the people! I want to eat the meat!” - Monkey D. Luffy
Jan 24, 2018 10:25 PM

Offline
Apr 2016
18822
When the anime original site story filled with anime original characters is better than the first two episodes, im starting to think that LN is bad. Like really bad.
Jan 24, 2018 10:26 PM
Offline
Dec 2016
61
i really like this episode. better than episode 2 only slightly
Jan 24, 2018 10:33 PM
Offline
Dec 2016
61
RezKun10 said:
I'm only here for the art & animation, the story is too boring for my taste.


lol for your taste, a nice way to convey it
Jan 24, 2018 10:46 PM
Offline
Jul 2009
783
Swagernator said:
When the anime original site story filled with anime original characters is better than the first two episodes, im starting to think that LN is bad. Like really bad.


Episode 2 was mostly anime original too, you know?

Anyway, the novel isn't anything groundbreaking. It's a nice little drama. One thing about the novel is that it starts when Violet is already working as a Doll. The anime staff probably felt they needed to dedicate a few episodes to show how the fuck she managed to become a somewhat competent Doll to begin with. This episode did just that.
1idd0kunJan 24, 2018 10:52 PM
Jan 24, 2018 10:48 PM

Offline
Aug 2017
11947
Also the whole school thing makes little sense. Was this literally a two day class? WTF!!?
BANZAI NIPPON. Nippon is the Land of freedom. Nippon is the Land of Peace. Nippon is the Land of Justice and Prosperity.

In Nippon, we trust.

We love Nippon, we love Anime. Anime love us, Nippon love us. 日本
Jan 24, 2018 10:52 PM
Offline
Jul 2009
783
Burguburu said:
Also the whole school thing makes little sense. Was this literally a two day class? WTF!!?


Nah, they just time skip it most of it since it was just a backdrop for Luculia and Violet's interaction.
Jan 24, 2018 11:08 PM

Offline
Aug 2017
11947
DatRandomDude said:
Lmao.. graduating just like that. thats pretty bullshit.

Also, the OP song is nice but goddamn the visuals are disappointing.


Yeah, that part was bad.
BANZAI NIPPON. Nippon is the Land of freedom. Nippon is the Land of Peace. Nippon is the Land of Justice and Prosperity.

In Nippon, we trust.

We love Nippon, we love Anime. Anime love us, Nippon love us. 日本
Jan 24, 2018 11:20 PM

Offline
Mar 2016
401
Jan 24, 2018 11:22 PM

Offline
Jan 2008
1771
I'm just sitting here wondering...who was that student with brunette hair with the single-braid, wearing green sitting in the far back corner desk, or rather--why did they put so much emphasis on her reaction? My first guess was she was related to the instructor since they both had very high cheekbones, like she was her daughter or something. Or maybe this is supposed to be setting something up for a future episode where she'll take the focus like Luculia in this episode. Or maybe she was just a one-off noname character who got nervous at the the instructor's strict demeanor, I don't know. At the very least, it looks like she graduated the class as well, so I doubt there will be any drama brewing there. I hate it when little things like this make me overthink mysel, as it's still nagging at me in the end.
Jan 24, 2018 11:38 PM

Offline
May 2015
10936
Oooh, True is singing the OP. Good choice!

200 characters per minute...so around 40 words per minute, the average typing speed. We're taking keyboarding class!

LMAO! That letter! Violet is such a soldier!

Well it looks like Violet figured out a way to express one's feelings in ghostwriting: keeping it short, sweet, and to the point. And she can start learning more from there. I'm guessing that the peak of the story is when Violet finally writes a full-fledged letter of her feelings. That'll be worth watching.

Wait...uhh...so how many classes does an AMD need to take to graduate? All they had to do was write one good letter? And why are all the AMDs female? That's racist. *DING!*
Jan 25, 2018 12:09 AM

Offline
Mar 2011
2731
I really enjoyed watching this episode to be honest. The scene where Violet gave the letter from Luculia to her brother was great.
Jan 25, 2018 12:45 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
562056
Heartwarming episode. The brother of Luculia finally realized that he was the important person for her sister. While Violet, didn't pass the challenge at first, but she gave her best at last after writing a letter. Writing a letter shouldn't have flowering words sometimes, little things could also be impactful. This was somewhat likeable but there's something that I do not like about this anime, I cannot explain it.
Jan 25, 2018 1:39 AM
Offline
Oct 2015
603
Since I haven't read the original source material I have no idea how long Violet was supposed to be in school but this was much shorter then I anticipated I was around expecting 1.5-2 episodes.
Heckle was here...
Jan 25, 2018 2:06 AM
Offline
Jan 2018
2
If you do not expect anything you will not be disappointed.

enjoy the show
Jan 25, 2018 2:07 AM

Offline
Jul 2017
281
The story is still crawling along at a snails pace and Violet still has zero character growth.

When she wrote the letter to Luculia's brother she invented a new technique. Instead of taking vague words and finding the right way to type them she made Luculia breakdown and made her tell Violet exactly what she wanted to say. So more like a therapy session than a letter writing session.

Luculia had a more compelling story and growth in this one episode than Violet has had in 3!
Jan 25, 2018 2:08 AM

Offline
Mar 2013
315
TheHeckle said:
Since I haven't read the original source material I have no idea how long Violet was supposed to be in school but this was much shorter then I anticipated I was around expecting 1.5-2 episodes.


Ventus_S said:
SalmonSandwich said:
Another lovely episode.
Really like how Kyoto Animation is fleshing out not only Violet's beginning but also the world itself these past 3 episodes. Really enjoyed the side character story and how it explored the life for veterans of the war outside of Violet herself since the novel didn't really cover that. The school for the auto memory dolls was a nice addition as well.

However i'm really struggling with the direction they are doing with this adaptation versus what they had in the novel. At this point it really is a re-imagining rather then a faithful adaptation which honestly I don't actually have a problem with that aspect! However the problem I have is the pacing...

The novels greatest strength and weakness is that it keeps everything concise and simple but at the detriment of losing out on world building. So Kyoto Animation changing the story is actually a welcome addition, but i'm worried it would be at the cost of losing out on some spectacular episodic stories later down the line because they were fleshing out Violet's beginnings. The pacing is super slow, like it feels like a 2-cour pacing, but at the same time since its a 1-cour everything feels rushed by the end and we don't get a satisfying narrative conclusion.

Overall I'll have to wait and see how the adaptation turns out, i'm enjoying the changes but worried about the direction TLDR.

Also super bare bone and boring opening. Really did not expect such an empty opening. I expected a slow paced opening after listening to the song previously but wow really bare bone...


Can you specify so far up to ep3, what're the difference?
Really curious though. Haven't read the novel.


Hmmh its really hard to say what was adapted since they are sorta mixing themes and idea with original content. Basically instead of what she did in a certain chapter for example they replace it with an anime original content with a different perspective, and they are switching around the timeline. No spoilers for anything passed this point in the anime but spoilers if you want to read the novel fresh


TLDR: The weird thing is the novel lacks what the anime is strong at, vice versa the anime is weak where the novel is strong.

It really rushes past the world building so Cattelya, Benedict aren't really a character, the postal service has no detail or depth, and the world just falls flat and boring. Where as the anime really goes in depth with everything but at the cost of the main character Violet having a slower development and the story pacing falling. (thats why majority of people just think of her as an kuudere/autistic robot/PTSD Saber). You have to realize in the novel they basically imply and rush past her rehabilitation in becoming a normal human being so when the novel starts with her working already, shes exhibit emotion like embarrassment, happiness, etc. Shes just more subtle about it (think disappearance version of Nagato Yuki.)
SalmonSandwichJan 25, 2018 2:31 AM
Jan 25, 2018 2:33 AM

Offline
Mar 2014
235
Major_Gilbert said:
Kirie-san said:

The novel is short according to me but it has 13 chapters which could have been easily adapted this way: 1 episode = 1 chapter (eventually two episodes for the last chapter of the second volume).
They do have material, it's just that the director s****. Kyoukai no Kanata was one of the worst Kyo Ani anime I've seen and I was afraid for Violet Evergarden anime adaptation when I saw his name. Really, what's wrong with this kind of directors who decide to change things while the source material is good???

You mean that the anime will only adapt the first volume, then there'll be a new season for the second volume?
Maybe they'll do a one-cour anime, then a recap movie and eventually a sequel if they didn't cover the whole novel in the anime... as for Kyoukai no Kanata. What a waste while the anime could have been really good considering the novel...


Man, I couldn't agree more there.


Me, too. I'm REALLY glad Violet Evergarden is NOT like Kyoukai no Kanata, some of my best friends recommended me Kyoukai no Kanata, but when I watched it I thought it is average. Might be because I never really got warm with the main heroine. If I think back, I still don't. I didn't buy her behaviour from her. Felt unauthentic/ unrealistic for me.

To speak for Violet Evergarden, reading the comments I got to be aware that the anime seems to be adapted in a different way. I haven't read the novel yet, but I really like how it is depicted so far and also the pacing of the show.

RebelPanda said:
I'm really enjoying this so far.

Violet finally learned how to convey emotion thanks to Luculia. It was interesting seeing her story and how it compared to Violet's. She's had a tough life so I'm not surprised she has so much emotion to contemplate. I hope going forward Violet will continue to grow from those few lines she managed to get down in her best letter yet.

I feel like this show has been moving pretty quickly despite each episode taking place over a short period of time. Kyoani really stuffed in as much detail as they could. And it shows too because so far it has been very engaging to watch.


Top_Sergeant said:
Excellent episode, watched it twice!

Violet's story continues to progress admirably. The art as always was top notch. The variety of music and instruments used is wonderful: violins for one piece, and then flute and piano for another.

Luculia's simple story was aptly used to prize out more of Violet's story and moved her character development forward. She is not always doing things exactly the way she was told to do them (removing her gloves) and is moving beyond the literal interpretation of her world and doing so in a way that cuts to the soul of the issue (very Violet) but still evokes the heart (her letter to Luculia's brother).


I also think, that Violet shows some character development, after all, she's trying to understand more what lies behind her current capabilities. I also think that having a friend, which Luculia seems to be for me, is a great thing. I know, there are the people from her workplace, who mostly are awesome characters as well, but I think it still makes a difference, if someone is a coworker or not. So far so good, the vibe I get from Violet Evergarden is kinda realistic in a good way. I know may lack in some details, like the letter from the last episode not being proofread, but for this episode, I don't mind her passing the auto memoir doll school. After all, she was one of the best with her skills, besides her understanding, but know she even shows signs that she starts to understand more and more. She didn't even try to write everything Luculia said. No, she tried to get what might be core of what has been said. And as we see at the end of the episode, she really helped out Luculia and her brother. I wouldn't mind to see Luculia again in the future, but I'm not sure if that'll happen as so many said, that the source material has been very episodic.

Major_Gilbert said:
Blarey said:
Okay, now we’re getting somewhere. Nice drama this episode.

I haven’t read the novel, but you guys know this isn’t an adventure anime right? This is a drama made by KyoAni, which means that we should all know pretty much what to expect.. If you aren’t liking it so far, I’m not sure exactly what you’re waiting for...


What we call "adventures" are separate stories where Violet goes to the customer's location and writes letters for him/her. Of course, most of them have emotional endings. That's where the drama comes from.


As it is for now, I really like the pacing and the development in Violet Evergarden. Yes, I haven't read the novel yet, but I'm really interested to see in which direction this is going. Although, wait... I think I'll wait until the anime has come to further development. I know the adventures of going to customers and writing for them, might be truly heart-touching stories, but I'd rather see the development of Violet and what lies behind her story, for example what's going to be with the major, how it works out for Violet etc. For now, the proportion between being an episodic anime and telling the whole story has been met really well. I get the feeling that the story is progressing, but it is also very convenient to watch on a weekly basis. That's usually not that easy to achieve.

Hibikase said:
Emotionally powerful and resonating. I feel like every episode in this show thus far has moments that make me want to tear up. I wonder what first-time binging this series would feel like after it all finishes airing.

I also have no problem with the episodic nature, as long as the characters are strong enough to carry it, and this show has no problems in that department for me.

Best OP song of the season, just hoped the beautiful visuals were a bit more... animated? (ironic considering this is the most well-animated shows of the season). I also really adore the ED's visual direction.

I feel like every emotion depicted in this series so far and genuinely felt by me is well earned. It's not overly melodramatic just for the sake of being some sort of cry porn (like Anohana and parts of Clannad), not that I dislike those type of shows, but this one is just... more grounded in its drama?

Although some may disagree with me, I think the way this show approaches its issues and its characters is very realistic, and oddly "mature" for anime standards (take that what you will, and please don't misinterpret what I am saying as I don't think shows that don't have mature themes are automatically bad)

Another thing that I felt this show does really well is how much it treats its characters with respect and consistency. Think about an anime in recently memory that didn't treat a "larger" side character as a NEET, a loser, or a creeper/pervert (other 3-gatsu/Shirobako). It is actually pretty refreshing.


I also get a very "grounded" feeling off this show. I haven't seen a series, which convinced me that much from the very first episode on. The love seems to be in the detail like the world, the characters, the animation, the music and also the pacing. It never felt off for me, but I don't mind good slow paced shows, so I guess I'm not the one to speak up here. xD Something which seems t me important is also how the world is bild up and if there is a consistency in it's characters interaction with the world itself. It feels natural, not out of the ordinary for this world. And it's so great to finally see a show again, which is not set in a fantasy background. Don't get me wrong, i'ts not as if I don't like fantasy shows, but it is so much more relatable to get such a setting. :3

landofthekwt said:
Did you ever stop to think that this is an antiwar show? This last episode showed in great detail what happens to the survivors of the war Those who fought and the families of those who fought were all hurt.
It had nothing to do with writing a letter. It had to do with Violet learning to understand how to feel. She was trained to be a weapon. The major developed feelings for her even though she was just a weapon.
Now that the major is gone she is trying to understand the feelings that the major had for her In other words, she is trying to learn what it means to be human


I agree with you on that point, I also get similar vibes, which I usually get from stories that are set during the war and tell stories about this time. It shows so many aspects of the war, while we haven't seen that many scenes of the war itself. Another thing is the "major is gone" topic, I kinda get the feeling that there is more to come about or with the major. Not sure, if he really is dead. But even this uncertainity suits this show well.

4kicks said:
I'm just sitting here wondering...who was that student with brunette hair with the single-braid, wearing green sitting in the far back corner desk, or rather--why did they put so much emphasis on her reaction? My first guess was she was related to the instructor since they both had very high cheekbones, like she was her daughter or something. Or maybe this is supposed to be setting something up for a future episode where she'll take the focus like Luculia in this episode. Or maybe she was just a one-off noname character who got nervous at the the instructor's strict demeanor, I don't know. At the very least, it looks like she graduated the class as well, so I doubt there will be any drama brewing there. I hate it when little things like this make me overthink mysel, as it's still nagging at me in the end.


Oh! I didn't see that! Need to watch that scene again and look if I get what you mean. :) Not sure, if you overthink this indeed, but I'll come back to you about it. As it is for now, I get the feeling that the more I watch/rewatch the individual episodes I get to be aware of other aspects of this show. Violet Evergarden truly is enjoyable, even after already having watched the episode.

...

So, now I watched the scende again you told us about and I agree with you that might be some foreshadowing we see there! While watching the episode, I was also stucked on that thought for a moment, but tho be honest I totally forgot about her after that, because of the development taken during the episode.

I also think that we will see her again at a later point. But about the drama part... I'm not so sure bout that. She either seems to be a rather poor person or one who has to fight and struggles with some things in life. So, I don't think it will just be a happy welcome back as soon as we see her again. Not sure if she's somehow related to the instructor, though. She was only shown twice (It think), but got some impact during the short sequences. At first the emphasis on her reaction and second the being "centered" during the scene of the graduation.

But I'm not sure, if you should think even more into it for now, because it might be that we won't see her for a while, because of the partly episodic storytelling in Violet Evergarden. Oh my, I love it when shows do such fine foreshadowing! *__*)/ <3
FlueckliJan 25, 2018 3:23 AM
Jan 25, 2018 3:08 AM
Offline
May 2017
39
I didn't read the novel so my opinion is only based on the adaptation.

I think a slow start is not that bad like most of you seem to think. For the first 3 episodes, I can sense that Violet is actually improving and start to understand people more (I really don't think she could write a letter like that one 2 episodes ago). But I do agree that they need to speed up the pace knowing that there's only 14 episodes (I think) and it can end really fast if they don't. Now that she graduated, let's see if they install a more interesting plot, but I'm not disappointed so far.

PS : The relationship between Benedict and Cattleya is gold xD

Jan 25, 2018 3:17 AM
Offline
Jan 2018
58
OK, so the episode 3 has come out.
First because i have to admit that before the anime air i had a very high expectation, they made the PV beautifully. they did not give a lot of information tough, so in my conclusion their very beautiful song and graphics in the pv is what make people(including me) ver high expectation, and lot of people declared that it's th best anime, the most beautiful anime, it can defeat FMAB and lalalalala.... but in the first episodeit was like someone spray a water to my torch. my expectation went down a lot(STILL DON'T HATE THE ANIME). almost 70% of what i tough about VE are wrong. But we must not hate it because we had an overly high expetation(still wondering where the score 8.58 come from to).. wellll....... about episode 3 i think it went way better than previous 2 episode, in episode 1 it was like telling that everything that i though was wrong, in episode 2 it made me almost hate violet if not because i know about her past. in episode 3 they make a lot of improvement. violet characteristic has improved a bit. her skill is improved a bit, make my (almost) hatred frome episode 2 disappear. it shows several emotional moment, but still it is not violet who has them(i think). it shows about how emotional people around her can be, about the atmosphere after the war. so it is better than the previous episodes. but still what (a little bit) annoyed me is my curiousness about what violet wrote in the letters, what make the colonel smiles in the end. because i think eventho luculia's letter has what you call "touching", but comparing what other dolls did, few sentence in the letter should not have been enough for graduiatng the doll school.

so i think i will score this episode 6.9/10 much better than the previous 2.....

Jan 25, 2018 3:19 AM
Offline
Jan 2018
58
D1tchd1gger said:
The story is still crawling along at a snails pace and Violet still has zero character growth.

When she wrote the letter to Luculia's brother she invented a new technique. Instead of taking vague words and finding the right way to type them she made Luculia breakdown and made her tell Violet exactly what she wanted to say. So more like a therapy session than a letter writing session.

Luculia had a more compelling story and growth in this one episode than Violet has had in 3!


i agree with you, but i think violet has a bit improvement
Jan 25, 2018 3:30 AM

Offline
May 2010
8099
Easily the best episode yet. I am starting to get tired of hearing about Major so yeah, it was nice to see Violet moving forward a little.
Jan 25, 2018 3:43 AM

Offline
Dec 2015
722
Baby steps are better than no steps I guess.

Not liking how Luculia spoke about Violet in the end with past tense, hope we see more of her.

Character development is kinda lacking tbh, I'm still not sure what role Benedict is supposed to play in this series + his beef with Cattleya makes things more confusing.
~
Jan 25, 2018 4:26 AM

Offline
Nov 2016
32142
Very emotional episode.

So glad that Violet progressed and made it successful through the course ,but it's also thanks to her good friend Luculia.

Well,in the end both girls helped each other out,liked the friendship and conveying emotions theme.


One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron


Jan 25, 2018 4:45 AM

Offline
May 2009
913
This show is getting better and better. Beautiful.
Jan 25, 2018 4:53 AM

Offline
Jul 2017
26
For those who aren't hooked to this show (I didn't read the discussion for this thread as I just came straight out from finishing the episode), I'll try to share why I love this show.

The reason why (even in just 3 episodes) this show is sold as potential AOTY for me is how the author uses Violet in the story. Sure, a lot would be put off due to her almost inhuman personality, but that is what makes the show shine. By having a 'unlearned' individual deal with emotional situations purely unknown to her allows the author to explore such situations from the perspectives of the people around Violet, and this exploration of situations allows us (the viewers) to ponder about them as well. What would we do in those situations? What could we have advised the characters to act in those situations? How much do we really understand the circumstances at hand? Questions like these have risen all because the author wrote a seemingly emotionless character in a world full of emotions. Violet could may just be a plot device (though I am still thrilled to see her grow as a character), but damn she does her role so well that there is nothing for me to complain about in what could be the next 10/10 in my list. Thanks for reading.
Jan 25, 2018 5:05 AM
Offline
Jul 2016
2
I'm glad Violet has finally showed signs of moving past her retard phase.
Super comfy episode too. Loved the story and Lucuria.
Jan 25, 2018 5:44 AM

Offline
May 2017
948
I haven't read the novel and there are a lot of people complaining about the adaptation but for me I'm loving the anime so far and i hope it gets better also i don't think the animation quality will drop either as it's a Netflix production
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jan 25, 2018 5:50 AM

Offline
Jan 2017
784
have they already shown the OP and ED in the previous episodes, or was this the first time... for some reason it sounds like I've only just heard it; so confuse but i can't be bothered to check the previous episodes.

you know what, everything is just 'right' with this anime; I haven't come across many anime that are able to convey emotion like this one... ooh the 'feels' are class. i was struggling to keep it together.
i like how this sort of unrequited love will actually never happen, yet they go into it so good

(provided the major has actually died and they don't do one of those "she escapes, as the hero's on his dying breath and then at the end of the series he comes back, which is followed by a flashback of some people finding a dying man; they take him to where they reside and do their utmost best to save his life and he couldn't contact anyone whilst recovering, and/or had no way to contact him)

this theory will probably be debunked by those who've read -i guess?- this anime's source
on the other hand, hopefully this major is actually gone -though my heart's against it- and the pain of unrequited love lingers in her heart forevermore.

on a lighter note, i'm shipping Cattleya Baudelaire and Benedict Blue, they got this nice chemistry going on between them XD XD ... oh yeah, that brings me to this:

I've already seen shipments of Violet X Luculia, like what the hell, the fandom's already created a yuri shipment of an anime where the girl is trying to find the meaning of 'I love you' which was said by major Gilbert; a guy whom she obviously has feeling for, and although she cannot comprehend what love is, her demeanour already implies that she has a deeper attachment to him (an attachment similar to love if anything)

P.S.
I've become so self conscious about what i write so it as though I'm having a rant, and the fact that I may actually be writing about something that so many others are already aware of and is common knowledge
Jan 25, 2018 5:56 AM

Offline
Jan 2017
784
What The Fudge... i have just realised that the messages in the violet evergarden episode forums are long AF
(mine included) no, not this one, comment #97... yh that one a bit before this, if not immediately above

lets make it longer,
XDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXD nope cant ar**d

i made a topic prior to this anime's air date that was about the hype surrounding this anime, well it was worth... this anime is bloody amazing
Jan 25, 2018 6:22 AM

Offline
Nov 2013
2722
Shame still can’t enjoying it. Sad character’s background and a very happy ending in the episode was just way too idealistic to my preference.

But still the episode was better than the previous two because the music and irronically the fact Violet emotionless personality doesn't show much.
I'm too weird to live but much too rare to die.


Jan 25, 2018 6:24 AM
Offline
Sep 2017
14
for all people who already read the LN and for some people who think this show boring, i sugest you wait until this series atleast reach 8 or 10 episode and watch all episode at once, i am sure you will get the feeling and start liking this series.
Jan 25, 2018 6:32 AM

Offline
Aug 2016
45
SalmonSandwich said:
Another lovely episode.

Really like how Kyoto Animation is fleshing out not only Violet's beginning but also the world itself these past 3 episodes. Really enjoyed the side character story and how it explored the life for veterans of the war outside of Violet herself since the novel didn't really cover that. The school for the auto memory dolls was a nice addition as well.

However i'm really struggling with the direction they are doing with this adaptation versus what they had in the novel. At this point it really is a re-imagining rather then a faithful adaptation which honestly I don't actually have a problem with that aspect! However the problem I have is the pacing...

The novels greatest strength and weakness is that it keeps everything concise and simple but at the detriment of losing out on world building. So Kyoto Animation changing the story is actually a welcome addition, but i'm worried it would be at the cost of losing out on some spectacular episodic stories later down the line because they were fleshing out Violet's beginnings. The pacing is super slow, like it feels like a 2-cour pacing, but at the same time since its a 1-cour everything feels rushed by the end and we don't get a satisfying narrative conclusion.

Overall I'll have to wait and see how the adaptation turns out, i'm enjoying the changes but worried about the direction TLDR.

Also super bare bone and boring opening. Really did not expect such an empty opening. I expected a slow paced opening after listening to the song previously but wow really bare bone...

That ending was much better than the OP ._.
Pages (8) « 1 [2] 3 4 » ... Last »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Violet Evergarden Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Apr 4, 2018

511 by gamerbaho1 »»
May 9, 12:37 PM

Poll: » Violet Evergarden Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Mar 14, 2018

659 by gamerbaho1 »»
May 8, 7:14 PM

Poll: » Violet Evergarden Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Feb 21, 2018

334 by gamerbaho1 »»
May 8, 4:59 PM

Poll: » Violet Evergarden Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Mar 7, 2018

299 by bordercrosser27 »»
May 4, 3:30 PM

Poll: » Violet Evergarden Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Naruleach - Jul 2, 2017

580 by frievinlatta »»
Apr 29, 2:12 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login