| What do you guys think is the most realistic depiction of bullying an anime has ever had? The topic came to me while watching 3gatsu, and couldn't get out of my head since then. I think 3gatsu's depiction is too idealistic. It does not properly introduce the sense of isolation induced by bullying, or being shunned. A much more realistic - but a bit still on the idealistic side - is the bullying in Koe no Katachi. Although the manga has more time to depict it, the movie does a great job too. You can't help but feel the despair while watching it. So which anime had the most realistic bullying scenes in it, and why do you think so? |
 |
| Every time some primal alpha male MC is doing some shady things to some other male MC. |
 |
| Tsundere beating up the main male character. They only slipped and now they are getting a 100-ton hammer on their head :( |
 πππ«π«π π±π¬π²π π₯ πΆπ¬π², πππ«π±π¦π«' πΆπ¬π² π΄π¦π±π₯ ππ©π© πͺπΆ πͺπ¦π€π₯π± ______________________ |
| I'd also go with 3-gatsu,this multifaceted topic with all it's layers was handled way too good. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
-Lofn- said: Tsundere beating up the main male character. They only slipped and now they are getting a 100-ton hammer on their head :( Well, I don't know whether I'd call that realistic, but I still hate that trope... Right alongside the donkan MC trope. |
|
oryouohagi said: I was joking m8 xD-Lofn- said: Tsundere beating up the main male character. They only slipped and now they are getting a 100-ton hammer on their head :( Well, I don't know whether I'd call that realistic, but I still hate that trope... Right alongside the donkan MC trope. I don't really know, haven't seen much bullying in real life, nor watch news and I haven't watched any anime with bullying aside Koe no Katachi I guess. |
πππ«π«π π±π¬π²π π₯ πΆπ¬π², πππ«π±π¦π«' πΆπ¬π² π΄π¦π±π₯ ππ©π© πͺπΆ πͺπ¦π€π₯π± ______________________ |
| The first act of Koe no Katachi...but usually not the rest. |
 |
Bobby2Hands said: The first act of Koe no Katachi...but usually not the rest. Yes, it gets a lot softer and idealistic after the first part. Swagernator said: Every time some primal alpha male MC is doing some shady things to some other male MC. Yay, I also like yaoi. |
|
oryouohagi said: Yay, I also like yaoi. I don't understand what people can enjoy those forced relationships there. Its just pure bullying. |
|
Swagernator said: oryouohagi said: Yay, I also like yaoi. I don't understand what people can enjoy those forced relationships there. Its just pure bullying. Yay, I don't know either. Never seen a yaoi in my life, but from what I've heard, it's basically rape (uke-seme). |
|
Yeah exactly, the "toy" MC is forced to be in relationship with another male MC against his will. And it's like that in every Yaoi show. Guess people like rape that much. |
|
Swagernator said: oryouohagi said: Yay, I also like yaoi. I don't understand what people can enjoy those forced relationships there. Its just pure bullying. Like every relationship with a tsundere |
 |
tragedydesu said: Like every relationship with a tsundere Oh come on man, like if Rem x Subaru wasn't forced ( Ν‘° ΝΚ Ν‘°) |
|
Swagernator said: tragedydesu said: Like every relationship with a tsundere Oh come on man, like if Rem x Subaru wasn't forced ( Ν‘° ΝΚ Ν‘°) Nope, it wasn't forced, Rem is simply a doormat bereft of a personality or a will. ( Ν‘° ΝΚ Ν‘°) |
|
Swagernator said: tragedydesu said: Like every relationship with a tsundere Oh come on man, like if Rem x Subaru wasn't forced ( Ν‘° ΝΚ Ν‘°) nah it wasn't , she have a good reason to like him @oryouohagi yukinoshita fags .... |
|
| Vivid Strike Jokes aside, I think the bullying in Aku no Hana is kind of realistic, especially the social isolation. There are a couple scenes where other people awkwardly ignore the victim and isolate him, highlighting the mental side of bullying as it isn't always physical. Haven't watched the Koe no Katachi movie so I don't know if it handles anything differently but the manga is probably the most realistic you'll get. |
SignifieJan 14, 2018 9:06 AM
 |
| Koe no Katachi has the most realistic depiction of bullying in anime in my opinion. People tend to laugh at or talk behind the back of disabled people, even if they try to act like they're supportive and kind on the surface. The physical fight between the two main leads when they were children was the most realistic scene of the anime. Though it was done better in the manga in my opinion because it made it seem longer. It was more heartwrenching in the manga. I also liked that it depicted the consequences of bullying and how a former bully can become alienated from his peers and become the victim of bullying himself. |
Maneki-Mew said: Bobby2Hands said: The first act of Koe no Katachi...but usually not the rest. Not necessarily. Kids can be very stupid and realize their mistakes, when they are growing up. So tbh, I also came to good terms with people, who did something similar / close to bullying back then. Shit happens between kids and teens. ^^" If you mean Ueno: Yeah, I thought she was just there to create melodrama. Yeah I know, that's why I used the qualifier "usually". |
|
15poundfish said: I would say the most realistic depiction of bullying in anime are violent tsundere romances. koe no katachi depiction of bullying was not realistic especially its laughable reaction to suicide where the response to a suicide victim is to shame them and take umbrage that they caused inconvenience to them. Its collectivist bullshit propaganda, its no wonder japan has a big issue with bullying. The proper response to bullying is always to alert authorities or retaliate. Yes, it's best to push someone who just tried to jump off a fucking building. Also, that wasn't due to bullying... Oh, you can use BBCode? So, who are you 'rooting' for in Snafu then? |
|
| If 3-gatsu doesn't properly portray the feeling of isolation then idk which show does. I've only seen s1 so far, but it also struck me as being less about external reasons (like bullying) and more about internal ones (like depression). And it's pretty fucking good at portraying that feeling of isolation that comes with it. But maybe there is an arc focusing more on bullying in the 2nd season in which case I can't comment on it. It just struck me as odd to criticize 3-gatsu for what I found most impressive about it in S1, the realistic and organic depiction of that feeling of anxiety and isolation. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| I'd go with imouto sae: Nobody talks about it, and then you just find out that person x was bullied when they were younger. |
| @oryouohagi i didn't watch s2 because the ending is too clear i liked yui the most |
|
| @Pullman there are like 14 eps in the second season focusing on bullying, I was talking about that. Brb said: I'd go with imouto sae: Nobody talks about it, and then you just find out that person x was bullied when they were younger. That was a bit over-dramatized for me. Couldn't really get into that aspect |
|
I took you for an irohafag, I have to apologize. |
|
| Maybe Aku no Hana and A Lollypop or a Bullet. I wouldn't call them the most realistic depiction, but these two don't really sugarcoat the theme. They are so fucked up the MCs develop some sort of Stockholm Syndrome feelings for the abusers. Being a logical person that I am, it's frustrating to watch at some point. |
oryouohagi said: @Pullman there are like 14 eps in the second season focusing on bullying, I was talking about that. Brb said: I'd go with imouto sae: Nobody talks about it, and then you just find out that person x was bullied when they were younger. That was a bit over-dramatized for me. Couldn't really get into that aspect How was it overly dramatized. It was basically a 1 minute skit about Nayuta saying "I was bullied boo hoo hoo" followed by an overly long explanation about what saved her from the bullying and her love for Itsuki. The bullying was perfectly rational (the victims rarely talk about it during it, but instead look for outlets). PS. You were talking about bullying itself, not post-bullying, so the response had that in mind. |
Brb said: oryouohagi said: @Pullman there are like 14 eps in the second season focusing on bullying, I was talking about that. That was a bit over-dramatized for me. Couldn't really get into that aspect How was it overly dramatized. It was basically a 1 minute skit about Nayuta saying "I was bullied boo hoo hoo" followed by an overly long explanation about what saved her from the bullying and her love for Itsuki. The bullying was perfectly rational (the victims rarely talk about it during it, but instead look for outlets). PS. You were talking about bullying itself, not post-bullying, so the response had that in mind. Exactly, I can't even begin to imagine how someone as attractive as her could get bullied, if not for the sake of drama. You could probably say that for the other shows, as anime characters tend to look attractive, but this one especially boggles me. |
|
oryouohagi said: Brb said: How was it overly dramatized. It was basically a 1 minute skit about Nayuta saying "I was bullied boo hoo hoo" followed by an overly long explanation about what saved her from the bullying and her love for Itsuki. The bullying was perfectly rational (the victims rarely talk about it during it, but instead look for outlets). PS. You were talking about bullying itself, not post-bullying, so the response had that in mind. Exactly, I can't even begin to imagine how someone as attractive as her could get bullied, if not for the sake of drama. You could probably say that for the other shows, as anime characters tend to look attractive, but this one especially boggles me. Wait what? It wasn't dramatized (like I said, 1 minute long, heck probably might be even less). Did you like, sniff something weird or something? |
| Say I Love You had some realistic instances of bullying, or at least the isolation that comes from others due to someone being jealous Clannad AS although brief, had some realistic bullying with Kuroko's Basket also had 'bullying' in it but it has more of the pompous attitude bullying |
 'On-Hold' is another way for a completionist to say 'Dropped' |
Brb said: oryouohagi said: Exactly, I can't even begin to imagine how someone as attractive as her could get bullied, if not for the sake of drama. You could probably say that for the other shows, as anime characters tend to look attractive, but this one especially boggles me. Wait what? It wasn't dramatized (like I said, 1 minute long, heck probably might be even less). Did you like, sniff something weird or something? It's mentioned a few times in the show with bits of flashback. And I described why I feel it was overdramatized. Even a half minute segment is enough to do that for me. |
|
15poundfish said: oryouohagi said: She is half japanese and half foreigner which explains everything. Japan can still be a very racist and xenophobic country where its not uncommon to hear stories of mix-raced japanese being bullied in school and the workforce.one as attractive as her could get bullied, if not for the sake of drama. You could probably say that for the other shows, as anime characters tend to look attractive, but this one especially boggles me. Where is it mentioned that she is half-japanese? Is it in the novel? I can't recall it? Raito said: Hands down 3-gatsu no Lion 2nd Season and Koe no Katachi. Don't forget about GTO. Depicts it in a cruel but kind of realistic manner. |
|
| Hana yori Dango, liked the real life drama better tho! |
 |
This! Absolutely, GTO does it masterfully. |
 |
| Aku no Hana is the first thing which comes to my mind. I also think its quite underappreciated and that's most likely only because of the art style. |
 |
| For me it's Doraemon which is the closest to realistic depiction of Bullying in anime only Korean Manwhas are always unforgiving to their bullying elements like Dokgo, like they were really close to reality which infuriates the readers, though there's a lot of Classic Japanese manga like Real are similar to modern manwha. |
youseikiJan 14, 2018 11:17 AM
 |
| Teru Mikami from Death Note. Maybe not the most realistic depiction ever but it's the one I know. Basically he defended kids from bullies by getting himself beat up instead. I find incredibly realistic that no adults or teachers raised a finger to help stop the bullying. It was so shitty that he hoped God would strike down the bullies. Toji Suzuhara from Evangelion is also a good one. He punches Shinji for being responsible of his sister's injuries, but he later admits that he was dumb and needed to take out his anger on someone. |
this is the most realistic depiction of bullying i have set to see, beating the likes of the extremely unrealistic koe no katachi |
Edward Elric > your waifu  |
| i've never seen the level of bullying that happens it anime happen in real life. |
| Yugioh. Especially how it was all about one-upsmenship. Oniisama e... especially how it was about popularity and political/social power. This one creates isolation . Evangelion- Jealousy, one upsmenship, because femme in a military position, and being blamed for shit that isn’t his fault but he believes everything is his fault do to being told he is worthless or treated like trash despite being worth a lot. And if you want isolation as a consequence this is your anime. |
Energetic-NovaJan 14, 2018 10:02 PM
The anime community in a nutshell.  |
| There's this one hentai where the MC gets bullied a lot, but then he manned up and got revenge...... don't need to tell you what happened next. But that is the most realistic depiction of bullying. |
 |
More topics from this board
» How you feel about non-Japanese entertainment/media using Anime art style?Dragevard - 7 hours ago |
25 |
by logopolis
»»
1 minute ago |
|
Poll: » Does your first ever favourite anime(s) still holds a place in your favs?NubFix - 6 hours ago |
20 |
by Jellybeanx
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» Please recommend anime that has plot/tone sci-fi + fantasy?Donkunsan - 9 hours ago |
7 |
by Zarutaku
»»
15 minutes ago |
|
» What anime do a lot of people consider to be one of the greatest that you think is just good?arinthach - Yesterday |
45 |
by Ratris_Decision
»»
16 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Spring 2024 my fav anime lineup yet! What is your fav series that is going under the radar?rohan121 - 4 hours ago |
8 |
by Zarutaku
»»
25 minutes ago |