| The Big 3 is Naruto , Bleach and One Piece. But The Big 5 with the addition of Katekyo Hitman Reborn and Fairy Tail . Can someone tell me when the Big 5 is formed?  |
 |
| Once upon a time, 5 manga artist were bored with their lives. They were miserable, and they also wanted the people around the world to be miserable.So each one of these artists made their own manga and they wrote these manga in such a way that can only be describe as cliche, boring, and full of cheesy nakama powers. Legend has it, that to this day, only one of these repulsive manga are still on going. |
 |
| This big 3 and big 5 thing is just something started by fans in the West. In Japan it was always One Piece and two other popular shounen. Naruto was always one of the popular shounen. The other most popular shounen cycled between a few such as: Bleach, Beelzebub, Hitman Reborn, Rave, Fairy Tail, etc. But all of them were a lot less popular than OP |
| I doubt it will be "formed" at any point for several reasons. But the main one being that 4 of them had their source material end and depending on how you count Boruto 2-3 of them had their anime end. Unless it's a fan thing I never heard about in which case I would have thought Hunter x hunter would have taken priority over KHR personally. (Not to say one is better than the other but one is clearly more popular) |
GamerDLMDec 6, 2017 10:38 PM
NotThisShitAgain said: What about BEST 5?? - Gintama - Fullmetal Alchemist - Hunter X Hunter - Attack on Titan - Jojo Bizarre Adventure series Hmm I think it's much better than that BIG 5. I agree with you but replace aot with Rurouni Kenshin Dx |
NotThisShitAgain said: Best 5 . More like Rival 5 since all the fanbase hate each otherWhat about BEST 5?? - Gintama - Fullmetal Alchemist - Hunter X Hunter - Attack on Titan - Jojo Bizarre Adventure series Hmm I think it's much better than that BIG 5. |
|
| Weren't they called that way because of them being published in weekly shounen jump at the same time and also be lengthy manga? |
 |
| Lol I love katekyo hitman reborn but when the fuk where they even on the big 5 list? |
| Sonic X is basically an isekai |
Shiroyasha_97 said: who hates who, i never saw hate in gintama's fanbase?NotThisShitAgain said: Best 5 . More like Rival 5 since all the fanbase hate each otherWhat about BEST 5?? - Gintama - Fullmetal Alchemist - Hunter X Hunter - Attack on Titan - Jojo Bizarre Adventure series Hmm I think it's much better than that BIG 5. |
 |
| Huh funny. Up until just now, I know all of the so-called Big 5 except for Katekyo Hitman Reborn. Well anyways, not sure why those anime were termed but it's probably due to them being popular, long-running Shonens. |
My Anime List < Have a good day! > My Manga List |
Salamak said: Shiroyasha_97 said: who hates who, i never saw hate in gintama's fanbase?Best 5 . More like Rival 5 since all the fanbase hate each other Gintama's fanbase is peaceful. And JoJo's is friendly. Wuff |
LalatinaDarkness said: what do they fight on in aot and fma fanbase?Salamak said: who hates who, i never saw hate in gintama's fanbase? Gintama's fanbase is peaceful. And JoJo's is friendly. Wuff |
|
| I suspect this was from 2009 and 2010 when ft and reborn is airing and the big 3. They also have notoriously large episodes. Sad that gintama is forgotten though. |
"When you made this thread, I cried and screamed" -Swagernator 2017 |
| The DB franchise has been out long before any of these shows and still holds relevance to very day. Why was it never apart of this "Big #" list? |
   |
| There's no Big #. Simply it formed when a Manga is a shounen jump that released weekly. The story mostly similiar to each other by i mean a similiar it's basically the typical shounen you can find everywhere. It's not a bad thing though. |
| it's always about DB and OP, the reast is just other popular series... the whole big 3 or big 5 pretty much just western (or US maybe) thing... kinda funny how FT final volume barely break 200K.... bleach at least still in 500K... |
 "If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on." |
| lets make it big 100 now.. every series that was serialized in shounen jump is up for grabs |
 |
| How the big 3/4/5 was formed? Well just the international market having limited access to anime back then, leading to a stark contrast in popularity between a handful of anime and the rest. It has no basis in reality with the actual popularity of various anime in Japan at all. |
| I'm not a lolicon, you're just projecting your tendency to lewd 2D characters. If your favourite character is Tsutsukakushi Tsukiko, you are my soul mate. Been a long time since I've been here, I'll continue expressing myself freely and believe everyone should too. My MAL Interview |
| I use to consider them like that (except Faily tail, which wasn't around yet, thank god xD) when I was more of a teenager. |
| Doraemon? remember them? no? oh you must be from west. |
| Into the Internet! |
pgmhecateii said: No, it's Big 3. Don't include FT and Hitman. Those were the only ones that I genuinely enjoyed anyway (*abnormal love for mafia stuff*) . Plus, FT is split into 2 seasons and is newer, so it doesn't match with the characteristics of the Big 3. Hitman isn't really popular, and if you wanna include Hitman, why isn't D. Gray Man included? I 100% Agree, this 3 should be enough. |
| Never even heard of Big 5 before, just Big 3. |
"At some point, I stopped hoping." |
SigmaRhoIota said: Hey you don't need to be salty about characters with strong friendships just because you've never had a decent friend you could have relied on bruv.Once upon a time, 5 manga artist were bored with their lives. They were miserable, and they also wanted the people around the world to be miserable.So each one of these artists made their own manga and they wrote these manga in such a way that can only be describe as cliche, boring, and full of cheesy nakama powers. Legend has it, that to this day, only one of these repulsive manga are still on going. |
| All the fools who go around hating on everything should stick to them eighties anime. After all isn't that the golden age of TV anime. |
| Aren't you the one who formed the Big 5? Yeah, seems pretty original to me. |
pgmhecateii said: Dude Hitman ended in like 2014 and that's the big reason nobody talks about these days.No, it's Big 3. Don't include FT and Hitman. Those were the only ones that I genuinely enjoyed anyway (*abnormal love for mafia stuff*) . Plus, FT is split into 2 seasons and is newer, so it doesn't match with the characteristics of the Big 3. Hitman isn't really popular, and if you wanna include Hitman, why isn't D. Gray Man included? |
| All the fools who go around hating on everything should stick to them eighties anime. After all isn't that the golden age of TV anime. |
OneNaughtyBear said: The DB franchise has been out long before any of these shows and still holds relevance to very day. Why was it never apart of this "Big #" list? Because of the time period. There was a time span, between 2000 and 2010, when the top mangas in weekly shounen jump were: One Piece, Naruto, and Bleach. Top for both japanese reception and for western fanbases. The Big 3 stuff originated from the manga fanbases, not from the anime fanbases. Dragon ball stopped being published in shounen jump in 1995. Dragon ball super started releasing again only in the 2015 (and it is no longer in weekly shounen anyway) That's why. "Big 3" is a term which was used in the 2000-2010 to describe the top mangas in the top manga magazine(weekly shounen jump), and it has sense in that time frame. Other uses of it with the current shows, are reusing the same words, but the meaning is different. |
ZeandoDec 7, 2017 5:58 AM
 Fixes to make the Profile more bearable after "the Modern★Profile★Update★★Rip★Profile★" |
Only Big 5 I know about are these guys. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| That big 5 was probably formed in a period when people were looking for uninteresting works, with lots of action, boring adventure, noisy characters screaming the names of their techniques. A period when good works didn't exist either, when 20th Century Boys, Nausicaa, Oyasumi Punpun had been erased from people's memory. A sad period, I must say, but has this really changed? Today you have My Hero Academia, Black Clover, Boruto and in a few years you probably have an indigestible mixture of all these works you have already seen. Same for anime series, why is Evangelion so popular when you have series like [insert what you want]? x) |
TuyNOMDec 7, 2017 6:13 AM
 |
| Some say Big 3 but I only heard Big 4 but not 5. Anyway, A big 5 is formed by the number of fans watching it. Later, you suddenly hear BIG ANIME composing of the most popular anime that is currently or done airing. |
 |
| More importantly, why is that bleach and KHR got cancelled before their last 1-2 arcs in anime format, while fairy tail, for e.g which didn't sell too much better didn't? |
| So this thread is 'Big 5 in people opinion'. Meh, talk about 'Big', i choose Gintama for the option. Haikyu or Shokugeki no Souma is the next maybe? Hunter x Hunter is hard to choose because the 'hiatus' problem. |
Isterio said: Fact is: The Big 3 became associated as the succesors of Dragon Ball, which is the biggest, most influential Anime and Manga franchise outside of Japan. No contest. None of them reached it´s size outside of Japan, though One Piece has it beaten in their homecountry, but it´s an american term to begin with. Fact is: Since the Big 3. No such competition between a triangle or even two different Anime and Manga has occured. People are free to invent terms, but it won´t be the Big 3. It´ll be something new that´s equally as meaningless. Great summary/definition. In the current day, until there will be again fandoms growing huge and starting to border each other, the term will be just a ranking, missing the original sense of competition and rivality. Manga Sales by Series *1. 11,495,532 One Piece *2. *6,622,781 Shingeki no Kyojin *3. *6,184,214 Kingdom *4. *5,852,310 Boku no Hero Academia *5. *5,303,514 Tokyo Ghoul:re *6. *5,067,939 Haikyuu!! Light Novel Sales by Series *1. *1,173,096 Sword Art Online *2. **,960,418 Kono Subarashii Sekai ni Shukufuku wo! *3. **,925,671 Re:Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu *4. **,809,636 Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei (so many isekai up there in the light novel rankings) https://myanimelist.net/news/53279056 All those series have their own fandoms, big or small, but they rarely enter in contact with each other, in the same way (one piece, naruto and bleach) did during the 2000-2010. Nor any of those (excluding one piece and boku hero, and maybe Haikyuu!! ?) can clain any succession for the lineage of the top manga of weekly shounen jump (and by relation, the top manga serie of all japan). |
Fixes to make the Profile more bearable after "the Modern★Profile★Update★★Rip★Profile★" |
Isterio said: Alot of this even back in the day was projection tbh. Yup, it has always been an huge circlejerking, made louder and wider by the size of the fandoms involved. (and by the illusion posts on a forum matter anything for the world outside) Maybe it's just an impression, but fandoms in the recent years aren't as loud nor as big, some are generally recognized as popular, but it's less frequent to see a stable and big group of people being focused on the same serie for a long span of time. (making discussions, fanarts, etc) There is a lot more fragmentation over many many series. For the animes it may be caused by the shows themselves being averagely short and limited to few cours. The fandoms are born and die in the span of the airing time. |
Fixes to make the Profile more bearable after "the Modern★Profile★Update★★Rip★Profile★" |
| When I read the title I expected this thread to be related to Yugioh... now I'm disapointed. |
| pretty sure you made it OP there never has been a big 5, and likely never will be (and if there was, there's no way in hell fairy tail deserves to be there) There's the big 3, which was a term the west created to describe One Piece, Naruto, and Bleach... but that's about it. Not sure why you would want this "big 5" to exist anyway |
  |
| You are wrong. Its the BIG 100, bc you didnt add X and Y and Z People dont call them BIG 5 or anything. They just were the most popular shonen around at the time. When you start getting into shonen (when most people are like 12-15) you probably will watch all the longer ones and like them |
| Nothing more than Western folk lore... Used to label anime that are very popular and long running |
| This just seems like FT was invited to be nice and KHR wants nothing to do with any of this. |
 |
| Glad to know I wasn't the only thinking it was about the Big 5 from Yu-gi-oh. |
| How is DBZ /s not in this shit list? its waaay more popular than most of those shows combined |
| People just adding whatever battle shows they want like always I see. |
KuroudoAkabane said: How is DBZ /s not in this shit list? its waaay more popular than most of those shows combined Question already asked, question already answered. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1690480&show=0#msg53288675 and https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1690480&show=0#msg53288936 |
Fixes to make the Profile more bearable after "the Modern★Profile★Update★★Rip★Profile★" |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Do you watch anime on 1.5x/2x/etc speed or skip to next scene? ( 1 2 3 4 )Dragevard - Oct 13, 2021 |
165 |
by Passerby001
»»
30 seconds ago |
|
» Re zero is a censored mess ( 1 2 )mieruko999 - Dec 10 |
75 |
by Confetti112
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» Do any anime characters resemble you physically?justmaya - 2 hours ago |
5 |
by ALEXxAMI
»»
18 minutes ago |
|
» Are there any specific games you would like to see adapted?RobertBobert - Today |
12 |
by ALEXxAMI
»»
22 minutes ago |
|
» Do you get more offended by Controversial Contents in Anime or the Anime Fandom?Dragevard - 2 hours ago |
7 |
by kutuya
»»
29 minutes ago |