Shut_up_Shinji said: Petalview said: Because of various Anime Conventions which previewed the first episode. For now, the ratings of the people mirror what these people think of the first episode. I also went to the Europe premiere and I also rated this show already REALLY high. Usually, I wait to give a rating for a series after having seen a few episode of it, this one is an exception. Though, the rating might drop, if the quality/story/animation doesn't stay on the same level. Anyway, just to say it like this: I haven't seen such a good and promising first episode of an anime for years(!). And I watch anime frequently... Sorry, I understand people complaining about others who give ratings after just watching one episode, I also kinda understand people who give a rating after just watching one episode (after all I did in this case, too...), what I don't understand are people who aren't even interested in a show and give a bad rating just so that the ratings might drop. You don't even know if it is good or not, not even based from the first episode... You make quite a valid point there, Have you seen The Ancient Magus Bride? I had the feeling you are describing right now with that anime. After I saw the trailer I bought the first vol of the manga. Now I own all of them up untill now, and I am very hyped for whats next to come. No, I haven't seen it yet, but I only heard good things about this show. I highly favor one of the producing studios. I usually like productions/co-productions from Shochiku quite a lot. At least as far I've seen movies or anime series. Thanks for this nice reminder/the recommendation! I put The Ancient Magus Bride now on my Plan to Watch List. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| i gave up looking for justice a long time ago |
| i'm sure a lot of people giving it a 10 also didn't even see the first episode so i don't think it is wrong giving it a 1 too |
 |
AyumiVk said: i'm sure a lot of people giving it a 10 also didn't even see the first episode so i don't think it is wrong giving it a 1 too Both sides are wrong. |
 |
Kittens-kun said: AyumiVk said: i'm sure a lot of people giving it a 10 also didn't even see the first episode so i don't think it is wrong giving it a 1 too Both sides are wrong. I agree with you on that. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Because it shouldn't have been rated so highly anyway, precisely for the same reason you stated, it hasn't aired yet. |
| I feel that both sides are wrong here. Someone should not give an anime 10 if he only ever saw a preview of the first episode. And the same can be said for people who gave it 1. |
LalakoboldslayerSep 12, 2017 7:07 AM
 |
| People's view can change over time. It's probably that.. so in this case, their opinion changed slightly on the trailer? |
 Three things cannot be long hidden.. ...the s u n, the m oo n, and the tr u th. |
| I'm not a fan of ratting shows 1. but it's seriously high rated although it didn't even start |
| @Zelev @-NeW- I went to the Europe premiere and I rated this show already REALLY high. Usually, I wait to give a rating for a series after having seen a few episode of it, this one is an exception. Though, the rating might drop, if the quality/story/animation doesn't stay on the same level. Anyway, just to say it like this: I haven't seen such a good and promising first episode of an anime for years(!). And I watch anime frequently... |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Ketamigo said: Yaboku said: I got really mad when I saw that 93 people have given this anime a 1/10. Same for Noragami. I've never understood how people can hate noragami. If they had ever bothered to read the manga, they'd know that it's actually one of the most compelling and well written projects out there. I really like the Anime, too! |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| The drama is strong in this one. |
"When you made this thread, I cried and screamed" -Swagernator 2017 |
Turtles_Hunter said: Maybe you should make peace with the idea that most of the mal community is composed of hater who think their taste are the best, and everything else is bad. That they feel the need to puke on what a little popular and severly lack critical thinking and common sense. They rate things with some defaults as very bad but aren't able to see the exact same ones in the shows they like. Once you've made peace with that idea, you'll stop caring about all this shit. I rather believe in the good part of the MAL community than to accept that the majority might be like that. Aren't we/ our community lost if we stop caring? Well, the anime community is a small part but still a part of our overall community of the world, too. nymi said: The drama is strong in this one. It truly is. xD :P |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I don't care so much about ratings since I don't even rate my list properly, but this "I rate it after 1 episode" etc ruins the system for those who like to check the numbers. How come you understand/love/hate everything about a series if you barely watched it? Rating should only be unlocked if a certain number of episodes has been watched by the user. |
 |
| How does this anime even have ratings and is >constantly< "currently airing" while having 0 episodes at the moment? I haven't rated this series but have it on my PTW list for a long time. MAL should change it's status to "not yet aired", this might stop the blind hate/love the series gets. All 10 and 1 point ratings are pointless. MAL shouldn't allow any ratings until half the episodes actually aired imo. It's a bit similiar with Mahoutsukai no Yome, does it acutally air this season or is it also planned for 2018 (like Violet Evergarden)? A lot of the hate might result from the broken af "currently airing" status. |
Ketamigo said: Yaboku said: I got really mad when I saw that 93 people have given this anime a 1/10. Same for Noragami. I've never understood how people can hate noragami. If they had ever bothered to read the manga, they'd know that it's actually one of the most compelling and well written projects out there. As a rule of thumb, you shouldn't say "The anime shouldn't have low ratings because the manga was good" It's utterly meaningless. A great manga can have an awful adaptation, and vice versa. Also why should I have to read the manga to enjoy the show? I like Norogami (haven't marked it as it's been a while), but I'd never expect someone to read the manga to enjoy the anime. |
  300th pun xchyssa said: You got some nice viewpoint there, I always know I can't fool you with my sharpest tagging skills |
lazyboy76 said: imo both are stupid and defending either is dumb as well which is why i dont care for scores nor should anyone else moodie said: Suprised ppl arent looking at the opposite. How it has such a high score for a series that i bet most ppl rating it didnt even watch. It goes both ways. Someone give it a 10 and intend to watch it will change the score if they feel disappointed, but someone give 1/10 and don't intend to watch it won't ever change the score. In long term, the first type won't be different from the one rate it after watched the movie but the latter type is different. Of course there're also people give it 10 now and don't intend to change the rate later, but that's not everyone. Imo, it's better to give high rate now and watch it in the future than give it low rate and never intend to watch it. |
| You guys are having too much free time worrying about other people rating their anime. Is this some kind of competition where you get a medal if you rate all the show correctly? |
 "A Legend is but a tale of a beautiful lie." |
Ketamigo said: Sharpoint said: As a rule of thumb, you shouldn't say "The anime shouldn't have low ratings because the manga was good" It's utterly meaningless. A great manga can have an awful adaptation, and vice versa. Also why should I have to read the manga to enjoy the show? I like Norogami (haven't marked it as it's been a while), but I'd never expect someone to read the manga to enjoy the anime. I never said someone couldn't give a bad score to an anime simply because they didn't have the full experience/context from reading the manga, I just find it sad that peoples initial impression of the show is typically what drives them to leave a mediocre score. If they had stuck through to the end, I sincerely doubt they would have been able to overlook what pans out to be a pretty deep and emotional story. Peoples ratings on MAL in general are so grossly inconsistent with actual merit that it is kind of maddening. For some reason, Anime Ratings seem to be the most emotionally based out of any form of entertainment. People seem to judge an anime more do to hype, sexual preference, or simply what fucking mood they are in on the day they decide to rate something. There's also been a massive problem (like this thread addresses) with people spitefully negatively rating things for a various number of emotional reasons. Then, there is the cancer of the Moe/Loli obsession that has tended to ruin anime in a wholesale way, but thats a whole other conversation. While I do occasionally score anime, and quite liberally at that, I can't see the obsession with scoring in the first place. You shouldn't be able to score shows that have 0 episodes listed, because some people may have seen a preview or whatever. Review bombing is a problem, but if you sift through the reviews for a show (that's airing/complete) you should be able to find the real critique. Also keep in mind for many shows, people rate the shows off the high they get from just having watched an episode or the whole series, so their critical side might get buried a little. |
300th pun xchyssa said: You got some nice viewpoint there, I always know I can't fool you with my sharpest tagging skills |
Sebkh3192 said: Well all your prayers are answered. MAL made the series have a N/A rating and it's available Winter 2018. Yup, and now when it actually airs people will understand why it had such a high rating. |
Azurevin said: Kinda new here, how is it possible that like a 1,5k people have already rated this when not a single episode has been put out? There have been pre-screenings in a few anime expos |
Sebkh3192 said: Well all your prayers are answered. MAL made the series have a N/A rating and it's available Winter 2018. Yes, i would close this thread if i could. People keep đź…±umping it. But i just made this bigger lol. |
miX0NOct 22, 2017 1:03 AM
| "How is this anime's rating slowly decreasing if it hasn't even started yet ?" I don't even know how it was rated so high with only one episode aired to begin with. |
|
| It is just a rank get over it already, do not you think it's unfair considering how good other animes are in enission? If it's good, it'll go up, just wait. |
 |
AyumiVk said: i'm sure a lot of people giving it a 10 also didn't even see the first episode so i don't think it is wrong giving it a 1 too That's stupid as all hell. |
| added the fourth most popular anime onto this site |
moodie said: lazyboy76 said: imo both are stupid and defending either is dumb as well which is why i dont care for scores nor should anyone else Someone give it a 10 and intend to watch it will change the score if they feel disappointed, but someone give 1/10 and don't intend to watch it won't ever change the score. In long term, the first type won't be different from the one rate it after watched the movie but the latter type is different. Of course there're also people give it 10 now and don't intend to change the rate later, but that's not everyone. Imo, it's better to give high rate now and watch it in the future than give it low rate and never intend to watch it. Nothing is stupid because its just a score in the end of the day. And we all know that all scores given are biased in some matter and represent more one people feeling rather than the value of the show. The reason why I think it is correct to give a score to that anime is because when you know that the anime hasn't started airing, you immediately discard the score it got because it means nothing since it shouldn't have a score to begin with. So that it has a score of 7.50 8.50 or 9.20 that change absolutely nothing because this doesn't represent anything at all. |
EvenJellyOn said: AyumiVk said: i'm sure a lot of people giving it a 10 also didn't even see the first episode so i don't think it is wrong giving it a 1 too That's stupid as all hell. for you it might be but for me it is not, simple |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Violet Evergarden Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 14, 2018 |
617 |
by AMazingWay
»»
Apr 22, 5:27 PM |
|
Poll: » Violet Evergarden Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Feb 28, 2018 |
244 |
by _Anime-Lover-44_
»»
Apr 15, 1:02 AM |
|
Poll: » Violet Evergarden Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jan 17, 2018 |
422 |
by TabbyPog
»»
Apr 5, 2:36 PM |
|
» Do you love Violet Evergarden? ( 1 2 )Stacias - Jul 19, 2022 |
90 |
by Zarutaku
»»
Apr 5, 4:41 AM |
|
Poll: » Violet Evergarden Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Feb 14, 2018 |
239 |
by AdrianRawr
»»
Mar 30, 6:50 AM |