Minigame v10: K-On! Frills and Thrills v2 | Game End!

Offline

May 2014

7018

Jackrito said:
It is more because I wanted to pressure them I intend to vote Reynii still

Right, you said that earlier.

Ruu said:

Shinichi-Kun said:
126

I cant sse why she post something that could potentially help town lynch properly ik it sounds stupid, but as mafia i wouldn't give town ways to help them find my buddies

137

Feel like as scum she wouldn't feel the need to post this.

299

Another post where she explains what mafia would do in a certain situation

Maybe im just biased or something but if someone can prove that suzune is actually scummy this game ill still vote her

Btw the fact that she doesnt like me defending her in something i noticed she does as both alignments which irks me alot XD.

I like this post. I will never trust Suzu (too deep wolf for me) but I can see why you would town read her.

What does 'deep wolf' mean?

Mar 27, 2017 11:06 AM

#452

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

coromandel said:
Why haven't you voted for anyone yet, @Shinichi-kun?

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Suzune-chan said:
I'm uncertain why there is such a discussion about whether ties are good for the mafia. I guess, in my opinion I cannot see why ties are good for the mafia. However, Ruu you were the one pushing for a tie on day one, how no lynch was better. So it seems odd that your were the spear head of this conversation.

@Coromandel

I probably would have voted for followind too, mainly because of this post. So I don't find the people on his train all that suspicious, I can see why they voted for him in the end.

Coromandel I think this kind of thinking removes any of the energy from day one. Saying that it is fine and you can see it justified just covers up the reasons that people may have chosen or not chosen to be on trains. This kind of sweeping judgement ruffles my feathers a tad.

I'm super guilty of this too and I myself need be better at this. But I think we have to be careful as a group of, mafia must act like this..., because it causes too much town lynching. I'm not sure that makes sense but someone mentioned something about how mafia should act and that reminded me. Jack reminded me after my last game that anti-town moves do not mean that you are scum. Although...I might still lynch them.

-bottom of page 7-

I didn't say that we shouldn't look at people's reasons for voting, but I would have voted the same way so followind's train didn't seem all that suspicious to me at first glance. There were other things that caught *my* eye, but you're free to analyze anything you want. It's a good thing if everyone brings somethiing different to the table, imo.

Not everyone who lynches a townie is mafia, and not everyone who lynches mafia is a townie. For me, I find it often is the other way round, actually: Townies often aren't afraid of mislynching on the first day,
whereas mafia players
a) don't want to be in the spotlight (for lynching a townie), so they avoid trains - this not only makes other people not suspect them, they can then also blame the townies who were on lynch trains.
and
b) often emphasize how they don't want townies to die (because that seems like a pretty innocent thing to say, apparently)

"I'd rather have a no-lynch than mislynch a townie!"
... some people (including reiynii) said this at the end of D1, so I'm wary of them for those two reasons.

By the way, Suzune, is there no one you suspect enough to vote for them today?

If B. is true wouldnt that mean that me and ruu are 2 of ur suspects cause we do that alot.

A.If this is true then me jack and QC are innocent?

I still both A and B then on the player themselves cause everyone handles situations differently

hm.. maybe, but that's a little too black and white.
Reiynii did both A and B, plus a couple of other things that I've explained already. Lots of tells together make me think he's mafia.
Ruu for example also did both, but with her I get the impression that she was simply indecisive yesterday, and that's why she was fine with no lynch.

Well its between jack angel and rei, i think thereis 75% that innocent angel is a newbbie mafia sadly but ive been wrong before.

Mar 27, 2017 11:07 AM

#453

Offline

May 2015

6405

@coromandel deep wolf means a mafia players that plays so well they always get town read because they look townie for the rest of the players. Is hard to find them.

Mar 27, 2017 11:08 AM

#454

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

coromandel said:
Why haven't you voted for anyone yet, @Shinichi-kun?

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Suzune-chan said:
I'm uncertain why there is such a discussion about whether ties are good for the mafia. I guess, in my opinion I cannot see why ties are good for the mafia. However, Ruu you were the one pushing for a tie on day one, how no lynch was better. So it seems odd that your were the spear head of this conversation.

@Coromandel

I probably would have voted for followind too, mainly because of this post. So I don't find the people on his train all that suspicious, I can see why they voted for him in the end.

Coromandel I think this kind of thinking removes any of the energy from day one. Saying that it is fine and you can see it justified just covers up the reasons that people may have chosen or not chosen to be on trains. This kind of sweeping judgement ruffles my feathers a tad.

I'm super guilty of this too and I myself need be better at this. But I think we have to be careful as a group of, mafia must act like this..., because it causes too much town lynching. I'm not sure that makes sense but someone mentioned something about how mafia should act and that reminded me. Jack reminded me after my last game that anti-town moves do not mean that you are scum. Although...I might still lynch them.

-bottom of page 7-

I didn't say that we shouldn't look at people's reasons for voting, but I would have voted the same way so followind's train didn't seem all that suspicious to me at first glance. There were other things that caught *my* eye, but you're free to analyze anything you want. It's a good thing if everyone brings somethiing different to the table, imo.

Not everyone who lynches a townie is mafia, and not everyone who lynches mafia is a townie. For me, I find it often is the other way round, actually: Townies often aren't afraid of mislynching on the first day,
whereas mafia players
a) don't want to be in the spotlight (for lynching a townie), so they avoid trains - this not only makes other people not suspect them, they can then also blame the townies who were on lynch trains.
and
b) often emphasize how they don't want townies to die (because that seems like a pretty innocent thing to say, apparently)

"I'd rather have a no-lynch than mislynch a townie!"
... some people (including reiynii) said this at the end of D1, so I'm wary of them for those two reasons.

By the way, Suzune, is there no one you suspect enough to vote for them today?

If B. is true wouldnt that mean that me and ruu are 2 of ur suspects cause we do that alot.

A.If this is true then me jack and QC are innocent?

I still both A and B then on the player themselves cause everyone handles situations differently

hm.. maybe, but that's a little too black and white.
Reiynii did both A and B, plus a couple of other things that I've explained already. Lots of tells together make me think he's mafia.
Ruu for example also did both, but with her I get the impression that she was simply indecisive yesterday, and that's why she was fine with no lynch.

Ya now they i think about it rei did do both, qhile ruu does give off that impression.

Mar 27, 2017 11:09 AM

#455

Offline

May 2014

7018

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:
Why haven't you voted for anyone yet, @Shinichi-kun?

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Suzune-chan said:
I'm uncertain why there is such a discussion about whether ties are good for the mafia. I guess, in my opinion I cannot see why ties are good for the mafia. However, Ruu you were the one pushing for a tie on day one, how no lynch was better. So it seems odd that your were the spear head of this conversation.

@Coromandel

I probably would have voted for followind too, mainly because of this post. So I don't find the people on his train all that suspicious, I can see why they voted for him in the end.

Coromandel I think this kind of thinking removes any of the energy from day one. Saying that it is fine and you can see it justified just covers up the reasons that people may have chosen or not chosen to be on trains. This kind of sweeping judgement ruffles my feathers a tad.

I'm super guilty of this too and I myself need be better at this. But I think we have to be careful as a group of, mafia must act like this..., because it causes too much town lynching. I'm not sure that makes sense but someone mentioned something about how mafia should act and that reminded me. Jack reminded me after my last game that anti-town moves do not mean that you are scum. Although...I might still lynch them.

-bottom of page 7-

I didn't say that we shouldn't look at people's reasons for voting, but I would have voted the same way so followind's train didn't seem all that suspicious to me at first glance. There were other things that caught *my* eye, but you're free to analyze anything you want. It's a good thing if everyone brings somethiing different to the table, imo.

Not everyone who lynches a townie is mafia, and not everyone who lynches mafia is a townie. For me, I find it often is the other way round, actually: Townies often aren't afraid of mislynching on the first day,
whereas mafia players
a) don't want to be in the spotlight (for lynching a townie), so they avoid trains - this not only makes other people not suspect them, they can then also blame the townies who were on lynch trains.
and
b) often emphasize how they don't want townies to die (because that seems like a pretty innocent thing to say, apparently)

"I'd rather have a no-lynch than mislynch a townie!"
... some people (including reiynii) said this at the end of D1, so I'm wary of them for those two reasons.

By the way, Suzune, is there no one you suspect enough to vote for them today?

If B. is true wouldnt that mean that me and ruu are 2 of ur suspects cause we do that alot.

A.If this is true then me jack and QC are innocent?

I still both A and B then on the player themselves cause everyone handles situations differently

hm.. maybe, but that's a little too black and white.
Reiynii did both A and B, plus a couple of other things that I've explained already. Lots of tells together make me think he's mafia.
Ruu for example also did both, but with her I get the impression that she was simply indecisive yesterday, and that's why she was fine with no lynch.

Well its between jack angel and rei, i think thereis 75% that innocent angel is a newbbie mafia sadly but ive been wrong before.

So.. you can't decide?

Ruu said:
@coromandel deep wolf means a mafia players that plays so well they always get town read because they look townie for the rest of the players. Is hard to find them.

Ah, thanks!

Mar 27, 2017 11:10 AM

#456

Offline

May 2015

6405

Jackrito said:

coromandel said:

Really? I'm curious about this, because I have no idea what you two are talking about. x3

+1

It's happened before.
Although I wouldn't say Jack is leading the lynch, he's currently voting for InnocentAngel. @Ruu

It is more because I wanted to pressure them I intend to vote Reynii still

So your vote on IA was just to get their attention? You don't suspect them?

Mar 27, 2017 11:14 AM

#457

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:
Why haven't you voted for anyone yet, @Shinichi-kun?

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Suzune-chan said:
I'm uncertain why there is such a discussion about whether ties are good for the mafia. I guess, in my opinion I cannot see why ties are good for the mafia. However, Ruu you were the one pushing for a tie on day one, how no lynch was better. So it seems odd that your were the spear head of this conversation.

@Coromandel

I probably would have voted for followind too, mainly because of this post. So I don't find the people on his train all that suspicious, I can see why they voted for him in the end.

Coromandel I think this kind of thinking removes any of the energy from day one. Saying that it is fine and you can see it justified just covers up the reasons that people may have chosen or not chosen to be on trains. This kind of sweeping judgement ruffles my feathers a tad.

I'm super guilty of this too and I myself need be better at this. But I think we have to be careful as a group of, mafia must act like this..., because it causes too much town lynching. I'm not sure that makes sense but someone mentioned something about how mafia should act and that reminded me. Jack reminded me after my last game that anti-town moves do not mean that you are scum. Although...I might still lynch them.

-bottom of page 7-

I didn't say that we shouldn't look at people's reasons for voting, but I would have voted the same way so followind's train didn't seem all that suspicious to me at first glance. There were other things that caught *my* eye, but you're free to analyze anything you want. It's a good thing if everyone brings somethiing different to the table, imo.

Not everyone who lynches a townie is mafia, and not everyone who lynches mafia is a townie. For me, I find it often is the other way round, actually: Townies often aren't afraid of mislynching on the first day,
whereas mafia players
a) don't want to be in the spotlight (for lynching a townie), so they avoid trains - this not only makes other people not suspect them, they can then also blame the townies who were on lynch trains.
and
b) often emphasize how they don't want townies to die (because that seems like a pretty innocent thing to say, apparently)

"I'd rather have a no-lynch than mislynch a townie!"
... some people (including reiynii) said this at the end of D1, so I'm wary of them for those two reasons.

By the way, Suzune, is there no one you suspect enough to vote for them today?

If B. is true wouldnt that mean that me and ruu are 2 of ur suspects cause we do that alot.

A.If this is true then me jack and QC are innocent?

I still both A and B then on the player themselves cause everyone handles situations differently

hm.. maybe, but that's a little too black and white.
Reiynii did both A and B, plus a couple of other things that I've explained already. Lots of tells together make me think he's mafia.
Ruu for example also did both, but with her I get the impression that she was simply indecisive yesterday, and that's why she was fine with no lynch.

Well its between jack angel and rei, i think thereis 75% that innocent angel is a newbbie mafia sadly but ive been wrong before.

So.. you can't decide?

Ruu said:
@coromandel deep wolf means a mafia players that plays so well they always get town read because they look townie for the rest of the players. Is hard to find them.

Ah, thanks!

Cant decide true but i think ill end up going with angel just not yet.

Mar 27, 2017 11:18 AM

#458

Offline

Dec 2016

577

coromandel said:

Qoco said:
Then coromandel has this funny thing with her wordings. Whenever I feel like she's saying one thing, but the intentions behind her words are another, she usually flips Mafia.

So ambiguous~

Qoco said:
There's not enough lemons to make juice. We need a lynch for information. All we can do is just vote and pray.

I guess you're just praying today, not voting? :P

I am, once I get on my computer in a bit. I hope there is still time for that.

Mar 27, 2017 11:20 AM

#459

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

Ruu said:

Jackrito said:

It is more because I wanted to pressure them I intend to vote Reynii still

So your vote on IA was just to get their attention? You don't suspect them?

Of course I suspect them that is why I did it for pressure

Mar 27, 2017 11:23 AM

#460

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

My issue with angel lynch is they could be newish town but they have not helped themselfs either

Mar 27, 2017 11:26 AM

#461

Offline

Dec 2016

577

Shinichi-Kun said:

Qoco said:
I can't find a connection with reiynii and Shinichi/Ruu/Jackrito, and possibly* coromandel (given that they entered the game this phase). So many lengthy responses, going back and forth. So much effort, that it's difficult to make a correlation between them.

With all our interactions im sure u can find a connection unless your thinking that none of us have reasons to buss rei as his partner.

I'm not trying to evade giving an answer. The connection that I'm finding is that there is no connection. Right now I'm feeling that at least half of Mafia is either lurking or inactive.

Mar 27, 2017 11:34 AM

#462

Offline

Dec 2016

577

Ruu said:

- I don't like Qoco's absent - he was pushing for a lynch saying now the real game begins and stuff but they went MIA for a big part of it. His posts aren't helpful at all, I'm not a big fan of Suzune but his comment about a possible scum tell made no sense to me. He just put it out there but didn't try to build a case nor talk about Suzu's posts. He spend too much time looking for the famous money post instead of actually reading the thread and pressuring people. They are next on my suspects list.

First, I didn't go MIA. For the big part of it, I was alone in the thread, while everyone else was what I assume, sleeping. I guess you see my posts as non-helpful because I don't ask redundant questions. You can ask as many questions and "pressure" as much as you want, but that's not really indicative of alignment. And no, I didn't spend too much time looking for the post. I already knew where it was. It only took me a mere few minutes to find it, and I did it to prove a point. Whether the point is valid or not, we're going to have to see later on.

So there's that. You are wrong.

Mar 27, 2017 11:45 AM

#463

Offline

Dec 2016

577

Jackrito said:
My issue with angel lynch is they could be newish town but they have not helped themselfs either

They remind me of me the first time I played Mafia. I was scum, and I'd lurk around, throwing my two cents enough to stay active. I'd also apologize and say that I was new. I think I may have seen that here yesterday.

Mar 27, 2017 11:52 AM

#464

Offline

Dec 2016

577

I'm def getting that vibe... Though at the same time I don't want to pick on the new guy, because it's too easy.

InnocentAngel said:
Ok just got back reading the whole discussion , so maybe I'm gonna go with Vote : Lam-B

InnocentAngel said:
Still new to this game so don't really know who to suspect yet, but nvm

InnocentAngel said:

Jackrito said:

A bit more to it then base mechanics talk, and yeah this is more then a RVS, a lot of it is more gut then anything we will see how it develops.

What is RVS?

Mar 27, 2017 12:02 PM

#465

Offline

Dec 2016

577

Vote: Ruu

I'm going with Ruu. I don't really like how she asks too many questions, and then rephrases what you say in a question, to make it come off in a different tone. Almost as if to start some fires. People call me crazy, but I notice things.

Qoco said:
The way reiynii reacts makes it seem like they're hiding behind the lynch to look good.

Ruu said:
@Qoco so you are saying rei-chan, knowing followind was town, tried to save him to look townish and gain a "friend" that would town read him for it?

Qoco said:
I'm not saying that's the case. That's just how it feels.

Mar 27, 2017 12:04 PM

#466

Offline

Dec 2016

577

We have 1 hour left, btw.

Mar 27, 2017 12:06 PM

#467

Offline

Dec 2016

577

I kinda want to change my vote to Angel, but that will do for now, I guess.

Mar 27, 2017 12:08 PM

#468

Offline

May 2014

7018

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:
Why haven't you voted for anyone yet, @Shinichi-kun?

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Suzune-chan said:
I'm uncertain why there is such a discussion about whether ties are good for the mafia. I guess, in my opinion I cannot see why ties are good for the mafia. However, Ruu you were the one pushing for a tie on day one, how no lynch was better. So it seems odd that your were the spear head of this conversation.

@Coromandel

I probably would have voted for followind too, mainly because of this post. So I don't find the people on his train all that suspicious, I can see why they voted for him in the end.

Coromandel I think this kind of thinking removes any of the energy from day one. Saying that it is fine and you can see it justified just covers up the reasons that people may have chosen or not chosen to be on trains. This kind of sweeping judgement ruffles my feathers a tad.

I'm super guilty of this too and I myself need be better at this. But I think we have to be careful as a group of, mafia must act like this..., because it causes too much town lynching. I'm not sure that makes sense but someone mentioned something about how mafia should act and that reminded me. Jack reminded me after my last game that anti-town moves do not mean that you are scum. Although...I might still lynch them.

-bottom of page 7-

I didn't say that we shouldn't look at people's reasons for voting, but I would have voted the same way so followind's train didn't seem all that suspicious to me at first glance. There were other things that caught *my* eye, but you're free to analyze anything you want. It's a good thing if everyone brings somethiing different to the table, imo.

Not everyone who lynches a townie is mafia, and not everyone who lynches mafia is a townie. For me, I find it often is the other way round, actually: Townies often aren't afraid of mislynching on the first day,
whereas mafia players
a) don't want to be in the spotlight (for lynching a townie), so they avoid trains - this not only makes other people not suspect them, they can then also blame the townies who were on lynch trains.
and
b) often emphasize how they don't want townies to die (because that seems like a pretty innocent thing to say, apparently)

"I'd rather have a no-lynch than mislynch a townie!"
... some people (including reiynii) said this at the end of D1, so I'm wary of them for those two reasons.

By the way, Suzune, is there no one you suspect enough to vote for them today?

If B. is true wouldnt that mean that me and ruu are 2 of ur suspects cause we do that alot.

A.If this is true then me jack and QC are innocent?

I still both A and B then on the player themselves cause everyone handles situations differently

hm.. maybe, but that's a little too black and white.
Reiynii did both A and B, plus a couple of other things that I've explained already. Lots of tells together make me think he's mafia.
Ruu for example also did both, but with her I get the impression that she was simply indecisive yesterday, and that's why she was fine with no lynch.

Well its between jack angel and rei, i think thereis 75% that innocent angel is a newbbie mafia sadly but ive been wrong before.

So.. you can't decide?

Ah, thanks!

Cant decide true but i think ill end up going with angel just not yet.

I don't get why you're waiting so long - you haven't voted for anyone today. Why not?

Mar 27, 2017 12:23 PM

#469

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:
Why haven't you voted for anyone yet, @Shinichi-kun?

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Suzune-chan said:
I'm uncertain why there is such a discussion about whether ties are good for the mafia. I guess, in my opinion I cannot see why ties are good for the mafia. However, Ruu you were the one pushing for a tie on day one, how no lynch was better. So it seems odd that your were the spear head of this conversation.

@Coromandel

I probably would have voted for followind too, mainly because of this post. So I don't find the people on his train all that suspicious, I can see why they voted for him in the end.

Coromandel I think this kind of thinking removes any of the energy from day one. Saying that it is fine and you can see it justified just covers up the reasons that people may have chosen or not chosen to be on trains. This kind of sweeping judgement ruffles my feathers a tad.

I'm super guilty of this too and I myself need be better at this. But I think we have to be careful as a group of, mafia must act like this..., because it causes too much town lynching. I'm not sure that makes sense but someone mentioned something about how mafia should act and that reminded me. Jack reminded me after my last game that anti-town moves do not mean that you are scum. Although...I might still lynch them.

-bottom of page 7-

I didn't say that we shouldn't look at people's reasons for voting, but I would have voted the same way so followind's train didn't seem all that suspicious to me at first glance. There were other things that caught *my* eye, but you're free to analyze anything you want. It's a good thing if everyone brings somethiing different to the table, imo.

Not everyone who lynches a townie is mafia, and not everyone who lynches mafia is a townie. For me, I find it often is the other way round, actually: Townies often aren't afraid of mislynching on the first day,
whereas mafia players
a) don't want to be in the spotlight (for lynching a townie), so they avoid trains - this not only makes other people not suspect them, they can then also blame the townies who were on lynch trains.
and
b) often emphasize how they don't want townies to die (because that seems like a pretty innocent thing to say, apparently)

"I'd rather have a no-lynch than mislynch a townie!"
... some people (including reiynii) said this at the end of D1, so I'm wary of them for those two reasons.

By the way, Suzune, is there no one you suspect enough to vote for them today?

If B. is true wouldnt that mean that me and ruu are 2 of ur suspects cause we do that alot.

A.If this is true then me jack and QC are innocent?

I still both A and B then on the player themselves cause everyone handles situations differently

hm.. maybe, but that's a little too black and white.
Reiynii did both A and B, plus a couple of other things that I've explained already. Lots of tells together make me think he's mafia.
Ruu for example also did both, but with her I get the impression that she was simply indecisive yesterday, and that's why she was fine with no lynch.

Well its between jack angel and rei, i think thereis 75% that innocent angel is a newbbie mafia sadly but ive been wrong before.

So.. you can't decide?

Ruu said:
@coromandel deep wolf means a mafia players that plays so well they always get town read because they look townie for the rest of the players. Is hard to find them.

Ah, thanks!

Cant decide true but i think ill end up going with angel just not yet.

I don't get why you're waiting so long - you haven't voted for anyone today. Why not?

What problems does waiting cause? I both pinged angel and my other suspects are talking quite alot so where is the need to vote?

Mar 27, 2017 12:28 PM

#470

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:
Why haven't you voted for anyone yet, @Shinichi-kun?

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Suzune-chan said:
I'm uncertain why there is such a discussion about whether ties are good for the mafia. I guess, in my opinion I cannot see why ties are good for the mafia. However, Ruu you were the one pushing for a tie on day one, how no lynch was better. So it seems odd that your were the spear head of this conversation.

@Coromandel

I probably would have voted for followind too, mainly because of this post. So I don't find the people on his train all that suspicious, I can see why they voted for him in the end.

Coromandel I think this kind of thinking removes any of the energy from day one. Saying that it is fine and you can see it justified just covers up the reasons that people may have chosen or not chosen to be on trains. This kind of sweeping judgement ruffles my feathers a tad.

I'm super guilty of this too and I myself need be better at this. But I think we have to be careful as a group of, mafia must act like this..., because it causes too much town lynching. I'm not sure that makes sense but someone mentioned something about how mafia should act and that reminded me. Jack reminded me after my last game that anti-town moves do not mean that you are scum. Although...I might still lynch them.

-bottom of page 7-

I didn't say that we shouldn't look at people's reasons for voting, but I would have voted the same way so followind's train didn't seem all that suspicious to me at first glance. There were other things that caught *my* eye, but you're free to analyze anything you want. It's a good thing if everyone brings somethiing different to the table, imo.

Not everyone who lynches a townie is mafia, and not everyone who lynches mafia is a townie. For me, I find it often is the other way round, actually: Townies often aren't afraid of mislynching on the first day,
whereas mafia players
a) don't want to be in the spotlight (for lynching a townie), so they avoid trains - this not only makes other people not suspect them, they can then also blame the townies who were on lynch trains.
and
b) often emphasize how they don't want townies to die (because that seems like a pretty innocent thing to say, apparently)

"I'd rather have a no-lynch than mislynch a townie!"
... some people (including reiynii) said this at the end of D1, so I'm wary of them for those two reasons.

By the way, Suzune, is there no one you suspect enough to vote for them today?

If B. is true wouldnt that mean that me and ruu are 2 of ur suspects cause we do that alot.

A.If this is true then me jack and QC are innocent?

I still both A and B then on the player themselves cause everyone handles situations differently

hm.. maybe, but that's a little too black and white.
Reiynii did both A and B, plus a couple of other things that I've explained already. Lots of tells together make me think he's mafia.
Ruu for example also did both, but with her I get the impression that she was simply indecisive yesterday, and that's why she was fine with no lynch.

Well its between jack angel and rei, i think thereis 75% that innocent angel is a newbbie mafia sadly but ive been wrong before.

So.. you can't decide?

Ruu said:
@coromandel deep wolf means a mafia players that plays so well they always get town read because they look townie for the rest of the players. Is hard to find them.

Ah, thanks!

Cant decide true but i think ill end up going with angel just not yet.

I don't get why you're waiting so long - you haven't voted for anyone today. Why not?

Let me ask you something, whats the point ofasking me to vote? Basically if ur town all you do is set it up for me to look scummy when i vote when in reality i am town, so thanks for your question.

Mar 27, 2017 12:29 PM

#471

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

who is the leading train right now angel or rei?

Mar 27, 2017 12:31 PM

#472

SoulEaterQUEEN

Offline

Nov 2013

9383

Vote Count 2.5

InnocentAngel (2): Jackrito, Suzune-chan
reiynii (1): coromandel
Shinichi-Kun (1): reiynii
Qoco (1): Ruu
Ruu (1): Qoco

Players Not Voting (2): Shinichi-Kun, InnocentAngel

This game uses a plurality system and does not have a lynch lock

> Countdown <

SoulEaterQUEENMar 27, 2017 12:40 PM

Mar 27, 2017 12:31 PM

#473

Offline

May 2014

7018

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:
Why haven't you voted for anyone yet, @Shinichi-kun?

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Suzune-chan said:
I'm uncertain why there is such a discussion about whether ties are good for the mafia. I guess, in my opinion I cannot see why ties are good for the mafia. However, Ruu you were the one pushing for a tie on day one, how no lynch was better. So it seems odd that your were the spear head of this conversation.

@Coromandel

I probably would have voted for followind too, mainly because of this post. So I don't find the people on his train all that suspicious, I can see why they voted for him in the end.

Coromandel I think this kind of thinking removes any of the energy from day one. Saying that it is fine and you can see it justified just covers up the reasons that people may have chosen or not chosen to be on trains. This kind of sweeping judgement ruffles my feathers a tad.

I'm super guilty of this too and I myself need be better at this. But I think we have to be careful as a group of, mafia must act like this..., because it causes too much town lynching. I'm not sure that makes sense but someone mentioned something about how mafia should act and that reminded me. Jack reminded me after my last game that anti-town moves do not mean that you are scum. Although...I might still lynch them.

-bottom of page 7-

I didn't say that we shouldn't look at people's reasons for voting, but I would have voted the same way so followind's train didn't seem all that suspicious to me at first glance. There were other things that caught *my* eye, but you're free to analyze anything you want. It's a good thing if everyone brings somethiing different to the table, imo.

Not everyone who lynches a townie is mafia, and not everyone who lynches mafia is a townie. For me, I find it often is the other way round, actually: Townies often aren't afraid of mislynching on the first day,
whereas mafia players
a) don't want to be in the spotlight (for lynching a townie), so they avoid trains - this not only makes other people not suspect them, they can then also blame the townies who were on lynch trains.
and
b) often emphasize how they don't want townies to die (because that seems like a pretty innocent thing to say, apparently)

"I'd rather have a no-lynch than mislynch a townie!"
... some people (including reiynii) said this at the end of D1, so I'm wary of them for those two reasons.

By the way, Suzune, is there no one you suspect enough to vote for them today?

If B. is true wouldnt that mean that me and ruu are 2 of ur suspects cause we do that alot.

A.If this is true then me jack and QC are innocent?

I still both A and B then on the player themselves cause everyone handles situations differently

hm.. maybe, but that's a little too black and white.
Reiynii did both A and B, plus a couple of other things that I've explained already. Lots of tells together make me think he's mafia.
Ruu for example also did both, but with her I get the impression that she was simply indecisive yesterday, and that's why she was fine with no lynch.

Well its between jack angel and rei, i think thereis 75% that innocent angel is a newbbie mafia sadly but ive been wrong before.

So.. you can't decide?

Ruu said:
@coromandel deep wolf means a mafia players that plays so well they always get town read because they look townie for the rest of the players. Is hard to find them.

Ah, thanks!

Cant decide true but i think ill end up going with angel just not yet.

I don't get why you're waiting so long - you haven't voted for anyone today. Why not?

Let me ask you something, whats the point ofasking me to vote? Basically if ur town all you do is set it up for me to look scummy when i vote when in reality i am town, so thanks for your question.

I'm not asking you *to* vote, I'm asking why you've waited until now.
Voting = pressuring people.

Mar 27, 2017 12:41 PM

#474

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:
Why haven't you voted for anyone yet, @Shinichi-kun?

Shinichi-Kun said:

coromandel said:

Suzune-chan said:
I'm uncertain why there is such a discussion about whether ties are good for the mafia. I guess, in my opinion I cannot see why ties are good for the mafia. However, Ruu you were the one pushing for a tie on day one, how no lynch was better. So it seems odd that your were the spear head of this conversation.

@Coromandel

I probably would have voted for followind too, mainly because of this post. So I don't find the people on his train all that suspicious, I can see why they voted for him in the end.

Coromandel I think this kind of thinking removes any of the energy from day one. Saying that it is fine and you can see it justified just covers up the reasons that people may have chosen or not chosen to be on trains. This kind of sweeping judgement ruffles my feathers a tad.

I'm super guilty of this too and I myself need be better at this. But I think we have to be careful as a group of, mafia must act like this..., because it causes too much town lynching. I'm not sure that makes sense but someone mentioned something about how mafia should act and that reminded me. Jack reminded me after my last game that anti-town moves do not mean that you are scum. Although...I might still lynch them.

-bottom of page 7-

I didn't say that we shouldn't look at people's reasons for voting, but I would have voted the same way so followind's train didn't seem all that suspicious to me at first glance. There were other things that caught *my* eye, but you're free to analyze anything you want. It's a good thing if everyone brings somethiing different to the table, imo.

Not everyone who lynches a townie is mafia, and not everyone who lynches mafia is a townie. For me, I find it often is the other way round, actually: Townies often aren't afraid of mislynching on the first day,
whereas mafia players
a) don't want to be in the spotlight (for lynching a townie), so they avoid trains - this not only makes other people not suspect them, they can then also blame the townies who were on lynch trains.
and
b) often emphasize how they don't want townies to die (because that seems like a pretty innocent thing to say, apparently)

"I'd rather have a no-lynch than mislynch a townie!"
... some people (including reiynii) said this at the end of D1, so I'm wary of them for those two reasons.

By the way, Suzune, is there no one you suspect enough to vote for them today?

If B. is true wouldnt that mean that me and ruu are 2 of ur suspects cause we do that alot.

A.If this is true then me jack and QC are innocent?

I still both A and B then on the player themselves cause everyone handles situations differently

hm.. maybe, but that's a little too black and white.
Reiynii did both A and B, plus a couple of other things that I've explained already. Lots of tells together make me think he's mafia.
Ruu for example also did both, but with her I get the impression that she was simply indecisive yesterday, and that's why she was fine with no lynch.

Well its between jack angel and rei, i think thereis 75% that innocent angel is a newbbie mafia sadly but ive been wrong before.

So.. you can't decide?

Ruu said:
@coromandel deep wolf means a mafia players that plays so well they always get town read because they look townie for the rest of the players. Is hard to find them.

Ah, thanks!

Cant decide true but i think ill end up going with angel just not yet.

I don't get why you're waiting so long - you haven't voted for anyone today. Why not?

Let me ask you something, whats the point ofasking me to vote? Basically if ur town all you do is set it up for me to look scummy when i vote when in reality i am town, so thanks for your question.

I'm not asking you *to* vote, I'm asking why you've waited until now.
Voting = pressuring people.

But why do i need to pressure my scum reads then 2 of them are already participating and the other i pinged i cant force him to talk.

A vote is meaningless on someone like angel till the end of the phase cause its obvious its not making him appear.

As for jack and rei regardless if we vote them they will still continue to say things that will either increase their chances of being lynched or decrease that chance. My vote won't effect that outside maybe getting 1 or the other to post more.

Mar 27, 2017 12:50 PM

#475

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

my vote option is really limited cause i dont wnna caues a tie

Mar 27, 2017 12:51 PM

#476

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

So are we good with this lynch?

Mar 27, 2017 12:54 PM

#477

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

Jackrito said:
So are we good with this lynch?

Honestly yes but are u ok being scum read if angel flips town lol

Mar 27, 2017 12:54 PM

#478

Offline

May 2014

7018

- I still like my vote for reiynii, but no one else is voting for him now. -_-
- What InnocentAngel posted didn't make much sense. Either they're confused townie or nervous newbie scum like Qoco said. It's hard to tell with those few posts.

Everyone else is pretty neutral to me.
Is it possible these two are mafia together?

Mar 27, 2017 12:56 PM

#479

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

coromandel said:
- I still like my vote for reiynii, but no one else is voting for him now. -_-
- What InnocentAngel posted didn't make much sense. Either they're confused townie or nervous newbie scum like Qoco said. It's hard to tell with those few posts.

Everyone else is pretty neutral to me.
Is it possible these two are mafia together?

rei and angel? I would help lynch rei but i cant without causing a tie

Mar 27, 2017 12:56 PM

#480

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

Jackrito said:
So are we good with this lynch?

I still want reynii more tbh buta new person is unlikely to die and easy mislynch bait late so best to remove the doubts now

Mar 27, 2017 12:56 PM

#481

Offline

May 2014

7018

Jackrito said:
So are we good with this lynch?

Kind of.

Mar 27, 2017 12:59 PM

#482

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

Shinichi-Kun said:

Jackrito said:
So are we good with this lynch?

Honestly yes but are u ok being scum read if angel flips town lol

If they flip town yeah these are the risks I take.

Mar 27, 2017 12:59 PM

#483

Offline

Aug 2014

6565

Time!

Be like this seal. It is a happy seal.
~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~

Mar 27, 2017 1:00 PM

#484

Offline

Aug 2014

6565

Final Vote Count

InnocentAngel (2): Jackrito, Suzune-chan
reiynii (1): coromandel
Shinichi-Kun (1): reiynii
Qoco (1): Ruu
Ruu (1): Qoco

Players Not Voting (2): Shinichi-Kun, InnocentAngel

Be like this seal. It is a happy seal.
~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~

Mar 27, 2017 1:01 PM

#485

Offline

Dec 2016

577

I think I'm fine with this. It's either Angel, reiynii or Ruu. I kinda have some small doubts with Shinichi too. Mostly paranoia.

Mar 27, 2017 1:01 PM

#486

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

If this is the doctor I'm so done with this game

Mar 27, 2017 1:04 PM

#487

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

That vote count though is not good we need to get more on the same page.

Mar 27, 2017 1:05 PM

#488

Offline

Aug 2014

6565

Night 2: Karaoke!

Having recovered all her sleep during the school day, but not having settled her worries,
Yui decided to go on the offensive once again. This time, she invited everyone to sing with
her in a Karaoke booth. Innocent at the surface, but yet devious. Everyone started ordering
food and Yui certainly helped out, beginning to order food for other people as well.

By the end of the night, one person stood out as having eaten a little more than everyone
else because her friends had been so generous in buying food for her. However, it was
simply too much for her to take and she collapsed, bloated.

InnocentAngel has overeaten! She was:

Please PM night actions to both me and SoulEaterQUEEN
or submit them in the mafia club.
Countdown to Day 3

Be like this seal. It is a happy seal.
~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~

Mar 27, 2017 1:06 PM

#489

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

damnit adfdsfsdfsd ok so he was actually a newbie townie

Mar 27, 2017 1:08 PM

#490

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

Damn it I need to work on working out new players. at least it means they won't be a mislynch in the late game. We can still turn this round

Mar 27, 2017 1:08 PM

#491

Offline

Dec 2016

577

gg guys.

Mar 27, 2017 1:57 PM

#492

Offline

May 2015

6405

Qoco said:
gg guys.

Says the guy that did nothing and was about to vote for him..... I don't rephrase your posts by the way that's the way I interpret them. If I get them wrong please tell me so. Your vote seem more OMGUS than anything. I look forward to get some real conversation during the night and D3

Mar 27, 2017 3:58 PM

#493

reiynii

Offline

Sep 2014

2507

I totally thought I would be dead, but I'm glad I am not.
I don't usually talk during night, but I do read what has been said. I'll reply to any posts mentioning me/poking my attention later when I have time, because I need to go out today.

I'm also glad today is night because I will be super busy tomorrow morning, most likely not making it to phase change again.

Mar 27, 2017 6:09 PM

#494

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

reiynii said:
I totally thought I would be dead, but I'm glad I am not.
I don't usually talk during night, but I do read what has been said. I'll reply to any posts mentioning me/poking my attention later when I have time, because I need to go out today.

I'm also glad today is night because I will be super busy tomorrow morning, most likely not making it to phase change again.

Why did u think u would be dead? I mean if u were i assume you would have panicked yet u didnt which is weird.

Mar 27, 2017 6:40 PM

#495

Offline

Dec 2016

577

Ruu said:

Qoco said:
gg guys.

Says the guy that did nothing and was about to vote for him..... I don't rephrase your posts by the way that's the way I interpret them. If I get them wrong please tell me so. Your vote seem more OMGUS than anything. I look forward to get some real conversation during the night and D3

You say that you don't rephrase, but right now you're taking my quote out of context. When I say "gg guys" I'm including myself. I was fine with that lynch happening, so naturally I'm not pushing out guilt. I know what OMGUS is. I wouldn't put myself in that position. Re-evaluate your reads accordingly, please :)

Mar 27, 2017 6:44 PM

#496

Offline

May 2015

6405

Okay - so I was in the middle of a class when I saw the phase change post so now I'll give you my thoughts on the matter:

- This is what I feared but we can put blame on other people because I think IA was hard to read because he just sounded lost without giving away much about his alignment.
- Like I already told Qoco, I wasn't changing the meaning of his words, I was translated them into what I thought they meant. I still think that he is scum.
- We lost another townie but there is still hope because they didn't get a kill during N1 - hopefully they'll fail again tonight *fingers crossed*

- I also fear that now we scared him away lol and we were so happy with having new players ;-; we don't bite please don't leave us InnocentAngel T___T

Mar 28, 2017 1:11 AM

#497

InnocentAngel

Offline

Mar 2017

20

Sorry I didn't do much tho..... well its actually pretty better being lynched rather than making it more confused.

Btw is there any threads/discussions where I can ask for advice or how should I play the game?

Mar 28, 2017 1:46 AM

#498

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

InnocentAngel said:
Sorry I didn't do much tho..... well its actually pretty better being lynched rather than making it more confused.

Btw is there any threads/discussions where I can ask for advice or how should I play the game?

I just send you a PM with some links to help.

Mar 28, 2017 1:01 PM

#499

Offline

Aug 2014

6565

Day 3: It Feels Chilly In Here

Karaoke yielded no results. Yui simply could not find the attackers. There hadn't been
any more attacks, so maybe she should just stop worrying. After a fun night singing,
everyone went home happy.

The next day arrived and everyone went to school as usual. Everyone except one. She
had caught a cold the night before because someone had turned her thermostat way
down in the middle of the night unexpectedly. It was another attack! With so many of
her friends out of action, Yui was now very worried.

Jackrito has caught a cold! She was:

Countdown to Night 3

PentaFlareMar 28, 2017 1:05 PM

Be like this seal. It is a happy seal.
~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~

Mar 28, 2017 1:50 PM

#500