| The mighty masterpiece known as code geassuckass |
Pullman said: I hold no shame in it. The anime made me both deathly bored and absolutely furious. CodeBlazeFate said: Yeah, it's during me out, too. I shouldn't even be wasting my time takinbabout such a crap show that doesn't even remotely try to entertain. Got bigger, fuglier fish to fry (Hand Shakers). You like going for the low-hanging fruit, don't you? :> Also Everything that was so bad/gets criticized about Mahouka was also what made it fun for me. It was so clichéd it came out the other end and ended up being a fun watch, even tho I can't take it seriously. But entertain it did for sure, whether you see it or not. I certainly had fun with the show. I'm never gonna defend it against criticism but I'm not gonna pretend I wasn't entertained by all the shenanigans either ^^. To each their own. Some people enjoy that stuff both unironically and ironically. I has no fun front whatsoever since I could tell that it didn't want to entertain, but if it made you like it ir Nicely (or even unironically), that's fine. I'll still kick it's ass any day of the week. Not for an every blower having fruit, one that made me die a bit inside and turn into a vengeful and ruthless being on the internet: Hand Shakers. |
| Being wrong is just an occupational hazard. Follow me on twitter. I have an anitube channel so feel free to check it out and subscribe if you like what you see. |
| Big, f*cking, Order. A trainwreck off badness that makes Mirai Nikki look like a masterpiece. I've never been so disappointed by an anime... |
 |
| Surprised no one said Gantz. Plot holes everywhere. And the worst part? The show had two seasons and is still incomplete and didn't explain anything about it's shit ending that wasn't even canon (which also makes no sense because the manga was ahead of the anime) |
   |
CodeBlazeFate said: It may not have said that in the anime, I can't remember, but I know it was implied that he was working on it for awhile at least.When did he say he was working on flight for years, again? I never Neco netted thet dialogue. Love is not just some emotion like anger or happiness. It's much more complicated and different than that, and it produces other emotions like happiness, but is not an emotion in and of itself. Besides, if all of his strong emotions are erased, the how come he can still feel immense anger? At least, going based off the anime alone? I said all, accept his feelings for Miyuki. He can feel strong emotions like immense anger when her well being is at risk and suchSo, two vintage and rarely used CADs thet he got in episode 3 are some of the finest around? Finer than possibly a lot of what everyone else has? Well he designed and made them with the help of the division he helps run in his fathers company, and they are specifically designed for only his use. That's not something every run in the mill mage can do or have access to. I guess thet explains it. Maybe it falls under Mary Sue moment rather than plothole moment, but it's had writing nonetheless, not just because Mary Sue moment, but also since it took him less than 2 seconds to do all of that with a sniper wound to the heart and it took him longer to recover from an attack from Miyuki in episode 4 (if I'm remembering the number correctly). They happen at the same speed really, where his body is shown recovering in the information dimension, is something happening instantaneously realtime like the scene with the sniper. |
-MahesvaraMar 15, 2017 7:39 AM
My Queens  |
| Personally, Chaos:Head adaptation left a lot of things out. Any adaptation in general which tries to rush is likely to have plot holes. |
 |
Askorti said: OppaiSugoi said: Obligatory SAO plot armor for kirito-kun. Obligatorily I would like to ask you to elaborate. - Rushed development of nonexistent Asuna to "Chapter 16.5" nyan nyan by the lakehouse. - Timeskip in ep3. - Kayaba "forgot" why he trapped the players in the game. - Kirito & Asuna was supposed to die in the battle against Heathcliff, nope, deus ex machina pls. But since you have SAO on your favorites and rated it an 8, fuck my reasoning right? |
 |
| Code Geass, Fairy Tail and Mirai Nikki |
 |
| The whole logic of NHK rests on the idea that the world is overall a friendly place and outcasts should man up. It's an anime made way, way before Rene Descartes wrote a word. |
| WEAPONS - My blog, for reviews of music, anime, books, and other things |
OneNaughtyBear said: Surprised no one said Gantz. Plot holes everywhere. And the worst part? The show had two seasons and is still incomplete and didn't explain anything about it's shit ending that wasn't even canon (which also makes no sense because the manga was ahead of the anime) Can I nominate FLCL? It didn't make any sense and didn't explain anything! OppaiSugoi said: - Rushed development of nonexistent Asuna to "Chapter 16.5" nyan nyan by the lakehouse. - Timeskip in ep3. - Kayaba "forgot" why he trapped the players in the game. - Kirito & Asuna was supposed to die in the battle against Heathcliff, nope, deus ex machina pls. Timeskips and deus ex machinae do not count as plot holes by themselves. Neither does "rushing" anything (though as Askorti has said, their relationship developed on a believable timeframe). As for forgetting... can you truly remember why did you make all major decisions in your life? (did you make any decisions yet? Your profile indicates you were not yet born.) Do you have the heart to tell your real reasons to teenage children who had to face death numerous times because of what you've done? Kayaba is not exactly a honest person. |
| Wicked City. The ending revelation pretty much rendered everything that transpired in the film pointless. And that's a damn shame because I normally like Yoshiaki Kawajiri. |
Take care of yourself |
| what a hard to answer question i have no idea what i watched had the most plotholes of course the easy answer would be one of the long running shonen since they have this gigantc contunuity it is way more easy to contradict itself and create plotholes even when comparing to some nonsensical short anime and i still do not find that much of a reason to complain about them those plotholes are a natural effect of what those are trying to do and the ambitious nature of some of those is enough make me forgive them for some of the issues |
TheBrainintheJar said: The whole logic of NHK rests on the idea that the world is overall a friendly place and outcasts should man up. It's an anime made way, way before Rene Descartes wrote a word. I think the question here bends on holes in a fantasy or sci-fi type anime. Or just about any show that makes rules of its own and proceeds to break them. |
Deknijff said: pretty sure everyone is just going to say a show to trigger people or something they don't like so here is mine for the second one https://myanimelist.net/anime/9756/Mahou_Shoujo_Madoka_Magica Sure, it has some nice holes: But Rebellion movie is absolute garbage, so I can give you that. OneNaughtyBear said: Surprised no one said Gantz. Plot holes everywhere. And the worst part? The show had two seasons and is still incomplete and didn't explain anything about it's shit ending that wasn't even canon (which also makes no sense because the manga was ahead of the anime) Well, anime is shit adaptation. It simply doesn't exist. :)))) Although I agree Gantz is more of a shock-factor manga, I don't remember having many serious plot issues. |
AquamirrorMar 15, 2017 11:17 AM
 |
Pixel_Vapour said: Deknijff said: What plot holes are there in Madoka Magica? I've watched it twice but haven't picked up on any glaring obvious ones.pretty sure everyone is just going to say a show to trigger people or something they don't like so here is mine for the second one https://myanimelist.net/anime/9756/Mahou_Shoujo_Madoka_Magica Aquamirror said: surprised 2 people quoted me when I wasn't being seriousDeknijff said: pretty sure everyone is just going to say a show to trigger people or something they don't like so here is mine for the second one https://myanimelist.net/anime/9756/Mahou_Shoujo_Madoka_Magica Sure, it has some nice holes: But Rebellion movie is absolute garbage, so I can give you that. Pixel every show will have some kind of problem but I don't care enough about the show to remember the holes and I don't want to be an ignorant person who will just question the plot because I can't think of any valid criticism of the show Aqua I found the show to be garbage too not just the movie |
 |
Deknijff said: surprised 2 people quoted me when I wasn't being serious Pixel every show will have some kind of problem but I don't care enough about the show to remember the holes and I don't want to be an ignorant person who will just question the plot because I can't think of any valid criticism of the show Aqua I found the show to be garbage too not just the movie I know you were joking bro. XD ... at least you have slightly less shit taste for hating Rebellion, that shit was bad indeed :))) Not every problem is a plot hole though.. A lot of people often miss out things and claim them as plot holes. Personally, I don't think I've watched anything that horrible, but usually the popular waifu-bait shows have some of the most atrocious plots. And of course they are fucking LN adaptations. @Tenshi_Shura // |
|
Aquamirror said: bringing back good memories Deknijff said: I know you were joking bro. XDsurprised 2 people quoted me when I wasn't being serious Pixel every show will have some kind of problem but I don't care enough about the show to remember the holes and I don't want to be an ignorant person who will just question the plot because I can't think of any valid criticism of the show Aqua I found the show to be garbage too not just the movie Not every problem is a plot hole though.. A lot of people often miss out things and claim them as plot holes. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1594380 thank you Aqua |
|
| Parasyte had that one plot hole that was easily worth 10 But I still enjoyed the rest of the show :] |
 |
AltoRoark said: TheBrainintheJar said: The whole logic of NHK rests on the idea that the world is overall a friendly place and outcasts should man up. It's an anime made way, way before Rene Descartes wrote a word. I think the question here bends on holes in a fantasy or sci-fi type anime. Or just about any show that makes rules of its own and proceeds to break them. Sci-Fi/Fantasy have rules no different than realist fiction. By that, I mean that the rules are always about how a story is told, not about 'rules of the world'. All these rules are arbitrary anyway. |
| WEAPONS - My blog, for reviews of music, anime, books, and other things |
imeli said: HamburgerSpike said: Gintama has the most plotholes of any shitty show watching it so far i wouldn't say there are plot holes, but really no plot at all. Ye, maybe youre right Mushishi has much more plotholes, like for example what are these mushis anyway? Some people see them some dont so do they exist or not? plot hole. I bet the creator took drugs when making it. hehe XDD |
 Oshii is probably the only director that loves dogs. He thinks he's a dog himself. That's right, its slime! It will dissolve your clothing slowly before my eyes! |
| Hollywood has the most plot holes .. |
 |
| Fairy Tail may have a lot of plot twists and wtf moments, but everything is usually explained afterwards so I wouldn't say it has as many plot holes as people are saying on this forum. |
 |
| Neon Genesis Evangelion had a couple. |
 Three things cannot be long hidden.. ...the s u n, the m oo n, and the tr u th. |
HamburgerSpike said: Hey wait a minute! Gintama has a plot?!Gintama has the most plotholes of any shitty show |
| Dragon Ball Z maybe. I don't know, I don't tally this shit. |
 |
HamburgerSpike said: Ye, maybe youre right Mushishi has much more plotholes, like for example what are these mushis anyway? Some people see them some dont so do they exist or not? plot hole. I bet the creator took drugs when making it. hehe XDD I suggest you won't think how the mushi functions, but what they represent, what is the symbolism behind it. |
| WEAPONS - My blog, for reviews of music, anime, books, and other things |
| Cross Ange and Code Geass Season 2 probably (But i don't remember most of them by now) Even though people say "Mirai Nikki" i don't actually remember it's plotholes. So let's give new names to the list: Charllote and JoJo part 3 |
thewiruMar 17, 2017 2:34 PM
| My favorite anime obviously...... |
Please learn about cel animation and its technical process. Learn how special effects and backlighting were done without computers. |
| The Pokemon series, because Satoshi should have died long ago the number of times he was poisoned, electrocuted, turned in stone, turned into ice, in fire... |
 |
TheBrainintheJar said: HamburgerSpike said: Ye, maybe youre right Mushishi has much more plotholes, like for example what are these mushis anyway? Some people see them some dont so do they exist or not? plot hole. I bet the creator took drugs when making it. hehe XDD I suggest you won't think how the mushi functions, but what they represent, what is the symbolism behind it. yea the guy you replied to seems to have missed the whole point of the show or he's trolling (i think the latter) |
cash carti |
TheBrainintheJar said: AltoRoark said: I think the question here bends on holes in a fantasy or sci-fi type anime. Or just about any show that makes rules of its own and proceeds to break them. Sci-Fi/Fantasy have rules no different than realist fiction. By that, I mean that the rules are always about how a story is told, not about 'rules of the world'. All these rules are arbitrary anyway. No, these rules are set for the story to work around. An example is how Lelouch's geass works only once on a person. That isn't arbitrary at all. |
| Gants has quite a few I would say its better as a comedy anyway tho. |
| Surprised on the little mentions to DBZ xD My fav ever but it's undeniable it has several plot holes and continuity errors |
AltoRoark said: TheBrainintheJar said: Sci-Fi/Fantasy have rules no different than realist fiction. By that, I mean that the rules are always about how a story is told, not about 'rules of the world'. All these rules are arbitrary anyway. No, these rules are set for the story to work around. An example is how Lelouch's geass works only once on a person. That isn't arbitrary at all. Lelouch's Geass rule is a self-imposed mechanic whose purpose is to limit the storytelling in one way. Nothing prevents the storytellers from breaking it, pulling an ad hoc reason and coming up with a great story. There is no reason to obey that law completely. You can always break it and explain why. If this seems weird to you, remember that the world is a weird place and laws always end up being wrong. We have no reason to think the characters are authorities on anything. 400degrees said: TheBrainintheJar said: I suggest you won't think how the mushi functions, but what they represent, what is the symbolism behind it. yea the guy you replied to seems to have missed the whole point of the show or he's trolling (i think the latter) I don't think so. A problem in Fantasy/Sci-Fi fandoms is exepctations of too much realism, wanting explanations for everything. As if it really matters, because none of it exists anyway. |
| WEAPONS - My blog, for reviews of music, anime, books, and other things |
TheBrainintheJar said: AltoRoark said: No, these rules are set for the story to work around. An example is how Lelouch's geass works only once on a person. That isn't arbitrary at all. Lelouch's Geass rule is a self-imposed mechanic whose purpose is to limit the storytelling in one way. Nothing prevents the storytellers from breaking it, pulling an ad hoc reason and coming up with a great story. There is no reason to obey that law completely. You can always break it and explain why. If this seems weird to you, remember that the world is a weird place and laws always end up being wrong. We have no reason to think the characters are authorities on anything. It wouldn't be a plot hole if they explained why. It would be if the rule was broken without any reason whatsoever. |
AltoRoark said: TheBrainintheJar said: Lelouch's Geass rule is a self-imposed mechanic whose purpose is to limit the storytelling in one way. Nothing prevents the storytellers from breaking it, pulling an ad hoc reason and coming up with a great story. There is no reason to obey that law completely. You can always break it and explain why. If this seems weird to you, remember that the world is a weird place and laws always end up being wrong. We have no reason to think the characters are authorities on anything. It wouldn't be a plot hole if they explained why. It would be if the rule was broken without any reason whatsoever. What kind of 'why' do you want? Does the mechanism has any meaning? Is talking about neuro-transmitters meaningful or interesting? |
| WEAPONS - My blog, for reviews of music, anime, books, and other things |
TheBrainintheJar said: AltoRoark said: It wouldn't be a plot hole if they explained why. It would be if the rule was broken without any reason whatsoever. What kind of 'why' do you want? Does the mechanism has any meaning? Is talking about neuro-transmitters meaningful or interesting? I legitimately don't know what you're asking here. If the reasoning for going against the rule is logical, then it's reason enough. Otherwise it wouldn't make any sense and would feel contrived and unnatural. |
mattao313 said: Gants has quite a few I would say its better as a comedy anyway tho. Should've read the manga instead bro :/ |
AltoRoark said: TheBrainintheJar said: What kind of 'why' do you want? Does the mechanism has any meaning? Is talking about neuro-transmitters meaningful or interesting? I legitimately don't know what you're asking here. If the reasoning for going against the rule is logical, then it's reason enough. Otherwise it wouldn't make any sense and would feel contrived and unnatural. The Geass doesn't exist. It only controls people because the creators wrote a scene which goes BZZZZZT and suddenly the character does whatever Lelouch asks. So I'm asking what kind of 'rules' does it break - does it set up a theme and ignore/bury it? Do you want to know the neuro explanation of it? What kind of explanation do you want? I can explain to you either that the Force in Star Wars is some bacteria in the brains that gives them power. I can also explain to you the meaning behind it. What kind do you want? |
| WEAPONS - My blog, for reviews of music, anime, books, and other things |
More topics from this board
» Has the isekai bubble finally burstEastIndiaCompany - 2 hours ago |
14 |
by BilboBaggins365
»»
42 seconds ago |
|
» Credit cards companies are forcing the Hentai industryDije - 4 hours ago |
21 |
by MichaelJackson
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » So, is anime male or female?Tirinchas - Yesterday |
33 |
by W3TFT
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» im kinda new to animethefoxkiller12 - Apr 29, 2022 |
18 |
by MichaelJackson
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Bare feet or pantyhoses?Absurdo_N - 2 hours ago |
6 |
by FanofAction
»»
10 minutes ago |