GhostOutOfShell said:RobinVPersie said:
Do you think they have bad taste or do you think they're naive and haven't seen a lot of Anime?
I am more interested why is school days in this list? Funny fact, it's quite respected by more critical viewers and really hated by newcomers so idk that's a weird choice considering the point of this topic.
@Fang There is still diference between subjective and objective in art, implying otherwise raises quite a few problems tbh, there is nothing wrong to like show for subjective reasons even if it's not that good objectively tho.
If only art was as simple as 1+2 = 3. Of course there is objectivity in art, for eg, plot holes, but it is surely limited.
Art is mostly subjective, and is meant to be interpreted differently by each individual through there own perspective, the very fact that you think art should be looked at on a one dimensaional view, irritates me. Discussion would not even exist, if we all have the same perspective.
I can proof to you why art is not objective, all your friends on mal including @Marrone that was praising you on your statements, all rate anime differently from you, where each one of you, even if you guys have similar taste will still have different opinions on some anime than you, you know why is that? because we are unique beings, with different thoughts and perspective.
Answer me this, have you ever not have a intelligent discussion with someone where they explain why they like a series that you didn't, and even though you don't agree with him, you can at least understand the reason why he liked that series? Isn't that proof enough that art can be interpreted differently? Not only that, a person can like the same series as you, but for a completely different reason.
Art not being objective does not stop you from disliking or liking a anime, the whole purpose of all of us here, is to discuss anime with each other, and give reasons why we think this anime isn't good or vice versa.
It honestly seems like to me is that, if you guys let go of this objective none sense, your entire world will come crashing down. I know that the main reason why you guys want to believe in objectivity in art is because you guys want to feel a sense of superiority.
I'm not telling you guys to like every anime, I'm not telling any of you to change your opinion. All I'm saying is to stop using the word "objective" to try and put your unique opinion above someone else unique opinion.
Instead of using "objective" as a way of saying you are right, use your arguments and your own opinion on why you think these anime are bad.
Guess what? I too can go around spouting the word "objective" and claiming my opinion to be the truth. Anyone can do it, not just you. |