Fairy Tail Chapter 518 Discussion

Jan 23, 2017 2:24 AM

#51

Soniclover42

Offline

Jun 2016

27

The BS is over 9000!!!!!!

Seriously shonen really hold back on the meteor power

Jan 23, 2017 3:40 AM

#52

TheGrandSage23

Offline

Mar 2014

547

I'm sorry but this arc has been more of a chore to read. Back in Tartaros there were flaws(like every other arc) but it was clear Hiro was doing everything he could to bring his A game. My third favorite after Phantom and TOH

This just feels like padding. I can't explain it exactly. Obviously this Erza bullshit has to stop.. I think people in Japan love Erza when she does unrealistic things and Hiro has no reason not to stop I guess but come one I somehow find this worse than Kyouka

But besides that this arc just feels not needed. 465 is still one of my favorite chapters considering it contains 2 of the 3 characters this arc should be focused on

Jan 23, 2017 9:55 AM

#53

Wim

Offline

Aug 2013

3083

Eatos6 said:
Uuuuuuh
At this point, or maybe since 1 or 2 months, I only care about Natsu and Acnologia.
There's no more hype for others characters..

I feel the same except for Gildarts. Want to see him smash August and go face to face with Acnologia once again.

As for the chapter, it was ok but so bloody predictable. Can Mashima think of anything original or does he just want to copy paste crap from every other popular shonen?

Jan 23, 2017 12:56 PM

#54

Dead_By_Heart

Offline

Jan 2016

985

now this got me kinda emotional and somewhat confuted a bit but quite interesting. Erza.. Queen of the faires! little to much OP okey i still love FT.

cause MAL is doing there job for once.

Jan 23, 2017 12:57 PM

#55

vanillaskynet

Offline

Nov 2016

266

Um I feel like the more I read this arc, the more disappointed I get. The Spriggan 12 were hyped up as the toughest, dangerous, extremely skilled and powerful mages around and at first I believed the hype after first seeing Ajeel Ramal fight off fairy tail as they fled the Alvarez Empire and Brandish turn an island to a rock. I was especially intrigued and fascinated by Irene Belserion, but her fight with Erza and Wendy and pretty much the "fight for fairy tail" has been a bit of a let down, people die, everyone cry then they come back life (referring to fairy tail members), I thought this arc was going to change the mood of the series and be a lot darker. I was ready to see the series "grow up"and even have some deaths since it might as well be the last(eventful) arc. Every fight just shows how lame the spriggan 12 is now and they're all anticlimactic. I'm especially disappointed in how Irene is treated, she's supposed to be an old, wise and powerful mage but you would have to be dumb enough to think switching bodies with a person who also happens to use the same kind of magic you use without first defeating them and still have another person you're fighting to be a good idea. Now she's a dragon, so basically more power boast only to be defeated by the power of "friendship". The worst part is when most of fairy tail fought and defeated their opponents they didn't kill or wound them so they presented no threats in the immediate future....

vanillaskynetJan 23, 2017 1:06 PM

Jan 23, 2017 1:13 PM

#56

vanillaskynet

Offline

Nov 2016

266

I stopped reading this manga a few months ago, but since it was a new year and I heard Irene had finally confronted Erza, I was excited to catch up but I wish I hadn't.... now the only reason why I keep reading is to see a possible natsu vs acnologia fight (I'm guessing the reason why acnologia is not shown yet is because of the possible upcoming confrontation)

Jan 23, 2017 2:46 PM

#57

Aredros

Offline

May 2009

317

vanillaskynet said:
I stopped reading this manga a few months ago, but since it was a new year and I heard Irene had finally confronted Erza, I was excited to catch up but I wish I hadn't.... now the only reason why I keep reading is to see a possible natsu vs acnologia fight (I'm guessing the reason why acnologia is not shown yet is because of the possible upcoming confrontation)

Its really sad, because even if I dont actually like-like FT (I just read it because its a weekly short read) I liked the character of Irene and her design, and now her fight-backstory is one of the most half-assed-bullshitiest fight-backstory

Jan 23, 2017 6:33 PM

#58

saltncheese

Offline

Apr 2011

562

Next week!

Erza will be dying after taking on the meteor, Irene will pity her, swap bodies with her, Erza survives in Irene's body, Irene finally get's the body she wants and dies in it.

4 8 15 16 23 42 4 8 15 16 23 42 4 8 15 16 23 42 4 8 15 16 23 42

http://putridcheese.deviantart.com
http://www.booksie.com/tosh/
http://stoptazmo.com/

Jan 23, 2017 7:30 PM

#59

Im_Indifferent

Offline

Jan 2017

1

Okay so I get the whole daughter and mother/ Queen of faires-Queen of dragons. But after the meteor Erza better go down into natsus arms or something because

1. She has been fighting for forever now.
2. Only Dragon slayers can kill Dragons, unless they totally bs that fact now.
3. Natsu needs to make a big entry and just demolish Irene like she was in the way or something.

Also- super pissed about them hyping rahkeid for nothing, I mean seriously?

Zeref vs acno vs natsu
Mavis vs rahkeid
And guildarts and/or Cana should definitely play a role in the fight with acno/zeref.

(Guildarts because his beef with acno maybe, and Cana because Mavis hyped up the fairy heart shit)

Jan 23, 2017 9:59 PM

#60

ziggy_Z

Offline

Mar 2014

4596

My goodness! Irene is such a terrific villain. Erza proving once again she's the best ever heroine. Goddamn... this manga, such a fucking masterpiece.

Jan 24, 2017 12:42 AM

#61

Yehart

Offline

Jul 2014

10251

This chapter was pretty cool.

Then that last part happened.

"Hi!"

Jan 24, 2017 9:41 PM

#62

VLP_Senna

Offline

Feb 2015

37

saltncheese said:
Next week!

Erza will be dying after taking on the meteor, Irene will pity her, swap bodies with her, Erza survives in Irene's body, Irene finally get's the body she wants and dies in it.

YES! I was thinking this as I read that chapter too, :D . Good, now this theory has a following.
Just as long as the ending isn't super basic, ie. Erza wins against the meteor and Irene is forgiven.

Jan 25, 2017 6:11 AM

#63

Isterio

Offline

Oct 2013

4275

DeLegendarySwag said:

saltncheese said:
Next week!

Erza will be dying after taking on the meteor, Irene will pity her, swap bodies with her, Erza survives in Irene's body, Irene finally get's the body she wants and dies in it.

YES! I was thinking this as I read that chapter too, :D . Good, now this theory has a following.
Just as long as the ending isn't super basic, ie. Erza wins against the meteor and Irene is forgiven.

What´s the point of this.

That theory makes zero sense.

1. It goes against everything established between Irene and Erza. The whole biological family vs spiritual family, notion, thrown out the window.
2. It goes against everything Irene was established as and has not a single ounce of foreshadowing.
3. This would have major repercussions for Erza, both bodies look different and she would a be fucking Dragon, that transforms into a humna. Hiro barely writes his story with repercussions for the good guys and never for the Main cast. What you guys demand was never there in the series. Why would he start now instead of just delivering his predictable shit?
4. It adds zero flavor to the story if they immediately find a convenient solution afterwards to have Erza turn back into her body or look the same and if she doesn´t, which would never happen because all her marketability and her recognizeability would go poof, it adds nothing besides a changed character design, because Hiro Mashima is not an author that would go in depth with the consequences of living in someone elses body. How do i know that I read 518 chapters of this shit.

5. Now to the most retarded part of all that. Irene actively tried to do that and it failed. Why would it work now?

There theory dismissed, go home and do your homework.

Jan 25, 2017 5:58 PM

#64

saltncheese

Offline

Apr 2011

562

Isterio said:
There theory dismissed, go home and do your homework.

1. Realization of familial love, villain redemption. Shounen themes.
2. Foreshadowing? There was a time that Irene loved her child.
3. It is in fact the more predictable road he would take. Shounen themes, of love, friendship, camaraderie, family.
4. Lots of flavor. Same flavor as Gajeel turning good. Same as Angel turning good. Same as Sabretooth becoming friendly with FT.
5. Irene actively tried before and failed. In the heat of the moment she figures out how it works... through family.

I ain't saying it'll come true, cuz it's just a theory, a manga theory.

4 8 15 16 23 42 4 8 15 16 23 42 4 8 15 16 23 42 4 8 15 16 23 42

http://putridcheese.deviantart.com
http://www.booksie.com/tosh/
http://stoptazmo.com/

Jan 25, 2017 6:06 PM

#65

vanillaskynet

Offline

Nov 2016

266

Isterio said:

DeLegendarySwag said:

YES! I was thinking this as I read that chapter too, :D . Good, now this theory has a following.
Just as long as the ending isn't super basic, ie. Erza wins against the meteor and Irene is forgiven.

What´s the point of this.

That theory makes zero sense.

1. It goes against everything established between Irene and Erza. The whole biological family vs spiritual family, notion, thrown out the window.
2. It goes against everything Irene was established as and has not a single ounce of foreshadowing.
3. This would have major repercussions for Erza, both bodies look different and she would a be fucking Dragon, that transforms into a humna. Hiro barely writes his story with repercussions for the good guys and never for the Main cast. What you guys demand was never there in the series. Why would he start now instead of just delivering his predictable shit?
4. It adds zero flavor to the story if they immediately find a convenient solution afterwards to have Erza turn back into her body or look the same and if she doesn´t, which would never happen because all her marketability and her recognizeability would go poof, it adds nothing besides a changed character design, because Hiro Mashima is not an author that would go in depth with the consequences of living in someone elses body. How do i know that I read 518 chapters of this shit.

5. Now to the most retarded part of all that. Irene actively tried to do that and it failed. Why would it work now?

There theory dismissed, go home and do your homework.

@Isterio lol I loved that reply, I'm glad you said it because I wanted to but dreaded having to disprove such a stupid theory. I don't think these kids are actually READING the manga because if they were they will first of all realize how silly and anticlimactic this last few chapters have been...

Jan 25, 2017 6:16 PM

#66

vanillaskynet

Offline

Nov 2016

266

saltncheese said:

Isterio said:
There theory dismissed, go home and do your homework.

1. Realization of familial love, villain redemption. Shounen themes.
2. Foreshadowing? There was a time that Irene loved her child.
3. It is in fact the more predictable road he would take. Shounen themes, of love, friendship, camaraderie, family.
4. Lots of flavor. Same flavor as Gajeel turning good. Same as Angel turning good. Same as Sabretooth becoming friendly with FT.
5. Irene actively tried before and failed. In the heat of the moment she figures out how it works... through family.

I ain't saying it'll come true, cuz it's just a theory, a manga theory.

What do you mean by "lots of flavor"? I admit that there might be a possibility of Irene at least saving her daughter because she feels sorry or pity her but will not switch bodies with her because she simply cannot do that and "in the heat of the moment and through family?? (I didn't know through family was a power) will not change that and if the mangaka does that then I will drop this manga because that's the most dumbest plot/story idea ever and makes no sense at all, but then again this manga has been very bad lately....so you might just be right

Jan 25, 2017 8:31 PM

#67

saltncheese

Offline

Apr 2011

562

vanillaskynet said:

saltncheese said:

1. Realization of familial love, villain redemption. Shounen themes.
2. Foreshadowing? There was a time that Irene loved her child.
3. It is in fact the more predictable road he would take. Shounen themes, of love, friendship, camaraderie, family.
4. Lots of flavor. Same flavor as Gajeel turning good. Same as Angel turning good. Same as Sabretooth becoming friendly with FT.
5. Irene actively tried before and failed. In the heat of the moment she figures out how it works... through family.

I ain't saying it'll come true, cuz it's just a theory, a manga theory.

What do you mean by "lots of flavor"? I admit that there might be a possibility of Irene at least saving her daughter because she feels sorry or pity her but will not switch bodies with her because she simply cannot do that and "in the heat of the moment and through family?? (I didn't know through family was a power) will not change that and if the mangaka does that then I will drop this manga because that's the most dumbest plot/story idea ever and makes no sense at all, but then again this manga has been very bad lately....so you might just be right

We haven't been reading the same manga if you think something so pulled-far-up-the-ass could never happen. You aren't even pushing the envelope of ludicrosity that Mashima can come up with. Stupid theory you say? I just have a healthy imagination in trying to fathom this manga's frequently tangential narrative direction.

4 8 15 16 23 42 4 8 15 16 23 42 4 8 15 16 23 42 4 8 15 16 23 42

http://putridcheese.deviantart.com
http://www.booksie.com/tosh/
http://stoptazmo.com/

Jan 26, 2017 12:00 AM

#68

VLP_Senna

Offline

Feb 2015

37

Isterio said:

DeLegendarySwag said:

YES! I was thinking this as I read that chapter too, :D . Good, now this theory has a following.
Just as long as the ending isn't super basic, ie. Erza wins against the meteor and Irene is forgiven.

What´s the point of this.

That theory makes zero sense.

1. It goes against everything established between Irene and Erza. The whole biological family vs spiritual family, notion, thrown out the window.
2. It goes against everything Irene was established as and has not a single ounce of foreshadowing.
3. This would have major repercussions for Erza, both bodies look different and she would a be fucking Dragon, that transforms into a humna. Hiro barely writes his story with repercussions for the good guys and never for the Main cast. What you guys demand was never there in the series. Why would he start now instead of just delivering his predictable shit?
4. It adds zero flavor to the story if they immediately find a convenient solution afterwards to have Erza turn back into her body or look the same and if she doesn´t, which would never happen because all her marketability and her recognizeability would go poof, it adds nothing besides a changed character design, because Hiro Mashima is not an author that would go in depth with the consequences of living in someone elses body. How do i know that I read 518 chapters of this shit.

5. Now to the most retarded part of all that. Irene actively tried to do that and it failed. Why would it work now?

There theory dismissed, go home and do your homework.

Chill dude. The theory would be cool in my opinion, but there's no way it'll actually happen cuz your right on a lot of those points, plus I don't think that's how Mashima roles. Still though, hoping for something unexpected, you know.

Jan 26, 2017 4:17 AM

#69

Isterio

Offline

Oct 2013

4275

DeLegendarySwag said:

Chill dude. The theory would be cool in my opinion, but there's no way it'll actually happen cuz your right on a lot of those points, plus I don't think that's how Mashima roles. Still though, hoping for something unexpected, you know.

I´d be cool to have Naruto and Luffy in this series and see them have a banter with the Fairy Tail characters, but that´s still fanfiction.

I´d be cool to have a Hiro Mashima drawn hentai of all the girls in the series besides the kids. Well, can´t have everything.

IsterioJan 26, 2017 4:20 AM

Jan 26, 2017 3:44 PM

#70

VLP_Senna

Offline

Feb 2015

37

Isterio said:

I´d be cool to have Naruto and Luffy in this series and see them have a banter with the Fairy Tail characters, but that´s still fanfiction.

I´d be cool to have a Hiro Mashima drawn hentai of all the girls in the series besides the kids. Well, can´t have everything.

If that's what your into then I guess that'd be cool. You're right, thus the reason I said "there's no way that'll actually happen"

Feb 4, 2017 4:10 PM

#71

Romeo

Offline

Mar 2008

885

what a cringey dialogue.. sigh

May 11, 2017 8:40 AM

#72

ibraheem234

Offline

Dec 2014

12508

well that dragon transformation though....Erza stop the meteoroid

Aug 17, 2018 2:57 AM

#73

Ulquiorra

Offline

Feb 2013

24143

Lol, now she is going to be Goku vs Piccolo Daimao?

Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 275 Discussion ( 1 2 ) DuroDeMatar - Mar 16, 2012	52	by aod-kun »» 3 hours ago
Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 268 Discussion ( 1 2 ) BackLashWave - Jan 27, 2012	52	by aod-kun »» Apr 23, 6:16 AM
Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 46 Discussion Cali4nian - Oct 12, 2009	10	by MAYANK22 »» Apr 21, 11:30 AM
Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 418 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) Darklight0303 - Feb 2, 2015	185	by shinytrains »» Apr 13, 1:00 AM
Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 251 Discussion ( 1 2 ) kevin_video - Sep 17, 2011	81	by aod-kun »» Apr 6, 5:15 AM

Fairy Tail Chapter 518 Discussion

More topics from this board

Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 275 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 268 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 46 Discussion

Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 418 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Poll: » Fairy Tail Chapter 251 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Preview MangaManga Store

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters