| Sounds awfully generic. |
| Good, another recarnation anime. (The LN is ok/good but nothing amazing) I hope they continue this trend so that we get adaptions of something like Kumo desu ga, Nani ka?, Tate no Yuusha, Spirit Migration or Seirei Gensouki... That would be great. EDIT: Eh? Heibon desu yo?? is quite good too as it got a female MC (And writer) so I wouldn't mind that one either. |
RabbiacSep 22, 2016 10:31 PM
 |
| Another LN adaptation. I await with relaxed breath. |
 |
| Thank goodness there will be an anime for this. I can just follow this anime without waiting the LN and the manga. This need a decent studio and I am too expecting a decent action~ |
  |
IndigoBangarang said: yeah, I lowkey hoped that Konosuba and Re:zero would be failures, so that Isekai wouldnt get too popular, but oh well most LN fads don't last much longer than 2-3 years. Anyways, mecha + isekai + shota MC are like my least favorite things, so I'm probably skipping this. Other than concept those two aren't representative of it's typical genre conventions at all, which is why their popular to begin with. |
Jagd84 said: IndigoBangarang said: yeah, I lowkey hoped that Konosuba and Re:zero would be failures, so that Isekai wouldnt get too popular, but oh well most LN fads don't last much longer than 2-3 years. Anyways, mecha + isekai + shota MC are like my least favorite things, so I'm probably skipping this. Other than concept those two aren't representative of it's typical genre conventions at all, which is why their popular to begin with. True, so far japan has done a good job with not adapting the most generic kind of Isekai. (well maybe besides this one, but it still has the mecha aspect) I'm not a fan of the Isekai trope, but I guess when it is done in a unique way its okay. I'm just worried that they will soon adapt all the trashy ones, that literally go like " I got incarnated as an OP cheat magician in a fantasy game like world." |
gophercg said: Isekai silver haired half elf cute trap mech otaku? I feel the trashy potential, but two elements i'm bound to watch regardless. "Knight's" that apostrophe means something? Apostrophe's are kewl! |
 |
| It reeks of bad LN adaptation. Then again, the good LNs that are mecha are stuff like Advance of Z that never see an adaptation. Also, it wouldn't hurt to have originals in this genre, look at Dog Days, it was successful and got 3 seasons and it had a original premise to it's action. |
 |
| A lot of anime only fans hating on this for being generic but there is absolutely nothing generic about this. There is no generic harem or romance in this and it's a big focus on MC and his friends becoming the greatest pilots of the mechas they call "silhouettes" He uses his programming knowledge from the modern world and applies it to creating advanced silhouettes that out performs the magic worlds silhouettes. MC is a really mature and intelligent person who would definitely not bore you like the generic harem MCs. Most people haven't even read a single chapter of the LN and are judging it to be terrible which is a total shame because there are many amazing "reincarnated" or "transported to another world" novels out there that deserves to be adapted into an anime. |
NazcaiSep 24, 2016 4:51 PM
| "Have faith in the Lord Fifth, gain eternal life! When the Lord Fifth appears, who dares to cause strife!” |
Nazcai said: A lot of anime only fans hating on this for being generic but there is absolutely nothing generic about this. There is no generic harem or romance in this and it's a big focus on MC and his friends becoming the greatest pilots of the mechas they call "silhouettes" He uses his programming knowledge from the modern world and applies it to creating advanced silhouettes that out performs the magic worlds silhouettes. MC is a really mature and intelligent person who would definitely not bore you like the generic harem MCs. Most people haven't even read a single chapter of the LN and are judging it to be terrible which is a total shame because there are many amazing "reincarnated" or "transported to another world" novels out there that deserves to be adapted into an anime. As somebody who looked up both manga and first few LN chapters, this is ABSOLUTELY generic. The MC has no redeeming qualities or character flaws. He has no personality traits. He is even more gary stu than even your traditional LN MC would be and most of the story is about how great he is and other characters sucking up to him and how great he is. Its the kind of story that I wish I never touched. |
 |
| Hoo boy this reminds me of when people used to defend Mahouka as "actually interesting story with great protagonist". Kek. Harem is not the worst thing that can happen to a story. This LN's MC literally only has "I am mecha otaku" as his personality. No flaws. AT ALL. And most of story is him proving others how great he is. If you think that is the same as usual mecha protagonist, then you clearly have not watched mecha. The only equivalent to him is kira yamato. Because that dude also has no personality traits or flaws. You don't have to be "edgy" to at least resemble a realistic character. Or have any personality. Even SAO1 Kirito has more characterization than this dude. This dude is as blank slate as it gets. Zestiria's Sorey looks like best written most complex character in comparison to him. It is the most typical and derivative kind of LN but with not-Mecha added to it. As long as a viewer is satisfied with that kind of generic work, then that's okay. But anybody who wants to watch something actually good or interesting is bound to write this off into trash bin and rightly so. Given this will most likely be A1(or Madhouse) 12 episode LN advert adaptation so even those who only watch for popcorn will need to adjust expectations accordingly |
AhenshihaelSep 25, 2016 12:41 AM
|
| This is one of the better ones among the "isekai" genre. People always complain about "lack of originality". Well, this one is quite original in terms of lore. At least I can't remember anything that really came close in terms of lore. However whether or not the anime adaption will be any good is a different mater alltogether. |
 |
| Oh this actually looks pretty gre- *spots a school tag* Fuck no |
Fai said: Why is it that I can never go anywhere on this forum without seeing propaganda from you lolNazcai said: A lot of anime only fans hating on this for being generic but there is absolutely nothing generic about this. There is no generic harem or romance in this and it's a big focus on MC and his friends becoming the greatest pilots of the mechas they call "silhouettes" He uses his programming knowledge from the modern world and applies it to creating advanced silhouettes that out performs the magic worlds silhouettes. MC is a really mature and intelligent person who would definitely not bore you like the generic harem MCs. Most people haven't even read a single chapter of the LN and are judging it to be terrible which is a total shame because there are many amazing "reincarnated" or "transported to another world" novels out there that deserves to be adapted into an anime. As somebody who looked up both manga and first few LN chapters, this is ABSOLUTELY generic. The MC has no redeeming qualities or character flaws. He has no personality traits. He is even more gary stu than even your traditional LN MC would be and most of the story is about how great he is and other characters sucking up to him and how great he is. Its the kind of story that I wish I never touched. I just read the first chapter of this manga and I HIGHLY disagree with everything you said about the MC For one, unlike most characters that fall under the "Otaku thrown into a fantasy world" stigma, this kid was actually competent in both the real world and the fantasy world, and the reason why he was so talented actually makes fucking sense instead of the usual, "I'm OP just because" And like what @Dragon_Slayer_X said, his love for mechas is pretty close to that of the average mecha fan IRL (And no I'm not talking about some spin on the type of Otaku that Subaru, Staz or Kazama are) How is any of this even remotely not redeeming (Or realistic for that matter since you foolishly made this as a point) for an MC.....You made the comparison to Tatsuya of all people yet these two characters are like night and day if not soley because this guy has an actual personality/emotions unlike Tatsuya the robot Grey-Zone said: Amen for this postThis is one of the better ones among the "isekai" genre. People always complain about "lack of originality". Well, this one is quite original in terms of lore. At least I can't remember anything that really came close in terms of lore. However whether or not the anime adaption will be any good is a different mater alltogether. |
| isn't this the very definition of LN trash anime? |
Cross  AngeHey guys check my profile for current airing season anime recommendation (guaranteed best taste) |
GangsterCat said: Ln are good. Volume 4 is the best.isn't this the very definition of LN trash anime? |
 |
More topics from this board
» Manga 'Ninja to Koroshiya no Futarigurashi' Gets AnimeVindstot - Yesterday |
29 |
by Yui_Suzumiya69
»»
22 minutes ago |
|
» Original Anime Movie 'A New Dawn' Announced for 2025DatRandomDude - Yesterday |
3 |
by Etherius_ZS
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» 'Yuri!!! on Ice: Ice Adolescence' Anime Movie Cancels Production ( 1 2 )DatRandomDude - Apr 18 |
97 |
by Nanaca
»»
7 hours ago |
|
» 'Arifureta Shokugyou de Sekai Saikyou' Season 3 Unveils Additional Cast, First PromoHyperion_PS - Apr 21 |
2 |
by BankaiGoku
»»
Apr 22, 11:26 PM |
|
» TAAF 2024 Anime of the Year Winners AnnouncedSnow - Apr 19 |
10 |
by malvarez1
»»
Apr 22, 8:38 PM |