| Someone needs to make an anime that is a 100% direct adaptation of the A Song of Ice and Fire books. It would be the best anime to ever exist since the story is better than any anime to ever exist imo. |
 |
DEVlL said: Someone needs to make an anime that is a 100% direct adaptation of the A Song of Ice and Fire books. It would be the best anime to ever exist since the story is better than any anime to ever exist imo. Watch akame ga kill and you'll get the referrence |
 |
| Eh no. Stuff like LOTR and ASOIAF are the kind of things that do just well without needing to implement anime tropes and codes into it. Matr_iX said: Your comparison is dumb.DEVlL said: Someone needs to make an anime that is a 100% direct adaptation of the A Song of Ice and Fire books. It would be the best anime to ever exist since the story is better than any anime to ever exist imo. Watch akame ga kill and you'll get the referrence |
 |
| So....whenever an anime gets made into a live action movie/series....it sucks, A LOT! But anime fans keep insisting/thinking that the reverse would actually work! YEAH, let's make an already amazing series from live action into animation...surely it would be just as good! |
KingRequiem said: Eh no. Stuff like LOTR and ASOIAF are the kind of things that do just well without needing to implement anime tropes and codes into it. Your comparison is dumb. Just an opinion buddy, we cool okay? |
|
Matr_iX said: And my opinion is that it's nonsense since the two series have not much in common whatsoever. Unless you put all series featuring a significant amount of gore and mains dying in the same basket. In that case I guess Mars of Destruction is similar to ASOIAF/GOT too...KingRequiem said: Eh no. Stuff like LOTR and ASOIAF are the kind of things that do just well without needing to implement anime tropes and codes into it. Your comparison is dumb. Just an opinion buddy, we cool okay? |
|
JustALEX said: Anne of Green Gables was a popular anime. The first live action movie adaption was from 1919 (now a lost film) and the anime was from 1979, and entire 60 years later. The existence of a live action adaption doesn't make an anime adaption automatically bad.So....whenever an anime gets made into a live action movie/series....it sucks, A LOT! But anime fans keep insisting/thinking that the reverse would actually work! YEAH, let's make an already amazing series from live action into animation...surely it would be just as good! |
  |
| 100% direct adaptation of the books this is actually stupid because the books have so much pointless subplots that i actually prefer the way the series simplfies the story |
| It would have to be a 100+ episode OVA, and that's simply unrealistic. Even if it were possible to get the funds for something like that, a lot of people are getting burned out on GoT at this point. I've already experienced the story in text, and live action. I don't need to see it animated as well. |
 |
| Why does A Song of Ice and Fire need to be adapted anyway? The adaptation will never live up to the books. I'm saying that as someone who's not even a fan and gave up after book 3. But the TV show is worse and the anime would be too. I used to wish they'd finish adapting Nausicaa, but now I'm content just having the manga. 100 percent direct adaptations are a waste of time, mostly. |
| What about an anime based of Dunk and Egg. It wouldn't be too long and a animated trial of seven would be cool. Or a Jaime and Cersei anime called, "My Older Sister Queen Can't Be This Cute". |
| They should animate The Wind on Fire instead because reasons. |
| Game of Thrones is already way better than all other anime I watch. Making into anime will not work due to anime tropes and cliches. Besides, virgin otaku wouldn't like it when those girls having sex. Otaku loser want their anime girls to be pure. No anime has better story line than Game of Thrones. Even Japanese people themselves look down at their own anime. |
But it's important to remember that a movie review is subjective;it only gives you one person's opinion. http://www.classzone.com/books/lnetwork_gr08/page_build.cfm?content=analyz_media&ch=30 It doesn't matter if you like LoGH,Monster etc.If you are a jobless or college/school dropout living in your mom basement, you are still an unintelligent loser. Taste in anime does not make you a better person.If elitist don't exist, casual pleb and shit taste also don't exist. |
| That series would last like 300+ episodes. No thanks. Hate long AF anime like that. |
 |
JustALEX said: So....whenever an anime gets made into a live action movie/series....it sucks, A LOT! But anime fans keep insisting/thinking that the reverse would actually work! YEAH, let's make an already amazing series from live action into animation...surely it would be just as good! Yeah, I don't get that either. I think that live-action movies/series adapted from anime shows are utter shit. Llike, idk, it just doesn't fit. I love GoT overall but an anime adaptation would probably be shit. Anime shows should remain anime shows, and live-action movies/series should remain live-action movies/series. Like, could you imagine an anime version of Breaking Bad? Or a live-action version of Food Wars? Fucking yuck. |
| Je trempe mes cookies dans tes larmes. |
| The waifu wars about who is better between Daenerys, Sansa or Margeary would be 10/10 without any doubt. takenMalUsername said: I would watch that shit anytime.Or a Jaime and Cersei anime called, "My Older Sister Queen Can't Be This Cute". |
 |
| Given that it involves many battles between thousands of people, it will either require an absolutely massive budget or will be reduced to subpar CGI that occurs only when there's battles happening, which would sour the experience greatly. |
 It's an entirely different kind of flying, altogether! It's an entirely different kind of flying. |
| GoT itself is already anime enough. You got the ecchi scenes, hentai scenes, nee-san otouto incest and fantasy battles. |
 |
| I mean if you want porn of it just watch GoT, we don't need an ecchi/battle-harem series for it too. Might as well make an incest ecchi adaptation of Oedipus the King. Oedipus, the OG motherfucker. |
 |
JustALEX said: So....whenever an anime gets made into a live action movie/series....it sucks, A LOT! But anime fans keep insisting/thinking that the reverse would actually work! YEAH, let's make an already amazing series from live action into animation...surely it would be just as good! Where do you see adaptations from live-action? The writer is only interested into animated adaptations of english-speaking novels. He's probably waiting for a more faithful adaptation of the series than what HBO made (who's by the way a good live show from what I have seen). |
Rei_IIIAug 24, 2016 2:44 AM
DEVlL said: since the story is better than any anime to ever exist imo. Really? GoT is just a generic grimdark fantasy full of asshole characters no one could actually care about. Berserk (at least the manga) does the grimdark fantasy schtick way better. |
 We all know that people watch Game of Thrones "just fo' them boewwwbies". It's not THAT good... pretty boring the last seasons if you ask me. |
Lobinde said: DEVlL said: since the story is better than any anime to ever exist imo. Really? GoT is just a generic grimdark fantasy full of asshole characters no one could actually care about. Berserk (at least the manga) does the grimdark fantasy schtick way better. actually everybody seems to care for the characters for some reason i never could figure but to be fair tyrion is awesome |
On_the_Lam said: JustALEX said: So....whenever an anime gets made into a live action movie/series....it sucks, A LOT! But anime fans keep insisting/thinking that the reverse would actually work! YEAH, let's make an already amazing series from live action into animation...surely it would be just as good! Game of Thrones isn't even that good anymore. lul Animation to live-action is usually shit because they don't have enough money for special effects, or they're just impossible to replicate. The other way around actually works. Name a few times where they went from live action to animation and it worked. And better yet, name one time where a GOOD live action movie or TV series was made into animation and it was equally or better in value. |
On_the_Lam said: gabrielrroiz said: 100% direct adaptation of the books this is actually stupid because the books have so much pointless subplots that i actually prefer the way the series simplfies the story Haven't read the books, but I have an overall idea about what has happened so far. Could you give a few examples? well there are bit like sansa going into the valley with littlefinger and the way they make tyrion constantely take deteours on his path on meereen on the books thay are totally worthless in the books and the narrative in the series was paced way better by cutting this details |
On_the_Lam said: gabrielrroiz said: well there are bit like sansa going into the valley with littlefinger and the way they make tyrion constantely take deteours on his path on meereen on the books thay are totally worthless in the books and the narrative in the series was paced way better by cutting this details Really? I thought the HBO series could have been condensed quite a bit... the books are way worst in that aspect |
Zapredon said: Game of Thrones is already way better than all other anime I watch. Making into anime will not work due to anime tropes and cliches. Besides, virgin otaku wouldn't like it when those girls having sex. Otaku loser want their anime girls to be pure. No anime has better story line than Game of Thrones. Even Japanese people themselves look down at their own anime. LOGH is in every aspects better than GoT |
| You're totally right, I approve this 100%. |
 Ｓｗｅｅｔ♥I guess, as long as I have life, all I can do is fight with all my might. |
Whayle said: Zapredon said: Game of Thrones is already way better than all other anime I watch. Making into anime will not work due to anime tropes and cliches. Besides, virgin otaku wouldn't like it when those girls having sex. Otaku loser want their anime girls to be pure. No anime has better story line than Game of Thrones. Even Japanese people themselves look down at their own anime. LOGH is in every aspects better than GoT K-On is in every aspects better than LOGH. https://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=31515 |
But it's important to remember that a movie review is subjective;it only gives you one person's opinion. http://www.classzone.com/books/lnetwork_gr08/page_build.cfm?content=analyz_media&ch=30 It doesn't matter if you like LoGH,Monster etc.If you are a jobless or college/school dropout living in your mom basement, you are still an unintelligent loser. Taste in anime does not make you a better person.If elitist don't exist, casual pleb and shit taste also don't exist. |
| [troll] Zapredon said: K-On is in every aspects better than LOGH. https://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=31515 It isn't hard to be better than GoT or LoGH. These two series only appeal to insecure teenagers who want to feel mature. That's why Akame ga Kill is a perfectly valid comparison. KingRequiem said: And my opinion is that it's nonsense since the two series have not much in common whatsoever. Unless you put all series featuring a significant amount of gore and mains dying in the same basket. In that case I guess Mars of Destruction is similar to ASOIAF/GOT too... Yes, these are exactly the things that Game of Thrones is praised for. Otherwise, it's no different from numerous "strategic" anime like Maoyuu and Gate. [/troll] |
| @flannan Indeed now that I think about it, GOT is to western television what FSN is to Japanese entertainment. That would be a porn game/show with no substantial content behind it whatsoever. I take offense to the LoGH criticizing though, the masterpiece had fujoshi bait before fujoshi were even a thing. |
|
Whayle said: It is better. The story didn't masochistically dick around going nowhere.Zapredon said: Game of Thrones is already way better than all other anime I watch. Making into anime will not work due to anime tropes and cliches. Besides, virgin otaku wouldn't like it when those girls having sex. Otaku loser want their anime girls to be pure. No anime has better story line than Game of Thrones. Even Japanese people themselves look down at their own anime. LOGH is in every aspects better than GoT |
KingRequiem said: @flannan Indeed now that I think about it, GOT is to western television what FSN is to Japanese entertainment. That would be a porn game/show with no substantial content behind it whatsoever. I take offense to the LoGH criticizing though, the masterpiece had fujoshi bait before fujoshi were even a thing. *cough**cough*...says the Wapanese. Watch more than 800 anime already and nope, anime doesn't have substantial content. Meanwhile in Japan itself, anime is considered low form entertainment medium that most Japanese people themselves don't respect while GoT still get respect. The neutral would says GoT is better but since this is anime forum it's understandable. flannan said: It isn't hard to be better than GoT or LoGH. These two series only appeal to insecure teenagers who want to feel mature. That's why Akame ga Kill is a perfectly valid comparison. Troll harder.If GoT is for teenagers, then anime is for children. It is widely accepted not just in western countries,but also in Japan that most anime are not for adult. Why else do you think Japanese people like Natsuki Imai single out 5 Centimeters Per Second as anime for adult. It because in Japan, anime is considered for teenagers. Natsuki Imai, a Japanese television and film director known for her 2007 film Koizora, views 5 Centimeters Per Second as a film "completely for adults even though it is an anime".[31] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5_Centimeters_Per_Second#Reception Anime are generally for teenagers. This is widely accepted in both the west and Japan. |
ZapredonAug 26, 2016 4:27 AM
But it's important to remember that a movie review is subjective;it only gives you one person's opinion. http://www.classzone.com/books/lnetwork_gr08/page_build.cfm?content=analyz_media&ch=30 It doesn't matter if you like LoGH,Monster etc.If you are a jobless or college/school dropout living in your mom basement, you are still an unintelligent loser. Taste in anime does not make you a better person.If elitist don't exist, casual pleb and shit taste also don't exist. |
| No one needs brain damaging shit from the west. GitS and LOGH alone shits on 95% that comes from that shit named hollywood. |
 |
gabrielrroiz said: Lobinde said: Really? GoT is just a generic grimdark fantasy full of asshole characters no one could actually care about. Berserk (at least the manga) does the grimdark fantasy schtick way better. actually everybody seems to care for the characters for some reason i never could figure but to be fair tyrion is awesome Well the actors give some good performances in the live action series, but I'm referring to their personalities. Everyone in GoT/SoIF is some sort of standard medieval fantasy politics archetype, there is nuance is the web of character relations but that more has to do with the high amount of characters, not the quality of each character. On_the_Lam said: What exactly makes Berserk better, except for the needless amount of edge? Call it "grim dark" how many times you want, but even Berserk wasn't able to omit the "Friendship is magic!" storyline in a few episodes of the Golden Age arc (talking about the anime only, not sure about how the manga handled those scenes). GoT has a lot of edge too, because just about every character is an asshole for the sake of the plot. I'm not sure what you mean about the "Friendship is magic!" thing in Berserk Golden Age arc, the value of friendship is something that is more thoroughly explored in the later arcs. In the manga, the Golden Age arc is mostly focused around how Guts and Griffith are "equal but opposite", it doesn't really romanticise much. |
Lobinde said: gabrielrroiz said: actually everybody seems to care for the characters for some reason i never could figure but to be fair tyrion is awesome Well the actors give some good performances in the live action series, but I'm referring to their personalities. Everyone in GoT/SoIF is some sort of standard medieval fantasy politics archetype, there is nuance is the web of character relations but that more has to do with the high amount of characters, not the quality of each character. On_the_Lam said: What exactly makes Berserk better, except for the needless amount of edge? Call it "grim dark" how many times you want, but even Berserk wasn't able to omit the "Friendship is magic!" storyline in a few episodes of the Golden Age arc (talking about the anime only, not sure about how the manga handled those scenes). GoT has a lot of edge too, because just about every character is an asshole for the sake of the plot. I'm not sure what you mean about the "Friendship is magic!" thing in Berserk Golden Age arc, the value of friendship is something that is more thoroughly explored in the later arcs. In the manga, the Golden Age arc is mostly focused around how Guts and Griffith are "equal but opposite", it doesn't really romanticise much. The only characters that people care about in Berserk is just Guts. All the new side characters sticking around Guts are characters no one care. GoT has more characters that people care more than Berserk regardless of actor performance. Book readers told me they feel upset when Red Wedding happen. And Berserk also has plenty of characters who are asshole just for the sake of plot. And not every character in GoT are asshole. At least, the Stark certainly isn't. |
ZapredonAug 25, 2016 5:25 AM
But it's important to remember that a movie review is subjective;it only gives you one person's opinion. http://www.classzone.com/books/lnetwork_gr08/page_build.cfm?content=analyz_media&ch=30 It doesn't matter if you like LoGH,Monster etc.If you are a jobless or college/school dropout living in your mom basement, you are still an unintelligent loser. Taste in anime does not make you a better person.If elitist don't exist, casual pleb and shit taste also don't exist. |
| That would be awesome- goof idea I am watching Game of Thrones and as an anime it would be even better I am supporting your suggestion |
 |
| I can imagine a lot of girls would scream for John Snow as a beautiful animated character Tyrion would be kick-ass in an animer, right? ^^ |
|
More topics from this board
» Currently listening to ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )tsukareru - Mar 29, 2021 |
7552 |
by SilentAssassin88
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» What was the last song you listened to? ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Death - Oct 1, 2020 |
3379 |
by SilentAssassin88
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» AI generated OP/ED themes from imaginary anime that I came up with. (Over 20 songs and counting!)FFandMMfan - 7 hours ago |
0 |
by FFandMMfan
»»
7 hours ago |
|
Poll: » The Sopranos vs The Wire vs Breaking BadDOSS300 - 8 hours ago |
0 |
by DOSS300
»»
8 hours ago |
|
» What Are Your Thoughts On The Owl House?Enderobot - 10 hours ago |
1 |
by Amityblight
»»
8 hours ago |