A Silent Voice
| I really liked the manga till chapter 42 but after that it felt somewhat unrealistic,how tf he got away with minor injuries even after falling from such height, we weren't even shown how Nishimiya was saved when she was the one on the vulnerable side,next it was little opera drama :3 cat fights and individual story of each side characters which the least people cares about and idea of completing the film just to make him feel better sounds so odd to me. If I was in place of Ishida I would be like "F ur film,F u all" :3 I didn't read the manga for romance aspect,wait there weren't even any romance so nvm and the ending wasn't satisfying either,expected a bit more than the open ending. Had high hopes to finish in high notes since we got such captivating first half. Still 8/10. |
R_TFSep 16, 2016 12:55 PM
| Spoiler tag for the first sentence maybe? Anyway the most unrealistic aspect is how the police and ambulance arrived in time to escort Ishida away (nevermind how long it took to pull the body out) and start the inquiry before Shoko even makes it to the ground floor... must have taken under two minutes wow. Personally I like the brevity of the ending - once it's clear they're in a couple I couldn't care less what they get up to. The focal point of the story is them struggling together to be accepted by society in their own way; once they've achieved that, time to let go. |
 |
| I didn't like the ending because it just stopped. It didn't feel conclusive. |
| @remmi_demmi Sorry i edited it and yeah the whole thing was so unrealistic and it wasn't clear if they were couple or not after those two years ,you can say more of a close friend. |
| @Valaskjalf Indeed i felt the same :( |
RoyTF said: I really liked the manga till chapter 42 but after that it felt somewhat unrealistic,how tf he got away with minor injuries even after falling from such height and we weren't even show how she was saved when she was the one on the vulnerable side,next it was little opera drama :3 cat fights and individual story of each side characters which the least people cares about and idea of completing the film just to make him feel better sounds so odd to me. If i was in place of ishida i would be like "F ur film,F u all" :3 And i didn't read the manga for romance aspect,wait there weren't even any romance so nvm. And i wanted more not this type of open ending. I had high hope :( I feel similiar, like the manga should have ended with chapter 43. After that it somehow lost to be interesting, i'm down to the last 2 chapter, but don't feel like finishing it, the last few chapters was way to sugarcoated to me. Somehow it wen't into wrong direction for me. Sometimes i don't finish series, when i like them and i don't wanna close the story, the fun. Unfourtanetly it's not the case here. |
| I don't exactly remember how I clearly felt but based on my notes and trying to remember how I felt. ... I think I did feel it came out of nowhere this conflict. It was possibly forced or redundant. Maybe a bad choice of conflict to the story. I remember being kinda disappointed with the ending. I think ... Like I said I can't remember. But I know I didn't like that bitch being a misunderstanding bitch. While the heroine was giving care for a movie that wasn't really important at all in their relationship. ... I don't know. The beginning and middle of the manga was amazing but the ending was kinda disappointing. |
| I have mixed feelings because I feel like the manga was trying to show that the story might have been based more upon the redemption of the characters rather than the actual love story developing between Ishida and Shouko but im a sap and would have loved to see a kiss at least lol... |
on 
| Not really. there's thing i feel unsatisfied but not the ending. For me the story go with this stage (MC POV) Introducing>Characterization>Redemption>Conlusion In Redemption's part. (Fake)Confronting>self justifying> realizing > redeeming The plot on "redeeming" part is unsatisfying, I don't have any real problem with it 'cause it delivered the idea pretty well, just that I feel like it could be better or something along those line. |
 |
Valaskjalf said: I didn't like the ending because it just stopped. It didn't feel conclusive. The ending would have been stellar, if it lead us to a sequel for the manga. Which it doesn't happen, so I agree with you guys... |
 |
| I feel that if the ending wasn't so sudden and a little less anticlimactic it would have been a little bit better. It seems to always be hard to properly end a story for a lot of authors and most of the time that is because they either suck with romance or they leave themselves with too much material and not enough ideas and/or time. (Sometimes it is the publishers fault.) They really tend to dig themselves into holes a lot. |
| "Did you really think I wouldn’t cheat just because I was already winning?" - Dread Emperor Terribilis II "I chose glory and success. The box did not contain what was written on the lid." - Sand dan Glokta |
| I can't really say that this ending is either happy or bad , maybe a bad happy ending , nothing was answered , the romance was just dry towards the final chapters , we have a saying in my country " everything is in the tree and the tree is in the air " in other words nothing was resolved , at least not for me , the manga began strong but fumbled the ball right when it counted the most , I just hope that the movie will be better ... Because of this all I can give this manga is an 6/10 and I am generous if I say so myself . |
| yeah, I was pretty disappointed. I expected more tbh I thought there'd be a sequel but naH |
| hi,i like you. |
| The ending definitely disappointed me, it just kind of ended and didn't wrap up enough of the subplots well enough for me. They never did go back to Nishimayas confession and their romance progression. They just didn't give enough info for this to be considered a good ending. It was a lot more I wanted to know about and it just kinda ended. Wasted a lot of time near the end on people and plots that didn't matter enough but didn't flesh out Shouya and Nishimaya. |
| No I am not. It is an open ending so it is completely fine that they left off at the point they did. The symbolism in Shouya and Shouko holding hands while walking through the door is an amazing way to end off the manga. Throughout the entire series you see these two characters being drawn to each other and needing to help each other out. While in the early volumes you see these same themes of relying on each other always fall short like when Shouya slips and falls because Shouko failed to grab him or when Shouya falls off the balcony after saving Shouko. By having them FINALY hold hands and take on the next challenge together the author implies this is a relationship that will last a lifetime. |
| Honestly, my only complaint about the ending was that even after everything Ueno did to her, Shouko decides to go to college with her. Seriously? If it were me, I'd tell the girl to fuck off and never go anywhere near her ever again, especially after the way Ueno kept treating her after Shouko's suicide attempt. |
| i am disappointed with made movie arc in general... |
 "If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on." |
| Overall, no. As some people have said already, I wanted to see some romance too, especially from him (a kiss or confession) but the story was never about that, so I'm not upset either; we can figure out the rest by the hand-holding at the last page. |
 |
More topics from this board
» Difference?Mangahater - Apr 19 |
9 |
by Zarutaku
»»
Apr 20, 1:32 AM |
|
Poll: » Koe no Katachi Chapter 62 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Maerow - Nov 15, 2014 |
291 |
by KanYeeT
»»
Apr 19, 7:55 AM |
|
Poll: » Koe no Katachi Chapter 61 DiscussionAna - Nov 9, 2014 |
45 |
by KanYeeT
»»
Apr 19, 7:41 AM |
|
Poll: » Koe no Katachi Chapter 57 DiscussionMaerow - Oct 11, 2014 |
40 |
by KanYeeT
»»
Apr 19, 6:46 AM |
|
Poll: » Koe no Katachi Chapter 50 DiscussionAna - Aug 26, 2014 |
39 |
by KanYeeT
»»
Apr 19, 3:35 AM |