Erased
ExTamplier said: OPM never got that far, because many haters dowvoted it (butthurt gintama fans), this show appeals to a larger audience. Mad cause Gintama is better than OPM? |
Trollsenpai said: ERASED outranked Hunter x Hunter (2011), I guess all it takes is some half baked time travel & bad drama to make a good anime according to MAL users. mmmm ALL THAT SALT!!! ; ) |
 |
Nagirah said: Judging by how much content is left to adapt and certain things happening in the manga, I hope the fanboys will taste the salt from their tears when this anime turns bad. This is impyling it hasn't already turned bad. MEsoJD said: Trollsenpai said: ERASED outranked Hunter x Hunter (2011), I guess all it takes is some half baked time travel & bad drama to make a good anime according to MAL users. mmmm ALL THAT SALT!!! ; ) I'm not salty cause it outranked everything in my favorites a long time ago, but how do people think a shitty time travel plot with characters that act way more deep then they actually fucking are and forced drama everywhere is in any shape or form good? Faith in modern anime fans=destroyed. |
| every single one of my forum posts is dumb and invalid except for 1, I don't claim them it was a different person it was all fake |
RainyRai said: Nagirah said: Judging by how much content is left to adapt and certain things happening in the manga, I hope the fanboys will taste the salt from their tears when this anime turns bad. This is impyling it hasn't already turned bad. I'm not salty cause it outranked everything in my favorites a long time ago, but how do people think a shitty time travel plot with characters that act way more deep then they actually fucking are and forced drama everywhere is in any shape or form good? Faith in modern anime fans=destroyed. All that NaCl tho. |
| Honestly I don't get why this is getting so much shit foe being number 5 but it's all fine and dandy for the new Gintama show is number two, not hating on Gintama as since it's so highly rated, it's number two for a reason, can't people just like what they like without everyone making a big deal about it being overrated. |
SakurasouBusters said: Gintama has a way lesser fanbase/community activity. The more people actively watching a show = the more people that'll shit on an anime and or talk about how bad it is.Honestly I don't get why this is getting so much shit foe being number 5 but it's all fine and dandy for the new Gintama show is number two, not hating on Gintama as since it's so highly rated, it's number two for a reason, can't people just like what they like without everyone making a big deal about it being overrated. |
 |
Tyrel said: SakurasouBusters said: Gintama has a way lesser fanbase/community activity. The more people actively watching a show = the more people that'll shit on an anime and or talk about how bad it is.Honestly I don't get why this is getting so much shit foe being number 5 but it's all fine and dandy for the new Gintama show is number two, not hating on Gintama as since it's so highly rated, it's number two for a reason, can't people just like what they like without everyone making a big deal about it being overrated. I get that I'm just talking in general, can't people just like what they like? |
| As I said like 2 or 3 times, the ratings will fall like crazy in 2~3 episodes. I don't think this show is something above 8/10. |
 |
RainyRai said: Nagirah said: Judging by how much content is left to adapt and certain things happening in the manga, I hope the fanboys will taste the salt from their tears when this anime turns bad. This is impyling it hasn't already turned bad. I'm not salty cause it outranked everything in my favorites a long time ago, but how do people think a shitty time travel plot with characters that act way more deep then they actually fucking are and forced drama everywhere is in any shape or form good? Faith in modern anime fans=destroyed. to be fair anime fans always loved forced drama that is why clannad and ano hana are so highly rated and i also despite that it has a higher rating than hxh the best long running shonen ever created |
| It probably will, and users will get so salty about it that they will travel back in time to stop it from happening. |
 |
ryuixyui said: The anime is making Detective Conan one of the greatest anime ever. It's really struggling to set up the core plot even from the start. Like a lot of recently adapted anime, it is rushed. If an episode sets up an event, that event should be fun explored. Kayo's death isn't even explained or why she was killed (or why her mother is abusing her to begin). I suppose it will be the same for the killer unless we have a confession in the end (which probably wouldn't happen). The most I would rate this would be 7. This anime could have been a masterpiece if it had stick to reality than this time traveling stuff. Maybe in the ending, we'll see Satoru before he was being hanged coming to his sense, showing us that he was just imagining everything from the start (He become convicted to death over her mother's death) and realizing that he can't do anything and that life is very unfair and unjust. After we saw him hanged, we realize that his conclusions are actually wrong and based on his own opinions. That the crimes were unrelated and the culprit he was looking for simply doesn't exist. (Based on the facts, Kayo's could actually be explained very easily even without the supposed serial killer). That would be a nice reality check for people. Except it just proves all the more that none of that stuff matters to modern anime fans as long as it has a cute girl and some tragedyporn storyline surrounding her. That's how you make an instant masterpiece and this show is far from the first that has proven that that's all that matters anymore. |
Trollsenpai said: No salt mate, I hope it gets the #1 spot, just to let people understand that MAL rankings are not to be taken seriously I expect people to forget about it a month after it ends until it comes time to give out those arbitrary year end "awards" to the usual same old suspects yet again at which point it'll re-enter the picture with the other mediocre seasonal hype shows that came out in the other 2016 seasons, probably all by a lot of the same producers featuring a lot of the same old people. |
kayosuru said: Its almost like a baby, its nice to see an anime you are really liking to make it up in ratings to say the top 10!why does rating matter? I feel like it may be worth of being in the top 10. It will NOT make it into the top 3 though. Its really great, but I saw a comment saying that based on the pacing in order to cover the rest of the manga it will have to be rushed which may lead to this shows downfall. I think in order to secure its spot in the top 10 it will have to: 1. Explain why Kayo is being abused by her mother 2. A solid ending (People are saying at its current pace it will have a rushed ending soo....) 3. Have a decent explanation of Satorus power. I am no critique, but I feel if these are addressed most people will be satisfied with the anime averaging around a 9.0 |
 |
| It's always the same thing. When a good show is on,butthurts coming... It isn't overrated imo( for MAL's standards obviously),for example how dare do you say that the first 8 episodes of S;G are better than these? |
Jklmn said: It's always the same thing. When a good show is on,butthurts coming... It isn't overrated imo( for MAL's standards obviously),for example how dare do you say that the first 8 episodes of S;G are better than these? Thats right dude SG is a masterpiece after episode 10 but before is kinda boring while boku machi is a masterpiece in each episode untill now ecept in one ep that is a 9/10 for me also its top 1 in animeplanet so isnt only MAl its a awesome anime thats all |
Siul-08 said: Thats right dude SG is a masterpiece after episode 10 but before is kinda boring while boku machi is a masterpiece in each episode untill now ecept in one ep that is a 9/10 for me also its top 1 in animeplanet so isnt only MAl its a awesome anime thats all I think people want that all anime are shit,when an anime just decent comes here that parts the shit-storm:"Ehhh but it's overrated!!!...the plot is forced,there isn't action,it's predictable,this anime is only hype,the hero doesn't go the toilet with regolarity. Every popular anime has 137.456 flaws,forgetting anime level is shit. |
xaos12 said: I read the manga of boku dake, give me a proper explanation of Revival's rules and I will give you reddit gold. For this don't you like the anime? |
Jklmn said: xaos12 said: I read the manga of boku dake, give me a proper explanation of Revival's rules and I will give you reddit gold. For this don't you like the anime? Well it makes Satoru's power seem like a plot convenience that only exist for the sake of making the plot move on. |
 |
xaos12 said: I read the manga of boku dake, give me a proper explanation of Revival's rules and I will give you reddit gold. 1. Revival can be used only to prevent harm from happening to characters other than user. 2. Revival follows ontological inertia to certain extent, so even when past is changed, events coincidental to the previous timeline will still happen, even if earlier participant is not here. 3. Revival is repeated until Satoru saves the person in danger (what was kinda neglected in anime). 4. When Satoru cannot rescue someone from a fatal encounter, he is sent back even further to the point, when he can protect him/her. |
No wonder, dragon with no head must be retarded. |
kayosuru said: It is a serious business here after all, especially for the fans of those animated series within the Top 10 Anime by MAL.why does rating matter? |
xaos12 said: @jakkubus..yeah you have read the manga so I expected that. However some points are just assumed from events, especially the fourth point. Becoz the second revival doesn't follow that. I think, that the second revival happened because Satoru noticed the killer and he knew, that there will be further murders, which he wont be able to prevent from prison. |
No wonder, dragon with no head must be retarded. |
Kirua- said: Maledict said: Number 5, huh... There are 168,000 users watching this. 48,000 of them can't help but give out 10/10's when they enjoy a show, and that's understandable, but there are still 3 times more people that haven't rated this at all. It looks like the score will be majorly influenced by how it ends. All in all, I'm just hoping it'll permanently be above Clannad. It will be higher than Clannad, but not higher than Clannad After Story. I think that's the most predictable outcome though. It passed clannad after story tho |
 |
| Faith was already lost in humanity lol I don't freaking care about the rating |
Kirua- said: terminador_2397 said: It passed clannad after story tho I used future tense. Erased's rank right now doesn't matter if it can't keep it, and I heavily doubt it will still be above CAS after it ended. EarlCiel said: Faith was already lost in humanity lol I don't freaking care about the rating What do MAL rankings have to do with faith in humanity? I mean you have a point but that sounded so overly exaggerated that it's hard to take seriously. Oops my bad, I had thought you posted that afterwards |
|
xaos12 said: As expected, you can't. Anyway if some rules are unexplained and just you can time-travel like that, wouldn't that create inconsistenties? If ppl found plotholes in s;g time travel, would they have rated it ten? I know it has got a supernatural tag, but some pts are bound to be explained. I've never seen anime without lacks neither I have the condidence to find about. |
Kirua- said: What do MAL rankings have to do with faith in humanity? I mean you have a point but that sounded so overly exaggerated that it's hard to take seriously. Was it meant to be taken seriously? |
EarlCielFeb 29, 2016 12:32 PM
| What's with the sudden influx of people with less than 10 posts all calling out regular users for being butthurt and trolling like they own the joint? Literally where did all these people come from all of a sudden and what makes them feel so important and self-righteous to act like they've been here forever and know exactly what's going on? Looks really bloody suspicious, like somebody even alt accounting or something. Like there's definitely something out of the ordinary going on with this show around these parts. Anyway this place is just too fucked regardless. I really need to get out for real at this rate cause it's just not helping matters trying to rationalize or argue with any of these people around the anime community anymore who are just so petty, self-absorbed and take everything for granted. I'll probably even start enjoying anime again if I get away from it's ridiculously nasty fanbase for a significant amount of time cause right now it's literally impossible to enjoy it fully while having any sort of contact with it's fanbase that makes everything a political fanboy hype affair and are just insufferably obnoxious to the point where they suck the fun out of anything by sheer proximity. It's making my personality worse too being engaged in it. And that goes for "fanboys", "haters", "trolls", whatever cause there's clearly no people that have much of anything in common with me anymore in the online community. Just officially tired of it all lol, like it really should be funner and enhance the enjoyment of something or not but it's the opposite with all this my anime is hyper and better than your anime seasonal BS and it's just clear it's never going to get any better again at this rate. I've kind of realized that while I've had my ups and downs with the anime community over the years that especially this decade interacting in it has not improved my appreciation of the hobby even one iota and literally only detracted from it more and more as time goes on even with limited contact. Honestly I'd suggest to anybody else interested in anime to just leave the online community too if they want to enjoy it more or even just get away from the bullshit that politicizes and compartmentalizes something that should just be a fun pass time, not an identity. Not making any guarantees it helps, but if others feel the same way at this rate I think there's everything to gain and nothing to lose the way it is nowadays, how ridiculous everyone acts now, and how it's frankly been sucking me down the same hole of misery and annoyance probably for several years now. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mQScjlXbBE Leaving this here as it pretty much says it all. |
PeacingOutFeb 29, 2016 12:48 PM
Kaioshin_Sama said: What's with the sudden influx of people with less than 10 posts all calling out regular users for being butthurt and trolling like they own the joint? Literally where did all these people come from all of a sudden and what makes them feel so important and self-righteous to act like they've been here forever and know exactly what's going on? Looks really bloody suspicious, like somebody even alt accounting or something. Like there's definitely something out of the ordinary going on with this show around these parts. Anyway this place is just too fucked regardless. I really need to get out for real at this rate cause it's just not helping matters trying to rationalize or argue with any of these people around the anime community anymore who are just so petty, self-absorbed and take everything for granted. I'll probably even start enjoying anime again if I get away from it's ridiculously nasty fanbase for a significant amount of time cause right now it's literally impossible to enjoy it fully while having any sort of contact with it's fanbase that makes everything a political fanboy hype affair and are just insufferably obnoxious to the point where they suck the fun out of anything by sheer proximity. It's making my personality worse too being engaged in it. And that goes for "fanboys", "haters", "trolls", whatever cause there's clearly no people that have much of anything in common with me anymore in the online community. Just officially tired of it all lol, like it really should be funner and enhance the enjoyment of something or not but it's the opposite with all this my anime is hyper and better than your anime seasonal BS and it's just clear it's never going to get any better again at this rate. I've kind of realized that while I've had my ups and downs with the anime community over the years that especially this decade interacting in it has not improved my appreciation of the hobby even one iota and literally only detracted from it more and more as time goes on even with limited contact. Honestly I'd suggest to anybody else interested in anime to just leave the online community too if they want to enjoy it more or even just get away from the bullshit that politicizes and compartmentalizes something that should just be a fun pass time, not an identity. Not making any guarantees it helps, but if others feel the same way at this rate I think there's everything to gain and nothing to lose the way it is nowadays, how ridiculous everyone acts now, and how it's frankly been sucking me down the same hole of misery and annoyance probably for several years now. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mQScjlXbBE Leaving this here as it pretty much says it all. Your one of the few users I seen on MAL that understands the situation with the online anime community , I agree completely with what you said |
|
| It's already reached #1 over at Anime-Planet. |
AnnaSartin said: It's already reached #1 over at Anime-Planet. http://www.anime-planet.com/anime/top-anime Wow. |
| "Beyond the veil of cherry blossom petals blown by the wind - almost like their promised reunion - Feelings pile up with the passage of time: once the torrent of emotions comes rushing down, what is the spectacle that awaits?" |
| After reading last chapter. Rank depends on fanbase. Taking all the salt and such. But it will go under 9.00 for sure. |
| I hope not, people are just giving this anime way too much credit than it needs. |
 |
| nah, it wont after the final chapter coming out and basically spoiled in many manga sites... fanbase is practically 50/50 on the ending, some of the salty will give it 1/10, me personally the manga is 6/10 because of poor characterization, the anime i don't know, i'll see where the pacing goes |
 |
Lololol Yeah, I'm Clannad and Key in general big fan, I love Steins;Gate too, but you really think that me, or someone else rated OPM low because I didn't want it on top list? You made my day, or rather night, it's 1:47am here. Seriously. I rated OPM low, because it was ridiculously not funny and repetitive like nothing else. I was bored as hell and it took me eternity to finish it. |
rsc-plMar 2, 2016 4:46 PM
| Dub = fake crap. Always. |
rsc-pl said: I rated OPM low, because it was ridiculously not funny and repetitive like nothing else. I was bored as hell and it took me eternity to finish it. I don't get it how can you OPM consider boring and repetetive and at the same time you like one of most boring girl ever - Onodera. |
 |
| It's pretty hilarious to re-read the first pages where everyone was saying it would never make it to the top ten. Look at its ranking now! Haha (It would definitely be entertaining to see MAL's reaction if it went any higher) |
| Proud founder of The Official Anti-Ging Freecss Fan Club Join now! Kellhus said: GuusWayne said: there is a limit to the suspension of disbelief And it's the fan that did it. Not the smoking porn reading rubik cube genius rape ape with a magic boat. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 24, 2016 |
1400 |
by bakakisima
»»
Apr 23, 12:43 PM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 17, 2016 |
1108 |
by bakakisima
»»
Apr 23, 10:13 AM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Feb 4, 2016 |
769 |
by Jocku
»»
Apr 17, 10:27 AM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 10, 2016 |
900 |
by bakakisima
»»
Apr 12, 2:03 PM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 3, 2016 |
498 |
by bakakisima
»»
Apr 11, 1:04 PM |