| Like most of the high rated movies in IMDB I liked a lot, but I rarely end up liking anime rated high here. Is it because people on imdb use the full rating scale? |
 |
| No, and you already made 3 topics past hour? |
Euphemistic said: HandsomeMan said: No, and you already made 3 topics past hour? Gotta raise that post count. +1 |
 |
Euphemistic said: HandsomeMan said: No, and you already made 3 topics past hour? Gotta raise that post count. 99 posts in more than 8 months, yeah I'm really concerned with post count. And posting in threads is a quicker way to increase not making threads. Once again you are an idiot. |
|
| No. In MAL at least there's an active hunt for fake and/or duplicate accounts that try to manipulate the ratings. IMDb has thousands or hundreds of thousands of users voting something that hasn't even aired, constant massive upvotes and downvotes, and doesn't seem to give a fuck about it. Also, their tops are really more about popularity than anything else, with their high vote limit. |
Nxtslide said: Euphemistic said: Gotta raise that post count. 99 posts in more than 8 months, yeah I'm really concerned with post count. And posting in threads is a quicker way to increase not making threads. Once again you are an idiot. Once again? Boy, I seem to have offended the OP without even knowing what I said. |
| IMDB is 1000x more reliable probably the most reliable rating on the net period but their anime ratings seem to be off |
 |
Euphemistic said: HandsomeMan said: Once again? Boy, I seem to have offended the OP without even knowing what I said. Nah,it is referring to me. Post raised +1 |
|
| I wouldn't say so. Just because you and IMDB users share a similar taste doesn't really mean much. Just because the scores reflect positive on your opinion, doesn't mean they are reliable. They are just reliable to you, but that doesn't mean in general. |
 |
| On imdb there's a bigger ratio of normal properly functioning adults who know what they're talking about to the big puddle of teenage autism. If shows like Mirai Nikki spread to the general public, I get the feeling that the reaction would probably not be as warm. |
 |
SeibaaHomu said: There's a bigger ratio of normal properly functioning adults who know what they're talking about to the big puddle of teenage autism on imdb. If shows like Mirai Nikki spread to the general public , I get the feeling that the reaction would probably not be as warm. Dragon Ball Super also had a 9.7 on IMDB when it first aired. |
|
Kagami_Hiiragi said: I wouldn't say so. Just because you and IMDB users share a similar taste doesn't really mean much. Just because the scores reflect positive on your opinion, doesn't mean they are reliable. They are just reliable to you, but that doesn't mean in general. I know.. I'm asking if it's reliable to other people as well. |
|
| while it wouldn't be my list, i'd call every movie i've watched in the imdb top 50 well above average (apart from star wars, but i have a particular aversion to the series) on the other hand, mal has attack on titan at #43 but in my experience, good movies are pretty universally accepted as good movies, i've never seen someone call the shawshank redemption overrated trash rottentomatoes >> imdb regardless |
Wrlccywrlir said: rottentomatoes >> imdb regardless Always use a group of professional critics scores over a group of random user scores. |
| Bring back down votes on reviews |
nitrohawk said: Wrlccywrlir said: rottentomatoes >> imdb regardless Always use a group of professional critics scores over a group of random user scores. cult classics would not be the same if this was true |
|
| 'Professional anime critics' don't exist. The closest thing you've got to a well known site that does anime reviews is ANN and they fucking suck. It's really no wonder why sites like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic don't take their scores into account. |
|
| >Rottentomatoes is better than iMdB Lmao are u joking guys? |
| Twitter and it's consequences had been a disaster for the human race |
| define "reliable" |
SeibaaHomu said: Metacritic seems to miss a few tv shows and films'Professional anime critics' don't exist. The closest thing you've got to a well known site that does anime reviews is ANN and they fucking suck. It's really no wonder why sites like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic don't take their scores into account. IMDB has EVERYTHING |
|
| There are some misses in IMDb, eh. Specially regarding short films. Still, it's the most complete database of audiovisual stuff by far. |
jnw93 said: nitrohawk said: Always use a group of professional critics scores over a group of random user scores. cult classics would not be the same if this was true But Cult Classics aren't necessarily good. The Room for example is a cult classic |
| Bring back down votes on reviews |
Nxtslide said: Kagami_Hiiragi said: I wouldn't say so. Just because you and IMDB users share a similar taste doesn't really mean much. Just because the scores reflect positive on your opinion, doesn't mean they are reliable. They are just reliable to you, but that doesn't mean in general. I know.. I'm asking if it's reliable to other people as well. You didn't clearly say that in the OP post so I didn't know that, my bad. |
|
nitrohawk said: You know what they say. Love is blaind.But Cult Classics aren't necessarily good. The Room for example is a cult classic |
|
More topics from this board
» Characters you like but everyone else hates. ( 1 2 )Spunkert - May 17, 2023 |
51 |
by Gator
»»
28 seconds ago |
|
» something you dislike about your favorite characterKenzolo-folk - Apr 22 |
29 |
by Ratris_Decision
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» Women tend to have superior anime preferences compared to men? ( 1 2 )Alpha_1_Zero - Apr 23 |
87 |
by Gator
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » How much do you consume from the otaku world?castle2001 - Apr 22 |
32 |
by Ratris_Decision
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Why are most current goblins green?Absurdo_N - 11 hours ago |
18 |
by Gator
»»
8 minutes ago |