New
What did you think of this chapter?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this chapter. If you want to discuss future events, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jul 14, 2015 11:11 AM
#1
THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- According to the raw, this is the final chapter. Lets's gets to the discussion, I am glad they end up together (Saipu and her Onii-chan). What a happy family, and their daughter is just like Saipu where she show only one eye. Such a cute ending and an incest ending. 8/10 |
Aug 24, 2016 2:54 PM
#2
hlubkoj2020 said: THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- According to the raw, this is the final chapter. Lets's gets to the discussion, I am glad they end up together (Saipu and her Onii-chan). What a happy family, and their daughter is just like Saipu where she show only one eye. Such a cute ending and an incest ending. 8/10 they are related by blood or not? |
Aug 25, 2016 5:50 PM
#3
kirinonakano said: hlubkoj2020 said: THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- According to the raw, this is the final chapter. Lets's gets to the discussion, I am glad they end up together (Saipu and her Onii-chan). What a happy family, and their daughter is just like Saipu where she show only one eye. Such a cute ending and an incest ending. 8/10 they are related by blood or not? Yes they are haha...wincest is what everone is saying. |
Aug 25, 2016 6:03 PM
#4
hlubkoj2020 said: kirinonakano said: hlubkoj2020 said: THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- According to the raw, this is the final chapter. Lets's gets to the discussion, I am glad they end up together (Saipu and her Onii-chan). What a happy family, and their daughter is just like Saipu where she show only one eye. Such a cute ending and an incest ending. 8/10 they are related by blood or not? Yes they are haha...wincest is what everone is saying. NOW I NEED to read only one more spoiler theres a bicycle scene? |
Aug 27, 2016 1:02 PM
#5
kirinonakano said: Well, I don't remember since it's bee a long time...you can try searching for the raw.hlubkoj2020 said: kirinonakano said: hlubkoj2020 said: THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- According to the raw, this is the final chapter. Lets's gets to the discussion, I am glad they end up together (Saipu and her Onii-chan). What a happy family, and their daughter is just like Saipu where she show only one eye. Such a cute ending and an incest ending. 8/10 they are related by blood or not? Yes they are haha...wincest is what everone is saying. NOW I NEED to read only one more spoiler theres a bicycle scene? |
Jan 24, 2020 3:36 AM
#6
Okay, I know this is a rather old thread to reply to, but I feel like I gotta clear some things up regarding the ending of this manga story. This is most certainly a massive spoiler, so click only if you're not worried about that. The outcome is, Fuuka and Hikaru do not end up together as an incestuous couple. I know that it's easy to make the wincest case based upon what the chapter shows you, if you can't understand the text. I read the German translation released by DKThias, and then retranslated it back to English. We are told that there was a 4-year timeskip after the events of the last chapters; Hikaru becomes a worker bee in an office, and Saipu attends a university. They are 24 and 19 years old in this chapter. At some point earlier, their mother had become pregnant, and had a daughter immediately before the timeskip began. This girl, Hitomi, is the one who greets 'papa' Hikaru at the door; she's only 4 years old, and is already huge, lol. What's going on here is that Hikaru and Fuuka pretend to be a married couple during periods when their parents are away on business; they even wear wedding rings! Three years prior to this chapter, Hikaru had told Fuuka that he wanted to marry her, and so she had seriously tried to give herself to him; but he ultimately refused while merely kissing her instead. Now, to somewhat fulfill her childhood dream, he agrees to play the part of her husband, just without any sex, haha. Both siblings are content with this arrangement, and Hikaru pledges to stay together "as a brother, as a friend" with Fuuka forever. Hitomi is listed as both a brocon and siscon, and is happy to be their 'daughter', even though she's actually their younger sister. The rest of the chapter talks about what all their friends have been up to these past few years; this chapter is real heavy with the exposition. In the end, I'm not even sure what the author was going for here, but it seems like a half-assed attempt to both quell public opposition to the incest fetish, and to also give fans of the genre a lukewarm compromise. The way I feel is that if you're going to open the door to that realm of possibility, go all the way through with it, instead of treating it like a turnstyle. |
Mar 14, 2021 7:55 AM
#7
DevLog said: Okay, I know this is a rather old thread to reply to, but I feel like I gotta clear some things up regarding the ending of this manga story. This is most certainly a massive spoiler, so click only if you're not worried about that. The outcome is, Fuuka and Hikaru do not end up together as an incestuous couple. I know that it's easy to make the wincest case based upon what the chapter shows you, if you can't understand the text. I read the German translation released by DKThias, and then retranslated it back to English. We are told that there was a 4-year timeskip after the events of the last chapters; Hikaru becomes a worker bee in an office, and Saipu attends a university. They are 24 and 19 years old in this chapter. At some point earlier, their mother had become pregnant, and had a daughter immediately before the timeskip began. This girl, Hitomi, is the one who greets 'papa' Hikaru at the door; she's only 4 years old, and is already huge, lol. What's going on here is that Hikaru and Fuuka pretend to be a married couple during periods when their parents are away on business; they even wear wedding rings! Three years prior to this chapter, Hikaru had told Fuuka that he wanted to marry her, and so she had seriously tried to give herself to him; but he ultimately refused while merely kissing her instead. Now, to somewhat fulfill her childhood dream, he agrees to play the part of her husband, just without any sex, haha. Both siblings are content with this arrangement, and Hikaru pledges to stay together "as a brother, as a friend" with Fuuka forever. Hitomi is listed as both a brocon and siscon, and is happy to be their 'daughter', even though she's actually their younger sister. The rest of the chapter talks about what all their friends have been up to these past few years; this chapter is real heavy with the exposition. In the end, I'm not even sure what the author was going for here, but it seems like a half-assed attempt to both quell public opposition to the incest fetish, and to also give fans of the genre a lukewarm compromise. The way I feel is that if you're going to open the door to that realm of possibility, go all the way through with it, instead of treating it like a turnstyle. Well, going to reply to an old reply on an old thread now. I'm a native german speaker and while I'm obviously missing context from the last 13 chapters preceeding this one some of the implications of this chapter seem to haven't carried over in the translation to english. The german word "Freund" actually can both mean being a friend or a boyfriend depending on context and I'm pretty sure if they didn't break up somewhere shortly before this and with the way it is said, it's meant in the context of a romantic relationship. In other words the two of them are still a couple just without the sex part. Otherwise you are pretty correct about the rest, just wanted to let you know that the ending is still a happy one reaffirming that after 4 years they still love each other. Although it's just pretending, as Fuuka puts it, "for now" her dream of becoming Hikaru's wife did come true and the narration is stating that they have a bright future ahead of them. |
KorodanMar 14, 2021 8:09 AM
Mar 22, 2021 4:06 PM
#8
Korodan said: DevLog said: Okay, I know this is a rather old thread to reply to, but I feel like I gotta clear some things up regarding the ending of this manga story. This is most certainly a massive spoiler, so click only if you're not worried about that. The outcome is, Fuuka and Hikaru do not end up together as an incestuous couple. I know that it's easy to make the wincest case based upon what the chapter shows you, if you can't understand the text. I read the German translation released by DKThias, and then retranslated it back to English. We are told that there was a 4-year timeskip after the events of the last chapters; Hikaru becomes a worker bee in an office, and Saipu attends a university. They are 24 and 19 years old in this chapter. At some point earlier, their mother had become pregnant, and had a daughter immediately before the timeskip began. This girl, Hitomi, is the one who greets 'papa' Hikaru at the door; she's only 4 years old, and is already huge, lol. What's going on here is that Hikaru and Fuuka pretend to be a married couple during periods when their parents are away on business; they even wear wedding rings! Three years prior to this chapter, Hikaru had told Fuuka that he wanted to marry her, and so she had seriously tried to give herself to him; but he ultimately refused while merely kissing her instead. Now, to somewhat fulfill her childhood dream, he agrees to play the part of her husband, just without any sex, haha. Both siblings are content with this arrangement, and Hikaru pledges to stay together "as a brother, as a friend" with Fuuka forever. Hitomi is listed as both a brocon and siscon, and is happy to be their 'daughter', even though she's actually their younger sister. The rest of the chapter talks about what all their friends have been up to these past few years; this chapter is real heavy with the exposition. In the end, I'm not even sure what the author was going for here, but it seems like a half-assed attempt to both quell public opposition to the incest fetish, and to also give fans of the genre a lukewarm compromise. The way I feel is that if you're going to open the door to that realm of possibility, go all the way through with it, instead of treating it like a turnstyle. Well, going to reply to an old reply on an old thread now. I'm a native german speaker and while I'm obviously missing context from the last 13 chapters preceeding this one some of the implications of this chapter seem to haven't carried over in the translation to english. The german word "Freund" actually can both mean being a friend or a boyfriend depending on context and I'm pretty sure if they didn't break up somewhere shortly before this and with the way it is said, it's meant in the context of a romantic relationship. In other words the two of them are still a couple just without the sex part. Otherwise you are pretty correct about the rest, just wanted to let you know that the ending is still a happy one reaffirming that after 4 years they still love each other. Although it's just pretending, as Fuuka puts it, "for now" her dream of becoming Hikaru's wife did come true and the narration is stating that they have a bright future ahead of them. Thank you for further clarification. I know that some people at Mangadex are almost finished translating the entire story into English, so it'll be nice to see a full picture. I stand by my initial critique of the ending to this manga. Though the author might indicate that they are going to be just fine as they are, the idea of not just loving, but being in love with someone, without any sex is a very unrealistic concept; especially so here, when the only thing blocking the consummation is Hikaru's morality. You have to ask yourself, is it truly a happy ending when Fuuka's dream of being Hikaru's wife can never truly come to pass? Not even a second-place physical relationship, without marriage, is offered by Hikaru. The author knows this couldn't go on for long and be sustainable, which is why the story ends with this summarizing chapter. |
Apr 29, 2021 12:22 PM
#9
I actually agree with you. Seeing as Fuuka wanted a sexual relationship all her life it is very sad to see them compromise like this. Hard to imagine her not just pushing him down at some point and getting it over with, but sadly this is the ending we're stuck with. In the end I'm just happy that they found happiness together, even with their unique circumstances. |
KorodanApr 29, 2021 12:29 PM
Sep 17, 2023 3:56 PM
#10
finally after all of those years, it's completed. completely degenerate and unhinged. was funny at start, but completely fall apart when author try to change the quo. the cop out ending just final nail on the coffin. 5/10. |
Nov 4, 2023 10:40 AM
#11
At first, all the chapters where saipu seduce her brother hiraku ,because she was not horny. she want to change her brother's feeling toward her from sister to women. she doesn't want her brother to fall in love or marry another women .the reason is she want to be her brother's wife. 1) when they talk about friends and sensei(last chapter 153) They talk about their everyone of their friends and sensei at once .(it's like we meet family or friends after long time and we talk about the all the peoples that we know common at once) My pov(1): if they live together as pretend couple they happened to talk about their friends ,sensei eventually in the past 4 years ,and they knew what their friends are doing ( but they talk all about their friends,sensei at once ,feels like they live separately happened to meet after long gap. And share the status of their friends.) 2) During the talk about their sensei marriage.(last chapter 153) saipu said in the last chapter(153) while telling hiraku about sensei marriage , 4 years ago if hiraku ask saipu to marry him she would have said yes on the spot immediately(And she not talk about if hiraku ask her " now "she will say yes) .this makes me think that, so after 4 years which is now saipu may not be said yes. My Pov(2) : This make me think that , saipu's romantic relation with hiraku is not as strong as 4 years ago( love diminishing).If it would be old saipu she insist on marriage at regular times .yes , I agree they are now couples (but pretending not real, and hiraku 4 years ago mentions this romantic relation is temporary) 3)By the way of talk(last chapter 153) Hiraku enters the home we see saipu dress normally not seductive type because 4 year ago she came to knew that her brother hiraku see her as women so she doesn't need to be seductive(now they are pretending couples). And in their conversation we see how matured they became especially saipu. hiraku mention that after he began to saw saipu as a women their this sort of romantic relation is temporary (this will be seen well clear in last chapter(153) .As when hiraku comes back home we can sense the love diminishing in their conversation except a following thing that saipu said. Hiraku doesn't express love directly or indirectly in their conversation only saipu express the love even after 4years by said I always love you brother in the last chapter 153 (but its also like a common thing to say normally to a brother.and it's not much different like the couples specifically say to eachother) (as in the last chapter (153)hiraku say I am with you" forever" as brother and lover(4 years ago ,not now) , and in the end saipu say i "always" love you brother (now) ) . (For me , I think there is less(no much) love in their conversation like they used to be when 4 years ago ).it's like their brother - sister love interactions is diminished. As hiraku said in previous chapter that their thing is temporary (it's convincing that this brother- sister romantic interaction reduced after 4 years and will be diminish upon further years . And soon they leave this temporary thing.) My pov(3): if the above pov is true, they soon get over this temporary thing .and they soon move on in their life but they continue to support each other as brother and sister and not as lovers. If this is a possibility then 4years ago ,hiraku dumb kamaji's love because of saipu ,would be a waste . If they move on ,then both of them lost many things in these 4 years years because of the temporary thing they had . I am not saying their love is worth nothing .what I am trying to say is their love is worth losing many thing but if they lose their love then they lose many precious and important things in their life But mostly i hope this is not possible . My pov (4) : But one pov of the last chapter (153) is they live together forever as lovers and pretend couple but controlling sexual desires as human is a difficult thing so that's why I feel like author if decides to leave it as cliffhanger ending or something. Author should leave them as married couple (as real) but hiraku doesn't agree with sex between them like that.so it leaves possibility that they may or may not done it in future like that. But author end it as they may or may not end up together in the future(as the temporary thing state by hiraku doesn't confirm to be permanent and also no marriage, no sex .which may change in future).if it changes they end up together .if not they not end up together.but atleast in this ending where they pretend to be couple atleast hiraku or saipu mention somewhere like " now we are pretend to be couples for permanent " like that she or hiraku mention that this temporary thing becomes permanent ,it would be much good ending. My Pov (5) : According to me this ending will be good : if they married for real but they haven't done sex, and saipu insist on sex and hiraku's as usual said no sex (which may or may not be change in future ,leave this as an open end) .it would be the perfect ending. (As if they pretend to be married ,and they continue to live forever as they have their little sister hitomi as their child this completes their family. My pov(6): According to me this ending will be worse Now saipu and hiraku pretend to be married ,and they continue to live as pretend couples forever with no marriage and no sex but consider them both are virgins and they live together forever , then as a human they have desire in sex but both restrain it (like no marriage and no sex) In the coming years ,if suppose they seek this desire outside their pretend marriage and eventually Falling in love with other person who they done sex with. And hiraku and saipu's temporary romantic thing(pretend couple) comes to an end and they decided to marry the person they done sex with . (when Apollo proposes to her ,she said her heart tremble (something like that)and yes soon after that she again come to sense like "I love only hiraku and my heart is only for him(something like that). This is happens 4 years ago when saipu is in deep love with hiraku But what if something similar happen with someother and she still virgin in the upcoming 5 years or 10 years or 15 years. This pov is due to the fact that human desires is natural and also saipu-Apollo interaction in manga. My Pov (8) Lastly , But according to how the story develops between saipu and hiraku ,they must be end up together. (I personally want saipu and hiraku to end up together(married and become real couples )not because I am into brother -sister relationship or I want to fantasize them having sex. I want them together because of the love that develops between them in the manga .And the things that they lost for their love in the manga and also the things that they endure when people say about them in the manga) Lastly with 2 important things I finish this ; 1) As those who finish reading manga knew, saipu never leaves her brother 2) As hiraku at first not saw saipu as woman but it changes over time.similarly this temporary thing hiraku say (and onto these temporary thing for 4 years )may change over time and become permanent thing In the future so may be i hope in this manga,as hiraku and saipu said they continue to live together as lovers and pretend couples ,soon after the coming years hiraku's mind can change and they become real married couples This is my pov, if some have different perspective discuss in this reply or same perspective also discuss in this reply .feel free to discuss it.i like to knew about your perspectives .thanks Note 1 : in above pov statements ,I mention few words repeatedly to enhance the importance of that words in the manga (example: temporary, 4 years ago ,now ,etc...) Note 2 : And there published one shot manga after the chapter 153, if someone saw that oneshot manga ,can someone said what happened in that .(I haven't seen that oneshot manga) |
zmrhNov 4, 2023 1:52 PM
Nov 4, 2023 10:41 AM
#12
Reply to DevLog
Korodan said:
Well, going to reply to an old reply on an old thread now. I'm a native german speaker and while I'm obviously missing context from the last 13 chapters preceeding this one some of the implications of this chapter seem to haven't carried over in the translation to english.
The german word "Freund" actually can both mean being a friend or a boyfriend depending on context and I'm pretty sure if they didn't break up somewhere shortly before this and with the way it is said, it's meant in the context of a romantic relationship. In other words the two of them are still a couple just without the sex part. Otherwise you are pretty correct about the rest, just wanted to let you know that the ending is still a happy one reaffirming that after 4 years they still love each other. Although it's just pretending, as Fuuka puts it, "for now" her dream of becoming Hikaru's wife did come true and the narration is stating that they have a bright future ahead of them. When the whole manga is finished translating I might come back to this post and add any other information that might come with additional context. But at that point it's obviously no longer needed.
DevLog said:
Okay, I know this is a rather old thread to reply to, but I feel like I gotta clear some things up regarding the ending of this manga story. This is most certainly a massive spoiler, so click only if you're not worried about that.
The outcome is, Fuuka and Hikaru do not end up together as an incestuous couple. I know that it's easy to make the wincest case based upon what the chapter shows you, if you can't understand the text. I read the German translation released by DKThias, and then retranslated it back to English. We are told that there was a 4-year timeskip after the events of the last chapters; Hikaru becomes a worker bee in an office, and Saipu attends a university. They are 24 and 19 years old in this chapter. At some point earlier, their mother had become pregnant, and had a daughter immediately before the timeskip began. This girl, Hitomi, is the one who greets 'papa' Hikaru at the door; she's only 4 years old, and is already huge, lol. What's going on here is that Hikaru and Fuuka pretend to be a married couple during periods when their parents are away on business; they even wear wedding rings! Three years prior to this chapter, Hikaru had told Fuuka that he wanted to marry her, and so she had seriously tried to give herself to him; but he ultimately refused while merely kissing her instead. Now, to somewhat fulfill her childhood dream, he agrees to play the part of her husband, just without any sex, haha. Both siblings are content with this arrangement, and Hikaru pledges to stay together "as a brother, as a friend" with Fuuka forever. Hitomi is listed as both a brocon and siscon, and is happy to be their 'daughter', even though she's actually their younger sister. The rest of the chapter talks about what all their friends have been up to these past few years; this chapter is real heavy with the exposition.
In the end, I'm not even sure what the author was going for here, but it seems like a half-assed attempt to both quell public opposition to the incest fetish, and to also give fans of the genre a lukewarm compromise. The way I feel is that if you're going to open the door to that realm of possibility, go all the way through with it, instead of treating it like a turnstyle.
Okay, I know this is a rather old thread to reply to, but I feel like I gotta clear some things up regarding the ending of this manga story. This is most certainly a massive spoiler, so click only if you're not worried about that.
The outcome is, Fuuka and Hikaru do not end up together as an incestuous couple. I know that it's easy to make the wincest case based upon what the chapter shows you, if you can't understand the text. I read the German translation released by DKThias, and then retranslated it back to English. We are told that there was a 4-year timeskip after the events of the last chapters; Hikaru becomes a worker bee in an office, and Saipu attends a university. They are 24 and 19 years old in this chapter. At some point earlier, their mother had become pregnant, and had a daughter immediately before the timeskip began. This girl, Hitomi, is the one who greets 'papa' Hikaru at the door; she's only 4 years old, and is already huge, lol. What's going on here is that Hikaru and Fuuka pretend to be a married couple during periods when their parents are away on business; they even wear wedding rings! Three years prior to this chapter, Hikaru had told Fuuka that he wanted to marry her, and so she had seriously tried to give herself to him; but he ultimately refused while merely kissing her instead. Now, to somewhat fulfill her childhood dream, he agrees to play the part of her husband, just without any sex, haha. Both siblings are content with this arrangement, and Hikaru pledges to stay together "as a brother, as a friend" with Fuuka forever. Hitomi is listed as both a brocon and siscon, and is happy to be their 'daughter', even though she's actually their younger sister. The rest of the chapter talks about what all their friends have been up to these past few years; this chapter is real heavy with the exposition.
In the end, I'm not even sure what the author was going for here, but it seems like a half-assed attempt to both quell public opposition to the incest fetish, and to also give fans of the genre a lukewarm compromise. The way I feel is that if you're going to open the door to that realm of possibility, go all the way through with it, instead of treating it like a turnstyle.
Well, going to reply to an old reply on an old thread now. I'm a native german speaker and while I'm obviously missing context from the last 13 chapters preceeding this one some of the implications of this chapter seem to haven't carried over in the translation to english.
The german word "Freund" actually can both mean being a friend or a boyfriend depending on context and I'm pretty sure if they didn't break up somewhere shortly before this and with the way it is said, it's meant in the context of a romantic relationship. In other words the two of them are still a couple just without the sex part. Otherwise you are pretty correct about the rest, just wanted to let you know that the ending is still a happy one reaffirming that after 4 years they still love each other. Although it's just pretending, as Fuuka puts it, "for now" her dream of becoming Hikaru's wife did come true and the narration is stating that they have a bright future ahead of them.
Thank you for further clarification. I know that some people at Mangadex are almost finished translating the entire story into English, so it'll be nice to see a full picture.
I stand by my initial critique of the ending to this manga. Though the author might indicate that they are going to be just fine as they are, the idea of not just loving, but being in love with someone, without any sex is a very unrealistic concept; especially so here, when the only thing blocking the consummation is Hikaru's morality. You have to ask yourself, is it truly a happy ending when Fuuka's dream of being Hikaru's wife can never truly come to pass? Not even a second-place physical relationship, without marriage, is offered by Hikaru.
The author knows this couldn't go on for long and be sustainable, which is why the story ends with this summarizing chapter.
@DevLog At first, all the chapters where saipu seduce her brother hiraku ,because she was not horny. she want to change her brother's feeling toward her from sister to women. she doesn't want her brother to fall in love or marry another women .the reason is she want to be her brother's wife. 1) when they talk about friends and sensei(last chapter 153) They talk about their everyone of their friends and sensei at once .(it's like we meet family or friends after long time and we talk about the all the peoples that we know common at once) My pov(1): if they live together as pretend couple they happened to talk about their friends ,sensei eventually in the past 4 years ,and they knew what their friends are doing ( but they talk all about their friends,sensei at once ,feels like they live separately happened to meet after long gap. And share the status of their friends.) 2) During the talk about their sensei marriage.(last chapter 153) saipu said in the last chapter(153) while telling hiraku about sensei marriage , 4 years ago if hiraku ask saipu to marry him she would have said yes on the spot immediately(And she not talk about if hiraku ask her " now "she will say yes) .this makes me think that, so after 4 years which is now saipu may not be said yes. My Pov(2) : This make me think that , saipu's romantic relation with hiraku is not as strong as 4 years ago( love diminishing).If it would be old saipu she insist on marriage at regular times .yes , I agree they are now couples (but pretending not real, and hiraku 4 years ago mentions this romantic relation is temporary) 3)By the way of talk(last chapter 153) Hiraku enters the home we see saipu dress normally not seductive type because 4 year ago she came to knew that her brother hiraku see her as women so she doesn't need to be seductive(now they are pretending couples). And in their conversation we see how matured they became especially saipu. hiraku mention that after he began to saw saipu as a women their this sort of romantic relation is temporary (this will be seen well clear in last chapter(153) .As when hiraku comes back home we can sense the love diminishing in their conversation except a following thing that saipu said. Hiraku doesn't express love directly or indirectly in their conversation only saipu express the love even after 4years by said I always love you brother in the last chapter 153 (but its also like a common thing to say normally to a brother.and it's not much different like the couples specifically say to eachother) (as in the last chapter (153)hiraku say I am with you" forever" as brother and lover(4 years ago ,not now) , and in the end saipu say i "always" love you brother (now) ) . (For me , I think there is less(no much) love in their conversation like they used to be when 4 years ago ).it's like their brother - sister love interactions is diminished. As hiraku said in previous chapter that their thing is temporary (it's convincing that this brother- sister romantic interaction reduced after 4 years and will be diminish upon further years . And soon they leave this temporary thing.) My pov(3): if the above pov is true, they soon get over this temporary thing .and they soon move on in their life but they continue to support each other as brother and sister and not as lovers. If this is a possibility then 4years ago ,hiraku dumb kamaji's love because of saipu ,would be a waste . If they move on ,then both of them lost many things in these 4 years years because of the temporary thing they had . I am not saying their love is worth nothing .what I am trying to say is their love is worth losing many thing but if they lose their love then they lose many precious and important things in their life But mostly i hope this is not possible . My pov (4) : But one pov of the last chapter (153) is they live together forever as lovers and pretend couple but controlling sexual desires as human is a difficult thing so that's why I feel like author if decides to leave it as cliffhanger ending or something. Author should leave them as married couple (as real) but hiraku doesn't agree with sex between them like that.so it leaves possibility that they may or may not done it in future like that. But author end it as they may or may not end up together in the future(as the temporary thing state by hiraku doesn't confirm to be permanent and also no marriage, no sex .which may change in future).if it changes they end up together .if not they not end up together.but atleast in this ending where they pretend to be couple atleast hiraku or saipu mention somewhere like " now we are pretend to be couples for permanent " like that she or hiraku mention that this temporary thing becomes permanent ,it would be much good ending. My Pov (5) : According to me this ending will be good : if they married for real but they haven't done sex, and saipu insist on sex and hiraku's as usual said no sex (which may or may not be change in future ,leave this as an open end) .it would be the perfect ending. (As if they pretend to be married ,and they continue to live forever as they have their little sister hitomi as their child this completes their family. My pov(6): According to me this ending will be worse Now saipu and hiraku pretend to be married ,and they continue to live as pretend couples forever with no marriage and no sex but consider them both are virgins and they live together forever , then as a human they have desire in sex but both restrain it (like no marriage and no sex) In the coming years ,if suppose they seek this desire outside their pretend marriage and eventually Falling in love with other person who they done sex with. And hiraku and saipu's temporary romantic thing(pretend couple) comes to an end and they decided to marry the person they done sex with . (when Apollo proposes to her ,she said her heart tremble (something like that)and yes soon after that she again come to sense like "I love only hiraku and my heart is only for him(something like that). This is happens 4 years ago when saipu is in deep love with hiraku But what if something similar happen with someother and she still virgin in the upcoming 5 years or 10 years or 15 years. This pov is due to the fact that human desires is natural and also saipu-Apollo interaction in manga. My Pov (8) Lastly , But according to how the story develops between saipu and hiraku ,they must be end up together. (I personally want saipu and hiraku to end up together(married and become real couples )not because I am into brother -sister relationship or I want to fantasize them having sex. I want them together because of the love that develops between them in the manga .And the things that they lost for their love in the manga and also the things that they endure when people say about them in the manga) Lastly with 2 important things I finish this ; 1) As those who finish reading manga knew, saipu never leaves her brother 2) As hiraku at first not saw saipu as woman but it changes over time.similarly this temporary thing hiraku say (and onto these temporary thing for 4 years )may change over time and become permanent thing In the future so may be i hope in this manga,as hiraku and saipu said they continue to live together as lovers and pretend couples ,soon after the coming years hiraku's mind can change and they become real married couples This is my pov, if some have different perspective discuss in this reply or same perspective also discuss in this reply .feel free to discuss it.i like to knew about your perspectives .thanks Note 1 : in above pov statements ,I mention few words repeatedly to enhance the importance of that words in the manga (example: temporary, 4 years ago ,now ,etc...) Note 2 : And there published one shot manga after the chapter 153, if someone saw that oneshot manga ,can someone said what happened in that .(I haven't seen that oneshot manga) |
Mar 5, 5:36 PM
#13
Reply to zmrh
@DevLog At first, all the chapters where saipu seduce her brother hiraku ,because she was not horny. she want to change her brother's feeling toward her from sister to women. she doesn't want her brother to fall in love or marry another women .the reason is she want to be her brother's wife.
1) when they talk about friends and sensei(last chapter 153)
They talk about their everyone of their friends and sensei at once .(it's like we meet family or friends after long time and we talk about the all the peoples that we know common at once)
My pov(1):
if they live together as pretend couple they happened to talk about their friends ,sensei eventually in the past 4 years ,and they knew what their friends are doing ( but they talk all about their friends,sensei at once ,feels like they live separately happened to meet after long gap. And share the status of their friends.)
2) During the talk about their sensei marriage.(last chapter 153)
saipu said in the last chapter(153) while telling hiraku about sensei marriage , 4 years ago if hiraku ask saipu to marry him she would have said yes on the spot immediately(And she not talk about if hiraku ask her " now "she will say yes) .this makes me think that, so after 4 years which is now saipu may not be said yes.
My Pov(2) : This make me think that , saipu's romantic relation with hiraku is not as strong as 4 years ago( love diminishing).If it would be old saipu she insist on marriage at regular times .yes , I agree they are now couples (but pretending not real, and hiraku 4 years ago mentions this romantic relation is temporary)
3)By the way of talk(last chapter 153)
Hiraku enters the home we see saipu dress normally not seductive type because 4 year ago she came to knew that her brother hiraku see her as women so she doesn't need to be seductive(now they are pretending couples). And in their conversation we see how matured they became especially saipu.
hiraku mention that after he began to saw saipu as a women their this sort of romantic relation is temporary (this will be seen well clear in last chapter(153) .As when hiraku comes back home we can sense the love diminishing in their conversation except a following thing that saipu said. Hiraku doesn't express love directly or indirectly in their conversation only saipu express the love even after 4years by said I always love you brother in the last chapter 153 (but its also like a common thing to say normally to a brother.and it's not much different like the couples specifically say to eachother)
(as in the last chapter (153)hiraku say I am with you" forever" as brother and lover(4 years ago ,not now) , and in the end saipu say i "always" love you brother (now) ) .
(For me , I think there is less(no much) love in their conversation like they used to be when 4 years ago ).it's like their brother - sister love interactions is diminished. As hiraku said in previous chapter that their thing is temporary (it's convincing that this brother- sister romantic interaction reduced after 4 years and will be diminish upon further years . And soon they leave this temporary thing.)
My pov(3):
if the above pov is true, they soon get over this temporary thing .and they soon move on in their life but they continue to support each other as brother and sister and not as lovers. If this is a possibility then 4years ago ,hiraku dumb kamaji's love because of saipu ,would be a waste . If they move on ,then both of them lost many things in these 4 years years because of the temporary thing they had . I am not saying their love is worth nothing .what I am trying to say is their love is worth losing many thing but if they lose their love then they lose many precious and important things in their life
But mostly i hope this is not possible .
My pov (4) :
But one pov of the last chapter (153) is they live together forever as lovers and pretend couple but controlling sexual desires as human is a difficult thing so that's why I feel like author if decides to leave it as cliffhanger ending or something. Author should leave them as married couple (as real) but hiraku doesn't agree with sex between them like that.so it leaves possibility that they may or may not done it in future like that. But author end it as they may or may not end up together in the future(as the temporary thing state by hiraku doesn't confirm to be permanent and also no marriage, no sex .which may change in future).if it changes they end up together .if not they not end up together.but atleast in this ending where they pretend to be couple atleast hiraku or saipu mention somewhere like " now we are pretend to be couples for permanent " like that she or hiraku mention that this temporary thing becomes permanent ,it would be much good ending.
My Pov (5) :
According to me this ending will be good :
if they married for real but they haven't done sex, and saipu insist on sex and hiraku's as usual said no sex (which may or may not be change in future ,leave this as an open end) .it would be the perfect ending. (As if they pretend to be married ,and they continue to live forever as they have their little sister hitomi as their child this completes their family.
My pov(6):
According to me this ending will be worse
Now saipu and hiraku pretend to be married ,and they continue to live as pretend couples forever with no marriage and no sex but consider them both are virgins and they live together forever , then as a human they have desire in sex but both restrain it (like no marriage and no sex) In the coming years ,if suppose they seek this desire outside their pretend marriage and eventually Falling in love with other person who they done sex with. And hiraku and saipu's temporary romantic thing(pretend couple) comes to an end and they decided to marry the person they done sex with .
(when Apollo proposes to her ,she said her heart tremble (something like that)and yes soon after that she again come to sense like "I love only hiraku and my heart is only for him(something like that). This is happens 4 years ago when saipu is in deep love with hiraku But what if something similar happen with someother and she still virgin in the upcoming 5 years or 10 years or 15 years.
This pov is due to the fact that human desires is natural and also saipu-Apollo interaction in manga.
My Pov (8)
Lastly ,
But according to how the story develops between saipu and hiraku ,they must be end up together.
(I personally want saipu and hiraku to end up together(married and become real couples )not because I am into brother -sister relationship or I want to fantasize them having sex. I want them together because of the love that develops between them in the manga .And the things that they lost for their love in the manga and also the things that they endure when people say about them in the manga)
Lastly with 2 important things I finish this ;
1) As those who finish reading manga knew, saipu never leaves her brother
2) As hiraku at first not saw saipu as woman but it changes over time.similarly this temporary thing hiraku say (and onto these temporary thing for 4 years )may change over time and become permanent thing In the future
so may be i hope in this manga,as hiraku and saipu said they continue to live together as lovers and pretend couples ,soon after the coming years hiraku's mind can change and they become real married couples
This is my pov, if some have different perspective discuss in this reply or same perspective also discuss in this reply .feel free to discuss it.i like to knew about your perspectives .thanks
Note 1 : in above pov statements ,I mention few words repeatedly to enhance the importance of that words in the manga (example: temporary, 4 years ago ,now ,etc...)
Note 2 : And there published one shot manga after the chapter 153, if someone saw that oneshot manga ,can someone said what happened in that .(I haven't seen that oneshot manga)
1) when they talk about friends and sensei(last chapter 153)
They talk about their everyone of their friends and sensei at once .(it's like we meet family or friends after long time and we talk about the all the peoples that we know common at once)
My pov(1):
if they live together as pretend couple they happened to talk about their friends ,sensei eventually in the past 4 years ,and they knew what their friends are doing ( but they talk all about their friends,sensei at once ,feels like they live separately happened to meet after long gap. And share the status of their friends.)
2) During the talk about their sensei marriage.(last chapter 153)
saipu said in the last chapter(153) while telling hiraku about sensei marriage , 4 years ago if hiraku ask saipu to marry him she would have said yes on the spot immediately(And she not talk about if hiraku ask her " now "she will say yes) .this makes me think that, so after 4 years which is now saipu may not be said yes.
My Pov(2) : This make me think that , saipu's romantic relation with hiraku is not as strong as 4 years ago( love diminishing).If it would be old saipu she insist on marriage at regular times .yes , I agree they are now couples (but pretending not real, and hiraku 4 years ago mentions this romantic relation is temporary)
3)By the way of talk(last chapter 153)
Hiraku enters the home we see saipu dress normally not seductive type because 4 year ago she came to knew that her brother hiraku see her as women so she doesn't need to be seductive(now they are pretending couples). And in their conversation we see how matured they became especially saipu.
hiraku mention that after he began to saw saipu as a women their this sort of romantic relation is temporary (this will be seen well clear in last chapter(153) .As when hiraku comes back home we can sense the love diminishing in their conversation except a following thing that saipu said. Hiraku doesn't express love directly or indirectly in their conversation only saipu express the love even after 4years by said I always love you brother in the last chapter 153 (but its also like a common thing to say normally to a brother.and it's not much different like the couples specifically say to eachother)
(as in the last chapter (153)hiraku say I am with you" forever" as brother and lover(4 years ago ,not now) , and in the end saipu say i "always" love you brother (now) ) .
(For me , I think there is less(no much) love in their conversation like they used to be when 4 years ago ).it's like their brother - sister love interactions is diminished. As hiraku said in previous chapter that their thing is temporary (it's convincing that this brother- sister romantic interaction reduced after 4 years and will be diminish upon further years . And soon they leave this temporary thing.)
My pov(3):
if the above pov is true, they soon get over this temporary thing .and they soon move on in their life but they continue to support each other as brother and sister and not as lovers. If this is a possibility then 4years ago ,hiraku dumb kamaji's love because of saipu ,would be a waste . If they move on ,then both of them lost many things in these 4 years years because of the temporary thing they had . I am not saying their love is worth nothing .what I am trying to say is their love is worth losing many thing but if they lose their love then they lose many precious and important things in their life
But mostly i hope this is not possible .
My pov (4) :
But one pov of the last chapter (153) is they live together forever as lovers and pretend couple but controlling sexual desires as human is a difficult thing so that's why I feel like author if decides to leave it as cliffhanger ending or something. Author should leave them as married couple (as real) but hiraku doesn't agree with sex between them like that.so it leaves possibility that they may or may not done it in future like that. But author end it as they may or may not end up together in the future(as the temporary thing state by hiraku doesn't confirm to be permanent and also no marriage, no sex .which may change in future).if it changes they end up together .if not they not end up together.but atleast in this ending where they pretend to be couple atleast hiraku or saipu mention somewhere like " now we are pretend to be couples for permanent " like that she or hiraku mention that this temporary thing becomes permanent ,it would be much good ending.
My Pov (5) :
According to me this ending will be good :
if they married for real but they haven't done sex, and saipu insist on sex and hiraku's as usual said no sex (which may or may not be change in future ,leave this as an open end) .it would be the perfect ending. (As if they pretend to be married ,and they continue to live forever as they have their little sister hitomi as their child this completes their family.
My pov(6):
According to me this ending will be worse
Now saipu and hiraku pretend to be married ,and they continue to live as pretend couples forever with no marriage and no sex but consider them both are virgins and they live together forever , then as a human they have desire in sex but both restrain it (like no marriage and no sex) In the coming years ,if suppose they seek this desire outside their pretend marriage and eventually Falling in love with other person who they done sex with. And hiraku and saipu's temporary romantic thing(pretend couple) comes to an end and they decided to marry the person they done sex with .
(when Apollo proposes to her ,she said her heart tremble (something like that)and yes soon after that she again come to sense like "I love only hiraku and my heart is only for him(something like that). This is happens 4 years ago when saipu is in deep love with hiraku But what if something similar happen with someother and she still virgin in the upcoming 5 years or 10 years or 15 years.
This pov is due to the fact that human desires is natural and also saipu-Apollo interaction in manga.
My Pov (8)
Lastly ,
But according to how the story develops between saipu and hiraku ,they must be end up together.
(I personally want saipu and hiraku to end up together(married and become real couples )not because I am into brother -sister relationship or I want to fantasize them having sex. I want them together because of the love that develops between them in the manga .And the things that they lost for their love in the manga and also the things that they endure when people say about them in the manga)
Lastly with 2 important things I finish this ;
1) As those who finish reading manga knew, saipu never leaves her brother
2) As hiraku at first not saw saipu as woman but it changes over time.similarly this temporary thing hiraku say (and onto these temporary thing for 4 years )may change over time and become permanent thing In the future
so may be i hope in this manga,as hiraku and saipu said they continue to live together as lovers and pretend couples ,soon after the coming years hiraku's mind can change and they become real married couples
This is my pov, if some have different perspective discuss in this reply or same perspective also discuss in this reply .feel free to discuss it.i like to knew about your perspectives .thanks
Note 1 : in above pov statements ,I mention few words repeatedly to enhance the importance of that words in the manga (example: temporary, 4 years ago ,now ,etc...)
Note 2 : And there published one shot manga after the chapter 153, if someone saw that oneshot manga ,can someone said what happened in that .(I haven't seen that oneshot manga)
@zmrh Chapter 153 is the end, the author has published no new works and likely isn't going to. Anything beyond this chapter is purely speculative fan-fiction. I have to admit, the way you arrange your comments is a bit confusing, lol. Realistically speaking, Hikaru and his sister will grow further apart as her biological clock continues to tick; this happens to all women at some point in their life. Even in this chapter, one can tell that Fuuka is not completely happy with this arrangement. If Hikaru cannot give her what she really wants, she will find someone who will. She is attractive and likable, and has no problems gaining suitors. Likewise, as Hikaru approaches 30, he will realize more and more that this fantasy pretend-marriage bullcrap is nothing but a fools' errand. He also has romantic candidates he could approach. Of course, there's also the legal considerations. If it were ever found out that they were an incestuous couple, both of their reputations in the public world would be finished. Good luck finding and keeping a job with that sh*t stain on your record. No, this ending for them is the happiest one that could be hoped for, given all considerations. Anything more would be too much of a suspension of disbelief. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Cyclops Shoujo Saipuu Chapter 134 DiscussionKuma - Jan 28, 2021 |
0 |
by Kuma
»»
Jan 28, 2021 6:00 PM |
|
Poll: » Cyclops Shoujo Saipuu Chapter 133 DiscussionKuma - Jan 24, 2021 |
0 |
by Kuma
»»
Jan 24, 2021 7:12 PM |
|
Poll: » Cyclops Shoujo Saipuu Chapter 131 DiscussionKuma - Jan 15, 2021 |
0 |
by Kuma
»»
Jan 15, 2021 2:51 AM |
|
Poll: » Cyclops Shoujo Saipuu Chapter 130 DiscussionKuma - Jan 11, 2021 |
0 |
by Kuma
»»
Jan 11, 2021 5:38 AM |
|
Poll: » Cyclops Shoujo Saipuu Chapter 129 DiscussionKuma - Jan 7, 2021 |
0 |
by Kuma
»»
Jan 7, 2021 7:10 AM |